Sign in to wowOwow

Enter the email address that you used when registering at wowOwow.
The password field is case sensitive. Click here if you have forgotten your password.

Please register for wowOwow

Newsletter subscriptions
Sign up to receive wowOwow's weekly newsletter and get our best picks delivered right to your inbox. Our newsletter content is hand-picked by the wowOwow editorial team and provides the top features, news, and commentary from our site. Subscribing to our newsletter is free and safe. We will never share your email or other information with a third-party without your direct consent.
By registering, you indicate that you have read and agree
with our privacy policy and terms of service.

Sheila Nevins | 04/10/2008 12:00 am

Who Is She?

© Shutterstock

Fiction

After reading the story, click here to vote: If you were Bart’s wife, what would you do in the morning?
a) Confront him
b) Poison him
c) Let it pass
d) Tell him he needs therapy
e) Have your own liaison
f) Leave him

It was 12:30 a.m.

Bart was working late. Being a lawyer in a high-pressure firm and having just become a managing partner was taking its toll. His nights were not his own. Many weekends he had to take the L.I.R.R. back to the city because his workload was so heavy. These demanding clients kept him always on call. Financially, he was doing quite well for the first time in his twenty-year career. She understood; it wasn’t that she wasn’t busy or preoccupied herself. Their kids were quite grown – twenty, twenty-two, and twenty-six – and out of the house. She loved her job as a librarian at the local Jericho library. On this particular sultry summer night, she was engrossed in a book being read by her book club. She hadn’t read Anna Karenina since college and so she was quite engaged, as if reading it for the first time.

His car pulled up in the driveway.

Bart stopped at the fridge, grabbed some iced tea, and tiptoed up to the bedroom. He said, surprised, "You’re up?"

She smiled, "I’m deeply involved with Anna. How’s it going, Bart? Tough case?"

"The clients are impossible," he answered.

"You must be tired?" she said.

"Exhausted," Bart said.

She couldn’t explain it, but somehow something was different. Bart seemed off-tempo. What was it? His hair. It was neatly combed. "Get a haircut?" she said. "It looks great."

"No. Why, do I need one?" Bart asked.

"Just wondered," she said. "And, by the way, Lila got a raise. She asked for it and they gave it."

"How much?" he asked.

"Five percent," she said. "And I’m so glad. They were taking advantage of her."

"She’s one great kid," Bart replied. "We struck a home run with this one."

They both smiled. Lila was a prize.

Bart took off his jacket and opened his pajama drawer. His tie was carefully knotted. Odd, she thought. On these hot summer nights he almost always came home without a tie. She imagined that he probably took his tie off as soon as he left his air-conditioned Manhattan office. She noted this careful knot.

Bart then took off his pants and flung them over the chair. She lifted her eyes from her book. She felt him avoiding her gaze; well, not avoiding it, but not catching her eyes – if you know what I mean. Then she saw that his jockey shorts were on backwards. The fly part faced her as he bent over to untie his shoes. Had he spent this sticky day in arrears? Her heart raced. There was no lipstick on his collar, no perfume in the air like in the movies. As a matter of fact, it was the absence of aroma that she noticed – no sweat. After twenty-eight years of marriage, late August work nights meant damp shirts. She knew this because she had put them in the laundry for all those years. She knew the circle of perspiration around the armpits, the badge of honest late work. Her cheeks flushed, her heart pounded. Had he showered before coming home? She knew he had not been working.

"Good book?" Bart said.

"Yes, yes," she said. "Read it at Mount Holyoke years, years ago. It’s all new to me. Tolstoy is so now."

"How was the book club?" he asked casually.

"Fascinating," she said. Her fingers felt numb. "Bart … " she started.

"Yes?" He was pulling the covers over his head.

"Bart … you are working so hard."

"Yes, sweetie," he said. He rolled over and kissed her. She felt the kiss’s compulsory quality, the repetitive wet peck.

"Bart," she said, taking a deep breath and pausing. “Bart, I got them to fix the den’s air conditioner and honor the warranty two days after it expired." He was sinking under the covers.

"That’s my girl," he said. His voice was getting drowsy.

She felt scared. Alone. She whispered to herself, knowing he wouldn’t hear, "Who was she?" – the tears running down her face. She whispered again more quietly, "Who was she, Bart?" But when she looked over at Bart, he was fast asleep.

She turned out the light, first looking at their wedding picture near the telephone on her side of the bed. She turned the picture face down, wiped her tears away, listened to his breathing, and wondered what she would do in the morning.

Click here for wOw poll: What would you do in the morning?

