Dear Margo | 04/08/2009 11:00 pm
Dear Margo: Tired of the Doghouse
He scarred his marriage by having an emotional affair … Margo Howard’s bright advice
Tired of the Doghouse
DEAR MARGO: My wife and I have been married for seven years, most of which have been wonderful. But now I fear our relationship is broken, and it is my fault. After many years of failing to have children, in 2006 we adopted a wonderful little boy. However, in the months leading up to the adoption I committed an indiscretion by becoming emotionally involved with a female co-worker. I turned to her for consolation while my wife was out of the country working on the adoption, and we became very close. I was never technically unfaithful, but the relationship was inappropriate and I knew it. I told my wife about it. She urged me to break it off, but I didn’t, and when she found out it was very painful.
I have had no contact with this other woman for the past 18 months and have assured my wife that I will never see her again (she no longer works with me). Unfortunately, my wife does not trust me anymore. If I need to work late or have a client dinner, she becomes suspicious and angry. I always tell her where I am and who I am with, and I keep my cell on so she can call me, but this doesn’t seem to be enough. When I try to talk to her about her feelings, she invariably clams up. If I press her, she becomes borderline abusive, making remarks about my appearance and habits that are very hurtful. I know I let her down, but I feel I have gone the extra mile to make it up to her. How long should it take for someone to forgive an indiscretion if she says she loves you? —- SEEKING FORGIVENESS
DEAR SEEK: Your mea culpa sounds heartfelt, though you clearly have much to be culpa about. Confessing and then refusing to break it off may be what you’re paying for now. Because your wife will not discuss her anger and lashes out at you while affirming her love, perhaps the question to ask her is how long she wants to live this way? To break this cycle I would suggest counseling for her — with or without you. Aided by professional guidance, time is a great healer, even when it involves a guy who has been a heel. —- MARGO, OPTIMISTICALLY
In Sickness and in Health, but Not in Bed
DEAR MARGO: I consider my best friend to be my "platonic soul mate" — like my brother, only closer. He’s a gay male, I’m a straight female; no romantic interest, but a deep and meaningful love nonetheless. We talk about raising children together, but adopting in many states requires the adopting parents to be married — which is fine. Would it be considered duping friends and family to have a real wedding? —- WANTING TO DO THE RIGHT THING
DEAR WANT: I doubt that you would be duping anyone, and I’m sure your friends would wish you well. Gay people marry straight people all the time for a number of reasons — and sometimes even without their knowledge! If you’ve decided you do not wish to marry a straight man and have your heart set on making a family with your close friend, it’s fine with me. There are many ways to live a life. Good luck. —- MARGO, ALTERNATIVELY
Got a question for "Dear Margo?" Send via e-mail to dearmargo@creators.com.
DEAR MARGO: My wife and I have been married for seven years, most of which have been wonderful. But now I fear our relationship is broken, and it is my fault. After many years of failing to have children, in 2006 we adopted a wonderful little boy. However, in the months leading up to the adoption I committed an indiscretion by becoming emotionally involved with a female co-worker. I turned to her for consolation while my wife was out of the country working on the adoption, and we became very close. I was never technically unfaithful, but the relationship was inappropriate and I knew it. I told my wife about it. She urged me to break it off, but I didn’t, and when she found out it was very painful.
