Sign in to wowOwow

Enter the username or e-mail address that you used when registering at wowOwow.
The password field is case sensitive. Click here if you have forgotten your password.

Please register for wowOwow

By registering, you indicate that you have read and agree
with our privacy policy and terms of service.

The Liz Smith Column | 11/25/2009 6:00 am

Liz Smith: Our Gossip Girl's Thanksgiving Dish

From the bad rap of turkeys to the history of the holiday, our Liz wishes you a Happy Thanksgiving.
© Shutterstock
"Thanksgiving is indeed the nearest thing we have to a national liturgy. From sea to shining sea, it calls forth a grand harmony of groaning boards … Yet what must we think of a nation that, as the central motif of this gustatory concerto, insists upon a bird that has a name used chiefly as an insult!"

So pontificated Episcopal theologian Robert Farrar Capon way back in the 1980s when he was writing of Thanksgiving for The New York Times.

And turkeys received another worldwide video insult when, right after the lost election and the Sarah Palin run at the vice presidency, we were treated to turkeys being smashed, crashed, delivered headfirst into a funnel behind her – the entire atmosphere reeking of blood, guts and horror. (Sarah didn’t know this was happening or else she surely wouldn’t have pronounced it "fun.") So, the dear old turkey has suffered the slings and arrows of many attackers, yet if the big bird is simply roasted properly, according to excellent recipes (and there are millions of them), the dish can be quite tasty, bearing no resemblance to the horrible processed "turkey" we get offered every day in delicatessen sandwiches.

At any rate, people go on trying to let turkey eating get out of control and to make Thanksgiving special because they eat about 46 million turkeys each November. And approximately 80% or 31.2 million Americans travel by car, 4.7 million by plane, 33 million by train or bus for this holiday to get with family, hated in-laws, deserted cousins and dear friends. And along with turkeys, Americans also celebrate at this time the lowly cranberry, which is one of the rare fruits native to North America.

The above mentioned Rev. Capon has also noted that Thanksgiving "is the only nationwide festival we have that still involves honest and considerable ‘sit-down eating.’ It is the perfect holiday, superior to all other federally finagled four-day weekends." He noted that other holidays are "vacancies in time … Thanksgiving, by contrast, has not only a common theme but a common ritual as well … Thanksgiving is better even than Hanukkah, Christmas, Passover or Easter. Those festivities, while they involve unifying activities, are enjoyable chiefly in anticipation. The feasts themselves are letdowns. Advent, for instance, is fun: It has in Christmas, a future that brightens each dark December day. When December 25 finally rolls around, it is simply a present with no future whatsoever to look forward to. Thanksgiving, however, has Advent, Hanukkah and Christmas waiting to burst upon us the minute the dishwasher is loaded."

I rather admire writer Bryan Miller’s defense of the turkey He says it "deserves respect for tradition’s sake," noting that "more than any other food, it embodies the early American spirit; tireless effort against depressing odds, spiritual sustenance, season renewal." And he adds the reminder that turkeys are close to red meat in protein content but only about 11 % fat, even less if the skin is not included. A serving has about nine grams of fat and that is unsaturated. So chow down, you food purists!

***

Sentimentalists believe the first Thanksgiving occurred about 1621 when early settlers shared a feast with the native Indians. (I rather imagine they were more worried about the natives eating them than about what they had to eat with the natives.)

34 Reader Comments (so far…) Sign In or Register to comment

carengittleman
Happy Thanksgiving To All!
By carengittleman on 11/25/2009 7:23 am
joan larsen

The Pope’s Nose, Liz Smith, brought me right back to my childhood where that expression seemed part of Thanksgiving along with the wishbone.  And that brought thoughts of the large large turkey platters where the turkey was elegantly carved at the table — a feat in itself.  A time of drinks, toasts, festive wonder for a child … and it wasn’t even Christmas.  Those were the days …

But we still have something called togetherness, and it is friends and family that truly make the holiday gathering … and so - to all my friends here (and especially Liz who started the memories flowing!!) — make it joyous and full of laughter on Thanksgiving.  I am sure you will !!! Joan

By joan larsen on 11/25/2009 7:33 am
LindaMyers
Happy Thanksigiving to all the ladies who headline WOW, contributors and Mr. Wow!
By LindaMyers on 11/25/2009 9:07 am
LauriateRoly

I have nothing to say on this subject but it seems the opportune spot for me to wish all of my fellow WOWers, and all the founders of WOW, and all of your families, the happiest moments and warmest traditions of this special season. May Thanksgiving bring all the finest and best things to you. LR.

By LauriateRoly on 11/25/2009 9:33 am
BelindaJoy

Happy Thanksgiving Everyone!

