Sign in to wowOwow

Enter the email address that you used when registering at wowOwow.
The password field is case sensitive. Click here if you have forgotten your password.

Please register for wowOwow

Newsletter subscriptions
Sign up to receive wowOwow's weekly newsletter and get our best picks delivered right to your inbox. Our newsletter content is hand-picked by the wowOwow editorial team and provides the top features, news, and commentary from our site. Subscribing to our newsletter is free and safe. We will never share your email or other information with a third-party without your direct consent.
By registering, you indicate that you have read and agree
with our privacy policy and terms of service.

The Lesley Stahl Interview | 06/28/2009 11:00 pm

Roya Hakakian: The Iranian Regime Is Coming Undone

Author Roya Hakakian joins Lesley Stahl for a post-election discussion about gender apartheid, an Iranian girlhood and the moves necessary for a better Middle East.
Roya Hakakian

ROYA: Yes, of course.

LESLEY: Yes.

ROYA: It’s a gender apartheid. We don’t see it. One side isn’t black and the other side isn’t white. They all look like each other. But the truth is that the laws are apartheid laws, and the discrimination is apartheid – proportion discrimination in the eyes of the courts.

LESLEY: You were saying that the Theocracy, the idea that Mullahs and religious clerics would run the country, had already died as an ideal, in terms of idealism, in Iran.

ROYA: Certainly for Iranians.

LESLEY: On television people in the region are watching the clerics ordering the beating and shooting of their own citizens. How do you think that’s going to play out in terms of the sense of legitimacy for this kind of power and rule in other countries?

ROYA: Well I can tell you what the few messages that came through Facebook to me were, and I think those are really telling. About three days ago I got a message from someone in Iran. It was a posting saying, "Wait a minute. For 30 years we have been marching on the streets of Iran in support of the Palestinians saying that each time the Israelis attack the Palestinians here we were demonstrating against the Israeli attack on behalf of the Palestinians in Iran. So where are the Palestinians now that we’re under attack? Why aren’t they pouring into the streets to support us?"

Yes, so much has changed – and nothing has changed ... Everything is exactly where it was in the year that I left, in 1984.

LESLEY: Yes. Right. I hadn’t heard about that. I do know that the Israeli government is rooting for Ahmadinejad to remain in power because they feel that with him remaining in his role, Iran is a weakened state – within and without.

ROYA: I think that Israelis, much like a lot of the American policymakers, have consistently gotten Iran wrong, and this is yet another manifestation of how wrong they get it.

LESLEY: Why? You think with Ahmadinejad in power that Iran remains powerful?

ROYA: No. I think Ahmadinejad shouldn’t have run and I know for certain that he didn’t get elected. But I think an Iran with a Mousavi in power, with fair elections, a strong Iran, will make for a much better Middle East. The closer Iranians get to a fair government, the better off Israel is and the better off the region is. So I think Israelis think about this sort of backwards. They think that Ahmadinejad and the suffering of Iranians somehow is to the benefit of Israel and their policies, and I think that’s totally wrong.

LESLEY: I’ve organized my questions based on what I’ve been seeing and what I’ve been reading. I was wondering what I didn’t ask that you think is important for Americans to know. Tell us something that I wasn’t clever enough to think up as a question.

ROYA: I don’t like that question because I think you are clever enough … but I think one of the things that we haven’t done, which I wrote about last week in a piece, is that we cover inconsistently. When my brother came to the United States in the mid-’70s, people in New York asked him where he was from, and when he said Iran, no one understood where Iran was. And in his first week in America, he had to actually go buy a map so he could point to the country where he was coming from.

LESLEY: Obviously before the hostages.

ROYA: Exactly.

LESLEY: Right.

ROYA: And the hostages kind of catapulted Iran to the forefront of international attention. And then with the release of the hostages, Iran completely died from view. The hostages came home in ‘81 so for the following ten years or so, unless there was an Iran contra campaign or McFarland was taking a key or a cake to Iran we really didn’t cover Iran.

19 Reader Comments (so far…) Sign In or Register to comment

Andrea Brandon

If I could, I would ask Ms. Hakakian:

What the status of the Iraniam government will be this time next year?

Will the protesters cease an desist? Or will they become more aggressive. If so, how?

As I understand it, the voluntary Basij, serve under the Revolutionary Guards and support the Ayatollah. It is comprised of young people and members can be found in almost every city in Iran. If the group is as large as it is purported to be, then how can the protesters ever expect to overcome the current government.

How difficult will it be to covert the Basij?

How are Mousavi and Ahmedineajad different?

These are just a few of the questions I would have asked.

By Andrea Brandon on 06/29/2009 1:05 am
Kelly In Texas

How interesting that the Ayatollah and Ahmedinejad attempt to blame America and others countries for the protests…The people are being fed these lies, as they bravely stand against the injustice themselves…knowing that it isn’t American interferring and that it is the Iranian government itself that is responsible for their suppression….

…And then, we have Obama running around the world apologizing for our actions…not helpful…not helpful at all…..These people deserve our support and not to have to wonder if they are being manipulated by America.

