Sign in to wowOwow

Enter the email address that you used when registering at wowOwow.
The password field is case sensitive. Click here if you have forgotten your password.

Please register for wowOwow

Newsletter subscriptions
Sign up to receive wowOwow's weekly newsletter and get our best picks delivered right to your inbox. Our newsletter content is hand-picked by the wowOwow editorial team and provides the top features, news, and commentary from our site. Subscribing to our newsletter is free and safe. We will never share your email or other information with a third-party without your direct consent.
By registering, you indicate that you have read and agree
with our privacy policy and terms of service.

A Friend Stopped By | 02/05/2009 6:00 am

Life's Work, by Linda Hirshman

By Linda Hirshman
Linda Hirshman/John Hall Photography

Editor’s note: Linda Hirshman is a retired professor of philosophy and the author of Get to Work: A Manifesto for Women of the World and occasional commentator in forums such as The New York Times and the Washington Post. Starting this spring, she will be a political columnist for Double X, the women’s political online magazine.

"The work-life balance is something I think about a lot," Michelle Obama told a convention of female bloggers gathered in Chicago last summer. I do not doubt that the new First Lady — and self-proclaimed "mom-in-chief" — is thinking about something a lot. But I hope it isn’t work on the one hand and life on the other. Because, as much as any other human undertaking, work is a part of life.

I don’t know when women (men, note well, never talk about work being outside of life) started the self-destructive notion that their work was not worthy of being included in the undertaking we call "life." But I do know that language matters. You name it, you own it. When women use language that separates their work from their very existence, their life, they are guaranteeing they will never get what they need from either.

I don’t think it’s overstating to assert that when women talk about work versus life, or balancing work and life, what they mean is private life, or family life. There was a time in history when, for certain middle-class, mostly white women, their families were their whole lives. They did not work in the public sphere, they did not work in the market economy. That time is long past in the United States. For many women, it was never the case.

Why, then, do people use language that is both false and harmful? When did family life expand to fill all of life? Don’t they care about what they do at work? Is work a burdensome load they have to tote because they cannot afford to pay the bills if they do not drag themselves out of their "life" to work every day? Many stay-at-home moms have written books explaining how, if you are willing to give up consumer luxuries like TVs and restaurant meals, women can afford to lay down that weary load and stay in "life." Yet, few do it.

I suspect that is because public or market work is a part of most women’s lives. Women are people (they have this in common with men). Sometimes work allows people to use their capacities — for creativity, problem solving, heroic accomplishment, power, service and, yes, even making lots of money. Even if not lots, enough to be independent and have some measure of security. If these "work/life" women would think about it, they would surely realize that creativity, problem solving, heroism, power, service, independence and security are very important parts of life. Sometimes work sucks, but it allows people to socialize with other adults in orderly and quiet surroundings, and to control their daily agenda in a way that informal family circumstances do not often allow.

