Sign in to wowOwow

Enter the email address that you used when registering at wowOwow.
The password field is case sensitive. Click here if you have forgotten your password.

Please register for wowOwow

Newsletter subscriptions
Sign up to receive wowOwow's weekly newsletter and get our best picks delivered right to your inbox. Our newsletter content is hand-picked by the wowOwow editorial team and provides the top features, news, and commentary from our site. Subscribing to our newsletter is free and safe. We will never share your email or other information with a third-party without your direct consent.
By registering, you indicate that you have read and agree
with our privacy policy and terms of service.

The Greatest Depression | 01/05/2009 7:40 am

When Jane Bryant Quinn Says 'Go Bankrupt' You Know We're in Trouble

America’s good girl of financial journalism goes subversive in this week’s Newsweek
By Deborah Barrow, Editor-in-Chief
Credit: Newsweek

Admitting that she’s risking her "good girl reputation," Jane Bryant Quinn, one of the country’s most-trusted conservative voices in consumer financial journalism, is telling debtors in deep dollar distress to throw in the towel in 2009 and declare bankruptcy. This extraordinary advice comes in the latest issue of Newsweek. Quinn’s regularly featured column this week is titled "The Case for Walking Away" and is further evidence of the near-Depression-era straits many Americans are facing at the dawn of the new year.

Quinn has long been the last word in mainstream money talk. She’s been a contributor to Newsweek since 1978, writes a regular column for Good Housekeeping magazine and is the author of bestselling books such as her Smart and Simple Financial Strategies for Busy People.

Among the extraordinary advice she shares: 

It’s a mistake to tap your retirement accounts to make minimum payments on monstrous bills. IRAs and 401(k)s are largely protected in bankruptcy, as is most of your child’s 529 college-savings account. This money is your future. Leave it alone and use credit cards for your necessities. Card issuers know that some of their customers will fail. That’s why they charge elephant fees.

Don’t try to preserve your house if you’re going broke. Stop making payments, stay there while foreclosure is underway, then move out and rent.

Good on you, Jane.

For more subversive tips and advice from America’s Good Girl of Financial Journalism, the whole story can be found here.

In a further sign of the times, this morning Quinn’s column was No. 1 in Newsweek’s "Most Read" box.

