Sign in to wowOwow

Enter the email address that you used when registering at wowOwow.
The password field is case sensitive. Click here if you have forgotten your password.

Please register for wowOwow

Newsletter subscriptions
Sign up to receive wowOwow's weekly newsletter and get our best picks delivered right to your inbox. Our newsletter content is hand-picked by the wowOwow editorial team and provides the top features, news, and commentary from our site. Subscribing to our newsletter is free and safe. We will never share your email or other information with a third-party without your direct consent.
By registering, you indicate that you have read and agree
with our privacy policy and terms of service.

Joan Juliet Buck | 04/03/2008 12:15 pm

To My Amazement, 'South Pacific' Is About Race

Joan Juliet Buck

A friend took me to see the last preview of “South Pacific” before it opens tonight at Lincoln Center. I was excited to see this monument of the American Musical theater for the first time. To my amazement it turned out to be about race, when I always thought it was about hygiene.

In Paris as a child, all I knew about the show was that American friends of my parents’ would get tipsy and sing: “I’m gonna wash that man right out of my hair!” It was clear that we Americans washed our hair more often than French people; I assumed it was because we were cheery and innocent, like the slightly doughy looking Mary Martin on the cover of Original Cast Recording that my parents lugged around Europe as a touchstone of their home country.

To me, the shock last night was the story: I had never seen the film. The set of the Lincoln Center production, backed with a giant map of the islands of the South Pacific, suggests the vast tragedies of war. I was surprised that the show begins with two children singing, in French, the same song my grandmother used to sing to me: “Dites Moi, pourquoi, la vie est belle (Tell me why life is beautiful).” So, that’s where she got it!

I was more surprised to see that despite soldiers and sailors and marines and large engineered things and flashing lights and references to jeeps, “South Pacific” is about the love between a young woman from Little Rock and a French island dweller. And what comes between Nellie Forbush and Emile De Becque is not war, but Nellie’s horror at the revelation that Emile’s children are half Polynesian, because he was married to a woman … of color!

The presentation of race as an impediment to love is underscored by the subplot, wherein Lieutenant Joseph Cable, a Princeton graduate (read: an aristocrat ), falls in love with Liat, the daughter of the Tonkinese skull peddler Bloody Mary. In the manner of subplots, Joe and Liat have a tougher time than Nellie and Emile, but there are Enchanted Evenings again and again.

The spine of the story set me thinking about the importance of class and race in so many works of musical theater. As if, in fact, musical theater relied on the tensions of race and class for its plots: In “Madame Butterfly,” the Japanese Cio Cio San bears a child to Pinkerton, but since he marries a white woman instead, all she can do is kill herself. In “La Traviata,” Violetta and Alfredo are in love, but she is a courtesan, so his father convinces her to leave Alfredo, thereby causing Violetta to die of a broken heart as well as tuberculosis. In Jerome Kern’s 1936 “Showboat,” the plot revolves around the sheriff’s declaration: “One drop of Negro blood makes you a Negro in these parts.” Even in “West Side Story,” the enemy clans are the American (white) Jets and the Puerto Rican Sharks, which has a little more edge to it than the uniformly Veronese Montagus and Capulets. And Bob Fosse’s 1972 “Cabaret,” set in Berlin in the 1930s, had the song: “If you could see her like I do .. she wouldn’t look Jewish at all.”

I can actually write about this because I am a Jew with, if the DNA test is to be believed, 4 percent African blood and 12 percent East Asian blood. If I could not claim black and Asian ancestry, the mere typing of the words Color, Negro and Jew would label me a racist. We are in a period of aggravated political correctness where the naming of any difference between peoples violates the rules. There’s an ugly assumption behind these rules: that racism is so prevalent in the human psyche that people need border fences to keep it out of sight.

But differences between people are the basis of conflict, thus drama, thus tragedy. Which brings me to wonder if that is not the reason why there is so much mechanical, blind, pointless violence in films and television today — an undifferentiated threat to which no one can take exception.

