Question of the Day | 12/11/2008 11:00 pm
Weigh in: What do you think of Oprah's brave revelation that her weight has gone up to 200 pounds?

93 Reader Comments (so far…) Sign In or Register to comment
Maizie,
You put it so well! I don’t think Liz meant that Oprah is just plain “brilliant”. Cookie goes with it! lol The words i prefer for Oprah are “cunning” and “clever”.
Sibelle,
In fairness to Oprah, I’m probably not ‘qualified’ to make broad judgments about her because I’ve rarely watched her shows. I have a few friends who love Oprah, and who tell me that she often has very entertaining programming. And also, I’m told that she has shows featuring many well known celebrities. However, the few times I viewed Oprah, I ‘tuned in’ when she either talked on and on about her personal life and about her relationship with ‘Stedman’, or when she had guests on who were coping with some type of extraordinary crisis. In the former, I always thought she was ‘over the top’. Then when her magazine debuted, I pondered the psychological implications about her need to be on every cover of her magazine. Yet, it is the latter aspect of her shows, which were most disturbing. Simply put, I recall feeling ‘turned off’ (and even horrified) by the method Oprah used to delve into the fragile psyche of the guests, and the manner in which she seemed to lurch forward with prodding questions, evoking a bloodshed of raw emotional outburst from her ‘victim’.
I suppose what bothers me about Oprah is her ability to trigger that puzzling aspect of human nature, which aroused our morbid curiosity - similar to our ‘sneak and peak’ reaction to tabloid news journals ( at supermarket checkouts) depicting repulsive headlines, or the weird fascination we display when we slow down in our cars to glimpse at gruesome accidents. More often, our innate morbid curiosity is fueled by psychological factors, which are not easily understood. Nonetheless, we often experience a sense of underlining ‘guilt’, or shame when we ‘give in’ to these feelings.
I’m not sure if I’m ‘right’. But, it troubles me when ANYONE postures themselves to profit off of the cruel, traumatic, and devastating misfortunes of others - whether Maury, Judge Judy, Dr. Phil, or … Oprah.
Maizie,
“The method Oprah used to delve into the fragile psyche of the guests, and the manner in which she seemed to lurch forward with prodding questions, evoking a bloodshed of raw emotional outburst from her ‘victim’ “.
It could’nt be said any better! Like you, i don’t watch her show and wonder about her need to be on every cover of her magazine!
Again i appreciate your post because to be honest, i wouldn’t spend time on Oprah, but it also troubles me when anyone postures themselves to profit of the misfortunes of others, and your first post caught my attention. It is important to talk about it.
Sibelle,
Thank you for your reply. I feel relieved that you understand my comments because it was not my intent to ‘trash’ Oprah. Instead, my objective was to clarify/explain why I (and many others) find it difficult to relate to Oprah, especially considering her enormous popularity and success.
Again, thank you for sharing your comments. It’s comforting to know that my viewpoints are similar to opinions shared by others (such as you) who deviate from popular opinion.
I too take thyroid medication. I will have to take it for the rest of my life. But it was not responsible for my weight gain. (I stated before I have had gastric bypass surgery) My genes played a part of my being overweight. I think weight control is the hardest thing of all. Oprah is smart to get upset at 200 pounds. It could and would get worse if she let it.
Oh poohey. I’m now trying the Cabbage Diet after the uptenthtime. I totally understand her issue. Think about it, with her financial assets and support, she still struggles with one of the same problems that I fight and think about almost every day. I hate the weight thing. But I will conquer it one day. Yes I can………..
For at least five years now I have been listening to three alternative oriented licensed doctors who have call-in talk shows in New York, NY. One of these doctors sounds like he is very well informed about the ins and outs of thyroid treatment. Maybe Oprah should consult with him. He says that he is a trained internist. He is broadcast on Sundays on one of the most popular radio stations in New York, NY. He practices in New York also (in Manhattan).
haven’t read every post- BUT- i cannot believe that when she made this ‘revelation’ public, it was headlines on every major cable news. come on- this is news? w/all that’s going on?
I admire Oprah for talking openly about this struggle. I lost 20 lbs a year ago (sounds minor, but I’m petite and it took me to a normal weight). The work to maintain this loss is a daily struggle. Every day I forego things I like, I make compromises, I stick to a pretty boring regime. I’ve reconciled it, and am very proud of my achievement. I weight myself every other day to keep “creep ups” in check. People who don’t think about these things are lucky.
I hope Oprah finds a healthy solution. Maybe if she just ate heart healthy and forgot about calories and pounds?
I find this thread oddly disempowering. Yes, many of us struggle with weight, but it seems Oprah’s connecting her self-esteem to her body image. Shouldn’t the struggle be to feel good about herself regardless of weight? And from a place of feeling good about herself, she can still decide to diet and work out.
I’m reading it as, “I feel bad about myself because I don’t look like the airbrushed women in the magazines.” Sure, there’s a health issue to being overweight. But the image of a bird with mud on its wings isn’t about health; it’s about self-esteem.
Isn’t part of the whole thing to learn to feel good about yourself, *period*? Whether you’re fat, thin, white, black, classically pretty, or looking like Sylvester Stallone in drag?
I’m a short, red-headed, nerd who alternates between looking like a geek and a gnome. No matter how hard I try (and have I tried!), I just can’t seem to pass for Tom Cruise. So my journey has been to accept myself as I am.
(And P.S., I’m trying to lose an inch or two of waistline, myself. I’m just trying to do it out of preference, rather than a sense of deep personal identification with a physical ideal.)
Hi, Stever, I get your point but why are we all assuming Oprah is connecting her entire self estemm to her body image? I’d venture a guess that the woman might feel pretty good about a whole lot of areas of her life or parts of herself. I just see this as Oprah straightforwardly discussing something that first off, I’m sure anyone who follows her has noticed, and secondly, is real part of many people’s lives. I don’t see her advocating drastic measures to lose weight for the simple sake of looking good, her approach has mostly been about health (if we ignore the Opti-Fast thing of many years ago…) and that’s pretty valid, I think. I mean, it is true, she has gained weight, and she has the right to address publicly if she so chooses. That the news leads with this kind of thing, well, that’s a whole other ball of goods, that’s just plain stupid and out of touch.
I haven’t watched her discuss this directly; I’ve only read the media reports, so the bias I mention might be me reading into the way the story is being reported. And if that’s what I’m reading into it… isn’t *that* interesting? Maybe it’s MY issue I’m projecting on her. Having just returned from the gym where I was able to compare my body with many others in much, much better shape, it’s clear that I have plenty of my own work to do on the body image issue :-)
Yep, the way it’s being reported is sorta ridiculous, not only in how much attention it’s gotten but it does probably play the most superficial angle on the story. The thing is that so many women (and men too for that matter, maybe just concentrating on less body parts than we do…) have body image issues, god knows I do, that maybe it’s a good thing that it gets talked about, period. I somehow trust Oprah to go in the real person direction. And ok, before everyone jumps on me for insinuating she’s “just like us” (I honestly don’t get when people begrudge her her billions, she freakin’ earned them, right?…) let me remind folks that way early in her Oprah magazine days she was the first one to do one of those airbrush-make-up-celebrity photographer to real, untouched photo comparisons, way before Jamie Lee Curtis did it, to specifically make the point that holding yourself to a fake cover girl ideal is absurd.
Well, I think when you get to a certain age, health trumps beauty when it comes to weight issues. Her current weight is not healthy and there is a ton of medical evidence to spell out the risks. She’s a lovely woman at any weight, but needs to lose to be/stay healthy as she ages.

3 Comments




