44 Reader Comments (so far…) Sign In or Register to comment

shirley adams
Bankruptcy, is easy, but when you go to rent, or get car insurance, that another story. they check you TRW first of all and most rental will not rent to a bankruptcy person. Then the insurance co, some might give you car insurance, might but charge double what they normally charge. i know iv been down this road. not pretty. Talking about a 500 pound gorilla in the room!
By shirley adams on 01/05/2009 7:40 am
Susan B
Shirley, that was the first thing that popped into my mind when I read her advice. She’s fundamentally saying that the slate gets wiped clean with bankruptcy! The slate never is wiped clean and a person’s financial history — including bankruptcy — follows her for all the days of her life. That’s just what this country DOESN’T need, more people throwing in the towel.
By Susan B on 01/09/2009 11:30 am
Chrome Toe
I hear what she’s saying… that sometimes you’re just buried so deep there isn’t any point in digging slowly. you might as well get a bulldozer. bankruptcy isn’t a “good” think in any scenario. But i can see how for some people it’s the only way to get out from under.
By Chrome Toe on 01/05/2009 7:58 am
K J
It’s simply dumb to deny reality whenever you have too much debt to handle. Eric Tyson’s Personal Finance for Dummies (www.erictyson.com) helped me to see that years ago and I filed for bankruptcy and it was one of the best things I ever did. Quinn’s advice is good but I would hope she gives this same advice to folks in trouble during “better times”
By K J on 01/05/2009 8:47 am
deber B
This will be the year of record bankruptcy filings…by those who have lost their jobs and those who, quite frankly, just want to get out from under the bad choices they have made for themselves.
By deber B on 01/05/2009 9:27 am
Patty E
oh gheez Diane—-I guess I should not have ASKED to not be employed! Are you for real? Oh gosh—look—Ms. Piggy! a PUPPET!
By Patty E on 01/05/2009 4:36 pm
deber B
Did I hit a nerve or something? I made a simple prediction that this was going to the the year of bankruptcies. People who have lost their jobs will no doubt have to do something to get from under their debt. However, there will also be “those” people who take advantage of situations, perhaps they still have their jobs, when they simply want to walk away from stupid decisions such as living way beyond your means so that you can have all of those toys you feel you are entitled to have. The key is: Live within your means. Prepare for times like this. Why is it that some people who lose their jobs have four months of mortgage payments sitting in their money market account just for situations like this? I think you know the answer. We are all a product of the choices we make for ourselves. I happen to like Miss Piggy don’t you?
By deber B on 01/06/2009 4:52 am
Patty E
Yes, in a way you did, as I read your comment as an indictment, and even an ASSUMPTION, that of all those who are in the position they are in, created their own financial mess. Under ‘normal’ circumstances, I would agree with you. I am one of those who acknowledges and preaches that we, as individuals, have the power to create our own life….and that whether we know it or not, we are making our own choices, and living our own consequences….. But these are not normal times….this country, and this world…is experiencing a real crisis. There are a lot of people who made correct and ‘right’ choices, who planned ahead, and who lived within their means, who have no jobs anymore, whose bank accounts that were created for those rainy days are empty—because it has been raining for close to a year now. WHY? Not because they made bad choices, not because they were stupid and didn’t prepare, but because a lot of what we are experiencing was thrown onto them, in the back rooms of corporate greed and this administrations need for government power grabbing at the expense of those who had very little power to begin with… What about those women I have read about, who are living in their cars in California? they had jobs——good jobs. When they got their divorces, the husband had the greater job, and the credit rating…some of the women were booted out of their homes after divorce, and then booted out of their apartments—not becasue of failure to pay, but because the landlords were foreclosed on! these women—-boomers—live in their cars, and California now even has ‘car parks’ for them to go to at night, where it is safe for them to sleep——most of these women still have jobs—-but cannot afford to come up with a deposit for an apartment….WHO decides how much deposit and how much rent will be charged —or that once a person has no home, they are no longer ‘worthy’ of renting to, ever. There are ‘victims’ that are truly victims of the choices made for them—not ones they made for themselves. Young people have an advantage—-employers want them….young people often do not yet have a family, and because I am in a college town with a college, a University, and a well-respected Community College—-all three—-when I shop for food or anything else, it is the young people who are standing at the cashe registers, and who wait on me—they are the first to secure employment…their wages could not support a family, they don;t need medical insurance, they are willing to live 4 and 5 people in a house or apartment and split the rent, they have not yet accrued real furniture, or any thing they can’t give away. But the boomers, such as myself, and the women in California, find themselves in a real predicament. Not old enough for social security, too old for the jobs that are available that can support them, and even those with degrees up the yin-yang, such as myself, are passed over for employment because we ‘cost too much’ in this economy….. I have a friend who owns a furniture store in san diego….his ‘credit’ was discontinued several months back when Paulsen was asking for the bail-out….Who decided that he could no longer recieve his furniture except for COD? When in business for over 20 years, he had been able to pay 10-30 days after receiving it? Not he!
By Patty E on 01/06/2009 11:38 am
deber B
I’m very sorry you are in the predicament you are in. I really am. For me, personally, I’ve always lived my life expecting a “disaster.” Always taught…”be prepared for the worst possible outcome.” And so I did. I hope you find a job soon and life gets back to normal for you. Best of luck to you and those you know who are suffering in this horrible economy.
By deber B on 01/06/2009 12:18 pm
Ann B
That’s a hard way to “live” your life.
By Ann B on 01/06/2009 1:00 pm
deber B
I understand you are trying to be sarcastic but that’s okay. I understand precisely where you are coming from. It isn’t hard to be responsible. It isn’t hard to plan ahead. What would be hard for me is if I made my problems someone else’s problem because I had not planned for the unexpected.
By deber B on 01/06/2009 1:24 pm
Douglas Marston
Yes, not all of us will get trillion dollar bailouts from the Federal Government, like the banksters (rhymes with gangsters!) For those of us who are not super-rich, and cannot count on government bailouts to maintain our multi-million dollar incomes — have to live in reality. The only ones who don’t are the wealthy and well connected. Those people don’t have to live with their choices! The government only helps those who help themselves — and help themselves and help themselves to other people’s money!
By Douglas Marston on 01/07/2009 1:23 pm
Patty E
When you are unemployed, and there is no money coming in, and you are already living on your credit cards and selling whatever you own to keep those payments up—-but if you DON’T use the credit cards, you do not eat—-there is a lot to be said for bankruptcy—-especially at a time like this, when the average person has done everythign ‘right’…..this economic problem wasn;t the fault of the average person—-this problem was created by millionaires and millionaire corporations, who got greedy. And THEY get a bail-out, while the little guy like me has to sell their belongings just to pay the electric bill! I took my cat into the vet on an emergency run last week Wednesday. I did not have the money to pay for him—but I was not going to have him put to death! So I put it on the Credit card….and when he started crying, I started cyring—it was only just over a year ago, that I called the ambulance for my dad—-after paying the medical bills for both my mother, in 2002, and my dad, in 2007, I was pretty much wiped out. See, when my mother was diagnosed with Cancer, the insurance company cancelled BOTH my parents! The insurance company made a good profit—-but at the expense of my family…. Findng employment? Ha! That’s a joke….and while the tears fell down my face and the gasps in my breathing, as I told the vet—-jjust do what you have to, I will put it on the Credit Card….and when I reah my limit—-I am just going to declare Bankrupcty. To heck with it. They cannot take my house —-it is paid for! To be quite honest with you—-I am thinking that if I can sell the house—I can take the money and travel….after watching the History Channel last night on 2012——by the time the world ends, I will have had a great time!
By Patty E on 01/05/2009 11:01 am
deber B
That’s right, Patty E….sell the house and travel “Live for today” and file bankruptcy tomorrow
By deber B on 01/06/2009 4:54 am
Susan B
Deber, I get the feeling that you’ve never walked in Patty’s shoes. I know a number of people who have been extremely careful with their finances and thought themselves prepared, but yet were hit hard by “the unexpected” and are now struggling for their lives. Good health and money in the bank — it can be taken from you in an instant, no matter how well you prepare or how much you have.
By Susan B on 01/09/2009 11:43 am