Sign in to wowOwow

Enter the email address that you used when registering at wowOwow.
The password field is case sensitive. Click here if you have forgotten your password.

Please register for wowOwow

Newsletter subscriptions
Sign up to receive wowOwow's weekly newsletter and get our best picks delivered right to your inbox. Our newsletter content is hand-picked by the wowOwow editorial team and provides the top features, news, and commentary from our site. Subscribing to our newsletter is free and safe. We will never share your email or other information with a third-party without your direct consent.
By registering, you indicate that you have read and agree
with our privacy policy and terms of service.

Q & A | 02/03/2009 6:00 am

What's Wrong With Bernie Madoff? by Dr. Stanton Samenow

By The Staff at wowOwow.com
Bernie Madoff © AP

The news on the financial crimes of Bernard Madoff gets worse and worse. wOw reached out to the distinguished criminal psychologist, Stanton E. Samenow, author of Inside the Criminal Mind, to see if he could enlighten us on the question he himself posed on his website: "How can a man who is known for his decency and wisdom be so indecent?"

wowOwow: So, what would you label such a man as Bernie Madoff? Is he a Sociopath? Psychopath? Mentally ill? Was he in denial and did he somehow believe his scheme would work forever?

DR. SAMENOW: I have not found these individuals — and I have been evaluating psychologically individuals such as these for more than 30 years — to be mentally ill. Nor are they in denial. It’s very complex. There is a contradiction here in the minds of those who commit these financial crimes. They appear to be like anyone else — kinder, more charming — there is no badge announcing their intentions. They regard themselves as good people at heart. But they can be very insidious in the way they insinuate themselves into people’s lives.

wOw: So they de-compartmentalize?

Dr S: Well, they can do very kind things for people. No matter what harm they inflict, no matter what charitable organization they are cheating, they do not see themselves as bad people. Quite the opposite. They are narcissists … They are able to shut off whatever elements of conscience they have. It would be inaccurate to say they don’t have pangs of conscience, not unlike the Mafia, who engage in religious generosity even as they blow heads off their adversaries.

wOw: But this man betrayed his closest friends, his very family. He preyed upon the people who were closest to him as well as those he didn’t know.

Dr. S: Of course I never met him, never interviewed him, but I’ve evaluated psychologically individuals who are family men, officers of companies and pillars of the community, who have criminal minds. They can inflict devastating injury on those whom they say they love and who love them. These men have tattered, threadbare consciences. There are elements of conscience they can shut off. They are able to do these things by professing the noblest ideals. I’ll make you a bet that Mr. Madoff and others like him all say they’re good people; they by no means regard themselves as evil. I’ve interviewed serial killers who, despite leaving dead bodies in their own view, say they are good people.

wOw: But what about his wife? His closest family? Surely they must have known or sensed something. Were they enablers?

Dr. S: They appear to be enablers, but they are also victims. They are among the chief victims. There may be isolated cases where there is some collusion. They want to believe the best of their husbands. If you have a video tape and you could watch such a person in his daily life, I suspect you would see that he didn’t treat his family and others all that well. It’s my experience that the crimes he has been arrested for represent only the tip of the iceberg.

wOw: You mean he abused his family in some way?

Dr. S: I don’t know the facts here, but often the wives and other members of the family are so ground down, they yield. They make excuses and desperately want to believe their husband/father is a good man. So they appear to be enablers, but actually they just don’t want to believe the worst. By not thinking about the patterns that have unfolded over time, they perpetually live in hope. They are victims.

