Politics | 10/16/2008 11:00 am
Who Won the Presidential Debate? Votes Are In

So the presidential debates are over, and many agree that John McCain came out swinging — like he had to — in the last national public joust against Barack Obama. But the Democratic senator held his own.
Our wOw readers weighed in during the debate in our live reader forum, and we’d like you to take our poll and tell us whether the debates changed your mind about who you’re going to vote for at the polls next month.
Here’s a sampling of what the nation’s newspaper, TV networks and other media outlets — as well as everyday Americans — think the American public’s views are after the three debates:
-CBS News and Knowledge Networks’ poll of 638 undecided voters: 53% said Obama won in a clean sweep, while 22% said McCain won; 25% said it was a draw; 68% of uncommitted voters trusted Obama more than McCain to make the right decisions about health care, while 30% trusted McCain to manage health care before the debate; 64% think Obama will raise their taxes, while 50% think McCain will.
-An informal MSNBC.com poll shows that of the 253,108 voters who so far have weighed in online, 82% say Obama won, while 18.5% think McCain was the victor.
-58% of debate watchers questioned in a CNN/Opinion Research Corp. poll said Obama did the best job, with 31% saying McCain performed best. The poll suggested that debate watchers’ favorable opinion of Obama rose slightly, from 63% at the start to 66% at the end. McCain’s favorables dropped slightly, from 51% to 49%. Those polled said Obama was a stronger leader during the debate by 23 points, and more likeable by 48 points.
-An exclusive Politico/InsiderAdvantage nationwide survey of undecided debate-watchers taken immediately after the debate showed: 49% said Obama won, compared to 46% who think McCain came out on top, and 5% said they were unsure. Among respondents not identified with either major political party, McCain was judged the winner, 51-42%. Hispanic voters favored Obama 50-36%, while black voters chose Obama, 88-10%.
-Early returns from a Forbes.com Trailwatch poll show that readers thought Obama won. Of the 4,019 respondents, 3,252, or 80%, called the debate for the Democratic nominee, while 631 readers (16%) voted for McCain.
-AP says McCain’s feistiness and aggressiveness helped find him a lifeline and challenge his rival on his truthfulness, associations and record, and he won in that aspect, but it might not be enough.
-AOL’s Political Machine bloggers offer a scorecard of both candidates’ performances, including "Best Insult or Zinger."
-Reuters does an analysis of who won the body language war.
-U.S. News & World Report’s "Political Bulletin" has an article, "Media Sees McCain Falling Short of Debate Goals," that rounds up what many pundits and media outlets are saying about the debate.
-Voters in Virginia — what’s turning out to be a bit of a battleground state after years of being a GOP stronghold — weighed in on who they think the victor was at the PilotOnline.com.
-Today’s Rasmussen Reports daily Presidential Tracking Poll shows Obama attracting 50% of the vote while McCain earns 46%. But those numbers don’t reflect any debate impact and are reported on a three-day rolling average basis.























11 Reader Comments (so far…) Sign In or Register to comment