 

 

By Kelly In Texas on 06/29/2009 2:39 pm
Andrea Brandon

Kelly,

The protesters certainly have my support. I’m just curious how it is that so many young people are protesting and supposedly so many other young people are affiliated with the Basij. So hard to tell without independent journalism inside the country to tell the real story. The very fact that the news media in Iran is censored says everything.

Yes, definitely, bad move on Obama’s part.

OFFTOPIC:  A couple of us have had problems accessing the website in the past couple hours. Anyone know of anything going on???

By Andrea Brandon on 06/29/2009 5:45 pm
F P
I think this is a very premature opinion on Ms Hakakian’s part.  The Iranian mullahs are still very much in control and have the Revolutionary Guards under their thumbs. Khamenei’s repressive measures are still under scrutiny, should not be underestimated at all and whether the people of Iran do anything about him is still up in the air. Whether the protesters get the upper hand remains to be seen.  As for the Basij, they are nothing but thugs.
By F P on 06/29/2009 7:28 am
C jay

Yes, this is the beginning of change in Iran, but it will not come quickly; however, Iran will never be the same.

With that being said, I can only hope there will be no more human annihilation. If there is a shred of Islam in Iran it can easily measure that by the regard or disregard for human life. Violence will destroy that country’s majestic buildings.

Hate destroys everyone and everything!

By C jay on 06/30/2009 10:10 pm
caj p

The Iranian people have finally made their voices heard at least and I’m sure will keep up the pressure on the Govt as it stands now.  We hope all their brave efforts will eventually pay off for them and they can get a leader they want.  I think it will be a slow process for them but they obviously have the courage and determination to see it through.  I am wishing them all the luck in the world.

By caj p on 06/29/2009 8:27 am
S A

I really do wish I could believe.

It was with every ounce of my being that I couldn’t believe W.Bush would be reelected. He was.

If there is a ‘force’ to be ‘released’ then count on your fingers the numbers who hold convictions to stand on the side that is opposed to humanity.

Out of touch is not being out of time… it is self-delusion.

By S A on 06/29/2009 9:26 am
Maggie W
That people are willing to risk their lives and are taking such bold action shows that Iran has crossed a threshold and will never look back.  This is huge surprise and embarrassment for the Supreme Leader and Ahmadinejad, and the whole world is holding court on their actions.  What the world sees is that Iranians do care about democratic rights and that starts with an honest vote.   Let’s not forget that 30 years ago, Iranians deposed one of the strongest dictators in the world.  We should not underestimate the resolve of the Iranians.  Oppressed people can tolerate just so much and for so long. 
By Maggie W on 06/29/2009 10:50 am
J Holmes

Leslie,

Thank you for providing another informative interview.

By J Holmes on 06/29/2009 11:33 am
J Holmes
OOPS _ I meant to spell Lesley. Mea culpa!
By J Holmes on 06/29/2009 11:34 am
Bella Mia

The spectacle of Iranian women willing to compete in Olympic sports wearing the veil is called "overadaptation."  They bend over backwards to accommodate an unreasonable demand, instead of fighting against it. It’s unhealthy and eventually leads to burnout and defeat.  It’s common in abused individuals and populations, and only prolongs the abuse.

The regime-ordered murder and brutality happening in the streets of Iran is called "political decapitation." The tyrants are going after the most active participants and their promoters.  With Obama’s passivity, and unwillingness to take any action to support the citizen/hostages, this revolt is doomed to failure.  

Outside intervention is always necessary for a successful revolution when a unarmed populace as been intimidated back into submission.  The protest have actually done a service for the regime  highlighting and pinpointing the worst agitators so they can be identified, isolated and eliminated.  

Obama just got through saying in the middle east that violence never solved anything, so I’m afraid that Obama won’t be of any help to the desperate hostage citizens of Iran.  The revolt was 1/2 year too late.

By Bella Mia on 06/29/2009 2:25 pm
C jay
At the same time, Bella Mia, many Muslim women here and elsewhere in the world prefer to wear a chador, and/or a veil. That should be their choice. When they are punished, or tortured for their choices, that is when the world must step in and act to stop such crimes against humanity. But, before a nation "steps in" to any other country, they must be certain that their own "house" is clean, first.
By C jay on 06/30/2009 10:14 pm
phyllis Doyle Pepe
Iran is a country that is poor, starved of foreign investment, clumsily managed, and wholly dependent on energy exports. Its universities are good but far from outstanding and Iran has suffered a crippling, two-generation-long drain of much of its best talent. They have suffered from an underdog status and posture up like Davids to slay Goliaths, the US being the biggest giant. Obama gave exactly the right message in his Cairo speech. Iran’s clerical rulers, whose job it is to chase demons, will surely find devils in every detail, but our stance so far has been prudent and wise.
By phyllis Doyle Pepe on 06/29/2009 6:08 pm
phyllis Doyle Pepe
P.S. thanks, Lesley, for a good, informative interview.
By phyllis Doyle Pepe on 06/29/2009 6:10 pm
F P
Excellent insight Phyllis. :-)
By F P on 06/30/2009 7:02 am