Sign in to wowOwow

Enter the email address that you used when registering at wowOwow.
The password field is case sensitive. Click here if you have forgotten your password.

Please register for wowOwow

Newsletter subscriptions
Sign up to receive wowOwow's weekly newsletter and get our best picks delivered right to your inbox. Our newsletter content is hand-picked by the wowOwow editorial team and provides the top features, news, and commentary from our site. Subscribing to our newsletter is free and safe. We will never share your email or other information with a third-party without your direct consent.
By registering, you indicate that you have read and agree
with our privacy policy and terms of service.

A Friend Stopped By | 04/17/2009 11:00 pm

Why It's Cool to Move Your 94-Year-Old Mother in With You, by Ruth Charny

By Ruth Charny
Ruth Charny/Image: Kimberly Butler

Editor’s note: Ruth Charny’s career as an independent film producer began in 1992 with "Mistress" (starring Robert De Niro, Robert Wuhl, Eli Wallach and Martin Landau). Other film credits include "Grief," "Grace of My Heart," "Searching for Paradise" and "The Yes Men Fix the World," just to name a few. She recently has been consulting for gameLab and developing new projects with Daniel Handler, whose pen name is "Lemony Snicket."

Right off the bat, I’m going to skirt the obvious, which is that these tough financial times will demand radical changes in lifestyle. Necessity is probably the mother of cool, as it is of invention and all other terrific things that probably, if you asked them, would deny they even had a mother. How do you plan for a parent’s future, balancing the good news that they’re living much longer and the bad news that their savings have dwindled to a few shriveled stocks? Out of necessity, it’s likely that extended families, like communal living and public transportation, will enjoy a resurgence of popularity. Tastemakers retroactively will then anoint them cool experiments in group living.

Moving a parent in is an opportunity to avert or correct a regret, and in the process, mend a couple of other missteps along the way.

The problem is parents never are, never were and never will be cool. A priori, they’re not cool. Doesn’t matter what they do, think, wear, listen to, eat, whom they dated or whose name they effortlessly drop. But to be perverse, every parent is a child. In other words, relative to my sons, I may not be cool. But relative to my mother? Perhaps moving her in allows me, contrapuntally, to be cool once again.

President Obama finally put to rest the tired staple of mother-in-law jokes by moving his own into the White House. And VP Biden may be diametrically the uncool to Obama’s cool, until he strides center stage with his 91-year-old live-in mom. And who knew that Hillary Clinton’s mom lived with them in Chappaqua? If it’s cool to show off a genetic pedigree, then so, too, is John McCain.

One element of cool that all of these public figures have in common — and allows them to pal around un-self-consciously with their moms — is confidence. Can confidence be substituted for cool? It’s not so much what you do, but the élan with which you do it. People who are sheepish about public appearances with their parents might as well lack the confidence fundamental to cool!

For whatever reason, the Obamas, Bidens and Clintons don’t seem to reflect the way my contemporaries view having elderly parents move in with them full time. I know this because of the disbelief I heard when I broached the subject with friends and family members. (It’s going to be such a burden. Can’t you make other arrangements?) Their arguments about its impact on my lifestyle — the periodic incontinence, the paraphernalia of old age, the walkers, the wheelchairs, commodes, diapers, bed pads ruining my chic loft — confused me. Pets bring similar inconveniences and yet are photographed lounging insouciantly on expensive daybeds in design magazines, like Dwell. Long ago, I was happy to inherit most of my mother’s mid-twentieth-century modern furniture. Now I’ve inherited her to adorn it. Why doesn’t the sight of her lounging insouciantly across her Herman Miller sectional enchant? The more I was advised against it, the more I wanted to attempt it. It pleases me to consider housing my mother a revolutionary act!

I still need to answer the question of "why not?" What truths were these naysayers counseling me to avoid? Was it that every day I would wake up and old age would be staring me in the face? This was the future that would haunt my dreams? Sugarplum fairies replaced by the decidedly inelegant evidence of physical decrepitude?

