Sign in to wowOwow

Enter the email address that you used when registering at wowOwow.
The password field is case sensitive. Click here if you have forgotten your password.

Please register for wowOwow

Newsletter subscriptions
Sign up to receive wowOwow's weekly newsletter and get our best picks delivered right to your inbox. Our newsletter content is hand-picked by the wowOwow editorial team and provides the top features, news, and commentary from our site. Subscribing to our newsletter is free and safe. We will never share your email or other information with a third-party without your direct consent.
By registering, you indicate that you have read and agree
with our privacy policy and terms of service.

Question of the Day | 09/11/2009 11:50 am

On the anniversary of 9/11, what do you carry in your heart about this day?

This question and the Women’s answers were originally published on wOw in September 2008.
© Shutterstock
Judith Martin

Judith Martin | 09/11/2008 12:00 am

Judith Martin: A Change in Tone

Remember how everyone thought the tone of the everyday world had changed forever? Strangers started behaving politely to one another and being on the lookout to provide help. Estranged families got back in touch. Couples who had been unsure of each other craved permanence and got married. Young people decided to go into public service. Police and firefighters were applauded on the streets. Politicians worked together for the common good. Producers of popular culture started questioning whether what they did was in the best of taste. Abroad, foreigners put up American flags and treated American tourists gently. It was a beautiful example of how we could live if only we decided to. And it lasted about two weeks.
Cynthia McFadden

Cynthia McFadden | 09/11/2008 12:00 am

Cynthia McFadden's Remembrance of 9/11, Off the Record ... and On

I was at the office early that gorgeous September morning. My assistant at ABC was also there. She had a young friend who worked near the Trade Center who called her and said to turn on the television, something weird was going on. I immediately called our news desk and headed downtown with a satellite truck. We were clearly going in the wrong direction. Waves of people, vacant-eyed people walked by us heading north. The truck got stopped by the police but my producer and I continued on foot. Within an hour or so of the first plane hitting the Trade Center, we’d talked our way into the command center. It was totally silent. A horrible deadly silence. I found a payphone — our cells weren’t working — and talked to Peter Jennings live on the air. I told him that, so far, no survivors had made it to the trauma center on the East Side.

We walked through the dusty, silent corridors of New York west to Chelsea Piers. I remember running into Lesley Stahl and her crew. Thousands of doctors and nurses had assembled at the Pier to receive the injured. By midnight not one patient had shown up. A nurse waved me over: "Cynthia, you won’t remember me but I was in the delivery room when your baby was born. Off the record," she continued, "people either made it out, or they didn’t. There are not going to be any wounded coming here."

I called Jennings and asked to speak to him privately. "Peter," I said, "sources down here say that people either made it out or they didn’t. The survivors are safely out now. No one is going to come here." Remember that at this point no one knew for sure how many people were in the towers that morning, but some estimates were that as many as 30,000 people could have been inside when the planes hit. Peter said, "Cynthia, it’s too early for this. When I come to you on the air, don’t report this. People won’t be able to absorb it yet." It was such a human judgment, such a correct one. Jennings was at his best throughout. Wise, calm, insightful. I was proud to be a small part of ABC’s coverage of 9/11 for which I am happy to say we won a DuPont Award.

What else do I remember?

The dozens and dozens of people who came up to me when they’d see the camera, begging me to help them find their loved ones. One young woman stands out. She was 17 and had a ten-year-old and a seven-year-old with her. It was September 12. Her mother was in the first tower. High up. Their father was not in their lives. She pushed through the barriers as we were live on "Good Morning America," sobbing, "What am I supposed to do? She was all we have." As I struggled not to speak, Charlie Gibson said quietly, a catch in his voice, "It’s OK to cry Cynthia, hug her for us."

The cop who hugged me at Ground Zero and said, "None of us must ever forget this."

Going to the home of a firefighter who wasn’t supposed to be working that day, but insisted on going to the scene. Keeping his mass card on our refrigerator. Spencer, then three, calling him "our fireman." The sad eyes of his widow and children.

