Sign in to wowOwow

Enter the email address that you used when registering at wowOwow.
The password field is case sensitive. Click here if you have forgotten your password.

Please register for wowOwow

Newsletter subscriptions
Sign up to receive wowOwow's weekly newsletter and get our best picks delivered right to your inbox. Our newsletter content is hand-picked by the wowOwow editorial team and provides the top features, news, and commentary from our site. Subscribing to our newsletter is free and safe. We will never share your email or other information with a third-party without your direct consent.
By registering, you indicate that you have read and agree
with our privacy policy and terms of service.

Conversation | 04/30/2008 12:00 am

Whoopi: Why Isn't Anyone Screaming About Taxes?

© Shutterstock

WHOOPI: I am outraged. I’m outraged. I looked at my cable bill. I looked at my phone bill. And there are taxes on there … it goes anywhere from $10 to $15 a month that I’m paying for stuff I don’t know. There are letters — the LMNOPQ fund of the jacka-jacka … and no one says, “The what!?” And when you think about it, it’s every month that you’re paying it. So it’s ten bucks here or fifteen bucks here or twenty-five dollars there.

Then you’re writing out — they take the 50 percent of your income and it goes to God knows where. When I first started working I said, “OK. I don’t mind paying out because I know it’s going to go for some stuff I hate, and some stuff that I like.” But I’m looking and I see my friends who haven’t done as well as I have financially. You know, they’ve got kids, they’ve got house payments, they’ve got mortgages. They’ve got gas to put in their cars. Friends who are putting, you know, in a 500 gallon or 2500 gallon tank — they’re only taking 50 gallons of oil because they can’t afford it! They can’t afford it. I don’t understand why —

LIZ: Well, it’s pretty discouraging when Congress keeps doing these earmarks where they consign millions of dollars to stupid things like, you know, “We’ll study the button,” or “We’ll study ladybugs,” or something. Or they build these bridges to nowhere in Alaska. And then you do resent paying your taxes when that’s happening.

WHOOPI: I don’t mind paying them. I resent this idea that everything I do now is taxed. And I get no bang for my buck. I feel like I want to just dump tea in the river, because there’s no representation. And if I’m bitching about this, I can’t imagine what somebody who’s just living, literally, paycheck to paycheck is going through. Because there’s no government agency that says, “You know what? We’re going to pay this much to the oil company so that everybody can get the oil.”

LIZ: Well, I don’t believe we’re ever going to get rid of big taxes as long as America is in the industrial munitions manufacture business. And that’s the business the government is in — is constantly making these war machines and then they go obsolete and they junk billions of dollars worth of ‘em. And they just go on and on. And I don’t know. I know we have to protect ourselves, but —

WHOOPI: Here’s what started it, just so you guys know.

JOAN: Yes, let’s hear.

WHOOPI: I had a radio program, which did not work out. Very smartly, I was in a pay-or-play deal. So everybody said, “You know what? This isn’t working. But, yes, we know we still have to pay you.” They were supposed to give me my lump sum. Well it turns out that you can no longer be given a lump sum without 10 or 15 percent being taken out — as a penalty …

JOAN: As a penalty.

WHOOPI: … for getting paid a lump sum.

LIZ: Well, that makes no sense.

WHOOPI: It makes no sense. And what you have to do is you have to then defer the other half of your money. So you can take some now and then you can’t take it for another year.

LIZ: And then the company disappears and you never get it.

WHOOPI: Well, yeah. Or they go under. I said to the guy, “Who made this law? Did anybody put it on the books to discuss it?” No. This went into law about a year ago. If you’re getting ready to get paid a lump sum, you have a 20 percent tax on it — tax on top of the 50 percent they already took.

LESLEY: What always surprises me is when you see these people on Wall Street just cleaning up. Did you see the story the other day where these hedge fund owners — in this crisis and this recession that we’re in — in this Wall Street debacle, are making 3.5 billion dollars? And they’re the ones fighting taxes. They don’t —

JOAN: And they’re the ones that don’t pay the taxes!