36 Reader Comments (so far…) Sign In or Register to comment

Sandbee (FB) 54
;-)
By Sandbee (FB) 54 on 02/06/2009 6:54 am
Agyness O
Amen, DB…I am with you and there are many others.
By Agyness O on 02/08/2009 2:01 pm
Diana T
Thank you, Sandbee. That is exactly what I thought. All those years of supporting my family and/or children didn’t leave me any choice about the difference between job, work, career. So, I am still trying to figure out what I would have done if I had a choice in the matter when I was much younger. But…..your Higher Power puts you where you need to be at the time, so at this point, I enjoy each day as it comes.
By Diana T on 02/07/2009 6:18 pm
Belinda Joy
Oh Linda, I couldn’t disagree with your line of thinking more. With the current economic crisis and thousands of (now formally affluent) men scrambling to hang onto their millions that are now slipping through their fingers like precious grains of sands, these men are lost. What they DO is who they are, or so they think. Which is why so many are committing suicide, fearing that they are shamed now that they are without their millions. The work-life balance that Michelle Obama speaks of is echoed by millions of women correctly. We have the ability to compartmentalize our lives. Work is work, it is where we earn a living, foster important management and interpersonal skills and abilities. Home, our life away from work, should be a place of respite. A place where we are among our loved ones, friends, acquaintances, pets, neighbors, clergy, store owners, bloggers. A place where we can engage in activities that free our minds and take us away from the headaches and stress of our jobs. Work should not be our lives. It is completely unhealthy to even assume that would be a wise way to look at our jobs. Men need to stop thinking in that way. The millions of men all over the country that are quietly suffering from depression because of a fear they can’t provide for their families, should not be taking place. They need, as women need, to have a clear delineation between work and their “real lives”
By Belinda Joy on 02/05/2009 7:51 pm
%$#@* !@&*^!!
My life’s work is LIFE…and than entails quite a lot…all related to what is right for me.
By %$#@* !@&*^!! on 02/05/2009 8:31 pm
DeBúrca obj
NP—Agree. This is here soap opera schtick. A big loser like Blago that has no substance. Just loser schtick. By Carmel~by~the~Sea Pebble Beach on 02/05/2009 2:03 pm” I’m with you… let’s boycott all the Palin threads (that’s why I am posting this in here), at best they’ll stop running them, at LEAST the Palin lovers will get bored and leave!
By DeBúrca obj on 02/05/2009 8:34 pm
CYNTHIA NEIL
Although it was a rather slower lesson than many in my life, I realized that my two children were my most important work. I spent a large part of my single life pursuing singing and acting as my work, and was blessed to make it as far as supporting myself for a few years in New York with my singing. That time was a gift. I have spent their entire lives being their mom, their father while an excellent “provider”, ran away from being part of the family, I am still trying to grasp why, two years after his death. I taught my kids to read, think, make music, choose honorably and laugh. I taught them not to whine, lie, hurt people intentionally, or quit. And I have told them from a very young age that if i do not raise them right, (to choose to be the best people they can be) it doesn’t matter whether I win a Grammy, star in a movie, write a best seller or sing on Broadway (all goals I am once again working toward) I have failed in my most important work. It took me a long time to honor the hardest work a woman will ever be expected to do… raising children well and with love.
By CYNTHIA NEIL on 02/05/2009 8:43 pm
Linda Myers
I really believe that “your money flows from where your energy goes”. Life becomes where you put the energy you have. My primary job is enjoying what I am passionate about doing, my secondary job is a part time retail job, that I still am able to intergrate who I am, into what the job is. And I enjoy those hours of interaction and being spontaneous with the general public. And the hours I dedicate to my personal dreams and desires, are still plentiful. There is a balance of my creation. I enjoy working with kids, and I get the interaction from both sides of my life. With the part time job, I see alot of beautiful babies, and children for moments at a time, looking into innocent faces of our future world and seeing the eyes of tomorrow. I feel blessed! It’s work, it’s life, and I love it!
By Linda Myers on 02/06/2009 12:41 am
Kay Sara
I never was an advocate of separating your work from “your real life”. I love to apply myself, my efforts and my talents to an endevour - business, family, entertaining, home. I loved raising my children, taking care of my home (kind of a Martha Stewart type) and loved my work. I was a total package, not splintered and I feel I gave to each facet all that they needed and more —- though when my kids were little I was very very tired. I brought my children into what I was doing in business - as a part of their education. My kids were so proud that they had a hard working mom, and to my amazement my one son actually had scorn for the stay at home Moms he would see when he went over to his friends homes.
