Sign in to wowOwow

Enter the username or e-mail address that you used when registering at wowOwow.
The password field is case sensitive. Click here if you have forgotten your password.

Please register for wowOwow

By registering, you indicate that you have read and agree
with our privacy policy and terms of service.

Question of the Day | 04/13/2009 12:00 am

How important is a policy for small businesses in the effort to create new jobs and reach economic recovery?

There has been severe criticism of the Obama stimulus plan’s lack of support for entrepreneurs. How important is a policy for small businesses in the effort to create new jobs and reach economic recovery? Mary Wells, Candice Bergen and the wOw women start the conversation.
© Shutterstock
Liz Smith

Liz Smith | 04/13/2009 12:00 am

Liz Smith Sees Only One Lifeboat on the Horizon

The president’s plan is the only one I have heard so I want to give him every chance to make it work. If the Republicans had offered alternatives that seemed real, I’d have been eager to understand those. What I hate is the way Congress seems bent, in an emergency, on putting stumbling blocks in the president’s way when his is the only lifeboat seen on the horizon. My criticism of the president is mild. I do think he should have more than declared a national emergency on the scale of prepping for World War II, when Americans all threw in together and worked together and patriotism and sacrifice were considered the way to be. People seem to just want to wait a few months until things go back to "the old normal."

And, of course, small businesses need help to create new jobs (and big businesses, too) and reach economic recovery.

A draft of young people for service would be a good idea as well.

Mary Wells

Mary Wells | 04/13/2009 12:00 am

Mary Wells Knows How We Will Reach Recovery

Supporting small businesses and big ones, too, creating new jobs, good sturdy ones — that is how we will reach recovery. Obama has been stressing that recently.  

Candice Bergen

Candice Bergen | 04/13/2009 12:00 am

Candice Bergen on Stimulus: 'What Choice Do We Have?'

Unless there’s another, better solution … support the guy. What choice do we have?

Joan Ganz Cooney

Joan Ganz Cooney | 04/13/2009 12:00 am

Joan Ganz Cooney Leaves It to Others

I’m not qualified to have an opinion on this; I leave it to others.

58 Reader Comments (so far…) Sign In or Register to comment

3

In the San Francisco Bay Area is a very effective non-profit; Women’s Initiative. http://www.womensinitiative.org/index.htm

Women attend orientation meetings, then based on their applications subsequent to the event are selected based on merit for open slots in the 10-week business incubation courses. 

They learn how to run a small business including writing a business plan. At the conclusion of the course they can receive up to $10K in seed money, and also free rent in live-work space, plus membership in an extensive network, etc.  Major local companies and foundations support the program that has been highly successful.

Models like this could be duplicated around the country, and funded for a a fraction of bailing out corrupt major banks that got us into this economic debacle, and not limited just to women.

Since small business is the main engine of our economy it makes sense that they be supported, too. Esp when states are cutting social services when they are most needed when evil organizations like AIG aren’t just receiving hundreds of billions in bailouts, but are using large sums of tax payer dollars for outrageous executive bonuses, renovating offices, buying private planes, etc.  

I agree with Liz that there needs to be a national call-to-arms….that gets rewarded with real benefits like free college. And I think we also need a WWII-era WPA type national program, too.

 

By 3 on 04/13/2009 2:17 am
FrannieEm
The Women’s Initiative is for minority women.  It is a great program, but limited to minorities.
By FrannieEm on 04/13/2009 12:50 pm
3

It is curious that someone not from the San Francisco Bay Area, and probably not understanding the culture, would incorrectly comment that the Women’s Initiative is limited to ‘minorities.’

The selection criteria is based solely on currently being low income and if after an interview the program directors believe the applicant is a viable candidate for starting a business and thus justifying the investment of tens of thousands of dollars into her.