101 Reader Comments (so far…) Sign In or Register to comment

Vicki M
I’ve lived from paycheck to paycheck all my l hoped that when I got married the paycheck to paycheck way of living would be over, but it wasn’t. We have a home, a car to get back and forth to work, we have food on the table. The one thing we don’t have is a nest egg for retirement. It wasn’t because we didn’t know how to manage money. If we didn’t know how to manage money we wouldn’t have a home, car or food on the table. We know how to manage money but we don’t have the money to manage. I’m sick of the taxes and I’m sick of the politicians raising the taxes on everything and I’m sick of them going behind closed doors to give themselves big pay raises while the less fortunate have to live paycheck to paycheck. I just wish there would be an honest politican that is willing to fight for the people of our country. Once Bush is out, whoever gets in will have to raise taxes to get our asses out of debt, yet again. I’m just a little peon and everytime I get pissed I write a letter. It’s a wonder there isn’t a hit out on me. Of course now, you can’t even write a letter to Bush because if it isn’t a positive letter then you can be arrested and prosecuted for treason. What a bunch of crap. I guess I wasn’t the only one writing letters to him. I sure wish there was a way for the people but as long as there’s greed and corruption in our government there won’t be any excape for any of us
By Vicki M on 04/30/2008 1:37 pm
Bella Mia
Lowering tax RATES per person, increases the amount of total Revenues to the government. That is why the US is taking in more taxes than ever even though our tax rates are lower than before the war. The government is spending more per person than ever before. They don’t do it wisely or efficiently.
By Bella Mia on 04/30/2008 1:44 pm
Mahulda Fite
Bella Mia and Kay, I am so impressed how eloquently you both explained the tax situation in this country. My husband was an investment manager and years ago opened my eyes to how people are actually punished for working hard. All of the points you both made, the taxing of our investments twice via income and capital gains, the fact that 90% of all taxes are paid by 50% of wage earners, and the fact that there is now more tax money than ever before coming into the treasury after the tax cuts—and yes, they don’t spend it wisely. I am just so surprised that most people don’t know these facts. Most of my friends think that rich people are not paying enough, but actually they are paying more than enough. It would be more fair if people paid a fixed percentage—then someone making 20K would pay 2000 at 10% and someone making 200 K would pay 20,000 at 10%. The rich would still pay more, but at least it would be fair. And of course, people who do not pay taxes are not interested in lowering them, so the taxpayers are at the mercy of these people at the voting booth.
By Mahulda Fite on 04/30/2008 5:56 pm
Alessan O
People who do not pay taxes, are usually on fixed income and extremely poor, below the poverty line for a family of four $ 20,000. People living in the rural and urban parts of the country, can barely get to the voting booths, so I don’t know who wouldn’t be interested in lowering taxes, or better yet, not paying any taxes at all. Again, the rich are not taxed according to what they make only the working poor and middle class are. We all wish for lower taxes, we’d like the same tax rate as the rich, which is a considerably lower percentage than the middle class. Plus, to live a middle class life most people have to be married and need two salaries, then there’s the marriage penalty taxes on top of that. Rich people should not complain, just be happy you are rich, and don’t have to worry about foreclosures, high rents, food, healthcare, you are worry free. You just have think about how to cheat the government out of taxes you should be paying withl 10 homes, savings and stock. Pay up, and help the 47 million people living in poverty in this country.
By Alessan O on 05/01/2008 2:10 am
Mahulda Fite
Alesson O, I think we’re confusing what is rich. We have a progressive tax system that does punish people, because the more you earn, the higher the tax. I myself am on a fixed income, but my children work hard and the more successful they become, the more their taxes go up disproportionately. So it depends what is considered rich. To say the rich are not taxed according to what they make, is clearly not true— someone making 50K is in a lower tax bracket than someone making 200K. The person making 200K pays a much higher percentage of their income. I don’t know anyone who makes 200-300K a year that has 10 homes. As to helping people, my husband and I, when we could, gave a large portion of our income to charity. That is the way is should be done, people should be able to chose, not be forced to pay for others. Also, the government is not very good at handling money and there is just too much waste. For those who want more taxes, you can always pay more if you want to, just check the box on your tax form and tell them you think you don’t pay enough. They will be glad to take it.
By Mahulda Fite on 05/01/2008 6:42 am
Kay Mitchell
Thank you, Mahulda! We can go on forever talking about feelings and “making the world a better place” on this site, but are feelings really going to change things? I don’t think so- if billionaries like Warren Buffet and Bill Gates feel like they aren’t paying enough taxes, why don’t they contribute more voluntarily!?
