A Friend Stopped By | 11/20/2009 5:00 pm
Let Down and Felt Up? by E.D. Hill
How the new mammogram recommendations impact a high-risk woman

Editor’s Note: Emmy Award-winning journalist E.D. Hill is a nationally known TV and radio host and author. She spent the past ten years hosting several daily programs on Fox News Channel and was Bill O’Reilly’s sidekick on The Radio Factor, heard on 400 stations. She currently hosts "Good Day" with E.D. Hill on americaswebradio.com Tuesdays and Thursdays 8 - 9 AM EST. E.D. and her husband have eight children and pets too numerous to mention. She splits time between their ranch in Texas and the East Coast. You can contact E.D. at hillfriends.com.
Hey there, cute thing. Let’s play doctor. Feel me up. Yep. Grab my breasts and manipulate away. Why? Because if the government is going to buy into the philosophy that mammograms are unnecessary for most women until age 50 – which means that shiny new government insurance plan won’t be covering them until then – we’ll be reduced to grabbing each others’ breasts. Face it: Guys are willing to do it but they are clueless about what feels weird.The United States Preventive Services Task Force, which just a few short years ago recommended mammograms at age 40, now has new members who say 50 is the right age to begin saving your life. Well, I’m giving them too much credit. They actually say women age 50 to 74 should have mammograms but not frequently. Oh, and by the way, don’t bother with that self-exam that might uncover it earlier. Right about this point in reading their report I begin wishing my former neighbor Vickie didn’t live so far away.
Sure, there are groups that disagree with this newfound wisdom, but the USPSTF is the panel appointed by the federal government. Federal officials direct what Medicare or any other government health program should pay for, which means the panel’s recommendations count. The report concludes mammograms reduce the breast-cancer death rate by 15 percent but the task force is more concerned, it seems, with what it views as potential harm from over-screening. What is that harm? Anxiety. So let me get this straight: Concern about breast cancer is more harmful to me than actually finding it at an early stage?
I’m a bit touchy on this subject. Based on the rate of breast cancer in my family, I’ve just finished a year and a half of genetic counseling, including numerous discussions, research and testing. What I learned was that so many factors influence risk of breast cancer that it is virtually impossible to have a "standard" recommendation. My life experience has shown me that friends who detected it early are still alive, whereas friends who didn’t are dead. Closing my eyes, clicking my heels and chanting "I don’t want cancer, I don’t want cancer" isn’t going to take away "harmful anxiety." Women are concerned about breast cancer because every one of us knows a friend or family member who has died from it. It seems odd to me that just when our government is contemplating how to pay for nationwide health care, the first health recommendation is to scale back women’s medical benefits, which coincidentally, according to one of the data researchers, will save the government billions of dollars. Likely, private insurance companies will follow its lead and find – voila! – a cash cornucopia for them and less medical coverage for women.
As the health-care debate heated up this year, I became concerned about where health care – both public and private – was headed. I spoke with my doctor, my family and friends and decided, based on my risk factors, to have a prophylactic double mastectomy. I thought about waiting but was concerned insurance might change and not pay for it later, which now seems even more likely. The idea of major surgery makes me anxious but the thought of dying from something I can prevent now is even worse. When I told Whoopi Goldberg, the most supportive of women, about my decision, she offered to hold my hand through it. I meet with the surgeon again today to schedule the date. If, however, health coverage changes in the meantime, I may be asking Whoopi to do something else with her hand.























107 Reader Comments (so far…) Sign In or Register to comment
You really have to take all these "scientific" studies with a grain of salt. Look how many times scientific wisdom has shifted over the years on almost everything. Eggs used to be bad for you, proper CPR used to "require" mouth-to-mouth, etc. And I love how many scientists use words like "empirical" to make their opinions sound absolute.
There’s good science and bad science. And this latest study is bad science. It relies on the voices of outsourced experts. Five years from now another "conclusive" study will come along to disqualify it…or maybe five minutes from now.
James I’ve already gotten a letter telling me since I’ve been cancer free for 5 yrs I didn’t need another mammogram, three months after that test another lump was detected so do I not get the test because the insurance company says it’s not necessary acorrding to some panel who out sourced to others to do the research or have the test?? Tell me what you would do in my shoes??
Better safe than sorry, Denise. Get the test.
