Sign in to wowOwow

Enter the email address that you used when registering at wowOwow.
The password field is case sensitive. Click here if you have forgotten your password.

Please register for wowOwow

Newsletter subscriptions
Sign up to receive wowOwow's weekly newsletter and get our best picks delivered right to your inbox. Our newsletter content is hand-picked by the wowOwow editorial team and provides the top features, news, and commentary from our site. Subscribing to our newsletter is free and safe. We will never share your email or other information with a third-party without your direct consent.
By registering, you indicate that you have read and agree
with our privacy policy and terms of service.

A Friend Stopped By | 11/25/2008 8:30 am

Another Sarah - The Woman Who Helped Create Thanksgiving, by Myrna Blyth

Before Sarah Palin, there was Sarah Hale, who spent 40 years and wrote thousands of letters to make Thanksgiving a national holiday
By Myrna Blyth

Anyone who has read a women’s magazine in the last 25 years has most likely read the work of Myrna Blyth. Myrna is the founding editor of More magazine, was the longtime editor-in-chief of Ladies’ Home Journal, and was senior editor for Family Circle magazine. She is the chairman of the President’s Commission on White House Fellowships. She has received many awards including the Matrix Award from New York Women in Communications, Inc., the Woman of Achievement Award from the New York City Commission on the Status of Women, and was named Publishing Executive of the Year by Advertising Age. Currently she writes for The National Review Online.

I know many of us are convinced that only today could a woman over 40 reinvent herself and become a big nationwide success. But it isn’t so. And since it is Thanksgiving week I want to tell you about a forgotten but extraordinary Victorian woman named Sarah Hale.  

Born in 1788, she was left a widow at 34. Penniless, she had five children to raise and so she supported them by sewing and writing poetry. At 39 she wrote a novel called Norwood, the first novel about slavery that was a big bestseller. She then became the editor of the Ladies’ Magazine in Boston and wrote successful collections of poetry, called Poems for Our Children, which included the poem “Mary Had A Little Lamb.”  

Some S.I. Newhouse of the day lured her to Philadelphia to a bigger and better job on a magazine called Godey’s Lady’s Book which was the largest and  most successful publication in its day. It may be the fashion to sneer at women’s magazines and women magazine editors these days but Sarah at that time, through her publication’s pages, became the most influential woman in America. She was the first to advocate equal education for girls, start day nurseries for working women and suggest public playgrounds. She also supported American women writers and published them in her magazine. And the S.I. Newhouse of the day supported her. She remained the editor until she was 90.

Pretty impressive, right? But what she is remembered for, when she is remembered, is her promoting Thanksgiving as a national holiday. It was her idea. She wrote, “We have too few holidays. Thanksgiving, like the Fourth of July, should be a national festival and observed by all people.” She thought such a holiday would have a positive effect on our country. She wrote, "There is a deep moral influence in these periodical seasons of rejoicing, in which whole communities participate. They bring out … the best sympathies in our natures."

As the nation hurtled toward the Civil War, she felt such a holiday was especially important. In 1863, in the darkest year of the conflict, Lincoln did issue the proclamation that established Thanksgiving as a national holiday. Sarah had spent 40 years and written thousands of letters to achieve this goal. It is interesting in these troubled times to read Lincoln’s proclamation (www.historyplace.com). In, perhaps, our country’s darkest hour he still wrote of the blessings and the bounty of America.

Yes, the middle-aged Sarah Hale — tough, smart, determined — was quite a woman. Maybe she proves that women today are not different than American women in the past.  But, rather, we are lucky to be their descendants.  

