Sign in to wowOwow

Enter the email address that you used when registering at wowOwow.
The password field is case sensitive. Click here if you have forgotten your password.

Please register for wowOwow

Newsletter subscriptions
Sign up to receive wowOwow's weekly newsletter and get our best picks delivered right to your inbox. Our newsletter content is hand-picked by the wowOwow editorial team and provides the top features, news, and commentary from our site. Subscribing to our newsletter is free and safe. We will never share your email or other information with a third-party without your direct consent.
By registering, you indicate that you have read and agree
with our privacy policy and terms of service.

Rita Bahuguna Joshi | 07/16/2009 9:35 am

Indian Lawmaker Rita Bahuguna Joshi Jailed, Had House Burned, for Standing Up for Rape Victims

Critics say she made too many nasty statements toward the Dalit, or lower-caste, when she insulted a female minister; Indian brides-to-be forced into virginity, pregnancy tests.
By The Staff at wowOwow.com
Image: Wikipedia

A female Indian lawmaker is in jail for 14 days after she essentially tried to defend rape victims in her country.

Uttar Pradesh Congress chief Rita Bahuguna Joshi was sent to Moradabad jail today for insulting Chief Minister Mayawati, another woman. Her sentence comes just a day after her house was set on fire, allegedly by members of the state’s ruling Bahujan Samaj Party (BSP), who showed up with iron rods and gas cans. Joshi denied having said anything offensive.

"It was at a meeting in Moradabad that I had simply sought to draw the people’s attention to the fact that Mayawati’s dole of Rs.25,000 to every Dalit [low caste] rape victim was quite ironical as the state police chief was spending lakhs on the helicopter ride that he undertakes to hand over that paltry amount to the victim," Joshi told reporters. "My intention was to remind Mayawati that being a woman she should realize that a paltry monetary compensation cannot make up for what a woman loses on account of rape."

Joshi also said Mayawati should be raped so she can comprehend the plight of crime victims in her state. "Women who are raped should throw the money at Mayawati’s face and say to her, ‘You too should be raped and I will give you ten million rupees’," she said.

Joshi could face ten years in prison for this remark, and others. It’s illegal in India to make comments considered derogatory toward lower castes. She apologized if her remarks were "misconstrued and misinterpreted," and added, "I am myself a woman and I should not have spoken these words. I really apologize."

The Uttar Pradesh unit of India’s Congress will launch a state-wide protest beginning Friday against Joshi’s arrest and the arson.

Elsewhere in India, in the central state of Madhya Pradesh, a ruckus is being raised over brides reportedly being forced to take pregnancy and virginity tests via manual examination before they are married en masse during state ceremonies. Women’s rights groups are outraged, since many of the women felt humiliated and ashamed by the exams. Some reported that if the women refused, the government wouldn’t give them their wedding money.

"Such a shameful act where girls had to reportedly undergo tests to prove their chastity to avail the government’s financial aid were sinful and could not be tolerated in a sane society," said Girija Vyas, head of the Indian National Commission for Women.

10 Reader Comments (so far…) Sign In or Register to comment

Chrome Toe
God I love America
By Chrome Toe on 07/16/2009 9:58 am
F P
Once again more male religious stupidity.
By F P on 07/16/2009 10:31 am
Deena B.

I’m of two minds here.  Obviously, the rape victims were treated shabbily.  And requiring brides to submit to pregnancy and virginity tests is barbaric.  There is absolutely no excuse for Joshi’s house being set on fire.

But…I do find her remarks to Mayawati to be very offensive.  And I hate when people "apologize" by saying they are sorry if their remarks were misinterpreted.  I don’t find that to be a sincere apology.

Nevertheless, she should not be jailed for those remarks. 

By Deena B. on 07/16/2009 11:14 am
Rachel F
I agree, Deena…she worded that much too strongly, but there’s no way she should be arrested, jailed, or face court for it. As was said earlier, this just reinforces why I love America so much.
By Rachel F on 07/16/2009 11:24 am
S G
It is time women of the world stood up together. Rape is wrong. No one should go through that horror.
By S G on 07/16/2009 3:40 pm
Lauri Anderson

Oh, this issue continues to enrage me.  Yes, I agree Joshi overstepped by even suggesting that women would wish the other woman (or any other woman for that matter) to be raped, but she has already lost her home over it.  Jail is too harsh a punishment for the actual content of derogatory remark.  All it accomplishes is to yet again push aside the real issue.  The victims would be much better served to see their assailants prosecuted and punished.

These issues are not at all unrelated.  If it is so damned important that the woman be chaste at the time of marriage, then men who sexually assault them should be the ones to suffer, but everyone turns a blind eye as if the man has the right.  Women in these cultures should never walk alone, should carry whistles, blow horns, pepper spray, something to call attention if they are being attacked.  In my opinion, the man who stands by and does nothing is just as guilty as the assailant.

By Lauri Anderson on 07/16/2009 4:02 pm
mary lou s

you argue this as if the arguers had full rights. neither side does. it is like us criticizing ghetto people for self destructive behavior when we were the ones that put them into that trap in the first place:

http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2009/jul/12/jimmy-carter-womens-…
By mary lou s on 07/16/2009 4:35 pm
S G
mary lou, thank you for the article. Everyone should read it.
By S G on 07/16/2009 4:54 pm
Deena B.
I didn’t think we were arguing it at all.  Everyone agreed she should definitely not be jailed - regardless of her comments.
By Deena B. on 07/16/2009 6:16 pm
Lauri Anderson
Great article, thank you.  Even though I consider myself agnostic, I have long been a fan of Jimmy Carter’s.  It was not my intention to argue, either, I simply would like to know more about how these cultures feel they can have it both ways - they insist on brides being chaste, and indeed virgins, yet do nothing to discourage men from having their way with women.
By Lauri Anderson on 07/16/2009 6:55 pm