Marcia Cross (in these photos at least) is the most pulled together….they all look good except for Susan Sarandon. The shoes? The bracelet? Sleek and pulled together she is not..tone the shoes to the shoes to the dress. Basic concept.

Marcia Cross was simply exquisite!

My fav was Kyra Sedgwick, one I really liked that wasn’t mentioned was Brooke Shields, she gets more beautiful every year. One dress that wasn’t flattering in color or style was one worn by Mary Tyler Moore.

I agree, willow, Brooke looked wonderful, as did Kyra. I think all the pics were great, but Susan needed a bra and better shoes. What was she wearing under that dress, boots?

Kyra Sedgwick looked wonderful; she being the exception to my earlier snit about age-appropriate dressing)! Julia Louis-Dreyfus was glowing in that color and the dress cut her nicely. I loved the tulle and length of the dress Marcia Cross wore, but the appliques looked like a bride threw the bouqet AT her. I don’t understand HOW Susan Sarandon made this list, though. She sagged and clomped down the runway.

I’m not sure if it’s the way the pictures are taken, the screen on my computer or what. but I didn’t particularly like any of these looks. I think if I could have seen it a little clearer I’d have liked Holland Taylor’s look the best. Holland’s dress looked like “i’m gorgeous and sexy and I don’t have to try to hard”. Susan’s dress looked like “I’m stuck in the red dress with my cleavage showing AGAIN” and Marcia Cross looked like she’s headed out to a costume party as the “good witch”. Kyra’s gorgeous. which is why the sparkly starfish attacked her boobs and won’t let go! Okay… I couldn’t resist having some Joan Rivers kind of fun… LOL

I loved Kyra’s dress, but I would have put Mariska H and Vanessa W on this list- they looked AMAZING in their outfits… Hated Marcia’s dress- the appliques look like mold. :-/

My vote goes to Holland Taylor. She looks lovely and feminine and ageless. I think her smile is her best accessory.

I went and looked at the pics on another website and Mariska Hargitay would get my vote for best overall. She looked amazing. Heidi Klum had on a bizarre little dress but she pyulled it off big time.

Mariska Hargitay by all means. marcia Cross’ dress did, indeed look like mold. What on earth possessed someone as goregous as Eva Longoria to wear that tasteless tin foil thing. Don’t even mention Susan Sarandon and as for Mary Tyler Moore: did she have a stylist and if so, as they say in NY, he or she deserves a beatin’

Funny I though Marcia Crosses dress was a mess. The color was all wrong for her. A horrible thrift store find. Paula Weinsteins was a chocolate milk mess, the lines all go across her and make her look like a bus. Holland Taylors dress makes her look washed out and dowdy. OTOH Susan Sarandan looked amazing. Julia Lous-Dreyfuss totally rocked her dress love the color, the lines! Wow

I thought Susan Sarandan’s dress made her look frumpy. The girls were sagging, and what’s with the black shoes? The color was great; the line was wrong for her.