Sign in to wowOwow

Enter the email address that you used when registering at wowOwow.
The password field is case sensitive. Click here if you have forgotten your password.

Please register for wowOwow

Newsletter subscriptions
Sign up to receive wowOwow's weekly newsletter and get our best picks delivered right to your inbox. Our newsletter content is hand-picked by the wowOwow editorial team and provides the top features, news, and commentary from our site. Subscribing to our newsletter is free and safe. We will never share your email or other information with a third-party without your direct consent.
By registering, you indicate that you have read and agree
with our privacy policy and terms of service.

A Friend Stopped By | 12/17/2008 9:00 am

Made in America: Why We Need to Keep the Big 3 Afloat, by Jennifer Openshaw

By Jennifer Openshaw, President & co-founder, WeSeed

Jennifer Openshaw is co-founder and president of WeSeed, a new approach to demystifying the stock market for real everyday people. She’s also the author of The Millionaire Zone You can reach her at jopenshaw@weseed.com.

So it’s come to this: Either give carmakers some pocket money to buy them some time or they might just collapse.

To help out, the White House is looking at a $15 billion plan that would provide loans — don’t worry, it’s not freemoney — to get them into next year. But aside from this longer-term help, the real issue is that they need cash now.

Last week I wrote about the five ways this would affect everyday Americans. Let me say that, like most of you, I don’t support a pure "bailout." I don’t think anyone does today, including President-elect Obama. That would be like giving your kids your credit cards for a no-strings-attached visit to the mall.

We can’t afford it — and it certainly wouldn’t be making America better.

Like any plan you would make with anyone — and especially your kids — there have to be some strings attached. The Big Three can’t just do what they want. So that means they have to create great cars that will save energy, help you save money, compete with the other guys and make the world a cleaner place to live.

That’s one of the main reasons the carmakers are in this mess in the first place: Americans voted with their feet. The need for the huge, cushy ride went the way of the Oldsmobile. People wanted smaller, fuel-efficient cars, and Detroit just didn’t respond.

Take a look around the parking lot the next time you drop the kids off at school, or next time you go to the mall. Detroit’s bread and butter, the big gas guzzler, just isn’t what people want anymore.

So if the Big Three go under, maybe foreign manufacturers like Toyota or Honda would step in and pick up some of those unused car facilities. Still, haven’t we all seen the bloodbath that mergers and bankruptcies have left before? And those who would be hardest hit live in the ten states where most of our cars come from, states that don’t need any more bad news like Michigan, Ohio, Indiana and Illinois.

And when jobs are lost, families and communities suffer. There’s a big financial and psychological impact. Think about the family breadwinner losing a job — how would he or she feel about themselves? No wonder my psychologist-brother notices a spike in business during tough times.

Folks in Michigan and other auto-intensive states already can’t sell their homes. More homes under water, more foreclosures, you get the idea. And the reported cost to our cities and states over three years? About $150 billion in lost tax dollars, unemployment compensation and health benefits.

Here’s what scares me the most: If we can’t manufacture cars in America, what can we manufacture? Where does it stop? Because we’re not as competitive as we should be, even things like soap and toothpaste are being manufactured overseas now.

Before we let the plug get pulled, let’s stop and think carefully about how each of us, our communities, and our nation will be affected if we don’t keep our carmakers in business.

