Sign in to wowOwow

Enter the email address that you used when registering at wowOwow.
The password field is case sensitive. Click here if you have forgotten your password.

Please register for wowOwow

Newsletter subscriptions
Sign up to receive wowOwow's weekly newsletter and get our best picks delivered right to your inbox. Our newsletter content is hand-picked by the wowOwow editorial team and provides the top features, news, and commentary from our site. Subscribing to our newsletter is free and safe. We will never share your email or other information with a third-party without your direct consent.
By registering, you indicate that you have read and agree
with our privacy policy and terms of service.

Money | 03/28/2008 10:33 am

Financial Columnist Liz Peek Asks When Will the Economy Hit Bottom?

By Liz Peek

EDITOR’S NOTE: Liz Peek is a financial columnist.

“Attention, Shoppers! Please keep spending! Don’t worry about your slumping home price, the climbing price of gasoline, the scary stock market. We’re counting on you!”

Rather than engineering the bail-out of large investment banks, maybe Treasury Secretary Paulson should be issuing messages like the one above. After all, the crisis of confidence, which is gumming up the credit markets and which almost flung venerable Bear Stearns into bankruptcy, is now infecting the consumer, as shown by the stall in February spending announced today.

What, really, is at the heart of today’s economic slowdown, and the dramatic ups and down in stock prices? There are many problems, but the main answer is that investors, bankers and policy makers are still unsure about the extent of the so-called “subprime contagion”. Climbing defaults among those with weak credit who bought homes in recent years have infected many classes of securities built on those mortgages. Those debt instruments were layered (often with lots of leverage) into veritable investment napoleons and then sold all over the world to banks, hedge funds and other institutions. The buyers had no idea that at the heart of these complicated securities, which were often triple-A rated, there lurked very fragile subprime mortgages.

So we have great uncertainty, especially among financial institutions. Many have taken substantial write-downs of these assets, damaging their credit and worrying investors. Further charges are expected, and the estimates vary wildly. Andy Davidson, who specializes in risk analysis in the mortgage-backed securities business (and whose phone has been ringing off the hook for six months), told me last summer, “We have 10,000 financial institutions in this country and we know a few will go broke; the problem is we don’t know which ones they are.”

Shaken by these issues, bankers are not lending, despite massive infusions of liquidity engineered by the Federal Reserve. This is hurting small and medium size businesses and also causing the collapse of large deals such as the $19 billion buyout of Clear Channel, which has been in the news lately.

Fed Chairman Ben Bernanke and Secretary Paulson are doing their utmost to be sure that no big banks or investment banks go bust. This has angered those who object to the government “bailing out” the speculators who got us into this fix. The truth is that the failure of any large financial institution would be like a large ocean liner going down; it could suck any number of smaller vessels down along with it.

When will we hit bottom? I think a recovery has to start in the real estate markets, where the problems originated. Recent headlines on the housing front have been dramatic. Builders of new homes have slashed prices by more than 11 percent and have cut new home starts by half. Inventories of new homes for sale have dropped sharply. Prices of existing houses are down more than 13 percent from the peak. Mortgage rates have fallen too. This will help.

Still, a recovery in housing is probably at least a year away. Price declines on new homes appear to be slowing, but top economic firm ISI points out that in the 1990s real estate slump prices on new houses bottomed more than a year ahead of prices on existing homes.

Once real estate markets begin to stabilize, homeowners will be less tempted to walk away from their mortgages. As a result, the credit markets will begin to recover as lenders will have a better fix on their exposure to the subprime meltdown. Eventually, the banks will begin to lend again, spurring growth forward.

The markets will anticipate this turnaround. Some say the market has already hit its low point, when the Dow touched 11,600 in late January. I hope that’s true, but I expect that the recovery will be muted. This market scare will not soon be forgotten.

