Sign in to wowOwow

Enter the email address that you used when registering at wowOwow.
The password field is case sensitive. Click here if you have forgotten your password.

Please register for wowOwow

Newsletter subscriptions
Sign up to receive wowOwow's weekly newsletter and get our best picks delivered right to your inbox. Our newsletter content is hand-picked by the wowOwow editorial team and provides the top features, news, and commentary from our site. Subscribing to our newsletter is free and safe. We will never share your email or other information with a third-party without your direct consent.
By registering, you indicate that you have read and agree
with our privacy policy and terms of service.

Peggy Noonan | 03/07/2008 3:45 pm

The Post Peggy Noonan Finished Exactly Four Minutes Before Samantha Power Resigned

Samantha Power, former advisor to Barack Obama.
AP


The Hillary Clinton camp is demanding that the Obama foreign policy aide, Samantha Power, be fired. Power, of course, gave an intemperate interview to the newspaper, The Scotsman, calling Mrs. Clinton "a monster,” and saying there are, essentially, no depths she will not stoop to.

It looks to me at the moment that this story won’t go away. The Clinton campaign will pump the well until it’s dry, while quietly pouring water in on the side to keep it moist.

And none of this is terrible. It’s politics.

But Samantha Power should not be fired, or forced to resign, or thrown over the side.

She made a mistake. She lost, for a moment, her manners. She apparently knew what she’d done immediately because she told the reporter that what she’d just said was off the record. But for whatever reason or reasons, good or bad, the reporter printed it anyway. When it was printed, a mini-storm erupted. Power apologized. "I should not have made these comments, and I deeply regret them," she said. She damned her quotes as "negative" and "personal.”

And that should be enough. Every staffer in every campaign has just been reminded — again — that it’s dangerous to run off at the mouth. They can’t be reminded enough! Believe me, I know. I was once a campaign staffer.

Power is young, 37. This is her first national campaign. She is hardly unsophisticated — she is a Harvard professor, a former journalist, and a Pulitzer Prize-winning historian — but she made a bush league mistake, a gaffe. In saying this, I use the definition Michael Kinsley popularized: a gaffe, in politics, is the accidental, untimed blurting of a truth.

But, when you work in a campaign and you care about your candidate, you come to harbor dark feelings about the competition. You can call this unprofessional, but you can also call it being human.

Everyone gets a mistake. Power just made hers. She is no doubt mortified. She has embarrassed her candidate and caused him harm. I’m sure she is hitting herself on the head.

Advice for the press: Come to her aid. Your livelihood depends in part on the willingness of people in or near power to tell you what they’re really thinking. Power did just that. Far more important, a healthy democracy benefits from the regular releasing of verbal steam. Democracy benefits from candor. Voters learn from it. In this case we appeared to learn what all of us had previously guessed: the Obama and Clinton camps are full of people who really don’t like each other.

The latest question being bandied about in the Questionsphere is: Is it possible the Democrats will be able to field a strong and winning Clinton-Obama ticket, or an Obama-Clinton ticket? Is it possible both campaigns could come together? What does the Power interview suggest to you about the answer to that question?

(People have been wondering, when they think about the dream ticket, whether it matters that the Clintons are the Hatfields and the Obamas are the McCoys. Does it matter that they don’t like each other? Some people think no. I think yes. It matters a lot. -Presidents work closely with Vice Presidents. They have offices down the hall from each other. Their staffs work in the same complex and meet in the mess together. It is now modern tradition that the President and Vice President have lunch together once a week. It matters that they can operate with trust and respect. It mattered that the Clintons and the Gores really liked each other in 1992, and it mattered — it was news — that the Gores, in the late 1990’s, began to feel a detachment, a disappointment in the Clintons. George W. Bush and Dick Cheney were close. George H.W. Bush liked Dan Quayle a lot. President and Vice Presidents want to get along. Do you want to work closely, intensely, with a partner you dislike?)

Advice to the Clinton campaign: Everyone thinks you’re ruthless, rough and tough. And in going after Power all day Thursday and Friday you showed how ruthless and tough you are. But you don’t really have to show it all the time. It is not endearing. It is not admirable, either. Do some jujitsu. Flip it, surprise your foes; show grace. Say you accept Power’s apology and don’t want to see a young woman lose her job. "There’s been enough job loss in America already." Shock ‘em and show some class.

