Politics | 02/27/2009 3:30 pm
In Expected Move, Obama Moves to Lift Bush's 'Conscience' Rule

Women’s groups are hailing the Obama administration’s reported decision to roll back Bush-era protections for health-care workers who refuse to provide services because of moral objections.
"We heartily commend the Obama administration for recognizing this rule for what it is: a targeted attack on women’s health and rights. Rescinding this harmful rule is a step back from the precipice; women across the country will be able to breathe easier once their right to information and needed services has been fully restored," said Marcia D. Greenberger, co-president of the National Women’s Law Center.
The Bush administration regulation allowed federal funding to be cut off to any health-care facility that didn’t let doctors or nurses opt out of procedures — including abortion — to which they objected, or which were against their religious beliefs. Government officials told The Washington Post today that they’re reviewing a proposal to get rid of the regulation. Officials said the way it’s worded now is too broad and could restrict women from getting vital services. Family-planning groups have said it could even stretch to not giving women contraceptives. The Los Angeles Times notes that seven states and two family-planning groups have filed lawsuits against the regulation.
"We support a tightly written conscience clause. We recognize and understand that some providers have objections about abortion, and we want to make sure that current law protects them," a Health and Human Services official told the Post. "We want to be thoughtful about this."
But the Christian Medical Association argues there’s no confusion about the rule, and that rescinding it is what puts women’s health at risk, "threatens health-care professionals’ freedom to practice medicine according to ethical standards and exposes the myth of moderation in Obama’s abortion policy."
It even goes as far to say that health-care workers serving some of the nation’s poorest populations could be adversely affected by the rule. "Infringing on their right to practice medicine according to these life-affirming ethical standards will force them to leave the profession and to shut down the hospitals and clinics," said the association’s CEO, David Stevens.
The debate over this controversial topic undoubtedly will heat up over the next month or so. We’ll keep you posted on all the developments!























394 Reader Comments (so far…) Sign In or Register to comment
Can I ask you…should American Dr.s of Muslim faith be able to refuse to treat women? Should Pharmicists who practice white supremacy be able to refuse to fill a perscription for someone who is Asian?
Where do you draw the line?
If you don’t want to treat ALL patients then change professions. Use your Medical degree for research or work for a drug company. A Dr. takes an Oath that should be as serious to him as his faith…and if he can’t abide by that oath he needs to stop being a medical Dr.
I do not think there is anything in the oath about taking a life?..their oath is to save lives.
Your speaking of a racial issue not a life & death issue.
Even in "holy Catholic Ireland" where abortion isn’t even legal… ALL medical professionals are required to give Irish women full information. That is part of their Constitution.
No doctor is required here to perform abortions. But they are required to give all their patients full information, both men AND women. Also, you are going straight for the sensational with this… the fact is, the Bush rule even allowed pharmacists who were against birth control to refuse to fill a woman’s birth control prescription. That this was allowed showed Bush’s utter contempt for the rights of women to full and proper healthcare in this country.
You are 100% correct. The Conscience Rights Act was passed to keep doctors and nurses from being sued if they chose not to peform abortions.
Why would you FORCE someone to do a medical procedure on you that they don’t agree with - only for the pursuit of money and someone to blame other than yourself.
If your interpretation of your religion keeps you from performing the job you have agreed to do, you should find another job. It’s that simple. Most of us do not believe that abortion, birth control and the morning after pill constitute murder. It’s your belief, not ours and in the United States of America, religion does not constitute law. That’s one of the reasons my ancestors came to this land-to avoid religious persecution. Therefore, I reject your attempt to force your religious belief on me and my body.