45 Reader Comments (so far…) Sign In or Register to comment

Deborah G
Thank you for introducing a ‘difficult’ topic. Frankly, poor judgment and greed abound at every level of the process. Banks and mortgage lenders are in it for a profit, and more profit is always a goal. Real estate agents benefit from selling larger homes, pressing the buyer to extend their finances more that wise. (I have bought 2 homes during the course of my life and each time I had to curb the real estate agents’ enthusiastic advise to buy higher.) Buyers need to be realistic about income and stability. This is particularly important in a world of media images of large, lovely homes with gourmet kitchens. Mixed into the current scenario is the trend of buying to ‘flip’, when the buyer anticipates big revenue from a hot market.
By Deborah G on 03/29/2008 7:43 am
Liz Peek
Deborah- you are totally right. The difference in this cycle was that there were so many hands in the cookie jar - the mortgage brokers, the realtors, the banks that extended the loans, the investment banks that packaged the loans to create the mortgage-backed securities, the hedge funds that bought them and the ratings agencies that allowed the creation of them. There are probably more participants than that - and each one was one step further removed from the actual transaction, and less knowledgeable about the finances. truly, a recipe for disaster!
By Liz Peek on 03/29/2008 12:13 pm
ann dillon
i think it has -nothing left but super rich and working poor-how much worse does it have to get?
By ann dillon on 03/29/2008 1:39 pm
Kay Sara
I beleive the loss of jobs will impact the housing market negatively even after the bad loans are written off- taken care of whatever. This is a big problem and no short term solution looms in the future until we get FAIR TRADE- not FREE TRADE and tax corporations for shipping jobs overseas. Or better- those selling to U.S. market need to produce a designated % of the product or service in U.S. like other countries force us to do. With American’s not having jobs- they have no money to buy any homes, get loans approved, buy products. It lies in that “Global Market” that has made only Corp CEO’s rich. There is no trickle down to AMericans when products/jobs are overseas.
By Kay Sara on 03/29/2008 3:13 pm
Esther Bradley-DeTally
Anyone read The SHOCK DOCTRINE, The Rise of Disaster Capitalism-Naomi Klein, corporations, oh my, Greedy CEO’s would do well to heed the phrase, “Listen to the midnight sighing of the poor.” The extremes of wealth and poverty become more extreme every day.
By Esther Bradley-DeTally on 03/29/2008 7:27 pm
Emma Pathey
I too find it amazing how wide the gap is between rich and poor in the U.S. I was horrified to read in the paper today that the CEO of Countrywide Mortgage will get millions of dollars when Bank of America absorbs it. And all those poor sods who will lose their jobs and their health insurance as a result of the CEO’s incompetence and greed will get nothing. It’s an outrage.
By Emma Pathey on 03/29/2008 10:14 pm
Kay Sara
Obama wants to raise capital gains taxes from 15% to 25%! GREAT! What are we going to live on when we retire- corpoarte pensions are not there, social security won’t be there and our 401K’s are in the dumper and any capital gains we get will be taxed almost double ! Please we need someone who has a grasp on how to fix this economy- HILLARY!
By Kay Sara on 03/30/2008 6:33 am
Marie McConnell
All I know is that something better change and soon!
By Marie McConnell on 03/31/2008 8:39 am
Amy Van Cleave
THE BOTTOM WILL BE WHEN PEOPLE DON’T EVER WANT TO OWN A STOCK EVER AGAIN! AND PUTTING THE MONEY INTO CD’S. AMY
By Amy Van Cleave on 03/31/2008 11:29 am
Judy m.
I apologize if this comes across as intrusive. But,I feel like I am suppossed to know who Upandaway is and I don’t. I have checked the contributers on the banner and am quite confused.
By Judy m. on 03/31/2008 6:38 pm
Pamela Munro
Living as I do close of the fault lines of this financial earthquake, I do not see how the investors could be so blind that they didn’t not see how shakey the ground was for these sub-prime mortages. Houses were being bought by families who couldn’t possible afford them in the long term, in outlying areas where they would have to commute into the city (with expensive gasoline) - The whole thing didn’t make sense. To make matters worse, the lenders manipulated the ignorance of the people taking on the mortgages, because the paperwork was above their heads and they simply couldn’t read it themselves. This is a middle-class underclass that feels it should have the American dream, but can’t afford it, which is painful. My husband is a teacher, and we can never even THINK of buying real estate here in Los Angeles, where we both work, as we are not millionaires. But we also have not had children we couldn’t afford. The other point is that if the US market for imported goods is destroyed through short-term economic policy - where do they think the markets will come from? China will take a long time to equal the US as a market. If it weren’t for cheap Chinese goods, which have been papering over our economic woes, this would have happened a long time ago! We need to re-think the American economy, educate the next generations, and go for longterm stability instead of continuing the robber baron course we are on.
By Pamela Munro on 04/01/2008 4:06 pm
Kay Sara
My work commutes used to be bumper to bumper- stop and go. For the past year I have been sailing in - hardly any other cars on the road either way. I work in Detroit.
By Kay Sara on 04/03/2008 1:13 pm
Kay Sara
Without stopping the loss of good paying jobs by “globalization” greed to get into the new bigger markets at the loss of US citizen’s jobs - no solution for healthcare, energy, housing will be enough. Shame on our government for not having the foresight to see what free trade globalization would do to this country. No trickle down economics to U.S. citizens with globalization. Without the jobs there may not be any bounce back.
By Kay Sara on 04/03/2008 1:19 pm
Kay Sara
The government was negligent in their responsibility and obligation to regulate the financial industry to assure that bad loans were not running rampant.
By Kay Sara on 04/03/2008 1:27 pm
Kay Sara
Are we there yet?
By Kay Sara on 04/08/2008 11:42 am