Sign in to wowOwow

Enter the email address that you used when registering at wowOwow.
The password field is case sensitive. Click here if you have forgotten your password.

Please register for wowOwow

Newsletter subscriptions
Sign up to receive wowOwow's weekly newsletter and get our best picks delivered right to your inbox. Our newsletter content is hand-picked by the wowOwow editorial team and provides the top features, news, and commentary from our site. Subscribing to our newsletter is free and safe. We will never share your email or other information with a third-party without your direct consent.
By registering, you indicate that you have read and agree
with our privacy policy and terms of service.

Health-Care Reform, Smoking | 06/09/2009 8:20 am

Some Health Insurance Companies Making a Profit From Smokers

As health-care reform takes center stage, it turns out some big insurers make big bucks from people puffing.
By The staff at wowOwow.com
© Shutterstock

As President Barack Obama pushes Congress to pass by August a health-care reform bill that provides coverage to all Americans, a new study from Harvard University about the money-making practices of health insurers has caught our attention. 

Each year, about 443,600 people in the United States die from tobacco-related illnesses; about half of all Americans who keep smoking will die from it. This nasty habit kills more of us than alcohol, car accidents, suicide, AIDS, murder and illegal drugs combined, according to the American Cancer Society. It’s the leading cause of cancer deaths among men and women.

And it appears health insurers are hedging their bets that these deaths will actually make them money. The seemingly twisted findings are a part of a study out this week from Harvard doctors, who say that seven health and life-insurance companies in both the United States and overseas have nearly $4.5 billion invested in tobacco stocks. Prudential company alone has more than $1.5 million invested. That means those insurance companies have a financial interest in seeing more people smoke.

"It’s the combined taxidermist and veterinarian approach: either way you get your dog back," Harvard’s David Himmelstein, who co-author of a letter published in this week’s issue of the New England Journal of Medicine, told Scientific American, who contacted some of the insurance companies mentioned to get comment. "If you own a billion dollars [of tobacco stock], then you don’t want to see it go down."

Smoking is a health concern for all women who inhale. Smoking-related diseases caused the deaths of about 174,000 women each year from 2000 to 2004, and on average, those women died 14.5 years earlier because they smoked. The U.S. Senate this week is expected to OK new laws that for the first time will permit the Food and Drug Administration to regulate tobacco product, including how much nicotine is in each cigarette, and banning advertising and marketing aimed at children, among other things. 

Meanwhile, Democrats are mobilizing people around the country to push health-care reform. ABC News says that Sen. Edward Kennedy, D-MA, has drafted a plan that would require employers to insure their workers. Then there’s the portion of the plan that says some of the 164 million Americans covered by employer-provided insurance could be asked to give up part of a tax exemption allows for that compensation. These ideas, among others, have many businesses raising an eyebrow. The health-care reform battle is sure to be a nasty one, particularly with the powerful insurance industry also gearing up for a fight.

73 Reader Comments (so far…) Sign In or Register to comment

Maggie W

It’s important to remember that Ted Kennedy’s "plan" is actually a draft.  His draft has company with differing opinions.  They are Max Baucus, Henry Waxman, Tom Coburn, Paul Ryan…and don’t forget people like Chip Kahn, top hospital lobbyist.The shape health care reform takes depends on Congress, doctors, patients, and the insurers.  Corporate boardrooms and labor will be there.  All of that is not in play yet. 

At present, 75 cents of every health care dollar goes to asthma, heart disease, and cancer.  I’m  not certain Congress is the best arena for health care reform.  It will be a political minefield.  It might be better to turn it over to an independent Federal Health Board with continual oversight.

As for cigarettes, big tobacco will make certain people stay addicted and they will also make certain to continue to raise the price of cigarettes. Some things in life remain constant.

By Maggie W on 06/09/2009 8:40 am
Kelly In Texas

Once again, it is all about choices that we make. To blame the Insurance companies or Tobacco industry is ridiculous. People make decisions to drink, smoke, eat unhealthy, drive unsafely, take drugs, have unprotected sex.

No one elses fault but our own. Americans need to stop looking for someone else to blame for their own bad choices. Period.

Investment is a personal choice as well, for companies and individuals. So if you don’t like the consequences, then don’t smoke, drink to excess, have unprotected sex or eat junk from fast food restaurants. Period.

The Rep. have a health care plan that can work, without forcing the private sector out. We must not be in such a hurry for health care as to ruin what we have. If employers are forced to supply health care, many, many more will be facing the unemployment lines.

However, Obama does not really care if it works or not. He want control of the 17% of the economy that health care represents. He will tell the American people what they want to hear…but the people will suffer, not the government.

Oh sure, you can keep your private insurance….the problem is the private insurance will be forced out of business and taxed into oblivion. So you can CHOOSE it….but private insurance will not be available….small problem there… He wants the American people on the government plan, one provider…then they contol the money.