Let’s be blunt, the Sugarplum fairies are long gone, replaced by endless regret anyway. Moving a parent in is an opportunity to avert or correct a regret, and in the process of flexing this remedial muscle, to mend a couple of other missteps along the way. Consider it a missed opportunity.

35 Reader Comments (so far…) Sign In or Register to comment

Cheeky Wombat

E.

I too had a mother who cared more about her own happiness than what was happening to her children. My dad enjoyed being a father, but my mom left him for someone else. Our step-dad got too friendly with my sister and I, but my mother chose not to believe us. That relationship also ended. I never confronted her as an adult because I dislike confrontation. I did retain cordial contact with her, but with reticence on my side. Several years ago her current husband died suddenly and she expressed an interest in moving in with my family, or purchasing a trailer to place on our property. I ignored the comment because there was no way she was going to live that close to me. She suddenly died 5 months later and I didn’t have to deal with it. I felt a little guilt for not crying over her death.

My husband also had issues with his mother. She was manic depressive and on medication. She lived with my sister in law for awhile, but then went into assisted living. It was dificult for my husband to deal with her. He loved her, but couldn’t deal with her, as he also was on medication for awhile. I felt, in the issue of both of our mothers, that our marriage and child were more important to preserve than the appearance of a loving relationship with our mothers. Call us spoiled, the me-generation or whatever, but my marriage comes first.

By Cheeky Wombat on 04/18/2009 2:29 pm
E .
Hi Cheeky - the American myth of "mother" creates a mess on so many levels.  Anyone, even an American mommy, can be toxic.  It was a good thing for you to resist submitting your family to the daily reality of life with such a person (and the effect it would have had on you) and very generous to have maintained the relationship throughout her life in spite of her selfishness.  True and selfless love is always most important to protect and preserve - more so than anything an empty Hallmark promise/duty could bring to your life.
By E . on 04/19/2009 1:44 am
L. C.

Cheeky Wombat you made the right decision for your family! … If my experiences mirrored yours I would’ve made the exact decision!

My sentiments were based on the relationship I had with my mom! … We did not agree on everything and had our differences but for the most part ours was a loving relationship! … I miss her! … I did not cry at her funeral because I felt a sense of peace and comfort! … I did everything humanly possible I could for her! … She was 86 when she died 16 years ago! … It was my hiprocrital relatives and siblings who were in hysterics!

It is only logical for you to feel as you do, yours was not a mutually loving and selfless relationship! … I wish you all the best!

By L. C. on 04/19/2009 1:30 pm
Lee Harrison
Ms. Charney’s article is heart warming in a fairy tale kind of way.  The examples (Obamas, Clintons, etc.) all have the resources for very large homes and whatever help may be required.  Who wouldn’t be happy to take in an elderly parent when you can provide him or her with all the comforts and privacy of a grade A assisted living facility?
By Lee Harrison on 04/18/2009 5:30 pm
DeBúrca obj
That’s what I was thinking. Although it is wonderful when it is possible, there is a huge difference between moving and elderly, probably infirm, parent into a fully staffed mansion, or even have lesser resources but enough to room and resources to ease the burden, or to move them into a small or average family home with children, no staff and limited resources. Not that its impossible, but it is definitely a whole different ‘cool’.
By DeBúrca obj on 04/19/2009 7:48 am
Rainbow Power

Those willing and capable of taking in their parents or in-laws are definitely angels. 

After having a loved one in a nursing care facility, I have found these places are wonderful places, but they are not a "home".   It’s my opinion, with two incomes needed in current day families, most children are probably not be able to offer accomodations if the parent needs care of any sort.  End stage disease/illness typically requires more than living accomodations.

The number of people in nursing homes, who never have visits from sons, daughters, sisters, brothers, and other family, is very high according to some statistics I read not long ago.  That is sad.

By Rainbow Power on 04/18/2009 6:01 pm
Jeannot Kensinger

I am lucky, if it comes to the fact that I no longer can take of myself and husband then one daughter has repeatedly said she wants me in her home.Her son will go to college in 4 years and she wants me there, I hope I do not have to do that so soon.

