Sign in to wowOwow

Enter the email address that you used when registering at wowOwow.
The password field is case sensitive. Click here if you have forgotten your password.

Please register for wowOwow

Newsletter subscriptions
Sign up to receive wowOwow's weekly newsletter and get our best picks delivered right to your inbox. Our newsletter content is hand-picked by the wowOwow editorial team and provides the top features, news, and commentary from our site. Subscribing to our newsletter is free and safe. We will never share your email or other information with a third-party without your direct consent.
By registering, you indicate that you have read and agree
with our privacy policy and terms of service.

Politics | 06/19/2008 11:45 am

Manson Murderess Begs for Mercy

By The Staff at wowOwow.com
Susan Atkins in 1969 © AP

In August 1969 she slit the throat of a pregnant woman begging for mercy. Today, she’s hoping she has better luck when asking for the same from the government.

A former member of the Manson family, Susan Atkins, 60, has requested a "compassionate release" from prison on the grounds that she is terminally ill and has less than six months to live, Department of Corrections spokeswoman Terry Thornton told wowOwow.

The Golden State’s longest-serving female inmate, Atkins was convicted in 1969 for the murders of actress Sharon Tate (who was eight months pregnant) and four others. Perhaps the most gripping detail from the case file was that, before leaving the crime scene, Atkins wrote "PIG" in blood on Tate’s front door.

Atkins received the death sentence, which later was commuted to life in prison at the California Institution for Women in Corona, CA, where she remained until she was hospitalized in March. She’s listed in serious condition and, while Thornton declined to comment on her illness, it’s been reported that she has been diagnosed with terminal brain cancer.

According to Thornton, the prison did an evaluation of Atkins’s release request and found that she met the two necessary criteria — she is terminally ill with an incurable condition that would cause death in six months AND she has a supportive family with the means to care of her – to be recommended for review by the corrections department. If the corrections department makes a positive recommendation, the decision then goes to the sentencing court, which will do one of three things: deny the request, recall the original sentence and re-sentence to a lower term (which could result in a full discharge) or recall the original sentence and place her under parole supervision.

The Los Angeles Times’s op-ed says that Atkins should not be granted the release. What are your thoughts on this?

Click here to vote: Are you in favor of the death penalty in the United States?