Here are some of the graduates and their success stories. Obviously they are not all ‘minorities.’ Although am not sure what minorities means.

http://www.womensinitiative.org/aboutus/graduate-spotlights.htm 

And their "Cultivating Prosperity" videos and missions statement of financial independence for all women.

http://www.womensinitiative.org/newsroom/videos.htm 

In the past 6 months I’ve watched many local news programs, Oprah, etc. where women who were once earning 6-figure incomes are now in their last months of unemployment and on food stamps, fearing being on the street, and needing some kind of retraining or assist into self-employment. The stories are heartbreaking and the women [and their dependent children] cut across all lines of society, education, former income levels, and race. I learned about the program when speaking to a very attractive, smartly dressed and affluent appearing lady. When I asked about an article of clothing, she was the manufacturer, had a beautiful studio and was a graduate of the program, and completely impressive. She’d fallen on very desperate times not of her making, and a small investment had her on her way again on another avenue of success. Wish this program was more widespread, as well as their mission of ‘cultivating prosperity for all.’ 

By 3 on 04/13/2009 2:51 pm
FrannieEm

To answer your curiosity, I have two neices and a sister-in-law that live in the Bay Area, and I helped them to research and plan their new businesses.  We looked up the Women’s initiative and my s-i-law could take advantage of it because she is half latina (but she decided not to because she found she could teach it having been a partner in another business), but my nieces could not.  One niece is fabulous mural, trompe l’oeil, and faux finisher had to go to other sources.  The other niece, who is earning a degree in product design, went to work for a firm.  My nephew and his wife live up there, and she came across the same problem.  That was in the last year, maybe they have changed.  

You are correct, it is a wonderful program and provides great opportunities for women maybe they will expand it to be more inclusive.

I hope this satisfies your curiosity. 

By FrannieEm on 04/13/2009 3:18 pm
3
Perhaps they earned too much money or something—-because the program was never limited to anyone except by an income ceiling.
By 3 on 04/13/2009 3:51 pm
FrannieEm
No, at the time they weren’t earning much at all, so don’t know.  Maybe they say income ceiling and it has many stipulations.  When I was applying for scholarships for Calif State colleges (they hadn’t university system yet)  I was denied many because I was not "culturally deprived" because I had a high GPA.  Nor problem, I got other scholarships to UCLA, USC and Stanford, so I didn’t care and felt that it was important for minorities to have every chance. 
By FrannieEm on 04/13/2009 8:00 pm
Cjay

That is essentially the model for the women and minority-owned business initiative nationwide, Suzanne, not just the Bay Area..

When credit loosens up, the small business’ line of credit will also become more flexible; however, small business has always been at the heels of the feds for more money, since the WMB initiative begin in the 80s. They need t o learn to plan and hang on, too. In most instances, throughout the nation, there are many programs to assist the WMB, even in the incubators at community colleges, the GSA, SBA, et al. All is not lost, in fact, it is far easier for the WMB to ‘catch-up’ and indeed survive under incredible odds, that the currency/credit sucking major corporations that only exist to pay off their board, and appears the shareholder, which btw, is what has happened to health care in the US - most large physician groups and all the for-profit hospitals have precisely those goals siphoning off funds from even doctor’s pay, and definitely patient care.

 

By Cjay on 04/13/2009 5:33 pm
3
Cjay, That’s interesting to know….dumb me..I thought it was just a complete marvel. Think the admin should put a windfall tax on Exxon, Halliburton, Blackhawk, etc and fund initiative and micro-enterprise like Grameen Foundation that also operates in the US. http://www.grameenfoundation.org/
By 3 on 04/13/2009 8:21 pm
joan larsen

Love the idea of SF’s Women’s Initiative with all its steps and help for women starting out in the field of small business … and I wouldn’t be surprised if it may not be active in other large cities.  But do you know about SCORE?  No one thinking about getting in to a small business for the first time — or having a small business that needs help in surviving — should contact SCORE (found on the Internet) for help on the financial end, marketing, and a "score" of road bumps that we occur when acting as an entrepreneur. 

Our business was having a problem several years back and called SCORE.  To our surprise, a group of 3 retired executives with huge credentials and the need to feel needed and helpful appeared in business suits and briefcases, rolled up their sleeves and were ready to help us figure our problems out.  The cost?  Free.  The end result?  It was obvious that their sharing had made all the difference.  We all had made new friends and came out smiling.  It was a win-win for us all.

