Cynthia McFadden | 09/11/2008 12:00 am
Cynthia McFadden's Remembrance of 9/11, Off the Record ... and On
I was at the office early that gorgeous September morning. My assistant at ABC was also there. She had a young friend who worked near the Trade Center who called her and said to turn on the television, something weird was going on. I immediately called our news desk and headed downtown with a satellite truck. We were clearly going in the wrong direction. Waves of people, vacant-eyed people walked by us heading north. The truck got stopped by the police but my producer and I continued on foot. Within an hour or so of the first plane hitting the Trade Center, we’d talked our way into the command center. It was totally silent. A horrible deadly silence. I found a payphone — our cells weren’t working — and talked to Peter Jennings live on the air. I told him that, so far, no survivors had made it to the trauma center on the East Side.
We walked through the dusty, silent corridors of New York west to Chelsea Piers. I remember running into Lesley Stahl and her crew. Thousands of doctors and nurses had assembled at the Pier to receive the injured. By midnight not one patient had shown up. A nurse waved me over: "Cynthia, you won’t remember me but I was in the delivery room when your baby was born. Off the record," she continued, "people either made it out, or they didn’t. There are not going to be any wounded coming here."
I called Jennings and asked to speak to him privately. "Peter," I said, "sources down here say that people either made it out or they didn’t. The survivors are safely out now. No one is going to come here." Remember that at this point no one knew for sure how many people were in the towers that morning, but some estimates were that as many as 30,000 people could have been inside when the planes hit. Peter said, "Cynthia, it’s too early for this. When I come to you on the air, don’t report this. People won’t be able to absorb it yet." It was such a human judgment, such a correct one. Jennings was at his best throughout. Wise, calm, insightful. I was proud to be a small part of ABC’s coverage of 9/11 for which I am happy to say we won a DuPont Award.
What else do I remember?
The dozens and dozens of people who came up to me when they’d see the camera, begging me to help them find their loved ones. One young woman stands out. She was 17 and had a ten-year-old and a seven-year-old with her. It was September 12. Her mother was in the first tower. High up. Their father was not in their lives. She pushed through the barriers as we were live on "Good Morning America," sobbing, "What am I supposed to do? She was all we have." As I struggled not to speak, Charlie Gibson said quietly, a catch in his voice, "It’s OK to cry Cynthia, hug her for us."
The cop who hugged me at Ground Zero and said, "None of us must ever forget this."
Going to the home of a firefighter who wasn’t supposed to be working that day, but insisted on going to the scene. Keeping his mass card on our refrigerator. Spencer, then three, calling him "our fireman." The sad eyes of his widow and children.
What do I remember?
Staggering home after several days to find Spencer standing on the living-room sofa with a towel serving as a cape, "Mommy, I am Superman and I am going to save those people."

























9 Reader Comments (so far…) Sign In or Register to comment
Cynthia,
your rememberance gave me chills. Broke my heart. Poignant…
I watched the History channel all evening, reliving that horrible day. I was home with a migraine that day and was just heading for bed when the information about the plane (they initially thought it was an accident and a private plane) that crashed into the South Tower. I was horrified as I watched and was horrified all over again yesterday. There were pictures of people jumping and pictures of dead firemen on the ground - hadn’t seen those before. Death is ugly!
Eight years ago I watched as did millions of others as the second plane flew directly to the remaining tower and said out loud, with tears pouring down my face, "Oh my God, they’re doing it on purpose." Nearly impossible to the human mind to absorb such detestable evil. Numb, I sat there all day, unable to take it all in. When they said four planes had been highjacked and they didn’t know where the 4th was, I thought, "They’re going to hit the White House!" When the plane crashed in a field I knew the passengers had taken over and prevented that atrocity in spite of the fact they knew they were going to die.
Life changed forever in this country that day! No one should ever forget or let future generations forget. Last night it was familiar and just as horrifying as it was when it all happened. I too, wonder what happened to that 17 year old girl who was suddenly responsible for her younger siblings. I hope there were relatives somewhere who took them in.
Heartbreaking! Impossible to comprehend the evilness and lack of humanity in the minds and hearts of the men who did this and who continue to commit atrocities in the Middle East hourly. Evil abounds in the world, in the Middle East, in Africa, in Mexico. Life has never been so cheap.
I was raised to believe that we’re all created in God’s image - my faith has been badly shaken by the events in the past eight years. If God is love, how did these despicable creatures come to be? How could innocent little babies grow into men who thrive on hatred, revenge and violence?