Sign in to wowOwow

Enter the email address that you used when registering at wowOwow.
The password field is case sensitive. Click here if you have forgotten your password.

Please register for wowOwow

Newsletter subscriptions
Sign up to receive wowOwow's weekly newsletter and get our best picks delivered right to your inbox. Our newsletter content is hand-picked by the wowOwow editorial team and provides the top features, news, and commentary from our site. Subscribing to our newsletter is free and safe. We will never share your email or other information with a third-party without your direct consent.
By registering, you indicate that you have read and agree
with our privacy policy and terms of service.

Liz Smith | 04/24/2008 3:33 pm

Olbermann and Matthews Take It on the Chin from Hillary!

Liz Smith

It was fun to watch Chris Matthews and Keith Olbermann preside over MSNBC’s coverage of the Pennsylvania primary the other night. One suspects these two significant cable yakkers don’t much like each other, though they behave as if affably inclined.

They seem united, however, in their distaste for Senator Clinton. To see them have to concede her victory over Barack Obama, who is MSNBC’s pin-up boy, was great television.

Matthews at least tends to give Hillary a kind of half-admiring thumbs-up for stick-to-it-ness. But he was so anxious to offer that the results “were too close to call” that he misread the clock at 7:30 PM, saying it was 8 PM. (As the results came in with Hillary leading, I received a call from a pal who joked, “Chris Matthews has lost the power of speech!” Fascinating and likable as he can be, sometimes when Chris is interviewing dignified and mature spokespersons, you can see the pain on their faces as he repeatedly interrupts them and they are too decent to shout back.)


2008_0424_ap_cmatthews.jpg
Chris Matthews © AP

Olbermann for his part looked kind of grim and tight-lipped. He behaved better than he usually does but one feels he was itching to scream, “Why won’t she go away?” (Once she does, things will turn very dull for all these mediacasters, so I don’t see why they are so anxious for that result. They’ll be sorry if they don’t have Hillary to kick around anymore.)

Senator Clinton has it slightly easier at MSNBC now that Tucker Carlson has bitten the dust. But it’s still a frat house over there and the “tingle down the leg” that Hillary generates is one of fear and frustration. (That was Chris Matthews’s famous reaction to Obama’s oratory abilities, if you’ll recall.)

Only the network’s brilliant numbers-cruncher analyst Chuck Todd keeps a cool, on-the-ball detachment.


2008_0424_ap_kolbermann.jpg
Keith Olbermann © AP

Mr. Olbermann is the somewhat (but not always) liberal doppelganger of his arch enemy, conservative pundit, Bill O’Reilly. They really should meet in person, perhaps in the ring. And Olbermann is extremely tiresome when he tries to imitate O’Reilly’s voice. There is this ideological chasm between the two, but they share a sense of towering ego, self-righteousness and seem to be twin entities. Maybe they cancel one another out. (O’Reilly won’t utter Olbermann’s name and has attacked NBC relentlessly hoping to drive Keith out. But the latter has made big mileage from directly attacking O’Reilly, who is Roger Ailes’s great star at Fox News.)

Sometimes I think the young idiots at MTV’s “The Real World,” now in its 20th terrible year, behave more maturely than some of the big guys who are positioned to give us what is laughingly called “hard news” and what is mostly egotistical analysis.

Note: Click on this text to read my nationally syndicated daily column.

