Sign in to wowOwow

Enter the email address that you used when registering at wowOwow.
The password field is case sensitive. Click here if you have forgotten your password.

Please register for wowOwow

Newsletter subscriptions
Sign up to receive wowOwow's weekly newsletter and get our best picks delivered right to your inbox. Our newsletter content is hand-picked by the wowOwow editorial team and provides the top features, news, and commentary from our site. Subscribing to our newsletter is free and safe. We will never share your email or other information with a third-party without your direct consent.
By registering, you indicate that you have read and agree
with our privacy policy and terms of service.

A Friend Stopped By | 06/15/2009 12:00 am

My Father Fought for a 'Bonus Plan' of $264.17, by the Author of On Moving

A daughter recalls her machinist father’s poignant quest to earn a fair pension along with the white-collar ‘professionals’ who raked in huge rewards.
By Louise DeSalvo
Amazon

Editor’s Note: Louise DeSalvo is a writer, professor, lecturer and scholar who lives in New Jersey. She has written several books, including a memoir — On Moving: A Writer’s Meditation on New Houses, Old Haunts, and Finding Home Again — which takes a unique look at the pain, hope and turmoil involved in moving.

"Louise, can you help me?" This from my father, who never asked me for help. I was a senior in college, and my father wanted me to help him write a letter to his boss, asking to enroll in a pension plan – my father called it a "bonus plan" – reserved, he’d been told, for "professionals."

My father wasn’t considered a "professional." So, unlike the engineers he worked with, he wasn’t eligible. But my father was a highly skilled machinist, and his job – in a prestigious research facility – was to make working test models of ships, submarines and racing yachts from engineers’ crude plans. My father’s work was so highly regarded that when National Geographic ran an article about the facility, he’d been chosen to appear in a photo. But the rules were the rules. Engineers got pension plans; machinists didn’t.

Winning meant more to him than just money. He believed he’d proven his worth.

I sat at our dining-room table at my portable typewriter as my father told me his story. Years later I learned why he couldn’t write the letter himself: He’d stopped attending school in the eighth grade; he was dyslexic; he couldn’t spell. But he was smart, curious, well-read, hard working and he’d been a conscientious, loyal employee for 15 years.

My father earned less than I did at 16 in my first summer job. He knew he was underpaid for his work, and he believed he was entitled to a pension. After he retired he’d be living on Social Security, and he needed a pension to supplement that sum. Criteria for determining who received pensions were inconsistent; no one had adequately defined the meaning of "professional." Men like him who didn’t get yearly bonuses reserved for the "higher ups," as my father called them, couldn’t possibly save for their retirement. Yet without my father’s work, the research facility couldn’t function: "You can’t test a ship without a model," my father said. "Those damn engineers," he’d told my mother. "I spend half my time fixing what they screw up."

My father didn’t want to pressure his employers about their "moral obligation" to him. But he wanted what was fair.

My father won his case. He was granted a pension – not as much, surely, as the engineers. But something.

Winning meant more to him than just money. He believed he’d proven his worth. Still, he understood that the work of men like him wasn’t equitably rewarded.

"My life’s been worthless." This from my father during the last lucid week of his life. "I’m a member of a dying breed. No one has any use for men like me anymore, men who make things." Through the years, he’s tracked plant closings. Whenever I see him, he reports how many working men and women have lost their jobs since we last met. The cause, he believes, is a lack of vision, poor management, greed. He can’t understand why executives in these failing corporations earn so much money, can take home so many millions in bonuses. "Hell," he says, "if I did my job as poorly as they did theirs, I would have been sent packing, without so much as a ‘fair thee well.’"

I find a copy of my father’s letter as I’m cleaning out his papers five years after his death. He’s saved it for 43 years, and this lets me know how much my writing it meant to him. I find it as millions of dollars in bonuses are given to AIG employees. I also find a monthly statement listing earnings from the "bonus plan" my father fought for: $264.17.

