Sign in to wowOwow

Enter the email address that you used when registering at wowOwow.
The password field is case sensitive. Click here if you have forgotten your password.

Please register for wowOwow

Newsletter subscriptions
Sign up to receive wowOwow's weekly newsletter and get our best picks delivered right to your inbox. Our newsletter content is hand-picked by the wowOwow editorial team and provides the top features, news, and commentary from our site. Subscribing to our newsletter is free and safe. We will never share your email or other information with a third-party without your direct consent.
By registering, you indicate that you have read and agree
with our privacy policy and terms of service.

A Friend Stopped By | 06/25/2008 2:30 pm

Summer Shoes: Good Looking, Bad For Your Feet, by Shirley Lord

By Shirley Lord
Miu Miu
Halley Parry

Editor’s Note: Shirley Lord has been at the front seat of the beauty business for years. Born in London, she was working in Fleet Street at the age of 18 and became woman’s editor of three leading London evening newspapers. In the early 70s she moved to the United States to become beauty editor of Harper’s Bazaar, moving in 1980 to American Vogue to become beauty and health director and where she has had a long and distinguished career. She is the author of five novels, and has also written two "Bibles" on health and beauty, and an autobiography.

On Memorial Day, of all days, just as I was about to slip off my slingbacks, going "barefoot in the park" was given a thorough drubbing in The New York Times, with ominous warnings of lurking parasites in the grass and dangerous bacteria everywhere to infect naked soles and toes. It was a catch-22 start to summer for many foot docs, who look to the sunny barefoot season as a reprieve for feet otherwise shod in fashionable shoes that grow unsteadily taller and taller, and less and less substantial with — surprise, surprise — women increasingly crazy to wear them. (There is still a l-o-n-g waiting list for the latest Louis Vuitton five-inch-heeled disco sandal.)

Click here to see some of this summer’s sexiest — and scariest — shoes.

As far as the majority of experts are concerned, "crazy" is the operative word. Dr. Richard Kushner, a leading New York podiatrist, puts it bluntly. "Twenty-five percent of the bones in the body are in the feet. When you wear these bone breakers, you are essentially walking only on the ends of the metatarsals. Not even a ballerina would do that for long. The amount of time you spend ‘toe walking’ is all important. Too long and too often means repetitive trauma, which will cause permanent osteoarthritic changes. And there’s no age limit. Permanent damage can happen at any age. It all depends on the duration of the assault.

When you wear these bone breakers, you are essentially walking only on the ends of the metatarsals. Not even a ballerina would do that for long.

"If you must wear very high heels, plan to stand for only 30 to 40 minutes maximum, then you may be able to avoid trouble."

Today, however, to the concern of the American Podiatric Medical Association, more and more ardent fashionistas are making the problem worse by turning to elective foot surgery. Not only do they seek to remove bunions, but to shorten, straighten and even realign toes that inconveniently get in the way of being seriously stylish around the clock without pain, not to mention the risk of a twisted ankle or two.

A New York Times medical article exposed some podiatrists, who advocate these elective procedures (and have press agents to prove it). "Critics do not understand that when doctors tell their patients not to wear high heels, patients do so anyway," a doctor was quoted as saying. "’People say, why do toe surgery if they work just fine? Well, why do a nose job when your nose is working just fine.’ It’s the same thing. People want to look their best.’"

Dr. Rock Positano, director of the nonoperative foot and ankle service at the Hospital for Special Surgery in Manhattan had an immediate response: "’You don’t walk on your face. The foot is a complex network that must support more than 100 thousand pounds of pressure for every mile walked.’"

"Women don’t realize that by tampering with the anatomy of the feet they are changing the mechanics of how they work," says Taryn Rose, a qualified orthopedic surgeon, who a few years ago, after long dealing with patients with serious foot problems, caused by too much dedication to fashion, decided to design shoes herself that were as wearable as they were fashionable.

