Post | 04/10/2008 12:00 am

Who Is She?

© Shutterstock

Fiction

After reading the story, click here to vote: If you were Bart’s wife, what would you do in the morning?
a) Confront him
b) Poison him
c) Let it pass
d) Tell him he needs therapy
e) Have your own liaison
f) Leave him

It was 12:30 a.m.

Bart was working late. Being a lawyer in a high-pressure firm and having just become a managing partner was taking its toll. His nights were not his own. Many weekends he had to take the L.I.R.R. back to the city because his workload was so heavy. These demanding clients kept him always on call. Financially, he was doing quite well for the first time in his twenty-year career. She understood; it wasn’t that she wasn’t busy or preoccupied herself. Their kids were quite grown – twenty, twenty-two, and twenty-six – and out of the house. She loved her job as a librarian at the local Jericho library. On this particular sultry summer night, she was engrossed in a book being read by her book club. She hadn’t read Anna Karenina since college and so she was quite engaged, as if reading it for the first time.

His car pulled up in the driveway.

Bart stopped at the fridge, grabbed some iced tea, and tiptoed up to the bedroom. He said, surprised, "You’re up?"

She smiled, "I’m deeply involved with Anna. How’s it going, Bart? Tough case?"

"The clients are impossible," he answered.

"You must be tired?" she said.

"Exhausted," Bart said.

She couldn’t explain it, but somehow something was different. Bart seemed off-tempo. What was it? His hair. It was neatly combed. "Get a haircut?" she said. "It looks great."

"No. Why, do I need one?" Bart asked.

"Just wondered," she said. "And, by the way, Lila got a raise. She asked for it and they gave it."

"How much?" he asked.

"Five percent," she said. "And I’m so glad. They were taking advantage of her."

"She’s one great kid," Bart replied. "We struck a home run with this one."

They both smiled. Lila was a prize.

Bart took off his jacket and opened his pajama drawer. His tie was carefully knotted. Odd, she thought. On these hot summer nights he almost always came home without a tie. She imagined that he probably took his tie off as soon as he left his air-conditioned Manhattan office. She noted this careful knot.

Bart then took off his pants and flung them over the chair. She lifted her eyes from her book. She felt him avoiding her gaze; well, not avoiding it, but not catching her eyes – if you know what I mean. Then she saw that his jockey shorts were on backwards. The fly part faced her as he bent over to untie his shoes. Had he spent this sticky day in arrears? Her heart raced. There was no lipstick on his collar, no perfume in the air like in the movies. As a matter of fact, it was the absence of aroma that she noticed – no sweat. After twenty-eight years of marriage, late August work nights meant damp shirts. She knew this because she had put them in the laundry for all those years. She knew the circle of perspiration around the armpits, the badge of honest late work. Her cheeks flushed, her heart pounded. Had he showered before coming home? She knew he had not been working.

"Good book?" Bart said.

"Yes, yes," she said. "Read it at Mount Holyoke years, years ago. It’s all new to me. Tolstoy is so now."

"How was the book club?" he asked casually.

"Fascinating," she said. Her fingers felt numb. "Bart … " she started.

"Yes?" He was pulling the covers over his head.

"Bart … you are working so hard."

"Yes, sweetie," he said. He rolled over and kissed her. She felt the kiss’s compulsory quality, the repetitive wet peck.

"Bart," she said, taking a deep breath and pausing. “Bart, I got them to fix the den’s air conditioner and honor the warranty two days after it expired." He was sinking under the covers.

"That’s my girl," he said. His voice was getting drowsy.

She felt scared. Alone. She whispered to herself, knowing he wouldn’t hear, "Who was she?" – the tears running down her face. She whispered again more quietly, "Who was she, Bart?" But when she looked over at Bart, he was fast asleep.

She turned out the light, first looking at their wedding picture near the telephone on her side of the bed. She turned the picture face down, wiped her tears away, listened to his breathing, and wondered what she would do in the morning.

Click here for wOw poll: What would you do in the morning?

Read more about: Anna Karenina, Fiction
'wOw Friend' Liz Peek on the Dangers of Today's Dwindling DowntimeChanneling Norman Mailer

112 Reader Comments (so far…)

Paula Mac

LEAVE & get the best divorce atty.!

By Paula Mac on 04/10/2008 12:57 am
Betty in OH

Been there already. Before confronting him, watch and see if it happens again. Meanwhile rush out and get Susan Forwards book “When Your Lover is a Liar” and read it asap. Perpare yourself for what he’s going to say and understand where you fit in, so you don’t blame yourself or let him try and blame you for his lies. Lastly, get yourself to your doctor to be tested for STDs. You never know what unexpected “gifts” he may have brought home. Be prepared before you confront.

By Betty in OH on 04/10/2008 2:12 pm
Buh-Bye Hillary Hillary Buh-Bye

Paula, I’d change that slightly: Stand straight, look him in the eye, look good, maintain your dignity and cool, say little. One arched brow is probably the best response. A sigh is over dramatic. Call the attorney and the locksmith the second he leaves for work. Pack and messenger his things, if something pink and sticky happens to fall onto his best suits, accidents happen. Change your accounts. Charge something incredibly expensive to his. Go have a two daiquiri lunch with your best friend. But I’m just guessing. ;)

By Buh-Bye Hillary Hillary Buh-Bye on 04/10/2008 6:05 pm
judy keck

I would hire a detective if he was going out on me like I suspected .I would go to a lawyer have everything in order. Go to his place of employment dump his underwear on his desk and all the evidence . I would have a caked baked with the message thank you for giving me a new life instead of living a lie. I would walk out and never look back.