What do I remember?

Staggering home after several days to find Spencer standing on the living-room sofa with a towel serving as a cape, "Mommy, I am Superman and I am going to save those people."

Liz Smith

Liz Smith | 09/11/2008 12:00 am

Liz Smith on the Day America Lost Its Innocence

What I carry in my heart is remembering watching out my windows on East 38th Street, looking downtown as the first tower smoked and burned, as the second tower was struck before my very eyes and as both crumbled and fell. And then the ghostly hordes of people covered with ash trudging uptown below me on Third Avenue. I don’t need them to build any memorial to 9/11. It remains omnipresent every day of my life, the day America lost its innocence.

Click here on this text to read my New York Post column.

 

Joan Juliet Buck

Joan Juliet Buck | 09/11/2008 12:00 am

Joan Juliet Buck's Impossible Nightmare

Standing in the living room of my neighbor’s house in Santa Fe, watching the planes over and over again, trying to believe it has happened. Was happening. Impossible. And then Pennsylvania? The Pentagon? Watching until the sight turned into pornography — again and again the planes going into the towers, then the white smoke, the death, the helplessness. The bottom falling out of certainty. Remembering Sandy Berger at a conference that March, as he sat on the stage, telling us: “There will be a terrorist attack on the United States.” And we all shivered a little and thought he was being dramatic. It was impossible. Who knew then that those words were not so much dramatic as irresponsible? If he had known, others knew. And why had no fighters intercepted the planes? Why was no one protecting us? And the strange feeling of being so far away from all that, just a watcher.

After hours of watching the impossible nightmare, sitting at a table in a hotel garden with one of my oldest friends when the cell rings. It’s my second oldest friend, to say “Berry was on the first plane.” Berry, the happiest person anyone ever knew. Mind going to Berry’s last hour on earth, in the sky, in — as I later learned and will never forget — seat 19A. What did she see, feel, live through as that plane screeched over Manhattan? How ultimate the fear, how total the dread? What can that have been like? Were they screaming? Did she stay calm? I know she must have prayed. Hard. She wore a ring with a crucifix on it. Many weeks later, that ring was found in the rubble. Because I knew her and loved her, it is Berry — sitting in 19A in circumstances of total horror — that I will never forget. Ever.




Joan Ganz Cooney

Joan Ganz Cooney | 09/11/2008 12:00 am

Joan Ganz Cooney: The Sadness and the Stillness

I carry the sadness, the sense of enormous tragedy and loss and the stillness of that day and the days immediately following. Of course, there was a great amount of noise from fire engines and fighter planes overhead but it was still, nonetheless. My husband was abroad and was unable to get home. Oddly, I liked being alone, and sort of resented phone calls from outside New York that intruded on the trance-like state I was in. Peter Jennings on ABC News was my only company and that was the way I wanted it. On day two, I went to St. Patrick’s Cathedral and for the first time in years, I lit a candle and prayed. All I could think about were the dead, especially the police and firefighters but, of course, all those trapped civilians too.

Finally I came to on Friday and called my friend Liz Smith and said, "We’re going out to lunch. I have a car." She protested that she looked terrible and wasn’t dressed. I practically shouted, "Get dressed; I’m on my way." At the restaurant we talked and talked about the horror that had happened and about what might be coming. But we also laughed for the first time since Tuesday morning. A few days later, I went to our fire station which had lost several men on 9/11 to make a donation and as I handed the envelope to a firefighter I burst into tears and said nothing.

Candice Bergen

Candice Bergen | 09/11/2008 12:00 am

Candice Bergen: A City Holds Its Collective Breath

I will never forget the perfection of the weather on that day. And then after the towers fell, the eerie silence of the city, punctuated only by sirens and the screech of fighter jets crisscrossing overhead. Otherwise, just a city holding its collective breath. Then that evening, the spontaneous memorials that appeared on the sidewalks outside of apartment buildings where a resident has perished. Candles and flowers and photos. The doormen holding candles in tribute. And the shift in spirit of people in the city. The reaching out, the connection, the sharing of emotions beyond any of our experience. The intensity of emotions. The intensity of patriotism. The heavy sense of threat that hung over Manhattan. The persistent dread of attending a large gathering of people. A sporting event, say, or the theater.

