A Friend Stopped By | 08/05/2009 1:15 pm
Is There a Bonus Bias? by Shelby White

Editor’s Note: Shelby White is a New York-based writer whose work has appeared in Barron’s, The New York Times and Forbes. She is the author of What Every Woman Should Know About Her Husband’s Money, published by Random House in 1992.
It’s bonus time again. According to a report issued by New York State Attorney General Andrew Cuomo, nine banks distributed $32 billion in extra pay to their employees after receiving $175 billion in public funding. As the boys in the banks tally up their haul, there’s one question you can bet they are not asking: Is there bonus bias? Is that money going equally to men and women? Statistics are hard to come by about the actual bonus payments. But past analysis of the gender pay gap shows that women earn about 79% as much as men with an even greater gap for women working on Wall Street, who earn just 55.4% of what men do. It’s not a stretch to assume that once again the working woman is left in the dust.
Not that I’m the first to notice this. In June, Merrill Lynch broker Jamie Goodman sued the Bank of America (which now owns the brokerage firm) for gender bias over retention bonuses. Goodman had received high praise for her work, and was, according to the firm’s website, one of only 140 financial managers to receive a portfolio manager designation nationwide. But even that wasn’t good enough to give the $1 million producer what she thought was a fair shake.
Women are getting change, but it is still small.























19 Reader Comments (so far…) Sign In or Register to comment
I worked for a while in a government organization which handed out bonuses to "top performers." In my opinion, the true top performers, whether men or women, did not get the big bucks. The shameless self-promoters did.
One thing women need to learn to be more competitive is how to toot their own horns. You may think it is crass or immodest, but NO ONE notices those who quietly and competently do their jobs every day, even if they really excel.
I couldn’t agree with Lila more!
The biggest mistake women (and some men) make is the mistake in their belief that if they work really hard their boss will notice and then they will get recognition. I can not begin to tell you how wrong that is. It is the employee that not only works hard BUT ALSO tells their boss of their accomplishments on a regular (but tactful way - you don’t want to come off as a "know-it-all of kiss up) that gets the recognition.
I have always at every company I worked for "worked as if my name was on the company checks" Be aware of where you work, what they produce and why, clients and contracts they have and whenever possible try to learn as much about other departments and jobs so that you are perceived as an invaluable employee. Your role should never be to function as a worker bee or drone. No….it is always best to be the Queen Bee.
I hear what you’re saying Rita, but I have to disagree. I know a majority of women who are in power than those who are lower down on the ladder, and even among female executives there is this fear of losing their position. That it took years to make it to where they are and they don’t want to rock the boat or cause waves, so they acquiesce at every turn.
Now with that said, I agree with you that the good ol’ boys club is also at play. How could it not be. Women can do the exact same job as their male counterparts and still earn a fraction of what the men do. So clearly sexism is a play. But I still say we as women have to assert ourselves at every turn. I don’t think we should play it safe and blend into the woodwork, we should try to stand out.
Rita
I’m not going to try and re-invent the wheel so I’ll just say I agree with both you and Belinda Joy.
Belinda Joy - I find your philosophy on this subject is dead-on, and with good reason, because it is identical to an attitude I learned early in my working career…and it has been very successful for me. I would shudder to have anyone think that I consider myself “number one”. I couldn’t live with that terribly selfish label. But, I learned that it was okay if my motto was, “Do something good, then, tell it”. This goes along with your theory of the employee that not only works hard BUT ALSO tells their boss of their accomplishments…but of course, not get branded “bragadoccio”. One must remember to develop and perfect the method you recommend, “the tactful way - you don’t want to come off as a "know-it-all of kiss up”. It all leads up to success, and success leads to salary increases and bonuses.
This has been thought-provoking, all right. When the late sixties and early seventies feminist discussions came along, we were concerned about getting good jobs, being respected as equals, being considered as qualified contenders in the then mostly male-dominated fields like law, medicine, finance and on and on. And when we managed to break through in many ways, it soon became apparent that "equal pay for equal work" was NOT happening. It still isn’t. When I first began teaching, I was once told that a male colleague’s salary "had to be" more than mine because he was married and his wife was expecting, while I was a single woman whose "needs" were not as pressing. I seethed, and updated my resume and soon departed from that job. Today we wouldn’t hear something as blatant as I heard back in the day, but obviously there are many ways to hide the continued inequity in compensation, bonuses, promotions and so on.
Part of it, IMHO, may reside in women’s ability to negotiate firmly and assertively, to promote themselves effectively, and - most important - to develop a strong mentor network. For years, the boys met at the golf club, at the bar, at the gym, and did a lot of wheeling and dealing. Women, on the other hand, put in long, long hours, took work home, came in on weekends, and so on, and were not always in the loop of the politics of their organization. And let’s face it, finding the right way to make sure that your contributions and efforts are fully recognized is like walking a tightrope: one wrong phrase and you may be perceived as "aggressive"; "backstabbing"; "bitchy". (While the guys are just asking for their due, the women are "pushy".)
This being said, we still have a long way to go in the workplace. What should be rewarded is often completely ignored. Those who reap the hefty bonuses and praise are often the ones who least deserve it. And in the financial sector, bonuses are negotiated via contractual obligation, as we have seen. Whether the person actually performed well, or brought the company to the point of utter chaos or ruin, that contract is ironclad, and the payout comes despite the mess. Grrrrrrr.
Great discussion - and Susan, you are right on target. In re: "we were concerned about getting good jobs, being respected as equals, being considered as qualified contenders in the then mostly male-dominated fields like law, medicine, finance and on and on." Yes, and we had to jog in place at the kitchen sink "after-hours." What we ignored was equity in the workplace; equality didn’t serve us well at all.
On the military plane - all government service provides open information about pay for each level. That is how the for-profit sector keeps people in the bucket, in fact, threatens those "who tell." I was consulting for a for-profit corporation once where the employees posted their salaries on a bulletin board. Three were summarily dismissed and I was awe-struck just listening to the nasty planning in the executive suite. Terrible conduct unbecoming any level of management.
Women have made their break-through today with the appointment of Sotomayor! The African Americans reached a peak. The Hispanics have too. But, for women - today we saw our presence increased on the U.S. Supreme Court. It has been long overude. Iran has more women in national power than the USA. basta!
You are like a breeze from the ocean, Susan! It’s so relaxing to agree, isn’t it!
In re "corporate world" it’s an given, they’re grounded in abuse, and worse, perpetuate it, from the top down.