Medical Bankruptcy, American Journal of Medicine | 06/05/2009 10:10 am
Got a Serious Illness? You May Go Bankrupt From Your Medical Bills

If you have a stroke, heart disease, diabetes or any other serious issue that lands you in the hospital for any substantive amount of time, your medical bills just may bankrupt you.
A new study in The American Journal of Medicine shows that nearly two out of three — two out of three! — bankruptcies are caused by medical bills. And that number doesn’t even take into account today’s economic malaise. Even if you have health insurance, you’re not out of the woods. You still could meet your financial demise with that quasi-safety net, since the average bills were only about $10,000 less than those of the uninsured. In fact, in 2007, of those who filed for bankruptcy, about 80 percent had insurance. Consider these numbers: In 2007, medical problems contributed to 62.1 percent of all bankruptcies, and during the six years prior, the proportion of all medical-related bankruptcies rose by about 50 percent. Many others had to file because they lost much of their income due to illness, or mortgaged a home to pay their doctor’s bills. And these people aren’t poor — most, in fact, were well-educated, middle-class homeowners.
The Washington Post has the full study here. The New York Times notes that the health problems that left patients with the most out-of-pocket expenses were:
Neurologic (i.e., multiple sclerosis): $34,167
Diabetes: $26,971
Injuries: $25,096
Stroke: $23,380
Mental illnesses: $23,178
Heart disease: $21,955
"Our findings are frightening. Unless you’re Warren Buffett, your family is just one serious illness away from bankruptcy," said lead study author Dr. David Himmelstein, an associate professor of medicine at Harvard Medical School.
With scary numbers like that in mind, President Obama and Congress have big plans to overhaul the nation’s health-care system. But there seems to be a conflict between Republicans and Democrats over whether to include a "public option" in the bill — a government-run insurance program that would compete with private plans. That public plan would be similar to Medicare and would cover Americans who don’t have private insurance. President Obama and Democrats support the idea, but Republicans oppose the public option, and there’s no agreement on how to pay for it. One way may be to take $200 billion to $300 billion from Medicare and Medicaid over the next decade. There could be other cutbacks, as well.
“If we are going to make people responsible for owning health insurance, we must make health care affordable,” Obama wrote in a letter to Congress.
Nobel Prize-winning economist Paul Krugman said health-care reform is a great idea, but the "devil is in the details."
"Health reform will fail unless we get serious cost control — and we won’t get that kind of control unless we fundamentally change the way the insurance industry, in particular, behaves," Krugman wrote in The New York Times today. His advice to Congress? "Don’t trust the insurance industry," and "Don’t trust the insurance industry."























394 Reader Comments (so far…) Sign In or Register to comment
This is something that I am entirely too familiar with as my husband has a neuromuscular disease along with several other major health challenges. Without insurance we would be unable to afford his medical bills or the prescriptions he relies on to stay alive. Of course these health issues have an impact on his job performance. We know there will come a time when he is unable to work and may not be certified for disability right away. The company doctors have to determine that. They do not have to rely on the specialists he sees to make their determination for his fitness to work.
Compounding all this is the continuous rise in the cost of health care. We have seen office visits triple in price over the past ten years. Prescription medicines (the same medications not new drugs) increase over fifty percent even when we changed to generics. Only three of the many physicians that have treated my husband have been willing to work with us on billing. Some offices demanded the co-pay before you see the doctor. When we check our bills we find countless errors in favor of the providers. One hospital charged us for the use of treatment room three times.
Soaring healthcare has been a death sentence to many viable productive Americans because they can’t afford the care they require. To be eligible for most of the free state programs you have to spend down all of your assets before you are allowed to enroll. Maybe it is time for the government to scrutinize the healthcare industry to see if the rise in costs is justified.
No one should have to go bankrupt due to health care costs. But what is the answer? We are having the Canada, England and European systems shouted at us as an example of what ‘good’ universal health care could be and whoever flaunts this around (Obama being one of the first) has no idea of what they are talking about. The health care in Canada for instance is sub- standard. Money is being thrown down a pit and if you are an elderly person with kidney failure you will be put on a list for treatment but probably bumped by anyone who comes behind you that is younger. In England certain treatments for cancers are not approved because of the cost and in all cases the systems are bankrupt. I am not against a universal health care system here in America but we need to take a long look at the systems that are in place now and are failing. People who are older with chronic illnesses are dying because of them in those countries and we must do better here. To just jump into a plan that has not been scrutinized is suicide for any of us who have health care right now. I want time taken to make sure if we go down this path as a nation it is not going to bankrupt us or end up with substandard care and treatment of any kind. I for one do not want an unproven system shoved down my throat.
Canuck,
We certainly cannot attach whatever we do to employment any longer because of the many who are unemployed and don’t qualify for government help. I don’t know what the answer i, but we have to at least try something since no one saw any need to try to draft a plan as costs for health care sky rocketed. Way back before Clinton and Hillary’s attempt at creating affordable health care there were signs that the system was broke. Think about those who started going into Canada to get drugs!
Our Governator is a moderate on some issues, but he doesn’t have a good record of caring for those who end up with no other option but to turn to the state for health care. I personally know many of these folk because I run support groups for rheumatic/autoimmune diseases. My own diagnosis, which I received 23 years ago at the age of 23, is lupus, an automatic exclusion for private insurance in our state. The Governor has cut Medi-Cal so much that we don’t get all the monies we should get from the federal government for the program. He took away a large chunk of my tiny income with this move that was done so quickly that I knew about it before Social Security did http://www.californiaprogressreport.com/2008/12/schwarzeneggers_28.html . By the way I have been fighting unsuccessfully for the right to work part-time, so that I would have some way to live despite cuts, but Medicare Part D needs fixing before I could do this. Now the gov is telling people that he has to make the "hard choices", which could include people dying: http://www.latimes.com/news/local/la-me-budget28-2009may28,0,1322149.story My frustration is that there seems to be no move to reform state worker’s pensions, which will break the system entirely in a few years, or to remove the health care we pay for our politicians, or to take away perks like free use of cars, in the face of the budget crisis.
I also question why their is federal bailout for banks but not for people.
I often feel alone and uncared for, probably because I know too many people who are either blinded by extreme right-wing ideology and vote against their own interests, or who feel "I’ve got mine; why should I care about you." The sheep and the selfish…
but there is work going on for reform. Some links: http://medicareforall.net, http://familiesusa.org, http://ga1.org/campaign/singlepayer
My own page is under construction so please wait a week to visit it :) but it will be at http://www.xbeepx.org/Site/Beeps_Health_Care_Reform_Page.html