Sign in to wowOwow

Enter the email address that you used when registering at wowOwow.
The password field is case sensitive. Click here if you have forgotten your password.

Please register for wowOwow

Newsletter subscriptions
Sign up to receive wowOwow's weekly newsletter and get our best picks delivered right to your inbox. Our newsletter content is hand-picked by the wowOwow editorial team and provides the top features, news, and commentary from our site. Subscribing to our newsletter is free and safe. We will never share your email or other information with a third-party without your direct consent.
By registering, you indicate that you have read and agree
with our privacy policy and terms of service.

Conversation | 04/28/2008 7:52 am

Joan and Liz: The Health of Individual Americans Is Completely Subject to the Pharmaceutical and Insurance Companies

© Shutterstock

JOAN: I was wondering if Whoopi had anything to say about health insurance, in this country.

WHOOPI: Well, you know, I will never understand why everybody in this country doesn’t have it. I don’t understand what happened to the health stations that I grew up with.

JOAN: What’s a health station?

WHOOPI: A health station … they were situated all through the city. And you had a health card, which you took in there; it was where you got all of your inoculations and vaccinations.

LIZ: Was this in New York or San Francisco?

WHOOPI: No, this was here. And it’s still there; the building is still there on Ninth Avenue and 27th Street. And if you needed your dentist stuff done, you had dental work done — you got it all done there. And, really, it was very inexpensive for my mom, you know, as a single parent. I just don’t understand why, when we’re paying — and I have to marry the two together — if we’re paying 50 percent of my income and you’re paying 50 percent of your income, and Oprah’s paying 50 percent of her income, and Bill Gates is paying 50 percent of his income, how come —

LIZ: Well, all of that money’s going to Iraq, I guess.

WHOOPI: It’s not like I’m going to get any of that money back. You know, people get money back on their taxes. You know, in 25 years I’ve never gotten a penny back. So I don’t understand why — if you’re getting 50 percent of all these people making this dough — why it’s impossible for us to toss some of that dough towards a health plan. I mean, we bail out banks that set up certain situations that are cheesy and really bad, but we bail them out. We bail out everybody …

JOAN: Exactly.

LESLEY: I was remembering a story that I did, gosh, more than ten years ago, about a family on the west coast. Their son was a hemophiliac who got AIDS from a transfusion. This was before they really understood where AIDS came from. So they had these stunning bills for the medications that the son needed. And even though the father was earning a decent salary, they couldn’t keep up with the medical costs. In order to take care of their son – this family had other kids – they had to get divorced because the father earned too much money to go on Medicaid. They were happily married. They were raising kids. They needed the father in the household. But they had to get divorced, because the health care benefits had run out, and the only way to take care of their son was if they went on Medicaid. So this family was broken apart. It was a story that stayed with me. It weighs on my heart all these years later.

JOAN: It’s medieval.

LESLEY: It’s evil and it’s … did you say medieval or evil?

JOAN: I said medieval. But evil is just as good.

LESLEY: This story is something you could hear about in any place in the country.

JOAN: I have a friend who just came in from Paris, a guy who’s 48 years old who had a brain tumor last year. He spent three months in the hospital. It cost him nothing. With his work medical insurance, it cost him nothing, just the way the French thing is set up. It cost him nothing at all. I have friends here in America — an actor and his producer wife. The actor has brain cancer. The producer told me the other day that if he hadn’t been in SAG it would have cost them $800,000.

WHOOPI: Oh, my God. Yeah.

LIZ: Well, can I just inject one little practical note here? Nobody has a better health plan than Hillary Clinton. Hers is superior, I think, to Barack Obama’s. This is one thing that’s in her favor. But, once she became the president, could she really ever get that through the Congress? I mean, as long as we’re so evenly divided between liberals and conservatives, we’re never going to get any of these things through. And my friend, Pete Peterson, the great sage of Medicare, social security and health care, he just feels that all of these entitlement programs — the government is now in no position to put any of them into effect. You know, we haven’t even paid for the Iraq war yet. Isn’t it trillions of dollars, like three trillion?

JOAN: Yes.

