A Friend Stopped By | 10/13/2009 4:00 am
Raise Your Hand if Two Arms Aren't Enough, by Allegra Huston
How evolution let us down.

© Shutterstock
Editor’s Note: Allegra Huston’s new book, Love Child: A Memoir of Family Lost and Found, hit bookstores last spring. Allegra is the youngest daughter of film director John Huston and sister of Oscar-winning actress Anjelica Huston. She was born in London, raised in Ireland and Los Angeles, and now lives in Taos, NM. She was a publisher in London for nine years and has been a freelance writer and editor since 1994.
Do you drop things all the time? I do. Mainly keys. Sometimes a book, a sweater, a cell phone. That’s not a good thing to drop.Do you worry that this is a sign of ageing: an autumn sneak peek at the winter blockbuster "Crippling Arthritis"? Are you haunted by the thought that this might be the dreaded Dr. Parkinson whispering, "Pleased to meet you," with a ghostly handshake?
Un-knit that fevered brow. I have figured it out. This business of dropping things is due to age only in the cosmic sense. I blame evolution.
That first fish that crawled onto land: It should have been an octopus. I have been told, patiently, that then we wouldn’t have spines. But I honestly don’t see why we couldn’t have evolved spines if we wanted to stand up. With eight arms, we might never have wanted to.
Does anyone really think two arms are enough? For soccer, perhaps, as long as you’re not playing in goal. For tennis, on those days when you’ve got eager children to retrieve the balls. Now imagine the exponential increase in excitement if the Lakers had 40 arms between them. How about a lover with merely four?
Two arms are pitifully inadequate for the tasks of everyday life. Here is a picture of me, getting ready to leave the house. Spear my arm through the handles of my handbag: Great, I still have two hands. Balance the zip-up binder that we call the portable office of Los Rios River Runners in the crook of my elbow. The dry cleaning on top of that. Oh – my water bottle; I can hook it over my pinkie. But wait: I haven’t filled it. I can hold it out with my other hand, but I can’t reach the tap with my chin. Everything down; everything up again. Hmm, it seems to be clouding over. I’d better take a sweater for my son. "I’m hungry," he says, though he’s just eaten breakfast, so I grab a fruit rollup. I’m contorting myself trying to lock the front door … and here it comes: I drop the keys.
Now, how is that my fault? I’m even trying to be ecological, kicking reusable shopping bags toward the car and turning off lights with my elbows on the way out.
My niece recently went for an interview to study anthropology at the University of London, and was asked by the professor to name something that evolution couldn’t explain. "Sid Vicious," she answered brilliantly off the top of her head, and got in. My answer would have been babies. Specifically with reference to arms.
Chimpanzee babies grab on to their mother’s fur and ride under her belly until they’re old enough to ride on her back. In the millennia between the time when we lost our fur and the invention of the Baby Bjorn, a baby required half its mother’s available arms – and this, while hunting and gathering and running from saber-toothed tigers. When was the last time you tried to hunt or gather with only one arm? It’s astonishing that our species didn’t become extinct.
Evolution, we are told, produced the staggeringly complex eye in incremental stages, each of which conferred an infinitesimal advantage. Are we honestly to believe that no living creature ever sprouted a growth that could have increased the stock in the arm department, and that the proto-limb wouldn’t have added more to the sum of human happiness – by providing, say, something to hang things on – than those first light-sensitive cells? It’s ludicrous. It’s enough to turn one into a creationist.























6 Reader Comments (so far…) Sign In or Register to comment
Aren’t guys already accused of being octopuses? ;-)
I prefer being a tool-user to having extra limbs.
Think how long it would take to get dressed…
Where do you put all the extra elbows in an airplane or a movie theater?
In a perfect universe, Shiva and Darga would have a child, a god/goddess, with 12 arms. His four, her eight. Although I’m not sure 12 would suffice at this point. Not with all the computer gadgets we have to carry along with everything else.
Now I agree with you…
Shakira
Desperate Housewives