13 Reader Comments (so far…) Sign In or Register to comment

Lucinda Herbert
I prefer Thanksgiving to Christmas — a nice gathering of family and friends without all the hoopla and the unecessary materialism.
By Lucinda Herbert on 11/25/2008 8:49 am
J B
Thanksgiving is my favorite holiday…I get to be in the kitchen for days and I love nothing better. It just seems to me as if Thanksgiving is almost over looked, we jet from Halloween to Christmas in nothing flat. One of my favorite traditions at our family table is, after saying grace, we go around the table and each person says what they are thankful for…we really take the time to enjoy the day and focus on what it is all about for us, being together as a family and being thankful for that.
By J B on 11/25/2008 9:49 am
Delete This
Great piece, Myrna. I’ve always loved Thanksgiving the best of holidays. So even nicer to know that a woman fought for it and Lincoln proclaimed it. We had a special Thanksgiving tradition that we all loved: The rooms were serene and fastidious. The food like Babette’s Feast. Dad wore a navy blue sports jacket, turtleneck and gray flannel slacks. The pipe clinched between his smiling lips made his dimples deeper. His Schnauzer, Jiggy, trailed him like a four-legged Sancho Panza after his own Don Quixote. The Frank Sinatra records would be playing, eucalyptus logs would snap in the fireplace and give off their clean woodsy scent . My two young brothers dressed like Dad and my two sister’s in their frilly best set would smooth on the pale pink linen table cloth and set the good Limoges on the long table in the dinning room. Mom would stride from the kitchen in something yummy like a chic cut, rose-colored sheath, heels and pearls to check on how they were doing. Cool, blonde and beautiful as Eva Marie Saint in “The Russians are Coming” she’d light candles, dim the chandelier and hand me silver tureens to fill with holly and red pyracantha. Then the drive filled up with cars, the doorbell rang, and the relatives streamed-ed like theatergoers on opening night. “Everything and everyone smells and looks fabulous” they’d exclaim above the din of laughter and champagne corks rocketing-off. Dad and an Uncle passed drinks and mixed Shirley Temples for the kids. Seven-year-old Mimi helped serve canapés. In trim black wool and gold charm bracelets, Smoking Nana would sit in a wingback chair and coo over my brothers. Her smooth forehead wrinkled when they reported dive-bombing a local shopping center in the neighbor’s airplane, which he’d constructed in own his backyard. “One of those remote control toys, dear?” she asked and turned to peer outside. “No, Nana, a real plane, but it was OK because Dad was with us. “Has it started to rain?” “No, Nana, that’s the neighbor’s horse, Goldie, peeing in the ravine.” Nana would wag her empty tumbler towards Dad, and our nun-aunt would play Gershwin on the piano until Dad headed the train of platters heaped with standing rib roast, roast cornish hens and side dishes to the table and we’d take our seats eager for another of our mother’s spectacular meals. Plates were filled, ice clinked into glasses, wine was poured, ‘napkins in your laps, children.’ We’d hold our breath a little waiting for our family’s brand of grace. “Sing ‘Desert Song’ Dad!” Then, the room in California would morph into French-occupied Africa at the turn of the 20th century and before our believing eyes Dad became the romantic rebel leader, El Khobar, and Mom the French coquette who stole his wild heart. Beneath the glittering chandelier and reflected in a mirror and candlelight our tall, dark haired El Khobar swept his pretty wife into his arms and sang as we froze in the scene: “One alone, to be my own. I alone, to know her caresses. One to be, eternally, the one my worshipping soul possesses. At her call, I give my all. All my life and all my love enduring. This would be a magic world to me. If she were mine alone.” Even the dog cocked his furry head as Mother looked into Dad’s eyes and sang her response: “Oh give me that night divine, And let my arms in yours entwine. The desert song, calling, It’s voice enthralling, Will make you mine. ” In those post-Camelot years, and with my parents beautiful trained voices and in our jasmine scented proximity to old Hollywood, we believed in the magic of our little universe. Physically, it swirled off like autumn leaves, but spiritually it’s a snapshot that remains for life. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5kcrsTdcaAg
By Delete This on 11/25/2008 11:41 am
Ms. Dee
When I was a child, we had two dogs. Honey and Rocky. And on Thanksgiving, Daddy would load them, along with his guitar, into the trunk of our ‘54 Ford. My brother and sister and I were in the back seat, dressed warm in gloves and hats and boots and our old winter coats over corduroys and flannels. I sat in the middle, with my feet on the hump. We were headed down to the country. The farm where my father was born. By the time we arrived, Grandma and Aunt Frances already had several pots boiling on the stove. Daddy would set Honey and Rocky loose and they’d take off running down the old dirt road. Mother would hold my hand and guide me around the puddles in the yard and past the pump. The wooden boards on the back porch creeked under everbody’s feet, and the screen door squeaked and squeaked until we were all in and it finally whacked shut. And Aunt Frances, wiping her greasy fingers on her apron would reach out to me with her rough hands, hold my face and laugh as she kissed