251 Reader Comments (so far…) Sign In or Register to comment

doll lady
Elizabeth B. ….. I certainly respect anyone’s right to their own opinion, but I have one question for you. Question: Would you feel the same if you were Sharon Tate’s sister or family member?
By doll lady on 06/19/2008 1:28 pm
Mugsy Peabody
Since Ms. Bennett has ABUNDANTLY shown herself to be a woman of principle, I would bet yes.
By Mugsy Peabody on 06/19/2008 4:02 pm
Frank Peterson
I’m inclined to agree, Mugsy—she is a woman of great principle.
By Frank Peterson on 06/19/2008 7:14 pm
Get Sporty
Frank— And you are a person of GREAT cluelessness. Why don’t you STFU?? You are making me sick to my stomach. http://www.law.umkc.edu/faculty/projects/ftrials/manson/mansontestimony-…
By Get Sporty on 06/21/2008 12:45 pm
Elizabeth Bennett
Yes.
By Elizabeth Bennett on 06/20/2008 12:54 pm
Get Sporty
Go look at the crime scene photos, read Sharon Tate’s father’s letter, THINK about the 37 years 7 great people and an innocent baby lost, THINK about how much planning when into this mass murder and then the taunting of the victims families in court, and the GLEE and enjoyment atkins got in the repeated telling of what she did. THINK about the life that Sharon Tate loved, the sisters and mother who adored her and were so excited about the baby due in two weeks…..and then come back and say YES. It’s really easy to be glib when you haven’t endured what they did, when all of their lives were completely destroyed, when they had to live for the rest of their lives with the brutal reality of how this beautiful sweet 26 year old totally innocent victim was terrorized and butchered. She had a life and infinitely more humanity than what she delivered to her victims in their homes three homes, the musician she killed weeks before, Sharon Tate, the four others and her baby, and the couple the following night. She DOES NOT deserve release and I can absolutely promise you that the people who lived in that area then and remember it all very well will NOT let it happen. The compassion properly goes to the victims like Debra Tate and what they are enduring in this media circus. Atkins is in a hospital, not in prison. she already is getting infinitely more compassion than she deserves. She’s not put Debra Tate through this parole process 12 times. “Atkins testified she stabbed eight 1/2-months pregnant Sharon Tate to death, a particularly brutal act even within the context of the Cieo Drive massacre in that the group of murderers had kept Tate, who pleaded for the life of her unborn baby, alive to the last. Restraining Tate while her friends were brutally butchered before her eyes, Atkins said that she had coldly told the terrified actress that she would be murdered: “Look, bitch, I don’t care a thing about you. You’re going to die and there’s nothing you can do about it.” “She testified that she stabbed Tate repeatedly as the dying actress cried out in anguish for her own mother before perishing. She then tasted the blood of Sharon Tate . It was one of the most appalling stories of its kind, shocking people who had lived through more than half-a-century of mass-murder since the First World War. At the trial, the women defendants carved an X on their foreheads and shaved their heads to show their solidarity with Manson. On the stand, when Atkins was asked if she thought the killing of eight people was unimportant, she responded: “Was the killing of thousands with napalm (in Vietnam) important?” In 1981, via the mail, she met and married Donald Laisure, who claimed he was a millionaire. Upon discovering he was not, she had the marriage annulled. She married Harvard law student James Whitehouse in 1987, who has represented her at parole hearings since 2000. Her inability to show remorse and her failure to accept responsibility for her part in the brutal murders has meant that she has been turned down for parole 11 times, the last time in February 2005. In 2003, she made the contention that she was a political prisoner in a lawsuit filed against California Governor Gray Davis, as his policy opposing parole for most murderers meant she was kept behind bars. Her petition was denied.
By Get Sporty on 06/21/2008 3:10 pm
C A Rose
Get Sporty, Why are you so angry? Why do you keep dragging this thread through the horror and blood of these murders? It concerns me that you have put so much energy into this topic. A simple answer of ‘let her die in prison’ would suffice. It is as if you find great pleasure in revisiting these henous crimes and enjoy rubbing the noses of those who don’t agree with you in blood spilled so long ago. What is it that keeps you so riveted to this subject matter? I lived in Chicago when Richard Speck murdered a house full of student nurses. I saw the press photo’s that were too gruesome to be shown publically. I know this exists in the world…but in my world I prefer to let go lest we lose ourselves and become victims of our own devices.
By C A Rose on 06/27/2008 3:14 am
Bonnie Oliver
Mercy for a murderess? No, I don’t this so.
By Bonnie Oliver on 06/19/2008 1:51 pm
Bonnie Oliver
Sorry - should be “I don’t think so”.
By Bonnie Oliver on 06/19/2008 6:23 pm
kermie b