Read more about: Arts, Culture, Theatre

22 Reader Comments (so far…) Sign In or Register to comment

Jane Goodwin
Ah, South Pacific. So lush and beautiful and full of truths, both ugly and wonderful. “That woman… her color… what PIFFLE!” “I can’t help it; it was born in me!” “I do not believe it was born in you!” And then, of course, the near-tragedy because someone was a racist, and the terrible tragedy because someone was racist… and rising above it all, the song that sums up the causes of all prejudice: “You’ve Got to Be Taught.”
By Jane Goodwin on 04/03/2008 3:00 pm
Liz Smith
Joan Juliet Buck, your last sentence on ‘South Pacific’ is the smartest thing I’ve seen in print in weeks of black ink. You are just fabulous. That was so great and also makes us think how incredible that today, almost 60 years later, there are people who will be seeing the ‘South Pacific’ story for the first time.
By Liz Smith on 04/03/2008 3:01 pm
Frank Peterson
You have to be carefully taught.” Exactly what the story was about.
By Frank Peterson on 04/03/2008 3:01 pm
Mugsy Peabody
And Sound of Music was about fascism!
By Mugsy Peabody on 04/03/2008 3:40 pm
Maurine H
So well put, Joan. When I first saw ‘South Pacific’ all I could think about was the music because I was very young and very stage-struck. It took a little time to realize that it was a statement about war and prejudice and that, in its time, the musical was ground-breaking. I, too, appreciate your final paragraph, especially the final sentence even though the reality of it is sad to contemplate.
By Maurine H on 04/03/2008 4:18 pm
Buh-Bye Hillary Hillary Buh-Bye
Joan, Terrific piece. The Great American songbook and musicals are a unique form in the world that convey so much—and there was such genuis behind them: Kern, Hammerstein, Rogers and Hart, Lerner and Lowe, etc. South Pacific and the Michener book on which it was based won Pulitzer prizes. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/South_Pacific_(musical) I loved listening to musicals as a child and was fortunate to have parents who had musical traditions so we didn’t sit back and passively skim the top of things. When I was horrifed by the lyrics of “You’ve got to be carefully taught” my mother told me it meant the opposite of how I’d taken it. That children, people, nations had to be taught to hate and to do horrific things. “Dites Moi, pourquoi, la vie est belle” was my favorite among all the great numbers from South Pacific. It is so innocent and true and then the story comes out of that contrast. Maybe I was ten when I first heard it—one of those things that just take hold— and sang it all the time even when roller skating. Your reminder had me running to youtube to hear it again. And someone had set the original to pictures that depict just what we are capable of doing when we are lied to…and carefully taught that it’s ok. I always love great things for what they are but also for their origins and what they lead to…because everything is richer when we understand all the influences and connections…so thanks for your illuminating piece. http://w ww.youtube.com/watch?v=6dNg9vKsHmw
By Buh-Bye Hillary Hillary Buh-Bye on 04/03/2008 4:25 pm
Buh-Bye Hillary Hillary Buh-Bye
well, the links didn’t take…let’s try again http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/South_Pacific_(musical) http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6dNg9vKsHmw
By Buh-Bye Hillary Hillary Buh-Bye on 04/03/2008 4:28 pm
Tinka Parker
I agree with Liz: amazing conclusion to this piece. Re: violence in movies, Hollywood is having a lot of trouble designating villains these days - almost any segment of people are (thank God) politically incorrect as baddies. They’re getting a free pass for now with Muslim terrorists but eventually the Muslim community will mount a loud protest, as they should. It may explain why they’re doing so many comic books. There the villains are safely imaginary and the favored color is green! And about your African ancestry: apparently we ALL have this in common!
By Tinka Parker on 04/03/2008 6:02 pm
Pamela Munro
There was something courageous about that era in which artists and their audiences were trying to tell the truth and create a new and better post-war world. I got to taste some of that when I was growing up in NYC, and I have to say, I miss that sincerity and the desire to bring it into ART.
By Pamela Munro on 04/03/2008 6:06 pm
Jozie Lee
In my tweens our church choir director coached a few of the girls in songs from South Pacific. The girls were preparing for a school recital. The movie had just come out. The songs were hugely popular. Over the years I missed the play and film, until I was in my 30s. Boy, oh, boy what a shock to discover it was racist against Polynesians, which is part of my racial background. When I see that boat surface, I give it wide berth.
By Jozie Lee on 04/03/2008 6:46 pm
riley riley
the show that i saw highlighted the stupidity of racism against any group - the narrow mindedness of that thought process - the polynesians were portrayed as the one group that eschewed rasism. i don’t think you should have been offended - but, perhaps that is the part of the problem - everyone is so very willing to find fault and be offended, where no offense was intended.
By riley riley on 04/03/2008 8:08 pm
kat
How things have not changed.
By kat on 04/03/2008 7:33 pm
Alice Alice
Of course, South Pacific is racist. I am half Asian, and the message I got from South Pacific, when I viewed it many, many years ago, was that I could not really be accepted. Certainly not equal to full-blooded white people. I don’t know “hr” how you can say people who have been offended by the movie are just too easily offended. I guess you didn’t grow up in my world. Now I would probably laugh or get mad, but when much younger, I definitely got the message of being unacceptable.
By Alice Alice on 04/04/2008 1:06 am
Helene Rodgville
I just returned from a trans-atlantic cruise on a ship whose crew is split between Indonesians and Philipino men and women. The Indonesians make fun of the Philipinos because they believe are of a lower class. The Philipinos complain that the Indonesians leave their shoes and socks outside their doors at night and they always smell. The Philipino man told us that the Philipine people are extremely clean and still wash their clothes with rocks to get them as clean as possible. It was an interesting dynamic considering they were “taking care” of so many others that could be seen as “Ugly Americans”. We enjoyed talking to all of the staff on the ship. Their stories were to be admired, not pitied. They work so hard to take care of their families back home. Prejudice can be anywhere and I totally agree “You have to be taught”.
By Helene Rodgville on 04/04/2008 4:22 am