The realization that on this island we are fish in a barrel. Utterly trapped with no exit possibility. Then three weeks later, going down to Ground Zero to serve food with my daughter and husband as volunteers and seeing the fire still burning. The molten core. The eyes of the firemen and rescue teams that were hollow and haunted. And the constant surprise in seeing the depth of people’s nobility and courage and caring. Often from those from whom you would least expect it.

Julia Reed

Julia Reed | 09/11/2008 12:45 pm

Julia Reed on the Extraordinary Heroism of Ordinary Americans

On 9/11, which is, alas, my birthday, I was in New York about to head to Nashville to attend a 70th birthday party for George Jones (which I figured would be better than any party I could throw for myself). Before I left, though, I had promised a close friend I’d have breakfast at the St. Regis with an older friend of hers in town from Mexico City. I was in a cab in the usual slow Fifth Avenue traffic, and at a light, both the driver and I saw the fireball at the top of the first tower. (I hadn’t realized until that moment how very visible both towers were from points all over Manhattan.) He rolled down his window and another driver told us he was hearing on the radio that a small plane had flown into it.

A bit rattled, I went into the hotel dining room and met this lovely genteel woman. Halfway through my second cup of coffee, a friend rang my cell to tell me about the Pentagon. At that point I knew we weren’t talking about a small plane anymore. I told my uncomprehending breakfast companion to go back to her room, that her husband would be watching CNN in Mexico and he would want to reach her.

When I got outside there was no traffic on Fifth Avenue, even that far up (53rd Street). Cars had pulled over, people were listening to their radios, pedestrians crowded the streets. I began walking, fast, back uptown, toward home. I was trying to dial my then-boyfriend, now-husband in New Orleans to find out what the hell was happening (I figured he’d know a lot more than I did from TV) when a man grabbed my arm and spun me around and the two of us stood there holding onto each other as the tower literally disappeared before our eyes.

Every time I think of that moment my heart is in my throat again. It’s that feeling of watching something so, so much bigger than you or anything you’ve ever seen before and somehow comprehending the urgency and sheer awfulness of it even though there are no words. I will never forget that man, my brief companion.

When I got back uptown, without even thinking I went straight to my butcher and bought two enormous tenderloins (this is my mother in me — when something horrible happens or somebody dies, she cooks a tenderloin). When I got home, friends began pouring in and we sat glued to the TV (it was Peter Jennings — as Cynthia said, he was pitch-perfect that day). At one point I left the apartment to get something — cigarettes probably, as all of us reformed smokers were suddenly puffing away — and the sidewalks were full of families with dogs and baby strollers spilling out of cafés. I realized that like me, they were desperate for communion with other folks, to cling to normalcy (even though nothing was remotely normal), to somehow reiterate the fact that they were still alive.

There were cops everywhere and at my corner, 78th and Third Avenue, a couple of them were stopping crosstown traffic so that a fire truck carrying a crew returning from the rubble could get through. The men were soot-covered and stone-faced and a huge flag flew from the top of the engine. Hundreds of people were suddenly quiet and it was the first time I really cried. That’s what stays with me: the flag, our flag, and the extraordinary heroism of ordinary Americans doing their jobs that day. 