I read Helter Skelter and remember my jaw dropping at the insanity of Atkins et al. and their crimes. Nightmare times. They were brainwashed by Manson and on a boatload of drugs; no one wants to believe a young girl could kill on her own, without conscience, like that. This is a horribly tough question. I always wondered how doctors can say “six months to live” when they have been proven wrong by people’s sheer will to thrive. What if Atkins were let out of jail and did not die? Would authorities feel differently about letting her out? The whole idea is mercy because she will die in prison. My first instinct is maybe yes because she was so young and under Manson’s thumb. She changed. Her ideas changed. But where could she possibly live on the outside? Can anyone imagine an ex-Manson follower as a next-door neighbor? No. She belongs in prison.
By kermie b on 06/19/2008 1:59 pm
Get Sporty
They were NOT on a boatload of drugs when they committed the crimes. They cooly prepared for the killings overtime at the ranch. Learning how to thrust knives in and pull them up to do the maximum damage, swing a bayonet, use guns. The armed themselves with bolt cutters, knives, guns and drove long distances in the dead of night. Four of them together in the instance of the Tate murders, more when they were driving around LA to choose a random house to go in and kill more people, which turned out to be the LaBiancas, both business owners in their pajamas preparing for bed, and having just returned from a boating trip with their grown children. To reach the Tate residence was a long dark drive through a mostly deserted canyon so quiet you could practically ‘hear the ice tinkle in the martini shakers’ of the few residences. They cut the phone wires. They first murdered an 18 year old boy leaving in his car who’d been visiting the caretaker. Tex Watson snuck in a window and they let the women in the front door. He kicked one of the men awake who was asleep on the sofa. Susan Watkins waved at Abagail Folger who was reading a novel in one bedroom and proceeded into the master bedroom where Sharon Tate and the longtime friend of her and Roman Polanski were seated, talking. She hearded then by knifepoint into the living room. When Jay Sebring objected to the order that Sharon Tate should get on the ground face down, 8 1/2 months pregnant, Jay Sebring objected and Tex Watson shot and stabbed him in front of his closest friends. When the Abigail and her boyfriend bolted out the door in fear they were chased down and stabbed dozens of times. So bloody that the police thought Abigail’ nightgown was red when it had been white. Sharon Tate heard and saw everything while she begged for mercy, Susan Atkins taunted her and told her she was going to die, and while she and Tex Watson stabbed her repeatedly she called out for her own mother. There were MANY decisions points in this cold attacked in the planning, in the driving to the residence, there faced with the victims (one of the killers said when they got back to the ranch “they were so young” THEY KNEW what they were doing. They KNEW earlier when they slaughtered the musician, and the next night when they slaughtered the La Biancas. They partied afterwards as their victims lay hacked to death in pools of blood waiting for the housekeeper to discover them in the morning. Waiting for the LaBiancas children to find them the next night. Tex Watson became a “minister” in prison, married and has fathered two children on conjugal visits. He has had free run of the prison where they all are, a one story park-like campus where he leaves to go into town. They escaped death and had their lives. The surviving families paid mightily and spent the intervening three decades in parole board meeting after parole board meeting each separate for each mass-murderer (each convicted for either 7 or 8 murders. the state did not include unborn children at that time. They really killed 9) year after year reliving the gruesomeness of one of the 20th centuries most brutal and senseless and heinous mass murders. The two murderers that Truman Capote wrote about in “In Cold Blood” killed the parents and their two children also awoken in their beds in surprise and senseless attacks. In that case the murderers were soon enough hung. This was three separate events, 8 victims, over 100 family members left behind grieving, the murderers living cushy lives in a college campus like one story prison….escaping their death sentence by a fluke of timing….and putting the surviving families through parole hell year after year. Susan Atkins and Tex Watson were the worst of all, the leaders, the cruelest, the most brutal, the most unmerciful, still the most clueless of the weight of all they’ve done. They deserve absolutely no mercy. They received their parole when they escaped the death sentence that they deserved.
By Get Sporty on 06/22/2008 1:13 pm
Ro H
Having read most of your posts on this subject Sporty, I am inclined to ask you… Were you actually there at the time of the murders? If not how can you be so sure of so much of what you write. If so, why didn’t you help to stop it all instead of ranting about it. Why so much anger? Are you actually a member of the Tate family?
By Ro H on 01/04/2009 6:11 pm
Mugsy Peabody
Compassion and clemency are not about those who are the subject, they are about who we are as people who practice them. Who do we want to be, not who is she? I would love to see everyone reread Shirley Jackson’s short story, The Lottery before really answering this one.
By Mugsy Peabody on 06/19/2008 4:06 pm
Frank Peterson
Mugsy—apt choice, The Lottery—and one more truly good post —thank you.
By Frank Peterson on 06/19/2008 4:18 pm
Mugsy Peabody
Prego, Frank.
By Mugsy Peabody on 06/19/2008 5:04 pm