Question of the Day | 12/11/2008 11:00 pm
Weigh in: What do you think of Oprah's brave revelation that her weight has gone up to 200 pounds?

93 Reader Comments (so far…) Sign In or Register to comment
I wonder if it is true, as this article linked below states, that Oprah has gone off her thyroid medication. If so, that is one reason why she may be tipping the scales a little high. http://thyroid.about.com/b/2008/12/10/oprah-200-pounds-thyroid-weight.ht… I think Oprah would benefit from the forum at this web site on thyroid issues.

I’ve been taking thyroid medication since I was 30, and I don’t understand why anyone would “go off it” because it is such an easy thing to make part of an everyday routine (just a single little pill), it’s not expensive, and carries no ill side effects that I’ve ever experienced. Over the years, my doctor has kept tabs on my condition with just a simple blood test, and I’ve had my meds adjusted during pregnancy without problems. The thing is to get tested if you develop symptoms of fatigue, weight gain, bad skin and hair — that you never had before. There are many of us out there with this condition, and we’re functioning quite normally with the right medication and doctor’s oversight. Don’t let anyone tell you that it’s “just what happens as we age.” Get see a doctor and get some bloodwork.
Sad thing is now that she is older, the weight loss is even more difficult. Yes, I feel her pain and she shows it more in how she relates to her guests.
That’s an interesting observation, Peggy, about how she relates to her guests. Could you elaborate? I don’t watch her show.
Phyllis, I have watched Oprah from the beginning of her in Chicago. Having been involved in five shows, the last one was this last holiday show she had the day before Thanksgiving. In my perception, she was very unhappy at taping and the three friends I took with me saw the same thing. In the past she has been able to share wonderful ideas to get to the true spirit of life. When she featured the spirit segments I was one of those segments - the show was about 100 years in photography.
Now she seems to have lost the sharing of ideas and does more lecturing on what she knows. I loved the interaction of minds. Recently she did an add that talks about the brown elephant in the room. She said how can she tell people how to live if she cannot do it herself. Okay, that was a light bulb moment. No one can give all of us the answers but the pressure on her (self induced?) to help many people who put her on a pedestal is strong.
I disagree with some of the things said here in that it is a subject that should be talked about. Not just her weight but our nation of growing citizens. Our children will have more health issues than kids did in the past. So using Oprah as a springboard to help people understand why we are gaining weight is important. I appreciate that she is stepping up and talking about it even though it is again. It is a struggle for many and I hope she learns ways to help.
It might be difficult for me to explain to you since you do not watch her show, but it reminds me of the old adage “if mama ain’ t happy ain’t nobody happy”. She was unhappy at the “Favorite Things” taping and it showed. I just hope she gets happy again and brings back some inspirational shows.
Thanks for responding, Peggy,I understand what you are picking up from her demeanor. It must be tough to be so powerful and yet inside be as vulnerable as she seems to be. We tend to make heros of so many, don’t we? There seems to be something in our nature that yearns for Kings and Queens, rock stars, film stars, talk show stars, etc. and all those gurus who go on for hours (or write books) telling us how to live and find pure happiness. No wonder man invented gods. When I was a girl I was astonished to watch young girls swoon, cry, and scream over Frank Sinatra. I didn’t understand it then––today, I understand it, I just can’t relate.
Peggy Sue, I think I kind of understand what you’re saying. Oprah has gotten so much larger than life that when she got thin and fit and was running marathons, it was too much in a way. I remember thinking that her weight issues were the only thing that kept her connected to women in real life. I just don’t believe someone can be that successful and powerful and still relate to the average woman; that’s why I stopped watching her long ago. Maybe she uses her weight as a kind of subconscious tool in her career. Somewhere deep down, she realizes it keeps her humble and empathetic.
Gianna , I’ve often thought the same thing and that was maybe she has never forgotten where she came from and the thing’s she went through as a child. Many people have eating disorders as a result of childhood trauma and it is their way of taking complete control over some vein of themselves as they have had no other control over the remaining aspects of their life’s. Another concept would be that she is wildly successful and the underlying issues that cause her to battle her weight, cause her at the same time misery, because she may feel that as she has arrived and achieved so much and come so far, she perhaps feels that she should have moved forward and conquered this as well. I really think that there is yet something, that she has not let go of and when she finds it she will balance out not only her emotions in relation to that issue, she will then find a happy medium with her weight as well.
I can relate to the weight issue. I’ve been dealing with this for years. I wish I had her chef, and her trainer to help me out.

3 Comments






