Read more about: 9/11, History, Terrorism

247 Reader Comments (so far…) Sign In or Register to comment

Xiulan Li
I noticed there are postings on the first page which are from 2008.  I wonder why, when they are neither uplifting nor inspiring.
By Xiulan Li on 09/11/2009 2:49 pm
Melanie Waldrop
I was home sick from work on 9/11/2001. I was watching a report on the first plane that crashed into the twin towers, and saw the second crash live. The horror, fear, and heart-sickness I experienced was profound. I had never felt that way before, and I pray to God that I may never feel that way again…It was just devastating.
By Melanie Waldrop on 09/11/2009 3:58 pm
mitzi morris

On 9/11 I had the morning TV news on. My veternarian assistant came over to tend my cats who were on meds. Within a few minutes of his arrival we watched the first plane hit and thought it was an accident, but when the second hit we both looked at each other and said, "terrorists".

We sat quietly together for hours watching this beautiful clear day turn into horror.   It was eerily quiet for days, and yes we all felt confused,uneasy, and hearbroken for those that perished. I too noticed the hospital staffs lined up to receive the bodies that never came. And like many of us I was transfixed and shocky for days. The city was still and quiet for many days in an indescribable way.

One of my neighbors, an attorney, walked out against the advice of firemen telling him to stay. He’s alive today.  9/11 is a tragedy I will never fully overcome, as my heart still aches for all those that were lost.

 

By mitzi morris on 09/11/2009 5:59 pm
frances roehm
I lived in New York many years ago. The first Tower was up the second on it’s way. The day of the attack started out as one of the most perfect to be imagined down here in Virginia. That was all to end in horror. In retrospect, what I will remember most was the courage and goodness that Americans and New Yorkers showed to one another. We were all in shock. I remember staying with Peter Jennings with his twenty four hour broadcast begore he signed off in exhaustion. I remember all of the stories of people helping and feeding people that were the most affected by the horror of what had happened. No when I look back, I feel that Americans were robbed of the message of who we truly are. We care, we help, we can feel anothers pain. Somehow that valuable message has been taken away and political agenda perverted that day rather than let it define the good that we are as Americans. We were told to go shopping and keep this economy growing.  Since then we have invaded a country that had nothing to do with the attacks. We have caused the deaths of many innocent people and used our troops (brave and good people) to do it. We are now in Afghanistan and we are losing our own and there is never a mention of the man who did this to us. This horrible act of murder has caused the loss of our own personal freedoms and taken away the spirit of generousity that I feel made us uniquely American. 
By frances roehm on 09/11/2009 6:01 pm
joanne in jax

On September 10, 2001, I had surgery on my right hand for my severe carpal tunnel, which had been misdiagnosed for 30 years (the term carpal tunnel did not exist when I became symtomatic), and on the morning of September 11th I was attempting to apply make-up with my wrong hand, for my post-op doctor appointment, when my sweetheart threw open the door to our bedroom, looked at the TV and asked me why I wasn’t watching the news, which was what I did every morning.  He grabbed the remote and changed the station, yelling something about a plane, towers, New York, just in time to see the second plane hit.  I was "medicated", even though it had been out-patient surgery, I was still in a fog and I had taken pain medication.  I just could not take in what was happening before my eyes.  We had a 30 minute drive to my doctor’s office, listening to a news station the entire trip, and not saying a word to each other.  I kept thinking that this had to be a dream, but upon entering my doctor’s crowded waiting room, we saw on the wall-mounted TV the first of the towers to fall.  Their were gasps, woefully cries, and suppressed curses from men, and so many tears, but still there was this silence.  I remember looking at the man I love and asking him to please tell me that it was the drugs they gave me that was making me see this horrendous site, but I could tell in his strong face, and the welling in his eyes, that it was all real. 

I was in the exam room with my doctor when the second tower failed - we could hear the reactions of the strangers in the waiting room, the same as when the first tower fell -  and one of his tears dropped on my bandaged hand before he was able to continue to re-dress my wound.  I just sat there crying silently, only nodding or shaking my head to his inquiries.

Later, I remember sitting in a grocery store parking lot while my man filled a prescription for me, and was buying what he thought were survival necessities, and listening to a CBS news radio station on a gray, muggy September day, feeling like that was the most surreal moment of my life.  When his 15 year old son came home from school that afternoon and saw for the first time the film of the collapse of the towers, his first remark was "Cool".  Despite my infirmity, I had to be physically restrained from choking that little ingrate.  He later apologized, but I realized this reality, this horror, was totally removed from his reality.

