Sign in to wowOwow

Enter the email address that you used when registering at wowOwow.
The password field is case sensitive. Click here if you have forgotten your password.

Please register for wowOwow

Newsletter subscriptions
Sign up to receive wowOwow's weekly newsletter and get our best picks delivered right to your inbox. Our newsletter content is hand-picked by the wowOwow editorial team and provides the top features, news, and commentary from our site. Subscribing to our newsletter is free and safe. We will never share your email or other information with a third-party without your direct consent.
By registering, you indicate that you have read and agree
with our privacy policy and terms of service.

Conversation | 04/30/2008 12:00 am

Whoopi: Why Isn't Anyone Screaming About Taxes?

© Shutterstock

WHOOPI: I am outraged. I’m outraged. I looked at my cable bill. I looked at my phone bill. And there are taxes on there … it goes anywhere from $10 to $15 a month that I’m paying for stuff I don’t know. There are letters — the LMNOPQ fund of the jacka-jacka … and no one says, “The what!?” And when you think about it, it’s every month that you’re paying it. So it’s ten bucks here or fifteen bucks here or twenty-five dollars there.

Then you’re writing out — they take the 50 percent of your income and it goes to God knows where. When I first started working I said, “OK. I don’t mind paying out because I know it’s going to go for some stuff I hate, and some stuff that I like.” But I’m looking and I see my friends who haven’t done as well as I have financially. You know, they’ve got kids, they’ve got house payments, they’ve got mortgages. They’ve got gas to put in their cars. Friends who are putting, you know, in a 500 gallon or 2500 gallon tank — they’re only taking 50 gallons of oil because they can’t afford it! They can’t afford it. I don’t understand why —

LIZ: Well, it’s pretty discouraging when Congress keeps doing these earmarks where they consign millions of dollars to stupid things like, you know, “We’ll study the button,” or “We’ll study ladybugs,” or something. Or they build these bridges to nowhere in Alaska. And then you do resent paying your taxes when that’s happening.

WHOOPI: I don’t mind paying them. I resent this idea that everything I do now is taxed. And I get no bang for my buck. I feel like I want to just dump tea in the river, because there’s no representation. And if I’m bitching about this, I can’t imagine what somebody who’s just living, literally, paycheck to paycheck is going through. Because there’s no government agency that says, “You know what? We’re going to pay this much to the oil company so that everybody can get the oil.”

LIZ: Well, I don’t believe we’re ever going to get rid of big taxes as long as America is in the industrial munitions manufacture business. And that’s the business the government is in — is constantly making these war machines and then they go obsolete and they junk billions of dollars worth of ‘em. And they just go on and on. And I don’t know. I know we have to protect ourselves, but —

WHOOPI: Here’s what started it, just so you guys know.

JOAN: Yes, let’s hear.

WHOOPI: I had a radio program, which did not work out. Very smartly, I was in a pay-or-play deal. So everybody said, “You know what? This isn’t working. But, yes, we know we still have to pay you.” They were supposed to give me my lump sum. Well it turns out that you can no longer be given a lump sum without 10 or 15 percent being taken out — as a penalty …

JOAN: As a penalty.

WHOOPI: … for getting paid a lump sum.

LIZ: Well, that makes no sense.

WHOOPI: It makes no sense. And what you have to do is you have to then defer the other half of your money. So you can take some now and then you can’t take it for another year.

LIZ: And then the company disappears and you never get it.

WHOOPI: Well, yeah. Or they go under. I said to the guy, “Who made this law? Did anybody put it on the books to discuss it?” No. This went into law about a year ago. If you’re getting ready to get paid a lump sum, you have a 20 percent tax on it — tax on top of the 50 percent they already took.

LESLEY: What always surprises me is when you see these people on Wall Street just cleaning up. Did you see the story the other day where these hedge fund owners — in this crisis and this recession that we’re in — in this Wall Street debacle, are making 3.5 billion dollars? And they’re the ones fighting taxes. They don’t —

JOAN: And they’re the ones that don’t pay the taxes!

