A Friend Stopped By | 10/01/2009 3:00 am
'Another Outrage,' by Jodie T. Allen
Editor’s note: Jodie T. Allen, former managing and business editor at USNews and Washington editor of Slate magazine, worked at the Washington Post for many years, including as the editor of the Outlook section. She began her career at the Post as a writer on the editorial page.
It is rare that I wish I were back on the dim corridor where I, and a small band of similarly ink-stained wretches, slaved to churn out yet another offering for the morning edition of our newspaper. But when I got wind of the news that the popular American Girls brand had deployed "Gwen," a new doll who purports to be homeless, the old fighting spirit returned.
The debut of little Gwen is precisely the sort of happening that evokes a sigh of editorialist relief at the start of an otherwise daunting day. To begin with, there is in this case no need to do a hasty search for all the relevant background material. One wouldn’t even need to round up the usual sources for comment. Gwen’s story, as described by her maker, is simple. "Like the Chrissa® doll, Gwen arrives in an outfit that’s perfect for playtime: A white eyelet lace dress with embroidered accents; A pink headband that doubles as a belt; Pink underwear; Braided sandals to match."
Hmm, I don’t think I’ve seen many homeless people in white eyelet lace with pink headbands, let alone rosy underwear and matching sandals. That ought to be good for a snide aside or two.
In addition to a "soft cloth body," Gwen is blessed with brown eyes and long, blond hair. Is that supposed to denote that she is multicultural? And where are the required accessories? The purloined supermarket basket filled with moth-eaten blankets and rat-munched clothing? The grating to sleep on and the trash can in which to forage?
But enough irony. At bottom this is a clear instance of something that gladdens the heart of every editorial writer: another outrage! And, what’s more, one that offers ample opportunity for fulmination without the secret worry that one’s cry for reform will go unheeded (as do most editorial page injunctions) and that true harm or suffering will go unredressed. For what could be more appalling than the notion that a well-heeled company is reaping in profits, at the rate of $95 a pop – far beyond the reach of most parents, let alone those who are on the streets – for peddling a product that capitalizes on (never mind trivializes) genuine human suffering. Well I could go on and on, but I think I’ve already got enough words to fill up that space in the left-hand column …

Jodie T. Allen
























84 Reader Comments (so far…) Sign In or Register to comment
I’m not angered or outraged by this story, but I am confused.
Why? is the word that comes to my mind. What purpose does this doll serve and to who? What little girl would want or need this particular doll? And the cost, why? What is it about this doll that warrants such a high price tag?
Gwen offers another pricey doll that Mattel calls "valuable lessons about life." As well as marketing. ( Star Tribune)
So, for just $ 95 your child can get a "valuable lesson" about the homeless by cuddling with unfortunate Gwen. What’s next ? The Sweat Shop Factory doll or the Bulimic Doll ? The Cross Dresser Doll can’t be far behind. That one would come with lots of pricey accessories.
Ok I was really trying to find where this is true - I can’t find any link that goes to American Girls website that gives me Gwen’s background but I can find plenty of articles about it on google and yahoo.
Now if the profits of this doll was going to the homeless I may and that is a BIG may buy the doll for my daughter but since I can’t find where that is going to happen - there is noway in hell I will ever buy Gwen.
Ok - what are these people thinking, or are they not?
B…yes the doll and price tag is real but I was questioning the homeless story. I would think that American Girl would come out and say those rumors are not true but I can’t find anything on the internet about it. I mean the comments about Gwen are mostly positive so she has sold well and she is a very cute doll but personally I can go to walmart and buy my 3 year old a doll that is just as pretty as some of the American Girl dolls.
I have long wanted to have the money to get a doll made that looks like my daughter but I do not have the money to spend on that - maybe one day!