Sign in to wowOwow

Enter the email address that you used when registering at wowOwow.
The password field is case sensitive. Click here if you have forgotten your password.

Please register for wowOwow

Newsletter subscriptions
Sign up to receive wowOwow's weekly newsletter and get our best picks delivered right to your inbox. Our newsletter content is hand-picked by the wowOwow editorial team and provides the top features, news, and commentary from our site. Subscribing to our newsletter is free and safe. We will never share your email or other information with a third-party without your direct consent.
By registering, you indicate that you have read and agree
with our privacy policy and terms of service.

Liz Smith | 06/27/2008 12:35 pm

Who Is the Real Fifth Beatle?

Liz Smith

I’ll state my bona fides for this posting by telling you briefly about one Peter Brown who heads up my Literacy Partners project, and does so much more for New York City. This Britisher, living in New York, was once a very young aide to the Beatles manager, Brian Epstein. Today, he represents Andrew Lloyd Webber’s interests in the United States. He is a close friend to Barbara Walters and is one of those guys who knows everybody who is anybody – like actual friendships in the British Royal Family for instance.

When Neil Aspinall died of lung cancer last March, Entertainment Weekly did a piece on this onetime driver and road manager who had served as a personal assistant at the height of Beatlemania. In 1968, Neil took over their new record company, Apple Corps, and looked after their interests until 2007. He is credited with masterminding their famous 1995 “Beatles Anthology.”

So, EW named him the “Fifth Beatle” and in the process dropped other names of men who have been similarly cited – manager Epstein, producer George Martin, early guitarist Stuart Sutcliffe.

2008_0627_liz_cilla_brown.jpg
The Fifth Beatle Cilla Black cuddling with early Beatle aide Peter Brown

But nobody breathed a word about the woman whose picture I am showing you here – cuddling up to the aforesaid Peter Brown. She is none other than Cilla Black, a girl who hung with the Beatles in Liverpool and on through their early days. They adored Cilla and followed her lead.

When the Beatles went on to glory, Cilla did also. But she went her own way as a singer and musician. Eventually she had a big TV show in London that made her “the Barbara Walters of Great Britain.”

She is still slim, trim and dynamic and can sing up a storm. So I nominate Cilla Black for the Fifth Beatle and, you might note, she is a woman and you heard it here first!

P.S. Thank you to all the bright clever readers who corrected me from Cilla’s name "Brown" (wrong) to "Black" (correct). Sorry about that. Grateful to be corrected. Liz  

Click here on this text to read my nationally syndicated daily column.

 

Read more about: Beatles, Cilla Black, Music

19 Reader Comments (so far…) Sign In or Register to comment

Frank Peterson
WOW! i’d nearly forgotten Cilla—yeah I agree, in many ways, Liz—though George Martin still heads my list. Thank you so much for the ‘reminder’ ;-)
By Frank Peterson on 06/27/2008 11:41 am
Frannie Em
Frank, Who was the keyboard player on Abby Road? Wasn’t that who the Beatles called the Fifth Beatle.
By Frannie Em on 06/27/2008 11:45 am
Frank Peterson
Frannie—you’re remembering Billy Preston? Right? :-)
By Frank Peterson on 06/27/2008 12:20 pm
Frannie Em
Frank, yes thank you. That was it. Groovy man
By Frannie Em on 06/27/2008 2:48 pm
Frank Peterson
WOW! i’d nearly forgotten Cilla—yeah I agree, in many ways, Liz—though George Martin still heads my list. Thank you so much for the ‘reminder’ ;-)
By Frank Peterson on 06/27/2008 11:41 am
James the Game
Billy Preston was on the Hammond B3 organ; Martin, McCartney and Lennon all played various pianos on that album.
By James the Game on 06/27/2008 2:07 pm
Frannie Em
Thanks James, I know they all played keyboard, but they called Billy Preston the 5th Beatle. My vote is for Cilla.
By Frannie Em on 06/27/2008 2:50 pm
Frannie Em
Liz, Am I wrong here, or wasn’t her name Cilla Black? She was a singer too.
By Frannie Em on 06/27/2008 2:51 pm
Sherrie Crews
I remember Cilla from an old ‘60 London based music variety show that was shown here in the states called Hullabaloo. It was the British counterpart to a similar show based here called Shindig. A different British music star would be featured as the headline act each week. She was indeed an amazing singer.
By Sherrie Crews on 06/27/2008 11:45 am
Frannie Em
Sherrie, My brother and I used to dance on Shindig. Too groovy Huh? We thought we were, oh geesh, were we mistaken.
By Frannie Em on 06/27/2008 2:52 pm
Corinne M.
Her name is not Cilla Brown. Cilla Brown is a character on the long-running British soap, “Coronation Street.” The singer is Cilla Black. Her given name, interestingly, is Priscilla Maria Veronica White. It was a typo that changed her name from White to Black. She met the Beatles when she worked checking hats at the Cavern Club and I think it was John who got her the audition with Brian Epstein. As to nominating her as the Fifth Beatle, I disagree. At the Beatles’ 1988 induction into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame, George Harrison at one point stated that there were only two “fifth Beatles”: Derek Taylor and Neil Aspinall. Besides, there are many other musical “Fifth Beatles” who would come before her—Eric Clapton, Billy Preston, Jeff Lynne (ELO), Jackie Lomax, to name just a few.
By Corinne M. on 06/27/2008 12:42 pm
Emma Pathey
Oh I’m so glad someone else got their facts straight too. I couldn’t believe it when I read this piece. Liz, you’re slipping my dear! I was a big fan of Cilla Black and always watched when she was on “Top of the Pops”. It was always my opinion that she should not have had the beauty spot on her chin removed, but this was before Cindy Crawford and I suppose Cilla was pressured into having it taken off.
By Emma Pathey on 06/27/2008 2:12 pm
Frannie Em
Corinne, There is an old interview of the Beatles around the time they were breaking up and they called Billy Preston the 5th Beatle. I guess there were a lot of 5th Beatles. It must have been nice.
By Frannie Em on 06/27/2008 2:55 pm
Emcye Edwards
The Beatles had a pretty hilarious way of calling everyone who played with them ‘Beatle:’ Sharing the glory or the curse, depending on the mood. Watch George and John do it here: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e-5Jwdz2nv4 Interesting how ‘shy’ George seemed the funniest, loosest of all, as he aged. Like the four directions of the earth, those boys. I spent a great portion of my childhood with my ear glued to the Hi-Fi and worked out the drum beats to Beatle songs with my sister’s hairbrush. When I felt I was ready, I put on shows. I enlisted my mother as my promotional director and she whipped-up Rice-Krispie treats, which we sold for cheap at my one-person Beatles concerts out in the garage. When it was showtime in the garage, Mom put Rubber Soul on the portable turntable and I took turns playing each Beatle in order of my affections. I’d replicated their instruments out of kitchen utensils, pots and heavy cardboard. It was George’s Gibson Hollow-Body and his sideways sneer, Ringo’s head bobbin’ puppy-dog grin as he bashed his cymbals, Paul’s butt-out, left handed bass and John’s legs-spread-wide and lips tight defiance, peering out with his little rhythym guitar. Afterward, my audience got autographed Beatle cards, personalized with each Beatle’s carefully forged signature and funny captions I wrote on the back. I’m sure there were other kids all over the world doing the same thing in their garages… so, many Beatles. So much fun.
By Emcye Edwards on 06/27/2008 9:55 pm
Tinka Parker
Was she also known as Cilla Black? The singer? Or is that just a coincidence? Brown or Black?
By Tinka Parker on 06/27/2008 8:59 pm