101 Reader Comments (so far…) Sign In or Register to comment

Mahulda Fite
My son pays a lot more in taxes than I do, but he won’t get anything. That just isn’t fair. My friends are complaining that they won’t get anything either, but they didn’t pay any taxes. I try to explain that this is like a tax rebate, if you didn’t pay any taxes, why should you get any back?
By Mahulda Fite on 04/30/2008 4:08 pm
Pamela Munro
Most of the taxes I pay personally come in forms similar to the ones Whoopi mentions (drives my husband crazy when he sees the bill, too!)…and then of course, there is sales tax. I believe that those taxes are called regressive, because they fall harder on the poor than the more well-to-do. I had a millionaire uncle, now deceased, who didn’t give a damn what happened to the commonweal, as long as he had his - & could take it to an off-shore island if he so chose. I fear that too many influential people in this country feel the same way. They don’t feel any responsibility to the country which allowed them their success. How many houses and how much moneoy lying around do those folks really NEED? In some European countries like Germany, the taxes are high - but they give you health care, real unemployment help and there are facilities for the aged, infirm and mentally ill. Very few homeless people on the streets there. And most of the Germans consider it a fair deal. Our infrasturcture is crumbling - our ER units are faltering. Just one big gun is going to have to DIE of a heart attack or something similar because all the emergency rooms around downtown have been eliminated - before funding is restored. Just as bridges have to fail before we invest on the infrastructure. We should be ashamed at the nation’s overweaning venality. It’s been years in coming, but the middle class is finally hurting from the bites of health insurance and gas prices, to name a few issues. Hopefully, it will get people to WAKE UP and get their government to work for THEM, the majority, who made this a great country - and not a few hedge fund holders and armament manufacturers and other financial finaglers.
By Pamela Munro on 04/30/2008 5:04 pm
Julia Nemeth
In some European countries, healthcare is free, but you have to bring your own sheets, pillows, blankets, plates, utensils, bedclothes to the hospital. If you don’t tip out the nurses, they won’t change your bedpan. Even if you do tip them out, but you have no visitors, you’ll still sit in your own pile of stink for many hours. At the doctor’s office, if you don’t slip a high-value bill into the pocket of the receptionist, nurse and doctor, you will sit in a cold hallway only to be told they are no longer accepting patients and to come back the next day. The mentally ill are not treated or rehabilitated, but locked into cold white institutions until they kill themselves or die. The homeless often lie in hospitals because corrupt policemen beat the living-daylights out of them for fun. Real unemployment means you get a job managing the public restrooms, handing out strips of toilet paper for change and cleaning up the feces people smear on the walls because they were too cheap to buy your toilet paper. But yeah, you’re right they “give you health care, real unemployment help and there are facilities for the aged, infirm and mentally ill.”
By Julia Nemeth on 06/28/2008 1:06 am
Judith Burnside
We treat candidates for office to a hot seat that keeps the truly competent from running, then we elect the least repugnant person and send them to Washington to make laws and say how our taxes should be spent. Maybe we should stop having Federal income tax at all and do it all county by county so no one group of scoundrels can get their mitts in the till. We have to balance our need for more stuff and more oil and more of everything with the enviroment we are leaving for our children and grandchildren.
By Judith Burnside on 04/30/2008 5:59 pm
Emcye Edwards