I ended up watching the tube non-stop for about 36 hours, crying the whole time (who knew that pain medication was like speed for me!).  I thought it was only fitting that for the next four days it rained, unrelentingly, flooding our country road, filling it with frogs, and seeing wildlife that had been displaced, some we had never seen.  Surreal is the only description I can come up with.

Finally, on Saturday evening, I was pursuaded to leave my vigil, as the rains had stopped, and go have a nice dinner.  No food has ever tasted as good as that meal, though it was not exceptional.  I realized that I had not tasted anything in five days, and it was as if my senses had been restored by the loving gesture my partner gave me by making me indulge in the good food I love so much.  I still wanted to feel guilty to be enjoying this simple pleasure when so many were suffering, but I finally figured out that I can grieve for all of those lost, but I cannot carry that grief, it’s not my right.

I have had a difficult time on this day every year since 2001. So many much more personal losses and crisises have presented in the ensuing years, loss of parents, my breast cancer, diagnosed at exactly the time my partner was taking a lucrative, supposedly short-term job out of state (he now has been laid off - 4+ years later).  But, I think what resounds in me after reading last year’s posts, and the ones that posted today, is that "loss of innocence", and I was about to turn 50 years old when this tragedy happened.  I had a wonderful, some would say ‘privedged’, childhood and a good education, but I also struggled as a single woman in businesses that paid less than my male cohorts.  Despite my growing cynicism, I think I still had a polly-anna attitude about the world when it was destroyed by what happened eight years ago.

The conspiracy theories are interesting, and I have read/seen many via my man.  I don’t want to be an ostrich, but I can hardly comprehend what happend eight years ago, much less wrap my head around the thought that some of "our people" were aware it was going to happened and failed to prevent it.  I really believe they did, and that only makes it harder for me to comprehend.

One true thing I have learned today:  the grief never leaves us.

By joanne in jax on 09/11/2009 6:06 pm
Lee Harrison

I remember the utter disbelief and shock as we watched what was happening on TV.  And then I remember the absolute quiet…for days. 

We were in Naples, FL at the time.  On Sept 12 we had a small hurricane that never made the news…Hurricane Gabrielle did a lot of damage along the Gulf because of a tidal surge.  We spent several days helping clean up the beach…it was a good break to get away from television. 

When we could finally get on a plane to fly back to Ohio, the airport was like a ghost town; the plane was nearly empty.  There were no real security measures at that point, but I remember we were given metal cutlery except for a plastic knife!  There was a very suspicious looking and acting male passenger sitting near us.  (Remember, the hijacking pilots learned to fly in Ft. Myers, where we took off from.)  My husband and I were prepared to take him out or die trying.  We kept our metal forks through the entire flight, figuring we could stab him if necessary.

Suspicious male passenger nearly ran off the plane when we landed and headed straight to a restroom.  (He’d been in the plane restroom about 4 times in the course of 2 1/2 hours and he’d been into the overhead compartment an equal number of times during the flight.)  To this day, I believe he was an escaping terrorist.

By Lee Harrison on 09/11/2009 6:06 pm
Dona Howlett

Lee,

Did you ever think he just might have been a man who was

so frightened to fly that he developed DIARRHEA.

That’s the first thing that entered my mind as I was reading your post……lol

By Dona Howlett on 09/12/2009 8:44 pm
Lee Harrison

Dona,

Yes, as a matter of fact I did think of that, and it may have been part of the problem.  But there was something more going on.  Remember, he getting stuff out of the overhead compartment.  If I tell you any more, I’ll be accused of racial profiling.