To the Obama campaign: If Mrs. Clinton’s surrogates and aides succeed in keeping the focus on Power, and it becomes a daily distraction, you may have to ask her to step down. But do it only for the duration of the primary campaign. If you get the nomination, bring her back after her few months in Purgatory. Give her another chance.

Update: I just got the news that Power has resigned. Too bad. Clever on the part of the Obama campaign — they just stopped the next few days of Power debates. And, in the end, a loss to the Clinton campaign. You’re so rough and tough. Thanks. Got the message.

Advice to the JFK School at Harvard: Throw Power a lunch, gather ‘round your professor, invite all the students and debrief her. A two hour Q & A. "What I Learned in the ‘08 Campaign." She’ll have a lot to say. And now she can say it without losing her job.

24 Reader Comments (so far…) Sign In or Register to comment

Denise Rossman
Thank you to Peggy for giving strong and visible support to Samantha. Hillary could have done herself a lot of good by not being so raw and ugly about this unfortunate mistake. Shame on the press, shame on Hillary. “You hurt the world as much when you take offense as when you give offense” certainly applies here. denise rossman
By Denise Rossman on 03/09/2008 1:56 pm
Ann  Robinson
To bad Ms. Power resigned. In the scheme of things I think she only showed bad manners. Calling Mrs. Clinton a monster is nothing compared to general meaness in the campaign. She fessed up to her error. The ugliness that comes from is so much worse. I guess on one hand Mr. Obama wants to run a classy if possible but to ask her to resign over this is just silly. The Clinton people making such a fuss over this makes me think they are just the same old businees in a skirt.
By Ann Robinson on 03/09/2008 3:05 pm
jane adams
Even if Obama beat her to the ounch by firing Power, Hilary could still show the gracious, and, dare I say ‘womanly’ side of her that is known to all her close friends by taking Peggy Noonan’s advice ex post facto and issue such a statement. The people who hate her and have demonized her would say that’s pandering, but others might appreciate it. The demonization of the Other the Democrats are engaging in may be what seizes defeat from the jaws of victory in November…we’ve learned from Republicans from Lee Atwater to Karl Grove how to swiftboat candidates, even our own.
By jane adams on 03/09/2008 3:08 pm
Kamalesh Thakker
Here’s a discussion about “The Scotsman” reporter that interviewed Samanta Power and her stated reason for printing what was said… http://www.salon.com/opinion/greenwald/2008/03/08/carlson/index.html Shameful castigation of “The Scotsman” reporter Geri Peev here: http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/21134540/vp/23526624#23526624
By Kamalesh Thakker on 03/09/2008 7:54 pm
Louise Woo
Advice to the press: Come to her aid.” Peggy, you are kidding, right? Powers gave us “the quote of the day.” If she had said this in a news conference with a room full of reporters, you can bet the headlines in all the print venues would be “Hillary Is A Monster.” A political campaign is not unlike a sports competition. If the coach for one Superbowl contender called the coach of his rival a “monster,” you can bet the press would be all over that quote too! The press doesn’t need to come to the aid of Powers. She’s not a helpless little girl. She was in a position of power. She opened her big mouth in an interview and she paid her price. Would we even be writing about this if she had been “Sam Powers?” I think not.
By Louise Woo on 03/09/2008 11:35 pm
Heather Zwicker
*Fantastic* thought piece. Let’s not forget what the really big issues here are.
By Heather Zwicker on 03/10/2008 12:33 am
Jennifer  James
It was stupid of her to say, but calling for her head was totally uncalled for; in fact it simply reiterated to so many of us how much of a “monster” Hillary really is.
By Jennifer James on 03/10/2008 1:12 am
Joanne Bamberger
And would you feel this was just a tempest in a teapot if one of Hillary’s high level supporters had made that same comment about Barack Obama?? Somehow I doubt it. http://punditmom1.blogspot.com
By Joanne Bamberger on 03/10/2008 8:34 am
mary holzer
Considering her high level position in Obama’s campaign, she showed extremely poor judgment in her remarks. It was an immature statement to say the least. She obviously still has a lot to learn if she expects to further her career.
By mary holzer on 03/10/2008 7:47 pm