My son in law loves me and loves my cooking more so he is all set for some good cooking. He keeps telling me that he is ready any time.

I could not have lived very well with my mother in my home , I feel guilty for saying that but she never was what you would call an "easy person".

Here’s hoping I will not need that kind of help for a long while.

By Jeannot Kensinger on 04/18/2009 7:53 pm
Chris Glass`

It is not cowardly to say someone is not an easy person to live with. I have been caring for my husband’s father because he needed us. Because his dementia is getting to the point that it takes just about all my time for his care we recently filled out an application for him to be moved to a Veteran’s home when there is an opening. I feel no guilt about this move because they are equipped to deal with the issues he has.

Last year My father-in-law slammed a car door on me as I was putting in his walker cracking my hip. It took over six months for it to heal under the strain of caring for him. It took close to two months for me to get over pneumonia and bronchitis because I couldn’t rest enough to get of it. When your own health suffers it is time to put yourself first. I can understand why some caregivers die before the person they are caring for.This isn’t a matter for guilt but self preservation. Not every parent is a sage or person willing to help themselves.

You are blessed to have children that will welcome you in their lives. I hope that mine will be there should I ever require assistance. To help myself I bought a long term nursing home policy.

By Chris Glass` on 04/18/2009 10:50 pm
Emma Pathey
Obviously Ruth Charny has a workable relationship with her mother.  Mine died 10 years ago and I cannot imagine having had her live with me in her later years.  She couldn’t wait to get me out of the house at 18 and it took many years of therapy before I could even spend a few days with her without having a nervous breakdown.  On her deathbed she was still criticizing me and ordering me how to behave.  My father, despite his senile dementia, obviously felt relief at finally being set free from this rigid control. 
By Emma Pathey on 04/19/2009 12:10 am
Denise L
Hey - I just moved my mother in with me. She is 86 and having a hard time getting around. It will be fine - we are friends most of the time but once in a while she turns into my mother and I am the daughter. Not cool!  But Lordy, I have been raising my grandson since he was 3 mo and he is now 12. My son has also moved in again - he wanders. So here we are. Thankfully my grandson and my mother are each others best friends. And I have a daughter and granddaughter close and my mothers brother is close. This arrangement will work out fine, but I am finding that my mother has more problems than I thought, might have to do more.
By Denise L on 04/19/2009 12:25 am
Jazzy JJ

Denise, Not having time during the last 3 weeks to check WOW, today was like the spirits were giving me guidance. I to am in the process of moving my Mother 88 and My Dad 90 into my home,  I am the only child of my Mother, my step Dad has a son in CA who visits Dad maybe once every 20 years, if Dad paid for him to come.  Mom and Dad had been doing  well living on their own!  We had always told them they could live with us when the time came, the time is now!  They are getting very fragile Dad can no longer drive and it’s time. My friends tell me I am an angel for doing this, I don’t think agree, I believe that this is a lesson in life for my Children and my Grandchildren. It has always been understood by my Mom and Dad that there would be no nursing home for them…..unless I could not manage their care at home anymore.  I believe it has helped them to continue to live on their own up to this time. None of us know what the future will bring, I just want to do the best for them while I can.  My hat is off to the writer of this article, it gives us all pause to reflect!

 

By Jazzy JJ on 04/19/2009 8:23 am
Harriet Shoebridge

My daughter and I are friends.  We went through a rough patch when she was a teenager and, with prayer and hard work, we have come out the other end very close.  And, these days, myself, a woman in my late fifties and she in her mid twenties … I ‘had’ my girl in my early thirties … I find myself very grateful for our relationship.  Because I want, very much, and wherever I spend my elderly years, to be ‘heart’ close to this wonderful human being whom I call my daughter. 