122 Reader Comments (so far…) Sign In or Register to comment

Josie Sullivan
Charles- “She” is not wrecking her party. The demise of both parties began a long time ago. No one person wrecks a political party. It takes many more hats on the stand to do that. If it makes you feel good, go on and blame her. I blame Bush for wrecking the whole damn country so I guess we’re even.
By Josie Sullivan on 04/24/2008 6:03 pm
Josie Sullivan
I don’t trust either one of them. I prefer to listen to Amy Goodman on NPR. Much more reliable news without all of the petty media crap. I wish Phil Donahue would come back to TV but until he does, I say turn on the radio.
By Josie Sullivan on 04/24/2008 5:54 pm
No GOP
Josie, Amy Goodman, Phil Donahue two of the best.
By No GOP on 04/24/2008 11:37 pm
Brooklyn Gal
I’m with Candice!
By Brooklyn Gal on 04/24/2008 6:31 pm
Buh- Bye
boys club stuff, plain and simple. the media hatred of hillary is the fear of strong, competent women, period. i’d love it if she actually took the white house and fixed up this mess the way the clintons did the last time. what could those sad weak men say then? maybe they are terrified at the prospect of the words “first gentleman” being uttered for the first time in history. i’ve always thought the mark of a strong man, was one who revered strong women
By Buh- Bye on 04/24/2008 6:35 pm
The Ole Crone The Ole Crone
Nothing can be done within this two party system, —it’s a conglomerate, both owned by the same interests, and the interests ain’t you and me. Within this system of the political parties, districting, primary scam Hillary, or Bill, and certainly not Obama can do anything about it. To enough of a degree to not make too much trouble, —they are bought and paid for whether they like it or not. Sad. Couple of pretty good folk.
By The Ole Crone The Ole Crone on 04/24/2008 7:42 pm
The Ole Crone The Ole Crone
Kay Sara, Hold heart. He couldn’t objectify women if they were not ‘subject!’
By The Ole Crone The Ole Crone on 04/24/2008 7:57 pm
The Ole Crone The Ole Crone
Ginny, yesss. Are you a border state where you can get Canada’s CBC news? If you can it is excellent for U.S. real news and more in debth and World news. On an hr. at noon, 6 p.m. and 10 p.m. (if no hockey games, —those Canucks and their hockey! Ahhh hell it’s better than Britany and gossip politics!)
By The Ole Crone The Ole Crone on 04/24/2008 9:25 pm
Sandra Robinson
We cannot get CBC here in Pittsburgh, but we do get the BBC news which is excellent and certainly more objective and one hour long.
By Sandra Robinson on 04/26/2008 8:41 am
sl lambert
yes, Liz Smith, right again. i really do not want a chip on my shoulder and avoid defensiveness, but it is very clear, at least to me, that most ‘pundits’ dislike HC…too strong a woman??? probably . it is shameful, in the year 2008 that this behaviour is tolerated/even encouraged. I personally only admire Bob Schieffer among the current crop. And Candy Crowley,, but she is a woman and a real reporter, not just some attention-seeking egotist self-important blow hard jerk. Bill O’Reilly. and on and on and on. god, i miss journalists…..I really thought Wolf was going to faint over his exposure to Pope. what ever happened to r e p o r t i n g???????
By sl lambert on 04/24/2008 11:21 pm
ariadne a
there is something very wrong at this site, it takes forever to refresh, it won’t take my comments, i then get a page that says to try again and again and again. and THEN it takes them all! i never ran into this problem before. am i the only one experiencing this?
By ariadne a on 04/25/2008 12:12 am
Deni G
LOl! adriadne! you are not the only one experiencing this. However I mus say I enjoyed the ariadne page. I don’t know what you said, but perhaps someone somewhere in the great beyond decided you deserved a page all your own!
By Deni G on 04/25/2008 12:23 am
ariadne a
embarrassing actually. i almost died when i saw what had happened. maybe you are right the universe wanted to make sure i got my point across.:) now that is the epitome of rationalization. caio
By ariadne a on 04/25/2008 12:38 am
Deni G
I know I know, but really it has been happening to everybody. And I was kinda depressed tonight until I saw the “ariadne page” of the marathon post attempt and the longer it went on, the harder I laughed. I knew what was happening to you, and I knew you were gonna be upset as hell when you saw it. But maybe it was just for me, to lift me out of the blues! So I gotta say, Thank You! LOL! And I totally understand your reaction to what Hillary said. And I honestly don’t understand why she said it. I respect her. And I respect the people that support her. But Obama is now my choice.
By Deni G on 04/25/2008 12:47 am
Josie Sullivan
LOL- I thought you did that to be rude. Sorry!
By Josie Sullivan on 04/25/2008 9:41 am