Question of the Day | 04/02/2008 12:00 am

OUCH! Killer diets, strange-food fads, risky plastic surgery: Have you ever put your health at risk for the sake of beauty?

© Shutterstock
Read more about: Beauty, Diet, Health

83 Reader Comments (so far…)

Liz Smith

Have I ever put my health at risk? Let’s see, like drinking lots of Margaritas, using a bit of cocaine for fun and games, taking synthetic marijuana just as an experiment, eating lots of fried food, foregoing vegetables, not getting enough sleep, driving too fast and refusing to exercise?

It’s the story of my life. But if I eat from the brown and white food groups as Ann Richards always accused me, I have never taken any drugs to lose weight or tried any other miracle cures.

I suppose you could say having serious anesthetic for a face lift way back in the Dark Ages was putting my health at risk for the sake of “beauty.” Maybe it was just for the sake of survival and being able to keep working without looking like Margo leaving Shangri-La. I’d do it again. It helped a lot.

God bless Dr. Tom Rees. Now he doesn’t do silly things like face lifts anymore ; he works medical miracles pro bono in Africa.

By Liz Smith on 04/02/2008 12:00 am
Candice Bergen

Well. There was — many years ago — the famous Pineapple or Beverly Hills Diet that actually had Hawaii hustling to fill the sudden demand for pineapple. Of course, the acidic nature of the pineapples ate away my teeth and gave me sores on my tongue so I preferred the watermelon day of that diet. Then, the cabbage soup diet which, in fact, is very healthy although by day three, you never want to see another sip of cabbage soup and have gotten used to constantly farting. But I would say the way I consistently overeat is probably the worst thing I do to myself and why I’ve put on 25 pounds in ten years. But I love food. What can I say. I do not deprive myself. Almost never.

By Candice Bergen on 04/02/2008 12:00 am
Bella Mia

Yes, I had a nose job when I was 18 because my mother told me repeatedly that my Nose “was too big for my face.” It wasn’t, but she was self-conscious about her looks and had her own nose fixed. So I had the nose job, and afterwards, the doctor said I had the worst swelling he had seen in 15 years of medicine. My black eyes lasted 3 months - and this was during my first semester in college. What I wouldn’t discover until almost 20 years later, was that I had a bleeding disorder -von willebrands - that is a very mild form of hemophilia that prevents clotting - but only under certain conditions - and total relaxation was one of those conditions. I look back at my younger pictures and while my nose was pronounced, it was unique and I was very attractive, but my mother made me feel like there was something wrong. My three daughters tease me that they want to have their noses fixed because I did - and I have to tell them that my mother misled me, and it was a mistake. My oldest daughter has a nose that is very pronounced that she got from my husband’s side of the family. One day when she was 15 she asked me if I thought her nose was too big. I grabbed the Vogue magazine that she had bought, and thank goodness, it was filled with a range of exotic models from all over the world, many of them with very dramatic noses. I pointed out how strange they would look with little cheerleader noses - and she was very happy with that reply. It was one of my best mothering moments. My mother later had breast implants, and then complications from those when one burst. She had them removed and had reconstructive surgery on her chest. She has the bleeding disorder as well and so all those surgeries were risky. I recently saw a facelift procedure on Discovery Health and was shocked at how violent a procedure it is. I wonder how many people would have the surgery if they saw the video of how it is performed.

By Bella Mia on 04/02/2008 12:19 am
Meg Umans

Bella Mia, I’m so sorry for what you went through. For my mother, her daughters had to be bone-thin. We’ve spent our lives alternating between too thin for health and too fat for health. I love your mothering moment. Your daughter will be proud of her unique self, thanks to you. Bravas to both of you!

By Meg Umans on 04/02/2008 6:02 pm
Bella Mia

The best thing my mother did do for us was tell us we didn’t have to eat everything on our plates, because she had been a picky eater, and it had made her sick to be forced to clean her plate, when she was young. So I have followed that tradition with my children, and even though weight problem run in my husband’s family, all of my children, ages, 7, 9, 12, 16, 18, 19, and 21 are slim and active. When my teenage daughter, then 16, complained that her size 8 jeans were getting too tight and she was putting on weight, I had her review what she was eating, and then told her not to buy bigger clothes. I said, if you keep wearing your clothes that used to fit you, but are now too tight, it will be a constant reminder that you need to pay attention to what you are eating, and your activity level. Now she eats like a horse, wears a size 4, and works her tail off at her deli job after school. She just glows.