By Kay Mitchell on 05/01/2008 3:53 pm
Mahulda Fite
You know Kay, here is another thing that makes me mad and I don’t get mad easily. The idea that “AllessonO” puts forth that “you should be glad your rich”. It makes it sound like being rich is just something that happens to you—like eye or hair color. Well only if you come from a weathly family. All the “rich” people I ever knew worked hard to become rich and they have every right to keep their money. And most of them were the most generous people I ever knew, since they came from humble beginnings themselves, they never forgot what it was like to have nothing.
By Mahulda Fite on 05/01/2008 7:35 pm
Bella Mia
One of the new ideas presented is by John McCain to increase the dependent exemption from $3500 to $7000. That means for each dependent family member, taxpayers can deduct $7000 from their gross income. That would be fabulous for the poor, and the working poor, and the middle class.
By Bella Mia on 04/30/2008 1:37 pm
im p
Holy Moly… a Democrat complaining about high taxes. If you think taxes are high now… wait until they pass universal health care!!! I’m 72 years old and get $703 per month from Social Security after they take out the premium for my Medicare benefits. Wonder what I’ll have left from SS when they deduct for Universal Health Care.
By im p on 04/30/2008 1:44 pm
Deni G
President Cinton made Targeted tax, cuts while paying down the debt. something Republicans used to advocate.. Bush is the only president in history to give tax cuts during war time, something we cannot afford. But if he was taxing us, there would be tea in the harbor, daily. Clinton created a budget surplus from what Ronald Regan left (which was the biggest deficit in history to that point). Bush has taken Clinton’s surplus and created what dwarfs any deficit, that people could have even imagined. Bad fiscal management is what we have gotten from the Republicans. The Government has grown, peopled with incompetent stupid, selfish cronies and invaded our daily lives, at an exponential rate. Our infrastructure is falling apart, China is buying up our debt and we have absolutely no voice in where our taxes go.. Teatime in the Habor, Indeed!
By Deni G on 04/30/2008 2:36 pm
mary lou s
im p, they won’t deduct any more for universal health care than they do now for medicare.
By mary lou s on 04/30/2008 7:11 pm
Frau Quink
Hi All, I don’t mind paying taxes, because nothing comes for free, and I’m ‘small fry’. What I object to is the fact that people have to have several jobs to make ends meet, and they have no insurance coverage, especially the children. I find it inexcusable that the richest country on earth cannot insure people. It also bothers me that young people graduate from college and start out their lives being so much in debt. It’s not right. I hope Obama will do something about this….
By Frau Quink on 04/30/2008 1:45 pm
Judith Burnside
How can Obama or anyone else do something about the mind set of most americans, including college kids, that they need everything, now and are entitled. What happened to the starter home, the second hand car, the hand me down furniture, and the attitude of our society that not having it all right away is OK, not that some how if you’re poor you’re bad?
By Judith Burnside on 04/30/2008 6:08 pm
Julia Nemeth
Not all college kids feel entitled: I can attest to that. My friends and I all graduated college and are now five years later either living with our parents or renting, driving the same car we got in high school, and using the same furniture we bought for our college apartments from the thrift store. We can’t afford a new car, or a used one, because we can barely afford rent, gasoline, food, etc. We can’t buy homes because no one will give a 100% loan now, and we can’t save money because our student loans are eating away at our income. Our income won’t grow because bachelors degrees are now a dime-a-dozen in the higher paying industries so we have to go back to school to get our masters, only then employers don’t hire us because we have no real job experience. We’re delaying starting families because we can’t afford them, meaning we’ll probably need fertility treatments or adoption proceedings we can’t afford when we get to that point. It’s just an awful situation.
By Julia Nemeth on 06/27/2008 3:19 pm
Liz Seger
I’m here to tell you it’s not any better in Canada or at least in Ontario. I get access fees on the phone bill, I get cable bills that go up almost quarterly . I don’t get any more cable stations but they go up routinely and then you add on the provincial sales tax and the federal goods and services taxes on everything you buy and I mean everything. Whoo hooo I get a rebate of about 80 bucks every quarter for what I spend. I’ll take 320 believe me but it’s everything else that keeps going up and up . And frankly it rankles me that the super wealthy up here get tax breaks all over the place as do coroporations but then they all complain about how the poor people are bringing the economy down and it’s our fault we’re in poverty. Makes me want to scream. So I hear ya Whoopi and everyone else. Protesting about it , talking about it , writing your MP doesn’t do a darn thing. It sure makes you go hmmmmm though.
By Liz Seger on 04/30/2008 1:52 pm