106 Reader Comments (so far…) Sign In or Register to comment

Ginger Richardson
I agree with bleucrawfish. The programs you mention are called “alternative” medicine, and they generally can help keep us all healthier and not so much in need of what the medical/pharmaceutical industry now calls “traditional medicine”. In my opinion, “traditional” means taking care of your body, eating right, exercising, using natural/homeopathic cures…..and “alternative” is when something catastrophic happens and the traditional methods just aren’t enough, or when someone doesn’t take good care of themself and their health is beyond repair using traditional methods. I know there are women out there who rely heavily on drugs and surgery. That’s certainly your right, and I don’t in any way mean to insult you. At 41, I don’t take prescription nor over the counter drugs except occasionally an aspirin. I have a wonderful book “Prescription for Natural Cures” that I absolutely couldn’t live without. Before I’d give my money to big pharma or medical doctors, I’d consult my book and/or do plenty of research to find a natural cure.
By Ginger Richardson on 04/28/2008 12:02 pm
Frannie Em
Ginger, when I went through the big “C” - I believe my alternative - chinese medicine was what made a big difference for me. But, for certain things, you have go and do the western choice. I talked a long time to many practitioners in the field and there is only so much it does. You can prevent better, but sometimes you have to face what you have to do.
By Frannie Em on 04/28/2008 12:32 pm
Mugsy Peabody
Qi gong, as well, bluecrawfish. I would like to see some really basic information provided to everyone about health care. E.g., how much water do you need per day? What are good baseline supplements? Walking two miles a day baseline exercise. What we’re going to have to do for the next serious little while is take care of ourselves, truth be told, and take care of each other. I’ve got great health coverage right now because I’ve got good COBRA, but … And another truth is, eating right can really save your life.
By Mugsy Peabody on 04/28/2008 2:32 am
bleucrawfish ..............
eating right would do wonders. do you know what kind of high carb high, fat crap is served in the public school system? some schools even have vending machines. marketing has made eating right and healthy expensive. cheap food is full of chemicals. health and what you put in your body is all connected. your body will always tell you what it needs if you just listen to your cravings. for instence when i crave milk and orange juice, not together, i know i am severely dehydrated. every one is a little different but your body will tell you what you need. when you are in balance you can hear it loud and clear. if you are stressed you tend to just go for the quick fix, it takes discipline to stay on track.
By bleucrawfish .............. on 04/28/2008 3:10 am
Ginger Richardson
Right again, bleucrawfish. For several years, I worked for a chiropractor who deeply believes in natural, drug- and surgery-free living. He taught me so much about taking care of my body. He said that most of the time, the two things that can help our health are good hygiene, i.e. washing your hands often, and drinking plenty of WATER. Not fluids - water! A lot of people who feel “sick” from time to time are simply dehydrated. As you said, listen to your body!
By Ginger Richardson on 04/28/2008 12:12 pm
Star Lawrence
I don’t want to be mean, but you can eat “right” for decades and you may still get sick. It’s just a fact. No one healthens to death.
By Star Lawrence on 04/28/2008 12:24 pm
Mugsy Peabody
Yes, of course, you are right about that, Star. But, truth be told, when you do get sick, having taken care of yourself helps you heal. I have a friend who teaches Qi Gong and has always eaten right and taken her supplements, and she didn’t even take pain killers after breast cancer surgery. The nurses at the hospital are still talking about her.
By Mugsy Peabody on 04/28/2008 1:03 pm
Ginger Richardson
Star, you’re not being mean! This site is about ideas and opinions. Of course, you can do everything right and still get sick. What I’m saying is, it can’t hurt. And as I stated, before I would go to any physician, I would seek out natural cures. Unfortunately, I just can’t trust my health, nor the health of my loved ones, to “traditional” medicine. Too many physicians are in the pockets of big pharma, paid to prescribe certain drugs. The only person who really cares about my health is ME, and the only person I trust to take care of it is ME. If no natural cures were helping me, I’d have no choice but to go to a doctor.
By Ginger Richardson on 04/28/2008 3:42 pm
C A Rose
Need to add one more thing, even with the public assistance I receive I have had to file bankruptcy 2 times over my 18+ yrs of illness due to my inability to pay all the co-pays, hospital extra’s and my favorite of all, medications not covered for which there have been no substitutes. So in addition to being unemployable and uninsurable I also probably will never have good credit again in my lifetime. There’s something wrong with this picture. It certainly isn’t where I imagined I would be at this stage of my life.
By C A Rose on 04/28/2008 3:56 am
CAROLINE MuLVEY