James, My name is Deniseann :)
I’ve had the test, and biopsy’s , and I’m going through chemo for the third time in the last 20 years. My point being if a so called research panel who didn’t even do the work themselves recommend that women should for go proven test to detect the various diseases, do we listen to them, the insurance companies or what we know to be a proven way to detect cancers?
The below remarks are directed at the enitre site not one person in particular:
Most cervical cancers are the results of having sex, and yet they now tell young girls to get a shot to prevent cervical cancer, but what they don’t tell you is "yes it can prevent cervical cancer but sex is one of the major causes of cervical cancer". So are we telling young girls having sex is safe because of this vaccine????????? Another quandary we must endure.
This Health Care crisis in America is for the birds. Research being done on the major diseases in our country are getting their funding from "Walk for the Cure," "Run for the Cure", "Stand up to Cancer," and not from the government. There are so many orphan diseases out there that if it weren’t for fund raisers and donations from private citizens, cures would never be found. Thank you Jerry Lewis, Danny Thomas and others out there who have given their time, love and money to help those who can not help themselves.
My question is how much is the American Public paying out of their taxes for research and how many are donating to Organizations directly for research and possible cures?
How much are the pharmaceutical companies actually charging for the meds they develop? And are they holding us "UP" by over charging, or holding off on publishing their results and possible cures. Why don’t we take heed from the other countries on this planet who seem to be making headway in areas we’ve not even pondered.
Such a good post Deniseann (beautiful name).
Big Pharma is in bed with the administration and this health care take over. Money will be funded to them and used as THEY see fit. Of course they will control what we take, etc. They fund the medical schools that tell doctors what do prescribe, what to do. We will be treated as good little sheep and herded into the chutes to get what they say we need.
Even if you wanted to pay for the tests, with this government take over, you will not be allowed to do so. The elderly will be left out to die as quickly as they can, with least amount of cost that they can.
The youth does not get as sick, they cost less. All others will be a drain on the 17% of the economy that the government will then have their hands on….they will have to go.
True, first thank you, my father named me.
I’ve had 21 operations since I was 18, not one was for enhancements (to me I feel okay with what God gave me, and my parents of course). My last two operations were for breast cancer and placement of a port for chemo,. The side affects from the chemo will be with me for the rest of my life (loss of feeling in hands and feet, stomach problems that I won’t go into here), but when deciding on which meds to take to combat the breast cancer and the type I had, my choices were limited, because it had begone to spread to the lymph system.
I signed the forms for the removal of the breast that was diseased but when I came too, I had 1/2 a breast and they deem it unnecessary to remove it all, and what happens next, I find a new tumor this past summer and I’m dealing with it all over again. If they did as we discussed before my surgery, there’d been no breast there to have the cancer return to.
My Great Grandfathers generation was the first to pay into Social Security and Medicare and when he retired it was good for him, he could live on it nicely. Grandpa had to have more in savings to enjoy his retirement because witht he cost of living and the funk the cournty was in he couldn’t make it on his Social Security alone, Dad he never got to collect his Socal Security, he died two weeks before he turned 62, my generation needs to keep working even on Social Security because every time the gov’t been short they borrowed from the plan, and now my children are harping about how much they have to pay into SS and Medicare and it won’t even be there when it’s time for them to retire. Will all this said and done, lending money to banks and car makers to keep them from going down, well they put themselves in the financiall mess their in, not you or I. I make my car payments, and I decide where my money is invested, I don’t leave it up to the gov’t because they just screw it up every chance they get.
How come if a person serves in office (elected office) they get a pension for severing from 2 to 8 yrs. Doesn’t seem fair that if someone is elected to the Presidency and they serve 4 to 8 years they’ll get a pension equal to the pay they made while in office. I find that totally a waste of money, and that goes for Senators and Congressmen, governors, mayors. They don’t deserve a penison if they didn’t work 20 or more years like the everyday American person.
I’m scared to death what is going to happen to people like me in a state of constant medical problems with the gov’t being the one making my decisions and not me. that pharmaceutics companies who over charge for almost everything have such a tight grip on our economy, and research. I just don’t trust them. Maybe like in the 60’s we should go to Canada to hide from our gov’t. :)
Beautiful Deniseann, my heart goes out to you. You have been through enough.