By judy keck on 04/10/2008 7:54 pm
Elizabeth Flynn

He’s a lawyer.
The next day I’d seek legal advice from a divorce lawyer whose legal skills are far superior to my husband’s.
The day after that I’d take steps to follow a dream I’d been putting off for far too long.
This is not to say that a divorce would be imminent but that I’d begin to take steps to protect and enhance my “end”.

By Elizabeth Flynn on 04/10/2008 1:10 am
Hedda Lettuce

Yes, since the man is an attorney it would be prudent to seek the best legal advise right away for her own peace of mind. After having done that, I would explain what I felt and observed to my husband, giving him the opportunity to explain or deny. After 28 years of marriage, this woman knows her husband. Maybe he showered in the executive men’s room before returning home. Maybe he feels detached due to the amount of work he has been undergoing. Maybe he has been having an affair. My feeling is that this lady’s intuition is strong. There is nothing worse than a breach in trust in a relationship. I think she felt it.

By Hedda Lettuce on 04/10/2008 6:39 am
Buh-Bye Hillary Hillary Buh-Bye

Elizabeth and Hedda—-You are so right. Olivia Goldsmith (author of First Wives Club) lost almost everything in her divorce because her husband was a lawyer. Then she broke the mold on ‘Living Well is The Best Revenge” sold FWC film rights to Paramount aft her manuscript rejected 273 times…then placed the book and had far more money than the ex-louse.

By Buh-Bye Hillary Hillary Buh-Bye on 04/10/2008 6:14 pm
Paul Borash

You need to: Wake up, take a few deep breaths and, if only for your own sake, tell him what you felt last night and to tell you what the heck went on last night and to please be truthful. It does not mean you will get a straight answer, but his reaction(s) and demeanor will tell you a lot. There is not enough to throw accusations at him and start calling attorneys.

By Paul Borash on 04/10/2008 1:10 am
Buh-Bye Hillary Hillary Buh-Bye

Paaul, Men do not come home with their underwear on backwards, and their hair and tie perfect when that is not the habit, etc etc. I agree, never accuse, ask questions and you’ll see the truth in his demeanor, although that was pretty obvious from the description. I know a man who went to a company Xmas party (his company) had too much to drink. Wound up sleeping with a woman. Got up in the dark, pulled on his pants, and went home at 2AM. His wife was waiting up. He had on the woman’s jeans. Careful men do not put their underwear on backwards and leave it on that way all day. Give me a break!

By Buh-Bye Hillary Hillary Buh-Bye on 04/10/2008 6:20 pm
rashida howard

she such find herself a very very good attorney and clean him out and after that have yourself a party with friend and family RASHIDAHOWARD

By rashida howard on 04/10/2008 1:43 am
rashida howard

Thank You for WOWOWOW and keep uo with the good work

By rashida howard on 04/10/2008 1:49 am
Elsie Del Monaco

I probably wouldn’t see that shirt! I don’t see shirts that go to the cleaners!If he were dumb enough to leave it out with lipstick on it, well I’d think he was trying to tell me he needs attention. E. Del

By Elsie Del Monaco on 04/10/2008 1:50 am
Dana Phant

I agree with Paul…confront and don’t accuse… if you’ve been married that long, you’ll know by his reaction if he is telling the truth. That doesn’t mean you have to stay with him… but you will feel better if you try to stay calm enough to get to the truth… then you can hit him with a heavy object, call a mean-as-a-skunk divorce attorney and your best girlfriends. :-) (And since I’m a southern girl, I’d use a cast iron skillet!)

Seriously, I’ve been here before… many years ago. He denied that anything inappropriate was going on… but in my heart I knew he was lying so I divorced him anyway. My family and friends were shocked (I didn’t tell them about my suspicions) and since my daughter was little, I kept it civil and maintained a positive relationship with him. I was better off without him - but she was better off with him still an active part of her life.

About a year after we were divorced, I found out that he did have an affair while we were married. I cried - because I knew I had made the right decision. Then I celebrated with my best girlfriends - because I knew I had made the right decision.

Today - no regrets about any of it - including the marriage. I realized a long time ago that I got all the best parts of him - in my daughter. She’s 22 now and a wonderful young lady! I’m so glad I didn’t let bitterness and hurt become a part of our lives.

By Dana Phant on 04/10/2008 2:06 am
Buh-Bye Hillary Hillary Buh-Bye

Dana, Can’t hit him with a heavy object! Grounds for arrest plus makes the whole pink suit and tears schtick in divorce court unbelievable. If he pulls a Spitzer, you don’t want to be the one on Wolf Blitzer. For examples of what not to do, I give you the “Low Road to Spitsville” re billionaire Richard Scaife’s tawdry divorce. Slapping, spying and all.
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2007/10/21/AR200710

By Buh-Bye Hillary Hillary Buh-Bye on 04/10/2008 6:28 pm
ann dillon

confront is not the word-ask him to talk the next morning -find out what was going on and why-
every sitution is different -you may have already wanted out-if not -if you love him -if there is hope -then start the long process of healing-if you don’t want to then leave -not because men are bastards-which they are not -but because the relationship needed to be addressed anyway-i too have been there -there are no simple answers -i do know that these marigages can survive and grow if that is the way you would like to go-try it -but only if you love him more than you love your anger-by the way -my marrage did not -so i’m not being a pollyanna

By ann dillon on 04/10/2008 2:46 am