44 Reader Comments (so far…) Sign In or Register to comment

Patty E
hahaha….able to “turn off their conscience”. Now THAT is POWER! Mind over matter! Still, IMO,they are nothing more than crooks.
By Patty E on 02/03/2009 2:35 pm
Tee Zee
I was struck by the same thought…it does account for the actions of GWB, Dick Cheney and Dandy Don Rumsfeld! It also explains the Laura Bush victim role.
By Tee Zee on 02/04/2009 2:24 pm
Sam Mirando
Lily, even though the magnitude of Madoff’s crime exceeds that of previous similar crimes, Madoff himself is likely to have personality traits similar to those of people who have perpetrated similar crimes of lesser magnitude. Since there is plenty of information about various kinds of criminal, it is reasonable to speculate which hat fits Mr. Madoff. A murderer who kills five people is likely to be psychologically similar to one who kills twenty. And a mass murderer is not likely to be much different from either but, rather, someone with more opportunities.
By Sam Mirando on 02/03/2009 11:06 am
Lily Rose
Greetings, Sam. If I understand your comment, it is based in “profiling,” which seeks to identify the common traits of people who exhibit certain behaviours. While I concur that some modest insight can be gleaned from examining “types,” my point is that any such insight is limited to the accuracy of assumptions about common behavioural patterns - a far cry from insight into the actual individual and his circumstances. Namaste.
By Lily Rose on 02/03/2009 11:14 am
Victoria Victor
LR, I think your point is well taken. As we are unlikely to ever become privy to details of Bernie Madoff’s psychiatric or psychological evaluation, we will have to content ourselves with the experience of Dr. Stanton E. Samenow. I am intrigued to learn the true details myself.
By Victoria Victor on 02/03/2009 1:26 pm
f p
Lily I think it based more of psychological case-study rather than profiling. I truly don’t think assumptions are being made given my first statement.
By f p on 02/06/2009 6:40 am
sibelle daubigne
By not thinking about the patterns that have unfolded over time, they perpetually live in hope. They are victims”. Great lines! Sounds familiar! lol
By sibelle daubigne on 02/03/2009 2:12 pm
Sam Mirando
Lily, I think the person who got it right, as I noted this a.m., is Bonnie Oliver, who wrote: [Madoff needed to be] the controller of their lives without his victims even realizing what stood between them and financial calamity was him. Rapists also get off on the control aspect of their crimes, as do other molesters. Murder is the ultimate control, of course.
By Sam Mirando on 02/03/2009 4:00 pm
E .
Dr. Samenow - certainly B. Madoff is not insane but mentally ill to some degree. I’d say that he is likely “suffering” of narcissistic personality disorder - but naturally he’d be insulted by the serious use of the word disorder.
By E . on 02/03/2009 11:42 pm
Jeannot Kensinger
I don’t think we have to come up with excuses and mental disorders for this man. Like Frank said :A crook is a crook. I knew a man like him, all charms and full of devious lies. My mother did not fall for his stories, she had known him for 20 years in this business. She knew more about human frailties. She played it safe with her money. The man fled with millions and as far as I know is still living in Brazil. I on the other side of this coin would have invested with him but I did n’t have the money. Sometimes it is good to be poor.
By Jeannot Kensinger on 02/04/2009 10:43 am
Lena B
I loved this article-thank you wowowow and Dr. Samenow. Getting an examination of the criminal mind is crucial to understanding others. You never expect to be in the presence of a manipulator, but if you study people you will gain great interpersonal communication advantages. The danger is in using those excellent skills for evil instead of good.
By Lena B on 02/04/2009 1:43 pm
Angel Henderson
THIS IS THE MOST BLATANT EXAMPLE OF SUPERIORITY THINKING TODAY. IF THAT HAD BEEN ANYBODY ELSE, THEY’D BE IN JAIL AND WOULDN’T GET OUTTO LIVE IN THE LUXURY PROVIDED BY THEIR CRIME. THE POLICE WOULD BE IN THERE CLAIMING EVERYTHING WORTH A DIME TO PAY FOR COMPUTERS, MORE COPS, ETC THEY WOULD HAVE MADE THEM HOMELESS. IF HE WERE A BLACK, LIKE IN D.C. HIS INTIRE FAMILY WOULD BE PUT INTO PRISON FOR YEARS, MOTHER, SISTERS, BROTHERS, COUSINS, ETC. HOWEVER, IT SIMPLY SHOWS THAT IN THIS COUNTRY IF YOU HAVE MONEY, THE LAWS ARE DIFFERENT FOR YOU….THAT’S WHY THE SENATE WANTS TO MAKE SURE THAT 98% OF THE POPULATION STAYS, STRUGGLING FROM WEEK TO WEEK, WHILE THEY SUCK THE LIFE AND RESOURCES OUT OF EVERY SOURCE THEY HAVE CONTACT WITH AND OR KNOWLEDGE OF. IF YOU ARE POOR, YOU GET IGNORANCE OF THE LAW IS NO EXCUSE AND YOU GO TO PRISON AND YOU HAVE TO PAY FOR THE ATTORNEY PROVIDED FOR YOU….LEGAL AIDE, COST,(THEY PAID JEFFERY DAUMERS ATTORNEY $10,000.00, AND HE ATE 15 PEOPLE(MINORITIES)) IF YOU HAVE NO MONEY, THEY TAKE YOUR DRIVER’S LICENSE —-SO YOU CAN’T GET TO WORK TO PAY THIS LAWYER. GOD BLESS AMERICA, GOD FORGIVE AMERICA, GOD KNOWS, GOD PROVIDES, GOD WILL PUNISH, THE LEAST YOU DO TO THE LEAST OF THESE IS AS DONE UNTO ME…..WE WILL PAY FOR MISTREATING GOD’S PEOPLE ,GOD’S CHILDRENTHE POOR. WE WILL GET TO HEAVEN AND WE ARE SUPPOSE TO HAVE A TASTE OF IT NOW, HERE, THAT IS OUR DUTY AS DISCIPLES OF CHRIST. TO LOVE ONE ANOTHER, AND DO OTHERS NO HARM. IF YOU REMAIN SILENT, YOU CONDONE, JOIN IN, ACCEPT, ASSIST AND WILL BE HELD ACCOUNTABLE FOR THESE CRIMES AGAINST HUMANITY. PEACE AND LOVE.
By Angel Henderson on 02/07/2009 6:30 am
Don Larsen
By golly that’s an interesting piece.
By Don Larsen on 02/08/2009 4:30 pm
Looks Beyond
Well, for GoodNests sake. Many NestEggs are gone. What’s in a name. Bernie Madoff He ‘burned’ many people out of their savings He ‘made-off’ with their money Notice people’s name, there is usually a storyline there. Hook noses are all about ‘what’s in it for them’ also always into other people’s business…nosey people. Maybe we need to notice facial structure and names before dealing with them
By Looks Beyond on 02/08/2009 7:11 pm