Sign in to wowOwow

Enter the email address that you used when registering at wowOwow.
The password field is case sensitive. Click here if you have forgotten your password.

Please register for wowOwow

Newsletter subscriptions
Sign up to receive wowOwow's weekly newsletter and get our best picks delivered right to your inbox. Our newsletter content is hand-picked by the wowOwow editorial team and provides the top features, news, and commentary from our site. Subscribing to our newsletter is free and safe. We will never share your email or other information with a third-party without your direct consent.
By registering, you indicate that you have read and agree
with our privacy policy and terms of service.

A Friend Stopped By | 03/13/2009 3:00 pm

Michelle Obama Should Leave Daughters' Diets Out of the Press

By Alyse Myers
© Getty Images

Editor’s Note: Alyse Myers is the author of Who Do You Think You Are?: A Memoir, which comes out in paperback next month.

Growing up, I cringed whenever I was compared to anyone else. Or when I was used as an example — good or bad — in front of an audience. In the second grade (the same grade as Sasha Obama), I had a teacher who would constantly tell the rest of the class that if I couldn’t do something — an art project, keep quiet during recess, etc. — well, no one could. And as you can imagine, despite that teacher’s good intentions, I wasn’t very popular in that class. I hated being on that stage — especially at seven.

So when I read Rachel L. Swarns’s piece in The New York Times — "Michelle Obama’s Agenda Includes Healthful Eating" — I had a second-grade flashback.

Swarns’ article focused on the First Mom’s campaign to promote healthy food and living, and it made mention of how she is working to make sure her daughters develop the right eating habits, too.  It’s a challenge for mothers everywhere —- especially now. The article suggested that the White House kitchen might want to consider issuing regular news releases describing the menus of the First Couple and their daughters — so that other parents can use them as examples to share with their own children, a kind of "If Sasha and Malia are eating broccoli, well, you should, too."

At first read, the suggestion is a noble one. Mrs. Obama’s quest to make healthy eating a key part of her social agenda will no doubt positively affect millions of chubby American families.

But taking the extra step of using the Obama girls as salad-eating poster children to promote good eating habits among their peers? Don’t do it Mrs. Obama.

"Any time you use children as example to other children, your mission could backfire," said Dr. Ron Balamuth, a child psychologist and psychoanalyst affiliated with Columbia University. "Telling children that they should behave the same way as Sasha and Malia risks making them feel inadequate."

There’s also the issue of making your child feel unwanted. "You’re almost telling them unintentionally that you would rather be the parent of ‘those perfect girls,’" he said.

And finally, there’s the risk of undermining your child’s self-esteem. "By comparing and contrasting children, you elevate one — but bring down another," said Balamuth.

Ouch.

And let’s not forget the privacy matter. The First Lady has already declared that she doesn’t want her girls to be used for marketing purposes. Her office fired a presidential salvo across marketers’ bows last January when it asked Ty Inc., the maker of Beanie Babies, to remove two dolls that appeared to be named after Sasha and Malia — despite the company’s protests that those sweet and marvelous names had nothing to do with the First Daughters. I think most parents would agree that the White House made the right call there. I know I did.

2009_0313_Alyse_Myers_Book2.jpg If the Obamas decide to promote what Sasha and Malia are eating to set an example, their privacy could be violated. Beanie Babies or broccoli — exposure would put them on the spot. And the last thing those beautiful girls need is to have their dietary bar raised to the point of perfection. I would imagine most seven- and ten-year-olds wouldn’t want to have what they eat each day held up for all to see, either.

I’m all for promoting healthy eating. But please, let’s leave the First Daughters out of it. At least until they’re old enough to speak for themselves. The stage they’re on now must be uncomfortable enough.

 

61 Reader Comments (so far…) Sign In or Register to comment

Kryssi K
I actually had to click on the link to the author’s book and check out the back flap for a photo of her, because I could not understand how anyone could perceive this move on Michelle Obama’s part to be anything but RESPONSIBLE…unless the writer herself is embittered by struggling with serious weight issues. But alas, I am genuinely stumped by this one!
By Kryssi K on 03/13/2009 3:22 pm
amy selwyn
I agree wholeheartedly with Myers’ comments. Children do not like being held up to the public eye as examples of what is right, what is perfect, what is best. Please, let’s not turn these two beautiful young girls into characters in a food diary. Women and girls are already plagued by a host of issues around eating, food and body images in this country. So, while I applaud Michele Obama for promoting healthy eating, I side with the author re: the tactics.
By amy selwyn on 03/13/2009 4:19 pm
kathy kaehler
I LOVE that the First family is talking about the importance of eating healthy eating.  It is about time to have open discussions, suggestions, ideas and tips on eating well and moving our bodies.  I agree that the privacy issue should be considered and this is why I took the time to register and write in.  I am the former Today Show fitness correspondent and now a food coach for regular people, as well as celebrities.  I have three growing boys and know exactly what she is dealing with.  Maybe this administration will hire a spokesperson like myself to be the front runner for talking about fitness and healthy eating and that will influence not only the White House kitchen staff, the First family, but all families in the United States.  By Kathy Kaehler 
By kathy kaehler on 03/13/2009 4:46 pm
nanchan u

I think the real question is, why would any parent compare their children to anybody else? 