By Harriet Shoebridge on 04/19/2009 1:25 am
SURA B

As an independent woman of almost 80 and the mother of 2 adult children with families of their own, before considering sharing a home, I would appreciate telephone calls, visits, and conversation. Such contacts would enhance the quality of my life, for there are days when I remain indoors because of the weather or aches and pains, and a familiar voice does raise my spirit, for I speak to no one. And, losses are profound; it is not easy to replace an old friend or contemporary.

For several days during their school break, my 2 younger grandsons visited with me, and when they left, I was very sad; the apartment was dull and too quiet, and I resumed my role as independent person with no one to care for; their visit reminded me of my daily usefulness during those hectic, demanding family years.  

 My 40ish daughter sets strict boundaries, as the expression goes, which means conversation is minimal, telephone calls occur about babysitting, and listening non-existent. I do realize that my children are busy with their families, as well as with work, and their own social lives; however,I am disappointed that  there is a wide generation gap where goodwill is lacking.

Though I was not the best of daughters to my immigrant mother who criticized American life as being corrupt and dangerous, I do realize that I miss her, for she was a great role model, remaining independent for 15 after being widowed at 59. and refusing to move in with us (though we rented a large houe to accommodate her). Eventually, I found great housing for her where she maintained her own apartment in an urban senior residence with supportive health services, though she did not need assisted living, and  funds were limited; my children always say: "Grandma’s social like nearly killed her," because contemporaries in similar circumstances nurture each other. 

The social segregation in this country and the impersonal quality of organizations remind me how resilient my solitary, but gregarious mother had been; once she moved to a residence, she blossomed, found close friends, and I hope enjoyed her remaining years.  

I have friends whose elderly mothers live(d) with them, and though there are great differences in generations, the arrangments enhance everyone’s life. 

I applaud a daughter who recognizes that life is finite, and this is the time to cherish her mother’s presence in her home. Bravo! 

 

 

By SURA B on 04/19/2009 11:26 am
Star Lawrence
Circumstances alter cases. My sister and I have taken care of Mom for 20 years. She is 91, healthy, but suffers from dementia. She lives half a mile from here in a group home situation with two other ladies. We take her to the hairdresser every week, get her mails done, have lunch with her, see her three times a week at least. We sit all night in the hospital, we get her meds, we take her to the doctor. When B of A loses the rest of her trust fund, she will live here. I gather you people have nurses, help of some sort. I don’t. How will I work, leave the house to do the occasional errand? She hates animals and will have to adapt to mine. Who will answer her questions—constant, all day—who is in that car? What color would you call that? Was someone here last nite? How will I concentrate—be creative? Yes, this can be about me a little. I am old, too—I am on Social Security, too. If those idiots in DC and NY hadn’t lost all our money, this would not have come up. 
By Star Lawrence on 04/19/2009 2:40 pm
N P

I don’t know if it’s "cool" but I know that it’s the right thing to do.

To my mother, her children were everything. I mean everything. Through her marriage, and divorce, she was always there for us. And I will be there for her. 

When the man I live with now, and have for over 30 years, first suggested we move in together, one of the four conditions I presented to him was that he never ask me to move far away from my mother. Because I wouldn’t. And that when the time came, I was going to do the right thing by her. Well, he is a gem.    

I want my mother to be independent, and safe. And right now she lives a thirty minute drive from me, and she walks four miles a day. She’s a mix of Sally Field, Shirley McClain, Meryl Streep and Ann Bancroft. So for now, she’s a handful, and life is good. But, my boyfriend and my mom have both told me that they don’t want to live in So. Calif. forever. So I have asked them to think about where they want to end up. And if we can agree on a place, we’ll move there. I just want them to be happy. And I’ll be happy too. So, maybe Seattle. Maybe Portland. Maybe Canada. We have a lot of decision making to do, until the housing market turns. 

I don’t know what the future will bring. But I know we will all be together. And I know there won’t be any nursing homes. I promised my mother. That is a promise I intend to keep. And as I actually like my mother, any labor involved will indeed be a labor of love.      

Who knows for sure, but that’s my plan. 

By N P on 04/19/2009 11:04 pm