Much of this thinking - regarding restructuring our economic valuation system - has been done. By a woman. Hazel Henderson created The Calvert-Henderson Quality of Life Indicators to give us a new way of measuring macro-economic value; far more humanistic and encompassing than the tired old GNP. http://www.calvert-henderson.com/ She describes it as : “A systems approach is used to illustrate the dynamic state of our social, economic and environmental quality of life. The dimensions of life examined include: education, employment, energy, environment, health, human rights, income, infrastructure, national security, public safety, re-creation and shelter.” http://www.hazelhenderson.com/ It all begins with restructuring the way we valuate key factors that allow all people, including the dispossessed - to thrive. Every mother with more than one kids knows all about this. Negotiating for fairness. Women’s thinking needs to lead the way on economic and cultural issues. We were nice, we let the guys try it. Time’s up. This ain’t no rodeo, George - and you run out-ta rope. Innovation: ya gotta want it, babe. As we stop and look around, it’s clear that everything in our world: our bras, our houses, our tax bills started as somebody’s idea. Look at the Web. It represents a huge cognitive surplus; time formerly spent doing what? Gotta want it, babe.
By Emcye Edwards on 04/30/2008 6:34 pm
Charles Dance
thank you for the question and especially for the answers.
By Charles Dance on 04/30/2008 7:08 pm
Andy C
We ARE screaming! We’ve been screaming. Does anyone hear or care? I seem to remember a president saying “Read my lips, no new taxes”……….hmmmm That was a lot of new taxation ago. Screaming, voting, whatever; what can really be done? So frustrating to see people who worked hard all their lives who are now trying so hard to simply keep their heads above water. Taxes, health care, gasoline prices, mortgage rates, groceries; it’s frightening.
By Andy C on 04/30/2008 7:21 pm
DL L
Thank you Whoopi for starting a much needed conversation. We need to start paying attention to what our politicians are doing and letting them know when we are not happy with decisions they are making, at state and federal level. Living in Rhode Island, I am well acquainted with closed door meetings and back room deals. Why aren’t people making a stink. It’s business as usual, and people don’t seem to care.
By DL L on 04/30/2008 8:36 pm
Brooklyn Gal
Whoopie is correct when she talks about being paid in lump sums and having more taken out in taxes. This hurts employees who are paid bi-weekly. But what I don’t understand is why it is important to punish the middle class who invest or save small sums of money by taking away their dividends and interest at tax time. Aren’t we investing in the economy when we purchase shares? Aren’t we giving banks more reserve so they can make the necessary loans for tuition and small-business loans when we deposit our earnings? It seems our earnings are getting double taxed. Every time there is a change in the tax law, the bottom line—I’m screwed. Yet today Forbes reported that the worst CEO’s in America are collecting millions of dollars a year for being lousy managers. Oh yeah, they donate big bucks to the politicians that make these tax laws.
By Brooklyn Gal on 04/30/2008 11:04 pm
DL L
it’s of, for and by big corporations, most of our polititicians are in their back pockets.
By DL L on 05/01/2008 7:02 pm
C A Rose
Ok, my turn to rant. I don’t pay taxes because I live on SSDI, which by the way is less than $11,000 per year. I still have to pay my co-pays in my Medicare Advantage Plan because I make too much money to qualify for my state’s version of medical assistance. I am too wealthy to get a regular person’s food stamp allotment, so I get $109 per month for food. For that, I have to provide a copy of every receipt for everything I spend my great wealth on. Here’s the topper…you know that $300 folks can submit a non-tax paying persons tax form to get, if I did so I would have to count it as income for my next recertification for food stamps, and would probably have them reduced by 20%. Think about it, if you are a tax payer in this country and you get a tax rebate check you will have to declare it as earned income for 2008. Those incentive checks coming in the mail will have to be declared as income as well. Who’s kidding who here?
By C A Rose on 05/01/2008 12:47 am
Kathleen E Lo Pinto VIgnolini