This is my favorite meal of the year, hands down. It beats 4th of July burgers and brats. And it even out-shines Christmas ham. There is something about a succulent slice of moist turkey seasoned just right, with cold congealed cranberry sauce, dressing (we don’t call ours stuffing) sweet and tasty yams, corn, pea salad (yum!) greens and of course a roll for good measure. 

And for dessert sweet potato pie or chocolate cake or lemon meringue pie or……

I eat until I am ready to pop, plop down on the sofa like a beached whale, watch some football, let out a loud burp (in a feminine and refined manner of course) nod off into a coma for a couple of hours and then its time to put the food away and get on with normal life. A once a year binge that is condoned by doctors all over the country and a binge millions of people are doing simultaneously.

Aah Thanksgiving dinner. Here’s a tip o’ the hat to my favorite meal.

By BelindaJoy on 11/25/2009 10:06 am
LaurelSayler

I have to agree with you Belinda. Thankgiving is the best holiday ever. It beats Christmas, New Years, Halloween and any other holiday on the books. Thankgiving is dependable, you know what you’re gonna get. My grandma used to have the best Thankgivings ever and it was a sad day when she decided that she was to ill to handle it anymore. My mom actually inherited the cranberry sauce bowl when grams called it quits. The bowl is the best part of preparing the entire meal. Every year when my mom pulls it out of its bowl protection program and carefully cleans I can’t help but think of all the women who did the same thing every year since the Great Depression(It is a depression glass bowl). The cranberry sauce is always made from scratch and this is the only time of year we eat cranberry sauce. Since our family has decided that two more people at the table is too much my mom and I make a huge Thankgiving dinner for the two of us. I make the pumpkin pie, cook the turkey and take care of the mashed potatoes while my mom makes the cranberry sauce, the green beans and the stuffing. Thankgiving is all about family and good food and eating till you explode. I starve all day just so I can pig out one day a year. I miss all the family fun we had when I was little but I love the traditions that my mom and carry on with year after year. Who knows maybe next year we will invite the whole family to our new house in a new state to join in on the ritual pigout.

Thankgiving is hands down the best day of the year!!!

By LaurelSayler on 11/25/2009 5:48 pm
FrancoAlbo
Abraham Lincoln in the 1820s???? I don’t think so.
By FrancoAlbo on 11/25/2009 10:07 am
phyllisDoylePepe
Right. Lincoln was the one who proposed  Thanksgiving Day during the civil war–-1863––Seems that FDR changed the date during the Depression.
By phyllisDoylePepe on 11/25/2009 4:07 pm
EileenAlannah
"…representing tireless effort against depressing odds." That’s a quote all right, that may well be the spirit of all things, since life does end eventually so it is this spirit of the people we love that is appreciated, their bravery and their hope, always this wish and always this hopelessly optimistic striving that things might somehow work out, if not for ourselves, then for others. Happy Thanksgiving, Liz Smith. I am thankful that you battled it out of Depression-era Texas and landed in New York and that you were brave enough to turn the other cheek to those who hurt you and that you became a fair and honest and very entertaining writer. I raise a glass of bubbly to you! xo
By EileenAlannah on 11/25/2009 10:11 am
Liz Smith
Aw, shucks, Eileen and thank you for thinking of me. Love to all. Liz 
By Liz Smith on 11/25/2009 1:37 pm
TinaLittlepage
A very blessed Thanksgiving to everyone and their families :) 
By TinaLittlepage on 11/25/2009 10:41 am
DeirdreCerasa
I think it is hilarious that Robert CAPON dissed turkey!  A capon is a castrated rooster and if you have ever tasted a roasted capon you will not forget!  My mother used to serve both at Thanksgiving and my Italian father-in-law did as well.  They are delicious!  Anyway, Happy Thanksgiving one and all!  Liz, you are the best!!!!!
By DeirdreCerasa on 11/25/2009 10:44 am
phyllisDoylePepe

I was thinking the same thing, Deirdre, that a man with the name of Capon would be putting down turkeys. And yes, capons are delicious.

Delightful article, Liz, and good wishes  and good eating to you. The fact that you can make the gravy with one hand behind your back is something I would like to see. You surely need both hands to get the good stuff scraped from the bottom of the large turkey pan, no?  

By phyllisDoylePepe on 11/25/2009 4:13 pm
SteveR

It reminds me of the commercials with the cows trying to get people to eat more chicken.

Happy (gift) hunting to all.

Except the @#$%@# spammers!

By SteveR on 11/27/2009 3:25 pm
SusanGabriel

Thanks for this post, Liz.

In honor of Thanksgiving this year I came up with a list of 100 Things I’m Grateful For. It was a very positive exercise. Some of the things on the list were obvious, some surprising. I hope you will consider creating your own list, if you haven’t already.

Happy Thanksgiving to all my friends at WOW!

By SusanGabriel on 11/25/2009 11:33 am