28 Reader Comments (so far…) Sign In or Register to comment

John G
Take a look around the parking lot the next time you drop the kids off at school, or next time you go to the mall. Detroit’s bread and butter, the big gas guzzler, just isn’t what people want anymore.” That’s B.S. Now that gas is “cheap” again, most vehicles I see at the gas pumps are those big gas guzzlers with smiling drivers! Get over it… the big 3 should fail.
By John G on 12/17/2008 9:51 am
irish bell
I live in Michigan and I drive a jeep cherokee, for the simple reason that 6 months out of the year I need my 4wd. When I can afford a nice new hybrid 4wd, I’ ll buy one. As far as smiling at the pumps, right now-it’s more like shock!
By irish bell on 12/17/2008 11:39 am
f p
James posted that Michigan has a 9.3% unemployment rate already—if the addle-pated congress won’t give them a band-aid then that 9.3 is gonna jump to 12+ and that is not good for an already busted-ass economy. Detroit is at fault for their lack of foresight but they should be saved only with a complete firing of top management. If the auto industry during WW2 could retool to make tanks, planes, etc and do it as fast as they did, then it can be done now.
By f p on 12/17/2008 9:51 am
irish bell
If the big 3 go under, it’ll be real ugly here in Michigan. My husband has been in the car biz his whole adult life, he’s got his own views on why and how this happened and how it should be remedied. My very simple way of looking at it is this: the failing of any state’s major industry/economy is disastrous.
By irish bell on 12/17/2008 11:47 am
Irish Eyes NY
irish bell: I not only blame the ceo’s for taking their big bonuses, but I mainly blame the Unions (UAW). They are a bunch of blood thirsty culprits. These workers are over-paid and the Unions get huge amounts from the workers. After the oil problems of the 70’s we should all have been driving hybrids, but the big 3 didn’t make them. If they made them people would be driving them. AND, I’m not talking about the ones of today, too little too late.
By Irish Eyes NY on 12/18/2008 11:35 am
mary lou s
irish eyes, the paychecks of ford, general motors and chrysler blue collar workers are no higher than those of their foreign owned counterparts. it is the LEGACY COSTS—the pensions and health care of the many retirees that cost so much more. all the united states would have to do to relieve this burden is to pass universal health care. while that would still leave pensions, apparently the pension money was not misinvested.
By mary lou s on 12/18/2008 2:27 pm
Marilyn Rick
fp, I’ll bet Michigan’s unemployment rate is already past 12%. Government statistics do not include those who have been unemployed for 6 months or more. Individuals unemployed over 6 months are considered to be the hardcore unemployed, i.e., persons who don’t want to work. If I remember all my economic courses correctly, the government in good times considers the hardcore unemployed rate to be approximately 5%, maybe a little more and that amount is always eliminated from determining the available work force. There should be a statistic for those who are underemployed, too, but that would just be more bad news. Maybe we should consolidate the big 3 into the big 2.
By Marilyn Rick on 12/17/2008 6:19 pm
Dab-a- do
Right on, Frank. What the sh*t has happened to what our country has always been about?? First this WOW sight had a contributing writer encourage the wall st. bail outs now they have someone encourage the car industry bailouts. I can not understand what is going on. I live in the south and no one needs 4 wheel drive cars so that snow bs is just bs. the parking lots are full of suv’s, jeeps, etc. I am so sick of it and I just paid for my insurance preminum and my copayment for 3 medications I need for chronic condition was $150…that doesn’t count on the doctors visit copayment for writing the rx every darn month. Greedy is all I see. Sorry, on a rant today.
By Dab-a- do on 12/18/2008 1:51 pm
shirley adams
in this day and time there no reason for any one to fail, some one got to greedier how much does one person need, not 6-cars 4-homes, i think the CEO need to help there business too, not just the american people, it seem when something happen and its the blue collar workers have to bail the big company out, and they made all the profit and had all the wonderful vacation! we didn’t. here i am 64 still working, no insurance, no vacation in years, been on a plane twice in my life. worked since i was 13. where my help? what is sad there be only the rich and poor left.
By shirley adams on 12/17/2008 10:28 am
Mommy Dearest
As a society, my dears, we must either decide that there is a “moral hazard,” i.e., a risk for both profit and loss in business, or there is not. If there is not, we should nationalize businesses and call our society what it is -socialism. If there is a risk for both profit and loss, then there is a risk for loss that includes making decisions that result in business failure.
By Mommy Dearest on 12/17/2008 11:18 am
Amelie Poulain
Soooo. What is your point, mom? The only reason all these companies have gone to the government is not because the government wants to nationalize the US, its because the priveleged few that run the entire world, in private banks and organizations like the Bank of International Settlements for example, are pissed at all the corruption in the central banks and have slammed their doors. The BANKS can’t get credit, so the COMPANIES cannot get credit extended to them. Nobody trusts “nobody” today. Period. It is blatant greed and corruption of the few that has brought down the Western World. The Bernies of the world. The derivatives….false value / false collateral. I even heard that the BIS has called an audit on the FED and that Bush asked them to wait until he is out of office. Nice. That is why Paulson wants to leave. Why would he stay and hang around knowing that there is going to be a big audit????? Anyway, I am getting carried away here. Unregulated financial world is an opportunity for thieves in really really nice suits in really really nice cars. Just wanted you to define what you are trying to say. It looked like you are thinking this whole thing is a plan to start nationalizing the US. ?? Also, I wanted to point out that China has totally set an example of how capitalsim and communism (socialism) are not mutually exclusive ideals. A very frightening thought now that Russia seems to be learning this from the Chinese. Just a little lunchtime chat between us girls. :)
By Amelie Poulain on 12/17/2008 1:24 pm
Jim Henley
This post has been removed as per management request.
By Jim Henley on 12/17/2008 10:03 pm
mary lou s
when the loan money gets to the needy two, i hope they both pay their overextended auto parts suppliers so that the infrastructure it takes to manufacture cars will still be in the united states of america. in a comment stream elsewhere i learned that in germany, people order their cars six months ahead and then wait for them to be built. here, dealers take a shotgun approach to selling cars, stocking most of a manufacturer’s product and waiting for the customer to choose one. also, apparently, the big three have been gaming their dealers by not supplying as many fuel efficient cars (they are less profitable than gas guzzlers) as the customers sought. that trick has come back to bite them!
By mary lou s on 12/17/2008 12:30 pm
mary lou s
hey, thanks, tom, for landing me right after my comment when it gets made!
By mary lou s on 12/17/2008 12:31 pm
Irish Eyes NY
Oh great, now you want us to follow the German example.
By Irish Eyes NY on 12/18/2008 11:40 am