By Kay Sara on 02/06/2009 7:05 am
Chrome Toe
I often don’t read all the posts before I write as i’m usually just sort of spewing a thought out as it relates to whatever the topic is. But this time I read the posts. I think some folks are kind of missing her point. I don’t think she’s saying that everyone has to have their dream job. I think she’s saying that the way we talk about work and think about work in this country is harmful. I totally understand her way of thinking on that. I mean think about whatever job you have or do. whether or not it’s your dream job it brings something meaningful into your life. maybe you met your best friend there. maybe you spend your lunch times with a couple of folks tha tyou truly enjoy. maybe you’re on a company sports team. these are all things that matter in the scheme of “life” and are not separate. but beyond just the social thing.. even if it’s not your dream job.. maybe your still just damn good at it. what if tomorrow you got to leave that job and didn’t have anything in your life that you were that good at? Even if it’s data entry for a big company and you think it’s beneath you… but you are the best in your company. I think her entire post was really just about how we verbalize that work is separate from life and that if it isn’t the perfect job of our dreams… if we aren’t walking red carpets or spening our days in an art studio.. then it’s not our “life”.
By Chrome Toe on 02/06/2009 7:26 am
Heather Cariou
Yes, chrome toe, you are right, it’s about how we verbalize, and before we do that, how we THINK about the differentials between “work” and “life.” Except there isn’t a schism between the two unless we put it there. Yes, Joan, raising a family is hard work. Being a care-giver, as I have been, is hard work. But it seems to me that to characterize different sections of our life as hard work, or defining work as just something we do to pay the bills, is to undermine ourselves and our possibilities, and negate the rewards that come from our hard work in every area of our lives. Which reminds me of this quote by Rabindranath Tagore: I slept and dreamt that life was joy. I woke and found that life was service. I acted, and behold, service was joy. I learned from my dying young sister, who “worked” every day of her short life just to stay alive, and then went far beyond that, that joy is available no matter what your circumstance. We can’t control life by being afraid of it. Our only power is in how we choose to respond to our situation. Understand the difference between giving up and surrender. Never give up. All of that is about finding balance in our lives, every part of our lives. Work is not separate from life, it’s part of it. And if we recognize this, we don’t have to lose our identity when we lose our jobs. I define myself by WHO I am, not WHAT I am in the workplace.
By Heather Cariou on 02/06/2009 9:37 am
joan larsen
Heather … As you can guess, you and I are on the same page in our thinking - as well as our beliefs. I applaud your words, and love your quotation. Joan
By joan larsen on 02/06/2009 2:58 pm
Victoria Victor
Wholeness.
By Victoria Victor on 02/06/2009 11:52 am
Jill Miller Zimon
Linda, I’m taking the bait! :) I understand what you’re saying and I’m not sure which camp I’m in. But I do want to ask a question to clarify your line of thinking, at least for me. Today I listened to discussion, initiated by an African-American editorial writer for the Plain Dealer, Phillip Morris, that Black History Month isn’t necessary anymore and that it should be subsumed within History - that we have a shared history. Is your notion a similar notion - that women need to help re-define everyone’s notion of life as including work, for men and for women, rather than create this notion of work and life being separate? If that’s the case, I can understand the appeal of wanting to do that, but I share the fear that that understanding will get lost and not enough people - men in particular who make policy - will accept this notion. Then again, maybe you continue to be ahead of your time, or pushing us ahead, period. If I could trust that we’d have a shared understanding (“we” meaning employers, policy-makers etc.), I wouldn’t be concerned about the semantics. But, as with the Black History Month v. just our shared history…I don’t know.
By Jill Miller Zimon on 02/06/2009 12:10 pm
Heather Cariou
Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens can change the world. Indeed, it’s the only thing that ever has. -Margaret Mead We help to re-define everyone’s notion of life as including work by re-defining it for ourselves individually. That is the only way to begin. This is how we become a light in the darkness for others - finding the courage to shine our own. Semantics is just so much conversation. Or, to quote Howard Thurman: “Don’t ask what the world needs. Ask what makes you come alive and go out and do it. Because what the world needs is people who have come alive.” One could say, the world needs people who live life holistically - seeing the connectedness between work, play and praise, just as we need to see the connectedness in each other.
By Heather Cariou on 02/06/2009 3:32 pm