Sign in to wowOwow

Enter the email address that you used when registering at wowOwow.
The password field is case sensitive. Click here if you have forgotten your password.

Please register for wowOwow

Newsletter subscriptions
Sign up to receive wowOwow's weekly newsletter and get our best picks delivered right to your inbox. Our newsletter content is hand-picked by the wowOwow editorial team and provides the top features, news, and commentary from our site. Subscribing to our newsletter is free and safe. We will never share your email or other information with a third-party without your direct consent.
By registering, you indicate that you have read and agree
with our privacy policy and terms of service.

Joan Juliet Buck | 11/26/2008 11:00 pm

The Biggest Turkey of Them All, by Joan Juliet Buck

Joan Juliet Buck

I had broken up with my husband and was living in a drafty, dusty sublet on Madison Avenue, and whatever invitations came my way were like lifelines. I felt as if I were in outer space, whirling between planets. I was intermittently going out with a journalist who was a friend of my parents. He was bluff, a man of the people, a hearty and reassuring sort. Irish. I was in a state of semi-crush; I had no idea how popular he was. In his weekly column he sometimes wrote about a man and a woman who both loved books; I assumed this was about us, and I swooned. He’d told me about his house by the sea, a house full of books, and I longed to go there with him.

In the middle of all the parties and endless events of that fall, I told him I longed for the country. He invited me to come out for Thanksgiving. "We’ll go out later in the afternoon,” he said. “I have to do a family thing in town first.” That was fine; it allowed me to go to an editor’s house at lunchtime. I sat with the editors and grown-ups and nibbled at some turkey, humming with the prospect of that house in the country with its fireplace, its books and its owner. I got back to the dusty sublet at three, heart pounding. I folded silky pieces of lingerie into my bag, checked the box of Italian pastries on the table, checked the imported cheeses in the refrigerator and settled in to wait. I couldn’t concentrate. I opened a book of poems to settle my mind: Rilke. The Stephen Mitchell translation. The Duino Elegies.

A little after four he called to say he’d be picking me up at five. My heart leapt. I waited by the window, like the girl in the seventh Duino elegy. “Don’t think that I’m wooing, angel, were I doing so, you would not come,” I read, and closed the book.

The phone rang. He was held up with family; I heard noises in the background. He’d be there before seven. He’d call me when he was on his way.

The dusk fell on Madison Avenue. The number of cars increased around six, as the first shift of Thanksgiving guests headed back uptown. Taxis were rare, buses even rarer. The dusk turned to night and the phone did not ring.

I sat down and read the rest of the Duino Elegies. I did not reach to the angel’s knees. I vibrated with stasis. The street emptied out. At about seven there was traffic again, and then nothing.

The box of cakes stood unopened on the table. I didn’t want to ruin my house gift by taking one. I wasn’t eating much that fall anyway.

I started writing at the desk. A poet friend called from California.

“I’m waiting for someone to take me to the country with him. He’s late and I’m writing poems,” I said.

“Don’t do that,” said the poet. “It’s not a good idea.”

I carried on writing anyway.

At ten, my two European friends called, together. The French one was a childhood friend kept by a billionaire; the Italian one was older, a rich man’s wife with many lovers. “Va Fancullo,” said the Italian. “Come with us to my house in the country tomorrow. Stop waiting.”

At one in the morning I put the cakes in the refrigerator, took the silky lingerie out of the bag and went to bed. I was in shock: I hadn’t yet been single in New York, and I didn’t know that this behavior was common. I thought, of course, it was something I’d done.

8 Reader Comments (so far…) Sign In or Register to comment

Andy C
What could have been a disaster has turned into a funny, loving family anectdote. We were visiting my aunt for Thanksgiving. She was an excellent cook and came out of the kitchen into the dining room proudly bearing her perfectly browned, perfectly cooked turkey on a platter — beaming, she stepped toward the table and the turkey very slowly, almost gracefully….certainly with more grace than it ever had in life, slipped to the floor. The look on my aunt’s face. “How did it fly? It’s dead!” The shocked silence in the dining room waiting to see what she would do. My cousin saved the day: He quickly picked it up, took it in the kitchen, came back out and said “lucky for us that we cooked two” :) We laughed, ate and it’s become THE Thanksgiving story in our family.
By Andy C on 11/27/2008 8:18 am
phyllis Doyle Pepe
Joan: Love your story–––-I was right there with you and Rilke and the darkening hour. To have left you stranded––to have left you waiting when he obviously knew at some point he was never coming is beyond bad. To discover the lesser angels in this world is always a tough lesson, but a necessary one. And to think he was Irish to boot! Ye Gaads!
By phyllis Doyle Pepe on 11/27/2008 9:04 am
J B
The first Thanksgiving with my “starter husband’s” parents and siblings…his Mother would NOT let anyone help, her kitchen was off limits. Dinner was served and I sat down, trying to wipe the shock off of my face. Raised by southern cooks, I was accustomed to tables and sideboards that groaned with food with food during the holidays. Enormous bowls and platters, un-ending portions available…however, on this east coast table I saw a turkey that looked more like a chicken…and the smallest bowls of side dishes I had ever seen. I looked around the oppulent house and wondered WHAT was going on!? As it turned out, my new in laws had lived through the depression and abhored waste of any kind. Our plates were made for us, one slice of turkey, one “slice” of cranberry, a spare spoon of gravy and mashed potatoes…there was no stuffing…(too many calories) some over salted buttered corn…and that was it. I promised myself future Thanksgivings would be at my own table or at my Father’s…I needed those leftovers the next day damn it!! So no, in all of our married years…we never returned to his parent’s home for the holidays. They came to ours and complained the entire time about the “over kill” that was my cooking style. “Better too much than too little” are the words I was raised with and still live by today! Long Live The Leftovers!!
By J B on 11/27/2008 1:48 pm
mary lou s
i had a job at the time, and my little brother lived in the house on the farm where we grew up. i drove the over 100 miles to spend thanksgiving with my brother, not realizing that he had not prepared in any way. nor did i bring food. my oldest sister arrived later with her pantry of canned food literally in her car, where she lived. as the responsible female, i had to come up with something to eat. the fridge wasn’t quite bare, so i took out an egg, mixed it with water, dipped the stale bread in it, and made french toast. for topping we had some maple syrup that was beginning to ferment. at the time i was shocked at how my brother and sister lived. but now i understand that we each were short of a deck of cards and did what we could.
By mary lou s on 11/27/2008 2:48 pm
Brooklyn Gal
Joan, I can only imagine your heartbreak at that time. But you discovered something special—friendships are way better than cads.
By Brooklyn Gal on 11/27/2008 3:14 pm
Charles Dance
Mon Deu………..
By Charles Dance on 11/27/2008 8:05 pm
Ms. Dee
I don’t know if we’ve all been there, but I’ve been there. I’m such a sucker for a house full of books. Beautifully told, Ms. Buck. Thanks.
By Ms. Dee on 11/27/2008 9:17 pm
Charles Dance
YOU REALLY DO TELL A BEAUTIFUL STORY JOAN.
By Charles Dance on 02/18/2009 7:54 am