A Friend Stopped By | 05/02/2009 8:25 am
Just in Time for the Annual Malice Domestic Convention, the Best Mystery Novels

Editor’s Note: Sarah Weinman writes a monthly crime fiction column for the Los Angeles Times, contributes to The Washington Post, the New York Post, the Baltimore Sun and many other print and online publications, as well as blogs about the genre at Confessions of an Idiosyncratic Mind.
After romance, mystery novels are the most popular genre of fiction being bought and read — especially by women, and especially now. When times are tough, it’s hard to resist the allure of a chaotic world being restored to order with the help of a memorable detective. Or being whisked off to new worlds and amazing adventures. Or spending time in the company of quirky characters and sharing their love of a particular topic or trade, be it shopping for priceless antiques or looking for clues among ancient bones. Here are some recommendations for devoted mystery fans and newcomers alike, just in time for the annual Malice Domestic Convention, the most important gathering for murder written by women for women that takes place this weekend in Arlington, VA.
Lately I’m seeing a return to the traditional mystery fiction written by the likes of Agatha Christie, Margery Allingham and Josephine Tey, but these "new traditionalist" novels, as I like to call them, are still thoroughly modern. Take Louise Penny, a Canadian crime writer who sets her series in the deceptively sedate Quebec town of Three Pines — but as her lovably, crusty Detective Inspector finds out time and again, there are always secrets whose long festering leads to criminal misdeeds. Start with Still Life
and continue through to the latest, A Rule Against Murder. Or try Alan Bradley, another Canadian, whose upcoming début, The Sweetness at the Bottom of the Pie,
kicks off a delightful new series featuring 11-year-old Flavia De Luce, a plucky, resourceful girl with a passion for poison and a nose for crime-solving around her country English estate during the early 1950s. Morag Joss’s
award-winning psychological suspense novels, Half Broken Things
and Puccini’s Ghosts,
are as good as P.D. James
and Ruth Rendell
in their respective heydays.
And of course there’s Alexander McCall Smith, a veritable juggernaut who seems to produce a new work every other week. His #1 Ladies Detective Agency novels
are in the public eye at the moment thanks to the HBO adaptation starring Jill Scott as the "traditionally built" Botswanan detective Precious Ramotswe, but he’s also deep into a series of philosophical investigations featuring sensible Scottish heroine Isabel Dalhousie. McCall Smith has a knack for taking the tiniest of details and building fascinating mysteries of life and human behavior around them.
Donna Leon
has that same gift; she imbues her Inspector Brunetti
novels — the most recent is About Face — with the pungent flavors of her beloved Venice. If airfares prove too prohibitive and you still want to escape, travel vicariously to Laos in the company of Colin Cotterill’s
idiosyncratic protagonist Dr. Siri, first introduced in The Coroner’s Lunch. Or go to Norway with Karin Fossum, dubbed the country’s "Queen of Crime" for her chilling psychological thrillers (including the LA Times Book Prize winner The Indian Bride)
starring Inspector Sejer. Or visit Russia with Boris Akunin, whose Golden Age pastiches have sold in the millions since The Winter Queen
introduced raffish sleuth Erast Fandorin.
Here in America, you can experience "new traditionalism" by subject. If you love gardening, Susan Wittig Albert’s China Bayles series, starting with Thyme of Death, is your best choice. For antiques, appraise Jane Cleland’s four-book series, recently continuing with Killer Keepsakes. And if you’re a foodie, bite into Katherine Hall Page’s Faith Fairchild
novels, starting with The Body in the Belfry.
These are just a few of the many wonderful examples of how women from all walks of life can come together to contemplate murder.
Sarah Weinman























22 Reader Comments (so far…) Sign In or Register to comment
I love Ngaio Marsh, too!
For some reason, when you try to "Preview" your post it disappears completely when you "submit" it.
I’ve loved mysteries since I inherited my Aunts Nancy Drew books! I love a good series because I get addicted to the detectives as much as the crimes.
My two favorites are Martha Grimes Richard Jury series and Peter Tremaynes Sister Fidelma series, what’s not to love about an 11th century irish nun/detective/sister of the King?
I’ve read all of Sue Grafton and Tony Hillerman and Robert Crais and Lillian Jackson Braun and so many others.
My new favorite American mystery writer is the quirky Charlaine Harris and the Sothern Vampire series with Sookie Stackhouse…don’t let the HBO series True Blood scare you, the books aren’t nearly as ranchy as the sex filled TV show!
I just read John LeCarre’s A Murder of Quality, which features George Smiley investigating a gruesome slaying at an upscale prep school - it gives some intriguing background on the compliated world of spymaster Smiley - well worth a read!
I also adore Ngaio Marsh, as well as Josephine Tey (The Daughter of Time is a book to be read and re-read - a true gem!) And Maisie Dobbs is a favorite, too! But when I really want to sink into the whodunnit world, I pick up a Rex stout and let Nero Wolfe and Archie tear into some juicy murder and a few juicy meals prepared by Fritz Brenner. Stout created an amazing set of characters and placed them in a NY of bygone days that is still very fresh and evocative.
Love Kathy Reichs, Patricia Cornwell, Linda Fairstein and Greg Iles. Also, I have begun again reading Stephen King, his latest, general publication ‘Duma Key’ made me remember why I became a fan.
Greg Iles gives us well developed characters and fast-paced plots. Reichs and Cornwell have characters with which I am familiar and consider friends. Linda Fairstein I read to see what meals her characters are feasting on next!