The Liz Smith Column | 03/23/2009 11:00 pm
Liz Smith: New 'Carnage' for 'Sopranos' Star James Gandolfini

“Dahling, you’re divine. I’ve had an affair with your husband. You’ll be next.”
This is Tallulah Bankhead speaking to Joan Crawford in the 1930s when Joan was wed to Douglas Fairbanks Jr.
Of course, these people were before your time, as who would act that way now?
——————————
OK! What does “God of Carnage” mean and what are you to expect from a night in the theater that includes the TV superstar James Gandolfini; the Oscar-and-Tony winner Marcia Gay Harden; our old friend from the Purple Rose Theater – the journeyman actor Jeff Daniels; and the NY Film Critics winner and character woman of all work, Hope Davis? (To give all their credits would be simply too much.)
I’ll tell you what the title means; it indicates the historical way the all-powerful creator has treated miserable little human beings throughout history. And with this in mind, these four adept actors give us — human nature at its best, its worst and its most hysterical. Under the direction of Matthew Warchus, they interact together like a Mozart quartet breaking apart at the seams. Each actor is superb — their interaction like perfect clockwork — and each is someone you know and love; maybe you yourself.
Don’t let anyone tell you what “God of Carnage” is about. Don’t let anyone spoil it by explaining plot to you. Just go, fasten your seat belt and sit there for the bumpy night as these fabulous talents enact Yasmina Reza’s play as translated by Christopher Hampton.
(Playwright Reza previously wrote “Art” but that has nothing to do with this!)
This comedy of grown people holding back and letting go is one of the funniest things I’ve encountered in 60 years of Broadway!
So far, “God of Carnage” should win the Tony Award provided the voters aren’t too far gone in searching for “serious” stuff.
Gandolfini opens as a mild-mannered, somewhat henpecked, decent husband and ends with a roar, which he manages to make entirely different from the familiar tirades and assaults of Tony Soprano. What a great actor! Jeff Daniels, too – usually sympathetic and middle-of-the-road — has here perfected his cynical, insensitive lawyer into a realistic white-collar villain seldom realized. Miss Harden is the idealist out to save Darfur and the world; you know her very well – she is today’s Everywoman. And she is, as usual, magnificent. And Hope Davis must definitely win something for unprecedented projectile vomiting onstage and other feats of mesmerism in changing a character’s behavior about 40 times before your eyes. She is my new heroine!
The set by Mark Thompson is streamlined and effective and his white tulips are definitely the stars of the night! Don’t miss “God of Carnage” at the Bernie Jacobs Theater in New York City!
——————————-
The British press is quibbling over President Obama’s gift to Prime Minister Gordon Brown of a set of 25 classic American movies, including “Psycho.” Now they say the movies only work on the North American type DVD player and Gordon can’t even view them in Blighty. The prime minister’s office rebuts saying: “Any gift President Obama gave PM Brown would have been well thought through.”
But, look, this is worldwide open season on brand-new President Obama and he has to just go on doing his “thing” and not pay too much attention to the fact that the world expected miracles from him in the first days. He seems to be expected to, overnight, undo the policies and actions that have been afflicting America for the past three administrations.

Brown and Obama © Getty Images
I’d say it’s the antediluvian Congress that is keeping Americans arguing, weeping, sighing and unable to make progress even though we are faced with an economic crisis that makes World War II look easy.
























22 Reader Comments (so far…) Sign In or Register to comment
Liz,
Thanks for the review and advice on "God of Carnage." My husband and I will be back in NYC in May….to attend Andrea Marcovicci’s 6oth Birthday Concert…..hope we can catch this Broadway lovely!
I just caught the middle to the end part of a movie called "The Mexican" with Gandolfini, Julia Roberts and Brad Pitt. I’d never seen it before and couldn’t take my eyes off of Gandolfini. I’d been a sopranos fan of course but it was all id’ really seen him in. He’s just a mesmerizing actor. Since i’m comign to NYC in New York i’m goign to see if i can get tickets to this! it sounds incredible!
James Gandolfini - I am a big fan but the last 2 or 3 seasons of The Soprano’s were difficult to watch because his heavy strained breathing was a constant distraction. It made me want to tell him to get a thorough physical with particular focus on his heart health. He is a tremendous talent and deserves a much better level of health.
Ahh yes … the expectation of miracles from President Obama. Any objective person could see this was bound to happen before the horses left the gate during the primary season or election day. Barack Obama was marketed as a sort of second coming of Christ throughout the process - perhaps not formally by his own team but they rode that wild horse home and now there is a payment due. A gift ball to the Republican party and they’ll get all the play they possibly can out of it.
E.,
You can say that again.
See? You are so right!
Liz,
Why do you think people expect Obama to undo policies overnight?
Hey! Thanks to you guys for finding me here on Wow! I am so grateful to you and hope you will be catching and enjpying all the nuances of this fabulous site. As for MJ’s question why do I think people expect Obama to undo policies overnight; maybe its just human nature. We elected him to work wonders. In this case, considering what he inherited, he probably can’t or the Congress will stumblebum him. Meanwhile the pundits, weary of bashing Bush to little avail, are now bashing Obama.
To read the critiques in even the liberal New York Times is to weep. But these guys are just trying to do their jobs, I guess. I want the President to declare the situation just as serious as it is and to ask us specifically to make sacrifices and let’s save the world. Thanks again for chiming in. Liz Smith.
My theory is that we got lucky electing Obama, prob the most intelligent President we have ever had, because people got used to voting on American Idol and somehow began to feel their vote counted, and they trusted Tiger Woods, who is a gentleman and really really fantastic at what he does…..Without the TV show and the track record of a great sportsman who all races likes and admired it would not have happened…..Therefore we don’t know what to make of something taking more than a week to win or fix….I taught history and government to college students for a long time (25 years)…and trust me I am not that far off….Love you Liz, Alice Flannigan, Professor Emeritus
Thank you, Liz. I think your answer is right and it makes me feel better to hear you say it. Maybe the old saying, "Rome wasn’t built in a day…." is appropriate. I don’t read the New York Times so I won’t weep from that source. I do think if we all can help others who are down as well as making sacrifices of our own, we could feel as if we’re saving ourselves and the world. I do know there are posters on this site who are having a hard time and my heart goes out to them, angry as they can be sometimes. Then, there are others who just hack away at Obama and his wife, just for the sake of "hacking". For them, I feel nothing…
Again, thank you and God bless…
Is there a way to get alert to just the column and not to the post-scripts and answers to readers’ comments and questions?
There are too many "Liz Smith" emails in my mailbox; one a day would be plenty.
thanks.
Mike Sapio (a reader of Ms. Smith since the NY Daily News days)
Right, Liz. A lot of mistakes are being made by the Obama administration, but the economy was spiraling into a depression before he took office. The notion to do something, anything, seems to be a good one that O is undertaking. We can worry about "mortgaging our children’s futures" later; let’s worry right now about our own mortgage crisis.
Personally, I feel II-Bush bears much of the blame, but Bill Clinton didn’t fight for strict enough protections, either, when NAFTA and other trade accords were signed off on. Other countries have had a field day at our expense, and now we don’t have the leverage to quibble with China, for example, and its unfair trade practices.
The head of the National Superconducting Cyclotron Laboratory at Michigan State University told me that the United States needs to be the leader in high-technology, or it will be left behind. Let’s hope the stimulus package and other measures jump-start the industrial sector, and provide CPR for our dying manufacturing base.