Sign in to wowOwow

Enter the email address that you used when registering at wowOwow.
The password field is case sensitive. Click here if you have forgotten your password.

Please register for wowOwow

Newsletter subscriptions
Sign up to receive wowOwow's weekly newsletter and get our best picks delivered right to your inbox. Our newsletter content is hand-picked by the wowOwow editorial team and provides the top features, news, and commentary from our site. Subscribing to our newsletter is free and safe. We will never share your email or other information with a third-party without your direct consent.
By registering, you indicate that you have read and agree
with our privacy policy and terms of service.

A Friend Stopped By | 11/25/2008 9:15 am

Why 'Milk' Matters: The Proposition 8 Battle Continues

By Brenda Feigen
© AP

Editor’s Note: Brenda Feigen is Counsel to Kenoff & Machtinger, LLP, where she practices anti-discrimination and entertainment law. A graduate of Harvard Law School, she co-founded Ms. Magazine with Gloria Steinem and directed with (now Justice) Ruth Bader Ginsburg the Women’s Rights Project of the ACLU. Her memoir, Not One of the Boys: Living Life as a Feminist, was published by Alfred A. Knopf in 2000. She moved from Manhattan to Los Angeles to produce her first feature film and currently lives there with Joanne Parrent, her longtime partner and maybe spouse.

Exactly 30 years ago, San Francisco’s openly gay supervisor, Harvey Milk, successfully led the fight against that year’s version of our Proposition H(8), Proposition 6, that would have prohibited gays and lesbians from teaching in California’s public schools. The issue now, of course, is our right to marry, which Prop. H(8) eliminated this past election day.

At first, I was happy to hear that the California Supreme Court last week decided to hear arguments on whether Proposition 8 should be overturned. Then, I thought about it a bit longer. The justices didn’t say whether the 18,000 of us who married during that magical period between June 16 and November 4 still qualified as married. But they did say no other same-sex couples can marry in the Golden State until they decide – sometime this Spring – whether or not to overturn H(8). And, frankly, it makes me really mad that I don’t know whether my spouse and I are, in fact, still married. If we’re not, we hang in some legal limbo. And nobody – gay or straight – wants that.

2008_1125_Feigen.<span class="caps">JPG</span>(Above you see Brenda and her spouse, Joanne, just before they received their marriage license in California.)

Aside from the emotional aspects of the decision, I’m also angry because, as I’ve mentioned before, I had hoped our marriage would help us to challenge the Defense of Marriage Act. You know, the act Bill Clinton signed that guarantees that the federal government need not recognize same-sex, “non-traditional” marriage. If I were married in California, I could go against the federal government for depriving us of our social security benefits, the right to transfer property to each other without being taxed and a host of other rights. In fact, there are over 2,000 rights that married straight couples have that we don’t, even if we are eventually deemed really married legally in California. Those benefits include the right to transfer property. Heterosexual couples can transfer money, houses or whatever to each other with no gift tax liability, but not same-sex couples. Nor can we guarantee that our widow or widower will inherit the inheritance that heterosexual couples may take for granted. We know, for sure right now, that we don’t get any benefits earned by our “spouse” when that spouse dies. Those hard-earned dollars go to the government – the same government that refuses to recognize our relationships. Does that sound fair to you?

So, as these emotions swirl, I’ve also been reading about “Milk,” the Sean Penn-starring bio-pic of Harvey Milk. For the uninitiated – and those not reading Variety – Milk was San Francisco’s openly gay city supervisor and was one of the ‘70s great gay activists until he was brutally shot down on the steps of City Hall. Ironically, it opens tomorrow; it’s supposed to be quite the movie, and worth a view or two, and, coincidentally, has become a central player in the Proposition H(8) battle. Harvey Milk fought vociferously for gay rights, yet the CEO of one of the film’s exhibitors, Cinemark’s Alan Stock, helped fund Proposition 8 — donating $9,999, to be exact. Gays and lesbians are not amused, and have helped organize vigils and protests against the company. And, as another twist of fate, one of the tactics is telling people to wait to go see “Milk,” which opens tomorrow, until December 5. Rather than patronizing the Cinemark chain, activists of all ilks are instructing allies to see the flick at alternative theaters. We want “Milk” to break the top three that weekend, but we surely don’t want Mr. Stock and his comrades raking in our queer dollars that should be spent encouraging supportive companies to keep fighting for and with us!