I have had no contact with this other woman for the past 18 months and have assured my wife that I will never see her again (she no longer works with me). Unfortunately, my wife does not trust me anymore. If I need to work late or have a client dinner, she becomes suspicious and angry. I always tell her where I am and who I am with, and I keep my cell on so she can call me, but this doesn’t seem to be enough. When I try to talk to her about her feelings, she invariably clams up. If I press her, she becomes borderline abusive, making remarks about my appearance and habits that are very hurtful. I know I let her down, but I feel I have gone the extra mile to make it up to her. How long should it take for someone to forgive an indiscretion if she says she loves you? —- SEEKING FORGIVENESS
DEAR SEEK: Your mea culpa sounds heartfelt, though you clearly have much to be culpa about. Confessing and then refusing to break it off may be what you’re paying for now. Because your wife will not discuss her anger and lashes out at you while affirming her love, perhaps the question to ask her is how long she wants to live this way? To break this cycle I would suggest counseling for her — with or without you. Aided by professional guidance, time is a great healer, even when it involves a guy who has been a heel. —- MARGO, OPTIMISTICALLY
In Sickness and in Health, but Not in Bed
DEAR MARGO: I consider my best friend to be my "platonic soul mate" — like my brother, only closer. He’s a gay male, I’m a straight female; no romantic interest, but a deep and meaningful love nonetheless. We talk about raising children together, but adopting in many states requires the adopting parents to be married — which is fine. Would it be considered duping friends and family to have a real wedding? —- WANTING TO DO THE RIGHT THING
DEAR WANT: I doubt that you would be duping anyone, and I’m sure your friends would wish you well. Gay people marry straight people all the time for a number of reasons — and sometimes even without their knowledge! If you’ve decided you do not wish to marry a straight man and have your heart set on making a family with your close friend, it’s fine with me. There are many ways to live a life. Good luck. —- MARGO, ALTERNATIVELY
Dear Margo is written by Margo Howard, Ann Landers’ daughter. All letters must be sent via e-mail to dearmargo@creators.com. Due to a high volume of e-mail, not all letters will be answered. To read more about Margo Howard, click here.
COPYRIGHT 2009 MARGO HOWARD
DISTRIBUTED BY CREATORS SYNDICATE, INC.
Every Thursday and Friday, you can find "Dear Margo" and her latest words of wisdom on our home page at www.wowowow.com. Or better yet, click to sign up for an instant email alert that will send a message right to your in-box every time a new "Dear Margo" column is posted on wowOwow. Just click here for instant sign up.
Click here for all "Dear Margo" columns.Got a question for "Dear Margo?" Send via e-mail to dearmargo@creators.com.
Read more about: Cheating, Dating, Dear Margo, Family, Gay, Gay Marriage, Margo Howard, Marriage, Relationships

























80 Reader Comments (so far…) Sign In or Register to comment
i saw the almost exact same "In Sickness and in Health, but Not in Bed"in a dear abby column. http://www.uexpress.com/dearabby/?uc_full_date=20090126
I read both your articles
I read that as well. I guess "wanting to do the right thing" sent her letter to all of the columnists? Maybe to see who’s advice she likes the best?
I wonder if anyone has read it in "Annie’s Mailbox".
how would this affect children? can’t be worse than children having to deal with broken homes, unwed mothers and daycare. we never thought my grandson would adapt to being with daddy half weeks and mommy half weeks, but he has adapted excellently. it’s been the both families that have had to put up with more. at first he was a little confused but now he looks forward to each time he gets with each family and is pretty darn spoiled by it. he also gets strong parenting by both families and we all work together to be consistant. i’m sure if they are open about it i don’t see why it should be a big deal. are you oppsed to ALL gay marriage or JUST this type of gay-straight marriage? at least both parents are in the home. as opposed to our situation where they will NEVER be in the same home and someday will have to deal with step-parents and possible half brothers and sisters or step brothers and sisters.
if they provide a happy, loving home with discipline and when the children are old enough to understand that they tell them what is going on i don’t see how it matters. i think if they like it, i love it~
" How many psychologists think it is healthy for people to engage in this type of relationship?"
So what is healthier- two married, straight people who are abusive to their children, or two people with an unconventional relationship who are raising their children to love, respect, and tolerate themselves and others?
Tough call.
There is also the possibility that they send it to multiple columnists because they do not know if one will print it or reply. I know you at least try to reply to every letter you get (you replied to me on two different occasions when I wrote, one for advise and the other in response to someone else’s letter, though neither were ever printed, and I thank you for that.). But some columnists do not reply to the letters they do not print (I had that happen several years ago), or that get edited out in certain newspapers, but appear in whole online. But if someone does not read advice columns online, they might never see their letter appear.
It is simple, I know. But when you are in need of advice, and there is a columnist you like, and you do not know if they will answer, sometimes a person might try to hedge their bets a bit by sending it out to several in hopes that at least one will answer…
Great advice on both today, btw!