Hello Cynthia; I understand about having illnesses. and co-pays as high as $50.00 for each specialist. I have 6 specialists. Have you applied to Social Security? You only get a check once every month,but it does help. And even if you owe lets say a credit card company,they can not touch your bank account nor your social security checlk. As for the bankruptcy I know some people that went and bought a car right after they had bankruptcy. And it is only suppose to last 7 years. I wish you to get healthy and stay safe………………….Carol
By CAROLINE MuLVEY on 05/03/2008 1:57 pm
Renata
Thanks ladies for putting this on the WoW agenda! I have been working with HHS and Medicare Communications — primarily for Internet syndications regarding CAREGIVING — for 7 years, and the amount of money put into our totally dysfunctional system of healthcare distribution is STAGGERING! The for-profit/padding dynamic (combined with limited accountability) at every level has made healthcare the REAL place to make a killing. I had the pleasure of meeting Dave Walker last week (former Controller General of the US), the new head of the Peter G. Peterson Foundation (who referred me) and discussed the increased entitlement challenges as boomers make their ascent into an historically unprecedented longevity, 79 million strong — over an (also) historically unprecedented lengthy period of time (30 years). It is estimated 50% of the boomers will live to be at least 85 years old — courtesy of Medicare. That’s 40 million Americans ladies and gentlemen! The good news is that Americans are living longer, though women are beginning to show indications of a leveling off due to…dare we say it…lack of health insurance for approx. 40 mil Americans! The bad news — the first boomer turned 60 years old 1/1/08 — a retired school teacher in FL. She signed up for benefits during the Winter. If we don’t reconcile the universal health insurance debacle now, then boomers (1/3 of the entire American population) will do it FOR us, via very expensive, for-profit Medicare HMOs — leaving Xers/Yers/Millenials to carry the burden of more than 100 million seniors, while simultaneously trying to raise families, buy homes and make a life. I disagree with Liz on one matter. It will take a top strategist and collaborator to get ANY health proposal through Congress. Hillary Clinton has demonstrated via her Campaign that she is not any more capable of making this very difficult case than she was 16 years ago — because divisiveness and making enemies will once again cause a BACKLASH, leaving 40 million Americans in “medieval” straits. We cannot AFFORD this economically or otherwise. As someone who has READ the Medicare Modernization Act and has intimate knowledge about how the system really works, I believe Barack Obama’s plan is the best solution. The differences are minimal and, Hillary’s attempts to marginalize Barack’s plan wreaks with the SAME my-way-or-the-highway approach that has cost so much misery over the last 16 years until now there is a HUMAN CRY for universal healthcare, right and left. Focus on the STRAGEGIST, COLLABORATOR and plan…not just the plan. We’ve seen this movie before. Sadly, MANY have paid the ultimate price due to the FAILURE of management and leadership when we had the chance almost a generation ago. Do not put the same person in charge of this MAJOR CHALLENGE, America. Please keep health on the WoW agenda! Thanks!
By Renata on 04/28/2008 3:58 am
Frannie Em
Renata, my sister-in-law is a nurse and she says there is so much fraud and waste in Medicare and Medicaid that if that were cleaned up - it would solve about half of the problem. She works in dialysis so she works for many doctors, and she knows of some that continue to bill for people that have died. Not just for a little while, but for like a couple of years. That is outrageous.
By Frannie Em on 04/28/2008 12:40 pm
Mugsy Peabody
As I’ve said ibid, there is fraud and waste in every single system — military or stateside, political or personal. It’s a national epidemic that stems, I think, from (a) inability to think; (b) failure to think; (c) refusal to think; or (d) absence of thought…. Um, oops, I think my record is broken (or would be if we still had LPs)…. The fact is, this country is running on ignorance, arrogance and greed, ad we need to figure out ways to change, not just our systems, but ourselves.
By Mugsy Peabody on 04/28/2008 4:10 pm
J Boylynn
Mugsy, Wow! You are so articulate. And correct! Yes, change ourselves…”….Courage to change the things we can, and the wisdom to know the difference.” Maybe not with Hilary, but I believe it will take a woman to do it right.
By J Boylynn on 05/02/2008 6:12 pm
Khaki Doodle
On the one hand they climb over each other to get the fat count in our foods regulated and all, saying it’s because all of us lardbutts are going to cost the healthcare system mucho bucks a few years down the line. Then, on the other hand, they leave the average lardbutts like me without a way to have regular medical checkups, pretty much guaranteeing that whatever cancer comes to kill me won’t be diagnosed until it’s too late. Like Maggie D, I am also in the unwashed masses, so unwashed that the last time I had a standard “check-up” was when I went to jail 15 years ago. Perhaps I should break a law soon, because I’m pretty sure this sore tooth means I’m going to need some dental work before too long. When something goes wrong, I head to the emergency room. Last time was a scorpion sting. Big Ouch. I still haven’t paid the bill from that visit. Personally, my money is on Wal-Mart, and the li’l clinics they are going to be opening up for poor folks like me.
By Khaki Doodle on 04/28/2008 4:29 am