29 Reader Comments (so far…) Sign In or Register to comment

DeBúrca obj
I just read an excellent review of Penn’s movie “Milk” and his performance in the Chicago Tribune today.
By DeBúrca obj on 11/25/2008 11:33 am
Brenda Feigen
It got an absolute rave in today’s New York Times. Might be hard to keep people waiting until Dec. 5th when one of the groups wanted us to swarm non-Cinemark theaters, protesting the CEO’s large contribution to Yes on H(8).
By Brenda Feigen on 11/26/2008 2:43 pm
f p
Prop 8 was and is a stain on this country—all it shows the world is that we’re a nation of bigots and religious nutcases.
By f p on 11/25/2008 12:51 pm
Delete This
FP—I think it went down, ahem, because of the money of radicals devoting to defeating it: Eric Prince, CEO-Nutjob head of Blackwater, and the Mormons. Lost the battle, not the war.
By Delete This on 11/28/2008 12:45 pm
Brenda Feigen
Well, I may have been grappLing but now I’ve moved on and am infuriated by the ban (Prop. H(8)
By Brenda Feigen on 11/26/2008 2:53 pm
georgia fatwood
Now, now, Lily….we all know somedays it’s art, somedays it’s just paint (or failed pots!)….somedays it’s writing, somedays it’s just typos…. But I’ve got a word for you from a friend who was a bit of a Mr. Malaprop… he swore the words existed….pure hell in a Scrabble game…It was “gripple”….Verb and noun….”Heartfelt admiration for one’s own work”……as in, “Oh, I think I caught you grippling your new painting”…..or…..”Everyone deserves a little gripple now and then”…..You can also gripple yourself in a mirror if you’re feeling especially spiffy….
By georgia fatwood on 11/29/2008 9:32 am
Ms. Dee
Don’t be too quick to discount Obama’s role in securing gay rights. Don’t forget, Abraham Lincoln did not count himself among the abolitionists of his day when he first took office. Meanwhile, I can’t imagine the anger and frustration that must be circulating in the gay and lesbian community. It’s such an obvious injustice.
By Ms. Dee on 11/25/2008 10:21 pm
Kryssi K
Siiiiigh. (And what’s with all these Hollywood and THEATRE folk donating to (H)8??? You would think they of all people would have enough experiences and acquaintances to know that gay people are harmless and worthy of equality. Sheesh.) Brenda and Joanne, you look beautifully happy in that photo! Yes, you two are TOTALLY married in my eyes!
By Kryssi K on 11/25/2008 11:08 pm
Brenda Feigen
Thanks so much, Krissy. The “Hollywood and theatre” folks that we, so far, know have donated to H(8) are Mormons, and that Church has urged its people to fight against our marriage rights. In fact, an official challenge has now been filed that will require the Mormon church to reveal what it has donated, both money and in kind, to this political issue.
By Brenda Feigen on 11/26/2008 3:03 pm
Lena B
I was deeply moved by the documentary “The Times of Harvey Milk” (1984)—the huge candlelight vigil still is in my memory as evidence of a man of exceptional spirit. I look forward to seeing Penn’s celebrated performance, though not at a Cinemark theatre.
By Lena B on 11/28/2008 2:15 pm
Brenda Feigen
Lena — Go see “Milk” (not at a Cinemark!) It’s a fantastic movie and the director, Gus Von Sant, used footage from the documentary showing the real events and people. It is really, really painful that Milk was fighting a war back then that somehow got dropped after Prop. 6 and is only now really picking up steam via same-sex marriage (Prop. 8). I’m ready to turn all systems on and help energize THE civil rights battle of the 21st century.
By Brenda Feigen on 11/28/2008 4:07 pm
georgia fatwood
Dear Ms. Feigen, I would appreciate seeing your take on the Penn/van Sant interview on Charlie Rose last night….what was and wasn’t said….I was struck by the observation about what “might have been” in terms of the AIDS battle had Milk’s voice not been silenced…. Thank you very much……
By georgia fatwood on 11/29/2008 9:13 am
Brenda Feigen
I wish I had known about it. I would have TiVoed it since we were out. I’ll try to find out if they’re repeating that interview. Give me a little more information: If Milk had been alive, he would have fought AIDS and taken his attention off equality or if Milk had been alive, more gay men would have taken to the streeets instead of their beds?
By Brenda Feigen on 11/29/2008 1:18 pm
georgia fatwood
Thank you for your reply…. Often Charlie Rose is on too late for me to watch…or there is a conflict of some sort, so I usually go to his site the next morning and listen to “back issues” while I putter about my workspace….I think it’s Charlie Rose.com….haven’t re-run it yet from last night….it might take a day or two to post… But, even with a mind like a sieve, I “feel” that what was said is ….yes, he would have fought AIDS vociferously and brought it to the attention of the populace in general and the government specifically and… yes, thousands of lives might have been spared….. but it doesn’t seem that it would necessarily have meant that attention would have been diverted from issues of equality….. It was just one of those light bulb moments for me….not that I knew a whole lot of the story to begin with…..and it continues to be affecting…..sort of an inexpressable sadness for how it might have been otherwise….. I am most curious to see if there were any comments about the film industry’s involvement in Prop 8…..re: the observations in your post….Wish us Good Web Hunting…..!
By georgia fatwood on 11/29/2008 1:49 pm
Brenda Feigen
Georgia — Let me know what you find. I’m not great at hunting on the web. Anyway, yes Milk would have fought AIDS but so many others did, too. And that enlightened a whole bunch of straight people that gays are people, too. E.g. Elizabeth Taylor. BUT we need to move on in strength and numbers, which we have even though AIDS killed a lot of people. Too many, of course.
By Brenda Feigen on 11/29/2008 7:09 pm