Boy have you asked the right question! Why aren’t we walking, yelling and screaming, on DC about the tax structure? I think most of us agree, taxes are OK - BUT - within reason, please! Maybe a million taxpayer march would do it? (Course, we’d need to do it in each State too.) When we were in the military, I was appalled to find that Prez. Nixon, with an income of $200,000, paid LESS taxes than we did, making $6,000 annual income! (And he had more free “perks” too!) Unfortunately, it’s still that way. Today in some states, ALL items in a grocery store are taxed, foods included! With all the sales taxes, lopped on top of Federal & State Income taxes, & State property taxes - we are footing the bill for corporate America! Look at the severance packages for “retiring CEO’s” - in the millions! (Bet they don’t pay the “lump sum” tax, they have lawyers & CPA’s to insure they don’t! the poor in the south (north, east, west & middle can’t afford that.) Kay, I can’t believe you believe that drivel! We ARE in the predicament we are now - because we have “let the market operate freely” for decades! Deregulation led to the junk bonds & Enron debacle, the mortgage crisis, and on and on. And hedge funds only help those who deal them! Even Mr Buffet calls for more regulation on business, and fair share payment of taxes. I am part of the St Vincent de Paul society. You can’t tell me that the poor are that way, because they can’t manage their money! We have several who come to us for help who’s jobs went overseas, and most others work 2 and 3 jobs. Yet, the “Yuppy-ing” of our city leaves them broke. Rising costs of rent and utilities, higher food and clothing costs and the insult of increasingly high taxes - brings them to us for help. More charities, like the food banks, are turning people away - because we’re taxed and priced out of the ability to share. All the while our GNP is based on the “futures” and “commodities” of a very fickle Stock market - RATHER than on the productivity of our citizenry. Liz, that “bridge” you mentioned is nothing more than a boon for the AK Senator & his ilk. I lived in AK, Liz. Did you know, that Alaskans voted - 4 times - to move it’s capitol closer to where 90 % of the people lived? The politicians didn’t want it, because then people might be able to get to them, and voice their descent on issues! So why should he, or any of them on Capitol Hill pay attention to the Senator who asked him, out loud, in session, to give the idea up “his” bridge, in order to fix the one between Miss. & Louisiana that was destroyed by Katrina!!! Because it doesn’t benefit them!!! Call me cynical, but after 50 years if watching politicians & businesses lie in bed together, for their own benefit, has made me so. Kathleen E LPV
By Kathleen E Lo Pinto VIgnolini on 05/01/2008 1:37 am
Brooklyn Gal
Kathleen’s story reflects those of many Americans. The red-tape and rules do nothing to help Americans who need it. I am torn on this gas-tax issue because while it does not really give the “average” American much of a tax break, that $10 savings can help other families pay for milk and bread. There are many Americans who need their car to make a living. I am a fan of The Onion and a friend sent me this clip showing how hard it is for “the rich” to make ends meet. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TQt2cyzsHYg&NR=1
By Brooklyn Gal on 05/01/2008 11:06 am
Maurine H
The gas tax “holiday” is a ruse. First McCain, now Clinton, trying to make a silk purse out of a sow’s ear. I was intrigued by the idea until I went on-line and read some of the economists’ commentaries and realized that we are being had by this illogical- and, in the long run, costly- come-on. There’s a good, understandable discussion on http://marketplace.publicradio.org/display/web/2008/04/17/burman_comment…. Basically, when something sounds too good to be true, it usually is.
By Maurine H on 05/01/2008 11:40 am
Brooklyn Gal
I am inclined to agree with you. It’s politics like this that hurts Clinton’s campaign. Is it that she does not think things through or just wants the sound bite? Every time she has a good chance of getting ahead in the polls, she says something that brings her back down. I do believe she will pander to any group and hopes something sticks. Since McCain also endorses the program, it will not hurt her if she is the nominee. However, I would like to know which of the taxes that are tacked onto our utility bills are really necessary. I don’t see improvements in our infrastructure especially after a very long blackout that ruined a Queen’s neighborhood during a heat wave. Our electric company was very disrespectful to those who needed repairs, especially the elderly and disabled. Now the electric company is giving residents and businesses $100 each to compensate for their struggles. Not nearly enough to cover their losses. I bet they will be taxed on that little ditty too.
By Brooklyn Gal on 05/01/2008 1:20 pm