39 Reader Comments (so far…) Sign In or Register to comment

C jay
SN, it’s simple math, just look at the CEOs salary, (and those of the board members!!!!) and that of the highest paid staffers - true, it’s a public accounting formula but it doesn’t take a rocket scientist to realize the fish rot from the head down.
By C jay on 06/20/2009 11:01 pm
C jay

Laureen, as my wise grandfather said, "We did it because we could do it; that is no longer possible, and it is going to be impossible by the new millennium… " As usual, he was correct. They felt if a home and a piano could be purchased they were well off, and working 8-5 with time off for lunch was the way life should be. At the same time, I’ve gone back and looked at the salaries of his chairman, then, and believe me, it was nothing like the vast difference we have today. And, any corporate or utility chairman who would have sent work to the "outer islands" and not hired locally would have been shot in the square (no pun intended). Every family takes care of its own before help others, as it should be, and every nation must be forced to do the same. America has yet to return to that mentality, and we have yet to win any war!

Someone recently mentioned the senate, herein - does anyoneadmire the senate’s vote to release billions more to Afghanistan, and more? Are the senators representing the people? NO. Oust them. If we don’t we are complicit.

 

 

By C jay on 06/20/2009 10:48 pm
Kris Merrill
Louise, Your father’s story touches my heart and soul. I am so proud of being  an American and your Dad’s life was spent in being EXCELLENT. When the harpies of the right wing descend on this page, I pity them for their self righteous welfare mentality and  I wonder if we can rear another generation of real Americans who see a problem and care enough to get  out there and  work hard, and open their hearts to the goodness which our (LIBERAL) fore -fathers fought so hard to pass onto us. GOD bless America and never let us spend our time whining and criticising. There are so many challenge ahead of us. And that is a gift!
By Kris Merrill on 06/15/2009 9:56 pm
Mary Anderson
Them that controls the money, controls the salaries.  They get theirs first and rest can "eat cake".  If someone takes the risk and starts a company, then more power to them and their profits. If a person is just a "hired hand", I think there should be a formula that the lowest paid position should be paid a certain percentage of the highest paid position, with graduating percentage down the ranks but the lowest paid position should be earning a living wage.  It won’t happen, but I think it would be more fair.
By Mary Anderson on 06/16/2009 2:52 pm
Karen R

Henry Ford didn’t promote a specific ratio but he recognized that his employees would also be his customers if they could afford to buy what they built - that paying all well would be a win-win situation.

Peter Drucker, the management guru of his day, believed the gap should be no greater than 25-to1, and that 20-to1 was even more appropriate. He recognized that large pay gaps corrode companies. If executives wanted higher pay they would have to manage in such a way that the average pay of the entire company could be raised.

http://www.druckerinstitute.com/showpage.aspx?Section=RP&PageID=47

Modern management, however, just brushes aside such philosophies as outdated and detrimental.

By Karen R on 06/17/2009 1:08 pm
Mark Rowe

Yes, corporations today are attacking there employees. Yes, the very people who are making there products! It is one of the many reasons why "made in America" is not quality any more.

Now I will tell you my experience with Alcoa. They bought the company I was working for. It was a very honorable place to work when the French owned it. But after 23 years there, with only 5 years to retire they attacked me, as well as anyone who was close to retirement. Many lost everything.

I was called into the office of the plant executive head. He told me for no reason at all he was going to get me fired and that there was nothing I could do about it. And after lies from the main office and from the UAW officials, I was forced to quit my job. I was told that they had documents that had my signature on them that I did not sign. This is what is happening in America today in American companies.

By Mark Rowe on 06/16/2009 11:05 pm
C jay

Yes, Mark, and remember Silkwood? The brute in that company who ordered her demise ended up leading a Christian university, as president, no less. Lovely people in America - one hopes the FBI never ceases watching them.

I hate this saying, and I’m certain you do, too, but … "You are better off away from them." Grrrrr We’d all be better off without THEM. I have never hired but 1 person in my career who did not work hard, and often too hard - people are wonderful. Any employer who isn’t grateful for their employees is a sick sociopath without a modicum of conscience.

 

By C jay on 06/20/2009 11:09 pm
christine w

Obviously your father’s life was anything but worthless.  He inspired you, and many others with his simple and honourable approach to work.  He had a special gift of executing the designs of others, many of which are surely still used today.  Thanks for sharing such a moving tribute.

By christine w on 06/17/2009 6:52 pm
C jay
I agree. Few things in life could be as wonderful as looking back on a parent of such widom, and humility, who had the self-esteem to move forward. That is an incredible human, and we all thank you for sharing this inspiring part of your life. We have all learned something new.
By C jay on 06/20/2009 11:11 pm