Sign in to wowOwow

Enter the email address that you used when registering at wowOwow.
The password field is case sensitive. Click here if you have forgotten your password.

Please register for wowOwow

Newsletter subscriptions
Sign up to receive wowOwow's weekly newsletter and get our best picks delivered right to your inbox. Our newsletter content is hand-picked by the wowOwow editorial team and provides the top features, news, and commentary from our site. Subscribing to our newsletter is free and safe. We will never share your email or other information with a third-party without your direct consent.
By registering, you indicate that you have read and agree
with our privacy policy and terms of service.

A Friend Stopped By | 08/04/2008 3:00 pm

Beauty, the Burqa and Power, by Vishakha N. Desai

By Vishakha N. Desai
Vishakha N. Desai, center, in Karachi, Pakistan

Editor’s Note: Vishakha N. Desai is President and CEO of Asia Society, a global educational organization.

When we think of notable women in Pakistan, we might picture Benazir Bhutto, resplendent in salwar-kameez, head covered in a dupatta. Those who are a bit more savvy may also remember Mukhtar Bibi, a cause célèbre in the West as the victim of the most cruel Muslim laws in the tribal areas of Pakistan, charged as a criminal for being raped by men other than her husband, because she "brought dishonor to her family." The late Benazir’s power notwithstanding, there is a strong feeling that Pakistani society is mired in misogyny and tribal notions of womanhood.


2008_0804_desai1.jpgVishakha N. Desai in Karachi, Pakistan

As usual, the truth is far more complicated. In a span of just 24 hours, I recently had three different experiences in Karachi that gave me a deeper look into the role of women in urbanized Pakistan. The first was a luncheon given for me by a leading male public figure. Of a dozen business leaders and prominent journalists, not one was a woman. It did not seem strange to my host that there was none. Nor would he have even thought to try to get some. In the United States, I thought, it would be unthinkable to invite a female leader to such a luncheon, with not a single other woman present!

My second encounter was at a vocational school for women where middle and lower middle class female students take courses in subjects ranging from IT and English to cooking and "grooming" (manicures, pedicures, threading, waxing, makeup and hairdressing). Grooming was the most popular of all. Imagine a large group of young women in the burqa, covered head to toe, intensely focused on making themselves beautiful, and learning the trade with dreams of one day opening their own little boutique salon for other, better-off women. I was told that this was the most lucrative option for women. Judging from the number of beauty and bridal magazines at the airport, it’s easy to see that an obsession with beauty is well ingrained in this South Asian nation. Indeed, I saw more women with threaded eyebrows, made-up faces and manicured nails in 24 hours in Karachi than I would see in a month, even at home on the Upper West Side of New York!

My third meeting was with a group called "moderates," from the upper echelon of Karachi Society and diverse professions, dedicated to promoting tolerance, interfaith dialogue and moderate views of Islam. This time, out of about 45 people, there were at least ten women representing different fields, from politics and government, to medicine, media and human-rights advocacy. Mostly in their 40s and 50s, they exuded a quiet sense of confidence often seen in professional women of South Asia. From the educated upper classes, they were typically supported by their parents and husbands and privileged enough to have domestic help, making it possible for them to be professional without disrupting their family lives. None of them covered their heads nor wore a scarf of any sort.

So, what does this tell abut the role of women in contemporary Pakistan? First and foremost it reminds us that we had better not make generalizations about the whole society based on media headlines that rarely look beneath the surface. Secondly, as is true in Iran, there is a strong obsession with beauty behind the burqa that is not unlike what we find in the West among young people, even if it is not meant for public consumption in the same way. Thirdly, family support — especially from a husband — and class structure can play a huge role in the professional development of women. Lastly, there is no substitute for greater firsthand experience of these societies that figure so prominently in our political landscape but about which we know so little in a cultural sense. I am deeply grateful for these three eye-opening experiences, and look forward to sharing them with women worldwide.

3 Reader Comments (so far…) Sign In or Register to comment

Dab-a- do
The hand that rocks the cradle rules the world”. I have heard this quote many times in my life. What does it really mean? And why do we have to “rule” the world by passing that power on to the male gender? It seems, it that part of world, that only the very upper class have made any progress regarding women’s rights. I doubt that there will be any progress in our life time or in a very long time. This is just, as female circumcisions and young sex workers trying to live, another illustration of how women are really thought of in the world. (Also the way poverty stricken boys and girls in third world countries are treated as sex slaves is a shame) Men rule the world, isn’t that telling anyone anything?
By Dab-a- do on 08/04/2008 2:50 pm
Emcye Edwards
Vishakha, I’m curious, now, as to whether the standing of these women is still largely dependent on the castes of their birth or marriage. Does family support and spousal support cut across these sectarian lines? When you combine misogyny with caste politics - and cultural precepts against women controlling money - the tradition of women taking refuge by sharing beauty and grooming regimens takes on a deeper significance; one that women in the Western world can barely fathom. Beauty - so chained to all the forces of oppression these women face, is also an intimate dialogue they share with one another. In the case of Ghazala Shaheen, who was raped by members of an upper caste family her uncle had married into (as punishment for pursuing her own education) the level of pysychological danger and unpredictability women deal with, when they do assert themselves, is intense. Do you see hope for change in the expansion of the Grameen Bank? It has been hugely successful in helping women in small groups support one another as they receive micro-loans to build their own businesses. Some may use the money to run a beauty shop, another may become a cell-phone provider. My question: do you feel women will be leveraged out of poverty and caste oppression with larger loans and achieve greater influence?
By Emcye Edwards on 08/04/2008 3:39 pm
rocky rocky
Emcye, you bring to mind my early years when it seemed clear to me that my aunts and other women I knew were so highly focused on what they looked like to men and how they were perceived by men and how far they can go without going over any lines all to get and keep a man’s interest … they depended so much on men for everything having to do with living and survival. When my mother found herself with three children and a husband who had in all practical ways abondoned her, she did what she had to do to get work, but her real solution to the problem was to get another man. How she bent and twisted and arranged herself (physically, mentally, all ways) to achieve that goal! I suppose in a truly male dominated society it must be a great deal more intense an endeavor to keep one’s man interested enough … 
By rocky rocky on 06/14/2009 2:15 pm