36 Reader Comments (so far…) Sign In or Register to comment

J B
Oh, do we really need someone to tell us those arch breakers are bad for our feet? I cannot remember the last time I wore heels. All flats, all the time…that is, when I’m wearing shoes…I prefer to be barefoot.
By J B on 06/25/2008 4:09 pm
iris odonata
Ah yes, shoewear as art. If you’d care to design your own, check out http://www.fluevog.com Let your imagination and your twinklies run free…………
By iris odonata on 06/25/2008 4:11 pm
phyllis Doyle Pepe
I am surprised these experts didn’t mention that these heel killers are terrible for your back. I have always loved going barefoot––all the time–––and in the grass and if something bites, alas!
By phyllis Doyle Pepe on 06/25/2008 5:43 pm
beverly linens
The summer of 1950 I was 13 and baby sat for a woman who had been a neighbor. My pay was a Bikini [I was still built like a boy and it would be 4 more years before I had anything to put in that Bikini top], and a pair of RED ALLIGATOR PLATFORM SLING PUMPS WITH AN OPEN TOE WITH A BOW. They would be illegal today because they were real alligator. It was about three years before I was brave enough to wear them. I walked around downtown all day in them and they almost crippled me. I never wore them again. They sat on the my shelf in my closet only to be admired for their beauty. I understood why Joann had been willing to give them to me.
By beverly linens on 06/25/2008 5:50 pm
doll lady
ahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh such “loverly” killer red shoes. I call those stilts!!! Being a shortie, I used to hate to kiss a man’s armpits, so I wore those killer tall high heels. Those, coupled with my vintage high bouffant hair, I was suddenly about 5 feet 8 inches…..the thought of the day was tall meant sexy calves. When I took those suckers off, I walked on my toes for two days just to get my arches straightened out.
By doll lady on 06/25/2008 5:54 pm
Elizabeth Bennett
I don’t think I have even tried to wear high heels since I turned forty and started having knee trouble. Those heels are responsible for an awful lot of knee surgery. Better to wear flats or one to two inch heels and keep your knees intact. Then there are the fifty percent of women over fifty who have osteoporosis. Who needs a tumble when the bones are getting brittle? Even when I could wear heels, I rarely enjoyed it—and often ditched them at the earliest possible moment. What is the point of working for equal rights and then hobbling our gait? One must always be prepared for a quick getaway.
By Elizabeth Bennett on 06/25/2008 5:54 pm
beverly linens
Lily, see above. That is exactly what I needed at the end of that day. Bev.
By beverly linens on 06/25/2008 8:27 pm
Charles Dance
You’ve lost my lengthly response?
By Charles Dance on 06/25/2008 8:04 pm
Peg O my heart
I used to bemoan the fact that there were just no cute shoes in my size. Now I am glad - there is no way I could wear those high heels even if they were available in size “boat” - I’ve come to see this as a good thing.
By Peg O my heart on 06/25/2008 8:19 pm
Donna H
I love shoes!!!! Because I have wide feet like some of you, I have trouble finding shoes, too. This is my favorite source: http://www.masseys.com/home.jsp? I also Like the “Cloudwalkers” sold at The Avenue, a plus-sized women’s clothing store chain. They have extra padding o something & are comfy, even the heels. There’s usually a better selection online than at the stores. At home, I’m usually barefoot in warm weather & in slippers in cold. High heels aren’t for me. I am a clumsy person. I’ve broken both ankles, & was barefoot one time, in flat heels the other. If I wore heels regularly, I’d’ve been confined to a wheelchair years ago. After breaking the second ankle, & having it surgically rebuilt (which speaks volumes about my gracefulness), I put my CFM heels & shoe skates in the tzedakah pile. have to wear steel-toed shoes at work, most of the rest of the time I wear walking shoes or Crocs (the clogs, not the prettier slides & Mary Janes…they’re too narrow). However, people in my neighborhood are used to seeing me bop around barefoot, then slipping on flip-lops or Crocs just before I go into a store or cafe.
By Donna H on 06/25/2008 8:46 pm
Maurine H
These shoes seem a little like Christie Brinkley’s ex-husband - great to look at, but when you incorporate them into your life they’ll betray you and cause you so much suffering you’ll pitch ‘em out.
By Maurine H on 06/25/2008 10:17 pm
Elizabeth Bennett
Ha! Good one, Maurine!
By Elizabeth Bennett on 06/26/2008 2:09 pm
rocky rocky
The red-and-gold is a Christmas tree ornament, not a shoe. The cork platforms look like ones I wore in the 70s — with a miniskirt, no less — and still keep as mementos and for my granddaughter to clomp around in for fun. Funny, I recall they were comfortable; the cork cushioned my feet when I walked, absorbing the shock. Gosh, I loved those shoes. Long ago, when I yearned for a smoky glance or two, I would put on black leather stilettos with a conservative business suit. Always worked. So I couldn’t do it often.
By rocky rocky on 06/25/2008 10:18 pm
Get Sporty
I wore heels when worked, but something classic not flashy. And often those shoes produce a painful looking gait. Having just spent four months recovering from a shattered foot and able to take long walks again, will never do anything to undermine my feet. Am not going to wear any of the dreadful orthopedic looking shoes you see around, there’s a happy medium. My favorites, ballet flats aren’t good to walk distances in either. No support.
By Get Sporty on 06/26/2008 4:36 am
Charles Dance
You should do more on this shoe subject.Since this is a blog for older women, you might be able to do a great service to women approaching older age. But yur article was great,but somehow buried..had a hard time finding it. Care of the feet is SO important. Take a hard look every day,the way you would look at your face. AND when they hurt,pay attention.For the least little problem for one of those little bones you will spend months in some medical contraption called a “boot”. No fun.
By Charles Dance on 06/26/2008 7:53 am