By Lee Harrison on 09/12/2009 11:59 pm
L. C.
I remember acts of kindness and a short lived unity of the American people.
By L. C. on 09/11/2009 8:38 pm
Patricia Sprofera
In my heart, and in my mind’s eye, I carry/remember the photo that accompanies this article.  Also, I wear a Mercy Band (and have for almost 7.5 years) engraved with the name of Father Mychal Judge.  He was the first recorded victim of the September 11th attacks.  I also have some religious items, that a friend asked Father Judge, to bless for me, during the 1990’s.
By Patricia Sprofera on 09/11/2009 11:48 pm
Lauriate Roly

Patricia Sprofera - My dear friend, I have read all the postings anticipating coming across the one I instinctively knew would come from you. Yours is especially significant to me because I know you, and I know that you are a born and bred New Yorker and have lived in that wonderful city all your life. That day, was a terrible day for just about anyone who knows anything about New York City. Like so many others, I was horrified and devastated as I followed all the news reports. It must have been terrible for you. I wish I could properly express my deepest sorrow for you and all the others who suffered so directly from this terrible tragedy.

You speak of the picture showing the “light rays” reflecting the spot where the buildings stood and this alerted me to what a beautiful symbolic marker this is and how effective it becomes as a gentle but very effective reminder of the terrible tragedy.

Your sad remembrance of Father Mychal Judge is heartbreaking. I do not know who this special person was but I did read the very sad circumstances about a priest who died as the result of having been struck by one of the bodies which fell from one of the towers.

I find the whole thing too difficult to sensibly comment on. Reading all the feelings and sentiments of all the other posters helps me close some of the unsettling memories I have and continue to periodically relive every time I see or hear the numbers 9/11. I’m sure you cherish and find great comfort in having the religious items the kind Father blessed for you.

Sincerely, Lauriate.

By Lauriate Roly on 09/12/2009 5:49 pm
Patricia Sprofera
Lauriate - Thank you for your heart-felt reply.  Father Judge was a Franciscan friar and in 1992, become the NYC’s Fire Department chaplain.  He died while giving the Last Rites, to the victims that were in one of the Towers’ lobby.  Yes, I do cherish the items that Father Judge blessed, for me, in the 1990’s.  Again, thank you. Patty
By Patricia Sprofera on 09/12/2009 8:04 pm
Lauriate Roly

Patricia Sprofera - Patty, this is exactly as I suspected. Father Judge was indeed the priest I had read about. How very sad.

By Lauriate Roly on 09/12/2009 10:15 pm
starry Nite

I was in Dallas, Tx attending a training seminar.  My husband planned to join me to visit friends  in Austin, Tx at the end of the week.  Some of the employees were from New York and after our boss informed us of the attack  the people from New York were frantic about their loved ones. 

All forms of transportation were cut off and I could not return to California for 2 days and it took me a while to find out about my brother-in-law who worked at the pentagon.

I didn’t realize that our lives would change forever.  I mourn for my lost feeling of security and taking things for granted.

I mourn for the change in our people have created people who say they are "real"Americans and yet they lack the humanity and empathy. They hate the goverment and advocate its distruction.  They are rebels without a cause.

 I thought real Americans loved their country and were willing to work to make it a good place for all  citizens.  

I wish we could get back that loving feeling that we had toward each other right after 9/11.  We helped each other and did not blame the victim’s of 9/11 by saying they should have prepared.

By starry Nite on 09/11/2009 11:59 pm
Janna S.

Over 30,000.00 people are murdered in the United States every year.  Though 9/11 was a horrible act upon our country.  I think going over and over this act on cable news is morbid.  I feel those that lived In NY, DC and NJ might still need to relive these memories to still grieve this out.

 I use to work at the Trade Center back in the 1980’s.  I feel terrible for the people and their families that died that day.  But 30 thousand People are murdered a year in this country and that is obscene and worse than any terrorist attack at this moment in time!  We let the murder victims die in vain and cherish the 9/11 victims.  It’s too surreal for me!  All life is precious!  Everyone of us counts!  

By Janna S. on 09/12/2009 3:13 am