Sign in to wowOwow

Enter the email address that you used when registering at wowOwow.
The password field is case sensitive. Click here if you have forgotten your password.

Please register for wowOwow

Newsletter subscriptions
Sign up to receive wowOwow's weekly newsletter and get our best picks delivered right to your inbox. Our newsletter content is hand-picked by the wowOwow editorial team and provides the top features, news, and commentary from our site. Subscribing to our newsletter is free and safe. We will never share your email or other information with a third-party without your direct consent.
By registering, you indicate that you have read and agree
with our privacy policy and terms of service.

Liz Smith | 10/21/2008 2:20 pm

Liz Smith Passes on the 'Paradox of Palinism'

© AP

Dear wOw friends,

I have written in a brittle manner in the past about some of my famous bosses. I actually have four of them. There is Joni Evans who runs this website. There is Col Allen who is boss at The New York Post tabloid where my column appears. I do news commentary for “Fox & Friends” on weekends and my boss there is the famous Roger Ailes. And, I write two columns a week for Daily Variety, the Bible of Show Business. My boss there is the admirable Peter Bart, a man who once ran Hollywood studios and produced movies. He knows all there is to know about the cinema world.

This week in one of his rare Variety columns, Mr. Bart discussed a political cultural topic: “Pop Culture Must Face Big Divide,” ran his headline. I just want to repeat his commentary:

"I’ve finally come to realize Sarah Palin has been a big help. Whether your focus is politics or pop culture, Palin’s emergence has dramatized the Big Divide in this country. Palin’s America is split between (to use Palin’s lexicon) the ‘Joe Six-packs’ and the so-called ‘elites.’ And apparently, we all have to choose sides.

"The Big Divide, as it continues to expand, will impact not only the presidency and the party system but also film, TV and other sectors of our culture.

"So make up your mind, folks. Are you one of those ridiculous, pointy-headed, over-secularized and overeducated elitists? Or are you one of Palin’s down-home value-based ‘real’ folks?

"Some might ask, does this Big Divide make any sense? David Brooks, the conservative columnist for The New York Times, observed last week that Republican strategy seems based on a doctrine of disunity.

"’The Republican party has driven away people who live in highly educated regions and on the coasts,’ he wrote. ‘Polls have also shown that the party has systematically alienated whole professions – lawyers, doctors, tech executives, even the banking community.’

"At the same time, the party also is blowing off the working class, thus squeezing the party at both ends. Who’s left? Moose-hunters in Alaska?

It’s intriguing that Palin’s America has begun to assert itself at the very time the economy is tanking. Joe Six-pack (and Joe the Plumber, who emerged in the final debate) may resent the excesses of Wall Street, but Joe’s also the guy who’s been buying homes he can’t afford and running up credit card debt.

"General Motors for generations has been styling its gas guzzlers for Joe Six-pack, abjuring the tastes of those elitists who’ve been favoring the Prius or Lexus.

"Television has found its own way of dealing with the Great Divide. Broadcast networks are treading water with ‘My Name Is Earl,’ even as elitist snobs fork out the big bucks for pay cable.

"Similarly, it’s increasingly clear that the movie business is split into two dream factories – one hammering out tent-pole pictures for the teen Six-packs and the other focusing on specialty films for those damn elites. The studios only ran into trouble when the tent-polers tried to mess around in the art-house business.

"The paradox of Palinism is that it represents a basic misunderstanding of the conservative movement. Going back to Edmund Burke or even to William F. Buckley, Brooks reminds us that the thoughtful ‘right’ was sophisticated and urbane. Reagan conservatism came across as a pragmatic, if eccentric, blend of smalltown values with coastal reach.

"Take a look at Oliver Stone’s ‘W.’ and you’re also reminded that it was George Bush who made the cynical decision to reinvent the Republican Party. An abject failure at everything he tried, this prep school Yalie decided he could only succeed as, guess who, Joe Six-pack. Under Karl Rove’s guidance, Brooks says, ‘Republican political tacticians decided to mobilize the new Bush coalition into a form of social class warfare.’

"And now John McCain has reinforced it by making what may turn out to be the most erratic casting choice in modern political history as his vice president. No one’s ultimately going to gain from his choice except ‘Saturday Night Live.’"

Click here on this text to read Liz’s New York Post column.