I totally agree with you about the government pensions, they are a disgrace. Term limits on politicians and let them get back to the private life and live like we do. That would straighten out a lot of the scams and deals that are ruining our Nation. If they had to work and lived what they have legislated, things would be quiet different.
Hell, they don’t have to abide by the health care plan they are passing, now what does that say????
True when I had cervical/uterin cancer I was in the Navy and pregnant. I got great care but not at a military hospital, I went civilian. When we got stationed at Quantico, I went to Bethisda Naval Hospital for almost 19 yrs for all my medical needs. I met 2 presidents and three first ladies while going there. Bethisda is the best military hospital in the country, and all members of Congress, Seneate, Cabinet and the Pres and Vice Pres go there for treatment (if they want), and it cost them nothing, nothing at all. Since I’ve been in the VA system I’ve been misdiagnosed and can’t go out of the system because a I can’t afford to, being a disabled Vet they will cover most, but not all, and I have medicare because as I stated I’m disabled and can’t work all leading back to my first cancer 27 yrs ago. In fact my major reason for not being able to work can no longer be treated by the VA because they don’t have a clue what to do next, so there outsourcing me to the University of North Carolina medical college for help. If I could afford to go to civilian doctors I would in a heart beat, my medicare wouldn’t cover enough, and the VA won”t pay squat unless they authorize you to go. So I’m stuck. In a few months I’ll be moving closer to my children and I know if anything happens they’ll step in if I’m unable to make decisions.
But I’ve learn to live with it all, and I just pray everyday when I put my Armor on that the Lord will get me through another day without being sick.
I’d like for one day to have the Pres or a Congressmen/Senator live in my shoes to see what it’s like to be an everyday American Citizen trying to make a life worth living. :)
Deniseann, our veterans deserve the same quality of care that our members of Congress, Senate, Cabinet and the Pres. and Vice Pres. For them to have access to any less is beyond shameful.
It is a good thing that you will soon be close to your children. Hopefully you will be able to find the help that you need, the Lord can do these things for you.
It is a shame that our government is working to put more people in a health care system that offers less. Less of everything but the most rudimentary care. We could make the changes to our system that would make the best health care in the world more accessable to everyone, people as deserving as yourself.
Pray that the Senate will ingore the bribes and threats from this administration and will stand and make the changes in our private care system that can so easliy be done.
True, I’m worried about the youth of our country, those leaving home who are not covered under mom and dad anylonger. High price they are forced to pay every month just for minimal coverage.
My daughter had to have an emergency gall bladder surgery and it cost her 3000 on and above what her medical benifits paid. She had to take a loan to pay for it. Then you have dental, and eye care, and most young Americans fresh in the work force have no idea the cost of these things because Mom and Dad took care of it.
The elderly and the youth of this country are the ones who are going to have the hardest time with any insurance changes.
I pray every night that God will watch over the youth of our country, those abroad and here at home. They are our future and I pray that this gov’t get’s it act together so that they can live a decent life. The one we dreamt about as children ourselves.
You sound like Chicken Little. First of all, there is nothing anywhere that states a person won’t be able to pay out of pocket for medical care they want that their insurance won’t cover. That would simply be absurd. Secondly, health care is ALREADY RATIONED BY COST!!!! If you have insurance, that company decides what they will pay for. If they decide a procedure isn’t necessary, they won’t cover it.
And while the youth don’t get sick as easily as the elderly, we’re the ones who are bearing the brunt of this health care crisis. If you have any sort of a job, you are too rich for Medicaid. Obviously we can’t get Medicare. So, many of us do without and suffer as a result, all the while our money is getting siphoned out of our paychecks to pay for the old people….. Now personally I want to live in a civilized society where people aren’t dying of easily treated diseases, and that means universal health care. This also means that I don’t mind the fact that I’m paying social security when i won’t see a dime. But it completely pisses me off when the old, whom I am supporting through taxes and providing medical care through Medicare, decide that they don’t want to extend the benefits to those of us who are actually working. It’s a travesty.
Have no idea who you are, and your post is among others "off-topic" but I agree that we must provide health care coverage to ALL - preventive health for our youth is one of the best investments that CMS could legislate. Our young people need to learn how to exist, eat, and become far more wise health care consumers than they are today.
And, at this point in time, I have seen NOTHING out of DC that prohibits health care coverage, and I’m reading the bills put forth on www.thomas.gov (incidentally, the president has never put out a Bill!).