Let those little girls, and their diets, be.  Concentrate on your own children and what you can steer them to eat by your OWN EXAMPLE

By nanchan u on 03/13/2009 4:50 pm
deber B
nanchuan u, you are always the voice of reason.   
By deber B on 03/13/2009 7:21 pm
Camille Groom
Amen to that! I agree. As the youngest of 8 children I was always being compared in school to one or the other of my older syblings. It’s the same idea, ugh kids don’t need to be compared to "the girls" or have them be used as examples.
By Camille Groom on 03/16/2009 10:35 am
carolyn thacker
i think it was great fo her to post anything about her daughters, they will become role models for all girls their age, i have four granchildren, all of them are picky eaters, each in their own way, instead of criticizing her, they should offer ways to make meals more appealing, just as making grilled cheese sandwiches in different shapes to make them more appeatizing to young children
By carolyn thacker on 03/16/2009 12:57 pm
newzie snoozie

 

TODAY FOR A TIME I THOUGHT ABOUT THIS  FOR AWHILE. THEN I DECIDED THE WRITTER OF THIS PIECE  FEELS  SHE JUST FINALLY GOT FED UP WITH HER PARENTS AND DECIDED TO TELL THEM OFF GOOD SO SHE ASSOCIATED HER BEST PIECE AND SHE WAS SAYNG OK MOM AND DAD I HAVE HAD IT. I HAVE WRITTEN A PICE ABOUT  MICHELLE AND BARACKS KIDS ANDHOPE YOU READ IT BECAUSE  YOU ALWAYS MADE MY LIFE DIFFICULT AND NOW SINCE I HAVE SEEN MICHELLE BRINGING INTO THE SPOT LIGHT AND I KNOW  THIS IS HOW I CNA IMPORTANTLY  SEEM TO BE AND YOU  CNA SEE HOW I FEEL  ABOUT IT FROM MY VIEW POINT INCLUDING AND USIONG THE NAME OF
"THE PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES AND T WANT YOU TO TAKE IT AS PERSONAL.  I HATED YOU FOR   BLAHH!!!&ETC.NOW WE  WOUDL HAVE TO TELL THE FOLKS ON THELEPHONE  ALL OF THTA IN ONE BAD FEELINGS RETURNED TO THE ONES WHO CAUSED IOTIN ONE BREATH……..THE WRITTER IS FINALLY  SPOKEN HER GUTS AND SHE HAS GONE HER WHOLE LIFE WITHOUT SPEAKING TO HER PARENTS SHE HAS BEEN SO UP SET  WITH FOR MANY SEVERAL YEARS……………….THE ENDANY RESEMBLEANCE TO LIVING OR DEAD  IS PURELLY COINCIDENTAL.MANY AUTHORS ACTUALLY DO BLOW THEIR KNOWS  IN THE ARTICLES  THEY WRITEJUST THOUGHT YOU’D  LIKE  TO  KNOW!

By newzie snoozie on 03/13/2009 4:56 pm
phyllis Doyle Pepe
I just read the article that Ms Myers is alluding to and no where in that article can I find anything that suggests the Obama daughters are being used or held up as "salad eating poster children." We should be grateful we have a first lady that is concerned about healthy eating habits and is speaking out, giving good advice, and promoting a diet that is balanced and nutritious. I found the claims in this article, to be kind, a lot of tomfoolery.
By phyllis Doyle Pepe on 03/13/2009 5:38 pm
Sam Mirando
Yes, Miz Doyle Pepe :)
By Sam Mirando on 03/13/2009 6:16 pm
Mary Quite-Contrary
Its admirable that Mrs. Obama wants to promote healthy eating. Like the author, though, and as a mom myself, I would advise keeping the girls out of the spotlight as much as possible. The Clintons did a really good job of keeping Chelsea away from public scrutiny…the Bush twins were older so their privacy was a little harder to achieve. The Obama girls should just be allowed to be “kids” (their diet being private).
By Mary Quite-Contrary on 03/13/2009 5:59 pm
Rita@ Goldivas
I trust Michelle’s judgement, she and Barack are great parents. I think Alyse Myers is over-reacting.
By Rita@ Goldivas on 03/13/2009 6:06 pm
C Hardy

I kind of agree with what this article says.  I mean I am sure these two girls have a lot to deal with everyday b/c of who their Father is…now we will see what they eat.  I know heckling doesn’t go on in their private school but lets just say it does and the whole school knows what they eat when they are home…some kids will use that against them.  Kids can be mean…

But at one point we were asked to leave the Obama girls out of the media yet they are being put into it by their Mother, not saying that is bad or good, at least she is the one doing it…but dont put others down for doing it. 

Maybe what those two girls eat isnt any of our business. Now if the White House wants to put out the type of food it feeds the Obama girls, but not a daily menu…

By C Hardy on 03/13/2009 6:22 pm
Diana T

Me thinks Alyse Myers has a book to sell and will go to any lengths to sell it.  Lordy, I think back at everything that was written about the Nixon girls, the Ford kids, and thiis woman is whining about what the Obama kids eat? 

By Diana T on 03/13/2009 6:31 pm
Diana T
Sorry, type o…."about what is written in regards to what the Obama kids eat."
By Diana T on 03/13/2009 6:32 pm