73 Reader Comments (so far…) Sign In or Register to comment

beth willis
As a product of a mixed-marriage, my father was a staunch Republican and my mother was a dogmatic Democrat, I grew up in an environment of compromise in which both of these people were devoted to fiscal responsibility, an example of people living within their means. These were people who had grown up in the dirty steel town of Pittsbugh and made their way to Texas when I was a small child. Fort Worth was a small town to them, lacking the libraries, cultural opportunities and educational system (except for Ms. Mary Sweet) of the big city. Of course, Fort Worth did not have the Mellons and years would pass before the Basses made their mark. Supposedly, a Republican is just a Democrat who has been mugged, but to my dad, a Republcan could one day own a Buick if he worked hard, paid his bills and his mortgage. My mom didn’t care about the Buick, she volunteered in the schools because she thought education was fundamental. Republican: fiscal responsibility Democrat: social responsibility. So they have to be mutually exclusive? Two beliefs I strongly embrace: The more you label, the more you divide; and I can’t imagine being married to someone who did not share my political views. Peace and grace
By beth willis on 10/21/2008 5:53 pm
Vivvy Stewart
Beth, I can’t imagine being in a politically mixed marriage either! For me, that’s one of the things you learn early on in a relationship. Bless the Basses! Oh…you and I are neighbors.
By Vivvy Stewart on 10/22/2008 8:45 am
beth willis
Vivvy, thank you for your response. My parents never had big arguments about the issues, they just avoided them. Well, that’s no good. Worked for them, but I guess I’m just too much of a loud mouth. I have read here that you are a friend of Betty Lynn Buckley. Although we grew up in the same city and are sorority sisters, I never gave her full attention until I saw her in concert s in Denton and Irving this year. Oh My Gosh. Please call her and ask her for another concert soon………….Oh, and I’m not a stalker. Vivvy, we go to Bass Hall and Jubilee Theater frequently. You own a shop, store, business? Peace and grace
By beth willis on 10/22/2008 11:10 am
Vivvy Stewart
One who ends posts with “peace and grace” is surely not a stalker. How fortunate we are to have Bass Hall & we’ve been going to Jubilee Theater since it was on the far east side of town in that tiny space. I adored Rudy Eastman and his genius. Yes, I do own a shop here. Too bad we don’t have private message capability. We’ll figure it out.
By Vivvy Stewart on 10/23/2008 8:52 am
phyllis Doyle Pepe
Beth: Not only is/was the Republican credo proposing fiscal responsibility, it was also for less government, and strong military. It’s credo may still be in place but it has failed to deliver. The Republican party is in shambles thanks in large part to the Bush administration’s disastrous handling of almost everything. No wonder many Republicans are voting democratic this year––they no longer recognize their own party.
By phyllis Doyle Pepe on 10/22/2008 9:03 am
beth willis
Phyllis, if my dad were here, I have to wonder if he might finally vote Democratic. His would be a conflicted decision because of Barack Obama , and the world had become just so much more confusing for this 86 year-old-man. We talked so much about conflicts in the world, and he watched CNN hourly. Finally, I’d say, Dad, “Let’s get in your Buick and go play golf.” He gave me so much that I took for granted…..I’m grateful I had nine months to thank him after my mom was gone and before he died. Peace and grace
By beth willis on 10/22/2008 10:56 am
phyllis Doyle Pepe
And I’m sure he was grateful that he had a daughter like you who had the good sense and love to show him how grateful you were. sometimes people we love leave us suddenly without us ever telling them how much they meant to us.
By phyllis Doyle Pepe on 10/22/2008 12:35 pm
beth willis
Thank you, Phyllis. My previous post may have made it seem that my mother and I were at odds, poor phrasing. My dad and I trulay came together to care for my mom as she faced the last weeks of her life. My mom and I were more like-minded. In private moments with each of us in her final days, I know she sought to draw out those emotions my dad and I had guarded so long, knowing we would need each other. She was the most important person in each of our lives. Only nine months later, on Christmas night, he was hit by a ca while crossing a street…………but what a time we had in those nine months. Thank you for reminding me, Phyllis. I have my own family, and the knowledge I can survive experiences I never imagined. You needn’t respond, Phyllis. Thank you for listening. Peace and grace
By beth willis on 10/22/2008 1:10 pm
Irish Eyes NY
Dear Beth, Your story really touched me. I wanted to cry for you. I lost my parents many years ago, and I still wish they were here. I want to run to the phone with a question for Mom, but not more. I also lost my dear sister 3 years ago to cancer. She lived in OK, but we spoke almost daily, I still miss her so much. I guess dying is just a part of living. thanks for sharing,
By Irish Eyes NY on 10/22/2008 8:03 pm
beth willis
Irish Eyes, thank you so much for your response. Missing the phone calls were emotionally upsetting to me too. I would want to call my mom to share some feat of my children, and that part of our lives was gone. I find that most of my thoughts of my parents remain more recent, perhaps to justify that they had a wonderful life, but each day was more challenging for them. No excuse for my dad’s situation. With my children (35 and 30) my melancholy is for their childhood, those cute little kids with the curly hair, blue eyes and funny antics. I know you miss your daughter, and I can only imagine the heartbreak of that loss. Peace and grace, Irish Eyes NY (I am English/Irish originally from PA)
By beth willis on 10/22/2008 10:32 pm
beth willis
Pardon me, Irish Eyes , I mistakenly wrote ‘daughter’ in place of ‘sister’. Please forgive me. Peace and grace
By beth willis on 10/22/2008 10:37 pm
Sandbee (FB) 54
What I don’t understand is why, even if I fit in the “Joe 6 Pack” group, I would want someone from that group as a leader of the country. I want someone with the best education, best ability to understand what is happening in the world, the best person to work with the economy (not someone who has said they don’t really understand it), and a person who can represent our country to the rest of the world in a way I want to be represented. Not with a wink, you betcha.
By Sandbee (FB) 54 on 10/21/2008 6:06 pm
Lorraine Bates
How many facist dictators catered to the “common man” and imprisoned the educators and the educated? Just sayin…..
By Lorraine Bates on 10/21/2008 8:23 pm
Don Larsen
The “Paradox of Palinism”? Good Lord, that’s hilarious!
By Don Larsen on 10/22/2008 6:57 am
Barbara
I’ve always been an independent: liberal on social issues, conservative on financial issues. I cannot relate to either party. The Dems have gone way too far to the left and the Reps are so rigid and intolerant on social issues but have also been spending like drunken sailors while trying to win favor by cutting taxes. I want someone who manages money like I do my own: don’t spend it unless you have it, make those hard priority decisions. And then stop judging others. I don’t know who decided that “values” only means you must adhere to what I think. Sounds kind of Taliban-ish to me. Who says small towns are the only places with people who have “values?” I very much resent that. I feel my values are very good ones and that I am bringing up my children with those values. I hope with all my heart that the Repbulican nastiness loses this election big. To me the “real” America is anyone who is working away, adhering to what they feel in their hearts, whether I agree with them or not.
By Barbara on 10/22/2008 7:37 am