With one provider, waiting will become common place, health care will be RATIONED. There is NO OTHER WAY for the government plan to work. The Institute of Comparative Effectiveness will decide IF you deserve the proceedure, WHO will perform it and WHERE it will be done…and WHEN.

Beware…the numbers do not lie…the system can NOT support 50 million more…PLUS the extra MILLIONS more that will be forced to move to the government plan…NOT enough doctors, NOT enough medical professionals…YOU WILL SUFFER because of this plan.

It’s all about the money….Americans better wise up.

By Kelly In Texas on 06/11/2009 1:07 pm
Judy K.
Investors will invest where the money is.  Unfortunately cigarette usage is one of the categories.  When I smoked I enjoyed it and I got caught.  This is one vice that will continue to make money and investors will go there.
By Judy K. on 06/09/2009 8:48 am
C Hardy
Ok I have to say that I was shocked to hear that insurance companies have stock in cigarette companies…This surprises me b/c, Im not really sure, it just does.  Insurance companies I know invest but to see them invest in cigarettes….seems odd to me but they follow the money.  I truly hope they never denied a claim for anyone who got cancer from smoking knowing they are dipping their hands in those pockets. 
By C Hardy on 06/09/2009 8:53 am
Andrea Brandon

C Hardy,

Maybe because it sounds so totally contrary to what health care is supposed to be all about?

The thought that insurance companies own stock in tobacco companies is sickening. I find this deplorable.

By Andrea Brandon on 06/09/2009 12:56 pm
Barbara B
Tabacco just like Alcohol is a way of life and a fact of life.  You can lead a horse to water and hope he drinks.  I have given up smoking now going on 30 years as did my husband.  He works in advertising and was smoking 5 packs of lucky strikes a day.  Back when you were allowed to smoke in the office.  We as a society can do many things to make people aware of the dangers.  I know I got scared and quit and thanks god I did because growing older with my grandchildren is worth it.  Bottom line is choice and to get Congress or government involved in what people do with their everyday life is a bit much.  The commercials will never scare away a determined smoker.  Same goes for Alcohol.  People need to find that determination within themself.  We do have an obligation to continue to warn the public and the tobacco companies will continue to sell cigerettes.  If we band it in the US people will get it from other countries and pay any price as well.  I think the US has done the best job of awareness and we do have less people ssmoking than 20 years ago. 
By Barbara B on 06/09/2009 8:58 am
f p
I quit 30 yrs ago too—2 packs of Luckies a day then.  Sure glad I quit. 
By f p on 06/09/2009 9:14 am
Barbara B
Please excuse the spelling errors.
By Barbara B on 06/09/2009 8:59 am
f p
Really? You’re kidding me—making a profit? Insurance  Companies?   Aw geez who’d a thunk it!
By f p on 06/09/2009 9:00 am
caj p
Insurance companies and drug companies rule this country in the health care field and the the time has come for them to stop dictating the terms!   They are and always have been more interested in making money than giving a toss about all the citizens rights to have affordable health care.  Money drives these companies and most of the Reps are in their pockets alongside some weak Democrats who think more of themselves than they do about getting all citizens health care coverage.   The Reps of course will oppose any plan put forth by Obama…now there’s a surprise but make no mistake his plan will go forth this time, he ran on health care reform and he will get that done.   It’s sad that so many are just so selfish that they think about themselves and the average joe blow can go fish as far as they are concerned.
By caj p on 06/09/2009 9:21 am
C Hardy
"Money drives these companies and most of the Reps are in their pockets"…do you have proof of this claim?  Then you say there are some weak dems, why are the dems weak yet the Reps arent?  Bias comment dont you think?
By C Hardy on 06/09/2009 10:53 am
caj p
Why do you think that the Reps don’t want to change the system they are in the pockets of the lobbyists for the insurance and drug companies the proof my dear is exactly that!!!   The Dems are weak because they should be on board with this health care plan but they are also in the pockets of these folks, gutless wonders the lot of them and so self serving!!
By caj p on 06/09/2009 1:17 pm
C Hardy
Caj, I have always agreed that insurance companies rule our Country…its pretty sad but we can’t seem to live without them.  Anyone who takes money from these companies and doesnt make good decisions is just a "wing nut"…Healthcare is so important to anyone and for them to play around with it like they do, shows how much compassion they have, which is really sad. 
By C Hardy on 06/09/2009 1:40 pm
caj p
We both agree that insurance companies have too much sway in our health care system so something must be done about them to reign them in, they mustn’t be allowed to have monopoly rule anymore.  We need  health care for all our citizens no one should be locked out or priced out of having health care coverage in this day and age and in the richest country in the world it is obscene.  You and I also agree that those from both sides who pander to these people are "wing nuts" and they have no interest in the American people it’s all about them.
By caj p on 06/09/2009 7:16 pm
DeBúrca obj
You’re right caj p… the insurance & pharmaceutical lobby has them all shaking in their boots! The American people voted FOR healthcare reform and yet the Republicans and some Democrats are fighting against the will of the people for the will of the lobby.
By DeBúrca obj on 06/09/2009 1:59 pm