Read more about: Anna Karenina, Fiction

112 Reader Comments (so far…) Sign In or Register to comment

Ms. Dee
Dr. Klein, did you cheat on any of your ex’s? Did they all let their figures go?
By Ms. Dee on 04/10/2008 9:23 pm
Buh-Bye Hillary Hillary Buh-Bye
MK….not surprising….why not try some Rush Limbaugh fan site…they all want to bomb Iran over there….you could find some hate-talking honey….buh-bye
By Buh-Bye Hillary Hillary Buh-Bye on 04/11/2008 1:07 am
Mugsy Peabody
It’s hard to get a fish to see water, Mark, but you don’t belong here, and even though we keep telling you that, you ignore us. And then you wonder why your marriages don’t work? You know, I’m not having a lot of trouble understanding that.
By Mugsy Peabody on 04/14/2008 2:58 am
Buh-Bye Hillary Hillary Buh-Bye
MK, “A philosophical type said he learned from the experience if it flies, floats or f****, rent.” An extremely old, very worn out and stale joke. Your entire post is in you typically misogynistic style….shouldn’t you be off on your blog about how we should bomb Iran?
By Buh-Bye Hillary Hillary Buh-Bye on 04/11/2008 12:53 am
Lorraine Bates
So, you’re an avid Dr. Laura fan, apparently.
By Lorraine Bates on 04/11/2008 3:06 pm
quiltsis one
Ask him what’s going on. From his response/reaction you’ll know where to go from there. Lots of suggestions/strategy suggested. They’re all valid, you have to decide the next step, skip or leap.
By quiltsis one on 04/10/2008 9:21 am
Chrome Toe
This is one of those responses that would have been different when I was 25 or even 35. But today, at 45 my response is that I’d confront him and then see where it went. At 25 I’d have kicked his a— and ran screaming out the door. At 35 I’d have kicked his a— and booted him out the door. But at 45 I’d drink my coffee look him in the eye and say “tell me about it”. And then decide. Based on our history and connection and goals. I wouldn’t be abused or taken advantage of. But things happen. life is tough. it isn’t black and white.
By Chrome Toe on 04/10/2008 9:21 am
Black Diamond
For my own sanity’s sake, I would speak to him in the morning, calmly laying out the facts that I’d observed the night before. I’d stick to just the facts (neat hair, neat tie, clean smell, backwards underwear) and not my interpretation of them or any of the dozens of scenarios I’d cooked up in my head during the night. Then I’d ask him to help me understand why his underwear was on backwards. With no accusation before him, he’s left with nothing to attack, nothing to defend, just the facts and my amused looking face. The truth, or a really good lie, should follow. After nearly 3 decades together, I should know the difference!
By Black Diamond on 04/10/2008 9:25 am
bug B
I’d think about the Ann Landers question (or is it Dear Abby?): ” Are you better off with him or without him?” After many days, weeks of thought, when I found my answer, then I would react.
By bug B on 04/10/2008 10:01 am
Rachel Y
If I see a lipstick mark like the one in the picture, I will calmly ask “What is this all about?” and regardless of the answer, I’ll give him a big spank!
By Rachel Y on 04/10/2008 10:07 am
iris odonata
Your question is Who is she? She’s Anna.
By iris odonata on 04/10/2008 10:15 am
Christine Christensen
Depends on what she wants, if she still cares for him, talk to him don’t accuse, get proof and discuss options with attorney and be ready that it will probably happen again. If proof comes back he is having an affair make some hard decisions, what do you want, what is your tolerance level. If you decide to leave get out get what you need and don’t look back. If you stay set your own boundries and keep your proof current and see what happens. Take a trip without him and change your routine. Make sure you have “plan B” and make sure your future is as secure as you can make before your tolerence level is reached. Start becoming independent and become very fimiliar with your finances and financial planning. (Which of course every couple should be.) Whatever you do don’t second guess your decisions and always have “Plan B”.
By Christine Christensen on 04/10/2008 10:29 am
Mary Matthews
If you confront him, he’ll just lie about it. Poison is way too “over the top,” especially if there’s some innocent explanation. (Highly unlikely, I know.) I’d spend the night doing as Abby and Ann always advise — thinking about whether I’m better off with him or without him. And I’d probably invest a few hours thinking of a way to let him know I know he’s cheating. Perhaps a sophisticated version of, “Why don’t you invite your girlfriend to Terry’s party next Saturday, so I can meet her?”
By Mary Matthews on 04/10/2008 11:04 am
Jane Goodwin
I posted here a few hours ago, and now my comment is gone. Are we being censored?
By Jane Goodwin on 04/10/2008 11:58 am
Administrator _
Mamacita, I’m sorry that your comment seems to have been misplaced. I have contacted the 6 people that have the ability to remove comments from the site and all are positive that nothing was deleted. I assure you that the only way that a comment would ever be deleted would be if it was SPAM or could result in serious legal issues. In either of these rare cases it is our policy to email the author immediately to inform them what we did and why we did it. Rest assured that not a single person working at the wOw offices would ever stand for any sort of censorship on the site. I am now looking into any technical that may be responsible for the disappearance of your comment. I’ll keep you updated if I find anything. Thanks, Thomas Achtemichuk Director of Technology - wowowow.com
By Administrator _ on 04/10/2008 4:36 pm