me. Grandma was always covered with flour pressing me up against her. “…my baby girl!” There was always a sweetness to the way she smelled. The house was always full of old people who I didn’t really know, but they all wanted a hug and seemed delighted to see me. “Looks just like her daddy…” And Grandpa Bass in is “cadillac”…that’s what they called his wheelchair. He never gave me a hug. I was a little afraid of him. He chewed tobacco, and Mother didn’t approve. Grandpa Bass had built the house down in the country, and the barn where Uncle John kept his cows. Daddy said it would never fall down, because he didn’t use nails. The whole thing was pegged. Eventually, all the preparation was cleared off the table and the oil cloth wiped down before the they whooshed out the “good tablecloth. Sometimes, they’d let me put the silverware on the table, sometimes I could color the paper napkins for decoration; but I was too little to reach into the china cupboard, or fill the heavy glass goblets with the cool water that came from the faucet in the country. “Best water on earth!” Eventually they’d sit me on the phone book and start passing food around the table. I didn’t like the oyster dressing. I like the sage dressing. I didn’t like white meat. “Well, here, sweetheart, here’s a whole plate of dark meat. Take all you want.” One year I made a sign that said, “No pepper, please.” and hung in on the back of my chair. But I loved the biscuits and “Oh, now she’ll want some of her red stuff.” It was Aunt Frances’ home made strawberry preserves. I didn’t like the cranberry sauce, but I love the other red stuff. And the green beans and the mashed potatoes and the sweet potatoes and the corn on the cob and the jello salad and the potato salad and the apple salad. And Grandma’s noodles. My brother and sister were old enough to go out and play after the meal was finished. “Don’t go down in the bottoms!” But I was too little, so I’d go upstairs where Aunt Frances kept all her books, and I’d curl up with one in the feather bed, even if I couldn’t read all the words. There was an old Bible with wonderful pictures that I loved to look at over and over again. And the women’s voices in the kitched would echo up the stairs, until finally I’d hear Daddy singing with his guitar and I’d go downstairs again. I knew all the words to “High-ballin’ Daddy,” “In the Evenin’ by the Moonlight,” “Tie Me to Your Apron Striings,” “You Wore a Tulip,” I knew a lot of songs, but Daddy could only play a few of them on the guitar. There was a sofa and three big rocking chairs in the living room, and I’d curl up on somebody’s lap and sing along. Aunt Frances would harmonize. The rockers would creak. Honey and Rocky would lay on the linoleum by the black coal stove. They’d heard it all before. What I wouldn’t give now to hear it all again.
By Ms. Dee on 11/25/2008 9:27 pm
Delete This
Ms. Dee….That was so lovely to read. I love to hear the details of how people do things….you paint a wonderful picture.
By Delete This on 11/26/2008 6:08 am
Ms. Dee
I was only following your lead. I loved your pictures, too. Quite different from mine, but altogether beautiful. Thanks.
By Ms. Dee on 11/26/2008 7:30 am
DeBúrca obj
I think that in a country like the USA which unlike others, is founded upon ideas, not genetics, the national celebration of Thanksgiving is brilliant. It gives all Americans, even the newest among us, a common national holiday that invokes religious faith but certainly does not require it. Thanksgiving celebrates that we are all in this experiment called “The United States of America” together. In a country built upon diversity, a holiday we can all identify with together, is very important.
By DeBúrca obj on 11/25/2008 11:48 am
Belinda Joy
Great article Myrna, kudos! Thanksgiving is such a special and unique holiday, especially when you take into consideration the manner in which it became a holiday…..it is profound. And on that note, a heartfelt Happy Thanksgiving to the entire staff of wOw and ALL my fellow posters. It is at this special time we should set aside political and personal differences and simply celebrate the most important aspect we all have in common…..Americans!
By Belinda Joy on 11/25/2008 6:22 pm
Lauriate Roly
In my Country, we celebrate Thanksgiving a little later than in the U.S.A. That difference in time sometimes causes me to almost forget the American Thanksgiving. I say “almost”, but not completely. I have a great reminder, because I was married on your Thanksgiving Day and spent my honeymoon in Manhattan. I even got to see my first Thanksgiving Day Macy’s parade at that time. I was so impressed that I vowed to return every year to see Santa arrive in that wonderful, magic city. This preamble simply to allow me the opportunity to send all of my WOWOWOW friends a special wish. I wish all of you, and your families, the happiest moments and warmest traditions of this special season. May Thanksgiving bring all the good things to you.
By Lauriate Roly on 11/25/2008 8:52 pm
James the Game
My sister sent me a slide-show she put together of my father (and mother), whom I think of a lot at this time of year: http://www.slide.com/r/ih29BINE6z8BQwxMthTuHarWnq-AB40A?previous_view=18…
By James the Game on 11/26/2008 7:23 pm
Tee Zee
James, thanks for sharing…those are wonderful…enjoy the holiday!
By Tee Zee on 11/27/2008 11:54 am
James the Game
I appreciate your thoughts; have a super weekend!
By James the Game on 11/27/2008 12:57 pm
Tee Zee
Happy Thanksgiving to all!
By Tee Zee on 11/27/2008 11:50 am