What I am suggesting is that there is no need to wait - and wait some more for some "policy" from above.  .  . not when we have experienced able bodies willing to guide us, and give us the pats on the back to TRY now.  Creative ideas always have a place.  One that I see booming is the storefront tutoring after-school programs — an idea that is just not going to go out-of-date, ever!!! 

Great ideas come from small seeds, carefully planted with as much of free expert help that you could want. If properly nurtured and watched over, you too can SCORE!!     

By joan larsen on 04/13/2009 3:24 am
MaizieJames

No matter the continuing criticism of President Obama’s Stimulus Recovery Act/Plan’s lack of [financial policy] support for small businesses, entrepreneurial ingenuity will never diminish.  Implicit in the ‘connotation’ of enterprenerialism - literally - is the ability to devise business plans/ideas/strategies, which ultimately prove profitable - without ‘government’ monies.

I don’t feel worried about [entrepreneurial type] small businesses faltering, because there will always exist sharp-minded, smart individuals with brilliant creative ideas; mavericks, who hold the combination of perfect timing and a great business concept, which would generate start-up capital from suave investors - equity partners/joint venture capitalists.

This is how America was built - businesses which became ICONS, borne of the entrepreneurial spirit in a free enterprise democracy.

By MaizieJames on 04/13/2009 3:52 am
LindaKaplanThaler
Maizie, I couldn’t have said it better.  I believe that small businesses and the entrepreneurial spirit that gave birth to some of America’s most successful companies (let’s not forget that Google, Microsoft, and even my agency, The Kaplan Thaler Group all grew from tiny seedlings) will be the key to rebuilding our economy. Now is the time for the "little guys" to get up, get going, and "think small" to achieve their biggest dreams.
By LindaKaplanThaler on 04/13/2009 3:18 pm
FrannieEm

Maizie and Linda

Great posts.  We are trying to rally ourselves and our business forward, I just hope more will pick up the entrepreneurial spirit and come up with some great ideas that move our nation forward. 

By FrannieEm on 04/13/2009 3:21 pm
3

Apple is the most admired company in the world. And Steve Jobs was collecting bottles to eat, walking 7 miles across town once a week for a free dinner, and sleeping on dorm room floors before he started his business in his parents’ garage.

Obama becoming POTUS proves that the American Dream is alive and well. As the expression goes ‘argue for your limitations and they are yours.’

I did the Firewalk with Tony Robbins…..amazing. The coals are 2,000 degrees, you see them and think there is absolutely no way to walk barefoot down that 12’+ trench of red hot coals. Then you go inside and learn over 4 hrs or so how to do it. It’s not a trick, and it is a powerful metaphor for how much our belief systems, interior thoughts and representations limit and stop us.

Here’s a great 18 min Ted talk by Tony:

http://www.ted.com/index.php/talks/tony_robbins_asks_why_we_do_what_we_d…

And Steve Jobs Stanford University commencement speech:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D1R-jKKp3NA

The best thing about America is our entrepreneurial spirit when focused on life affirming dreams.  As Eleanor Roosevelt said ‘The future belongs to those who believe in the beauty of their dreams."

Yes, the government should give small business a piece of the stimulus pie instead of letting the corporations and banks gorge at the trough…..but still it has to come down to individual beliefs and actions…and never giving up. 

By 3 on 04/13/2009 4:10 pm
MaizieJames
PS:  There is already enough ‘legitimate’ criticism [from renowned/learned economist] about the mind-boggling cost of President Obama’s Stimulus Recovery Act - as it exists!!  Why then, continue to focus on areas which were left out of the kettle?  Instead, I hope our country will support the President’s efforts to make the current plan work - even if Stimulus Recovery Act has a minimal effect bringing about a sibilance of recovery in our overall economy.  
By MaizieJames on 04/13/2009 4:08 am
ZeraLee
Belittling the effort is the opposite of supporting it.
By ZeraLee on 04/13/2009 11:17 pm