By Bella Mia on 04/03/2008 9:32 am
Jean Marsh

Although I would never say never to plastic surgery, I truly believe and I know it sounds a tad trite, but if you havent fixed the inner you nothing will “fix” the outer one.

By Jean Marsh on 04/07/2008 7:42 am
Marci Burke

This question is timely for me. I have been overweight since my kids were born…thay are 12 and 7 now. That “I just had a baby” excuse wasn’t working anymore. I have a wonderful doctor who has revoluntionalized dieting for me and many others. I have had to re-think the way I eat, how I eat, and when I eat. It’s differnet for everyone. I have lost, albeit slowly, 43 lbs in 14 months. It may not seem like alot, but the changes I’ve made in my eating are forever…..NOW, when I reach my goal weight, which is still 35 lbs off, I am getting a tummy tuck. After 2 c-sections, no amount of sit-ups is going to remove the tire around the incision area. I wouln’t necessarily consider a tummy tuck “putting my health at risk”-I already did that by being overweight. I consider it a congratulatory, private, means to an end…a “hooray for me” type of thing. I’ve never considered any other type of elective surgery….it’s not really me!!

By Marci Burke on 04/02/2008 12:37 am
Buh-Bye Hillary Hillary Buh-Bye

Marci, My mother had a tummy tuck after she research the surgeon to the max and was just thrilled with the results. And statistics show that people who acquire new habits maintain the weight loss and at healthful levels so congrats….it’s an achievement that am sure frees up a lot of energy.

By Buh-Bye Hillary Hillary Buh-Bye on 04/02/2008 6:16 pm
Elizabeth Gage

Well, I’ve “dieted” off and on for at least 40 years, including the original Atkins that appeared in Vogue in about 1972, but that was the most faddy one. As a result my weight is fairly stable and okay, I have a pretty good idea what foods to eat for health, but my current eating suffers from an irregular schedule. So I’m like others in that I already risk my health by not getting enough sleep or exercise and eating Starbucks pastries instead of real breakfast. But… today I went to the gym and tomorrow I have another chance to be good to myself!

By Elizabeth Gage on 04/02/2008 2:30 am
G V

oh yes— frying out in the sun when I was a teenager, starving myself as a young adult to lose weight, then too busy for exercise and eating well as a working adult. And now that I am older and wiser I realize that with just a little effort I could have felt and looked so much healthier and vibrant. Now I have decided to attempt to be satisfied with whatever results I get from good nutrition and exercise. Face lifts, tummy tucks, breast reductions, botox sound absolutely scary to me. I know how it is to want to look good though. It would be so wonderful to have even one day in my life when I don’t think about my body and my weight, or better yet, think positively of my body! May all of you have only positive days (I once believed that women’s liberation was going to give us pride and confidence in our bodies, instead I think maybe we got talked into trying to look perfect and the freedom to be slutty….just a thought)

By G V on 04/02/2008 2:32 am
Mugsy Peabody

Hi five and ditto to every word, except I was never slutty. Couldn’t pull it off.

By Mugsy Peabody on 04/02/2008 1:15 pm
Upanaway

Heavens no. I’ve had enough doctors do that to me. I’ve spent all of my life trying to live, and be healthy. This doesn’t mean I’m perfect, not by the farthest stretch of my imagination, but there’s no way I’ll harm myself, for anything, or anyone. My parents did everything they could to destroy me, too - that’s most likely the source of my determination to survive, and it’s served me incredibly well (according to my present doctors and friends).

By Upanaway on 04/02/2008 3:33 am
Upanaway

PS: I remember learning everything I could about natural birth to avoid taking any medications, or invasive procedures, in fact. The shocker came when I moved to the SW from Cambridge - back ‘there,’ women didn’t ‘get’ pelvic exams after the first pre-natal visit. In the SW even dentists wanted to do them!

By Upanaway on 04/02/2008 3:36 am
Buh-Bye Hillary Hillary Buh-Bye

UP! I had a c-section when I was 17 that was such a disaster that the doctors told my husband and parents I might not survive (thank goodness my son was fine and I came through.) My sisters were 16 and 7 at the time and when they saw me hooked up to machines and breathing apparatus that was the image that stuck…what happened to the older sis who seemed invincible. I never would go through it again…and neither of them had children. So you wonder how those women in the SW survive! They must be tougher than I was.

By Buh-Bye Hillary Hillary Buh-Bye on 04/02/2008 6:31 pm
CAROLINE MuLVEY

Years ago when I met my husband I was 70pds. Then after we were married I worked hard to gain some pds. I finally reached 90pds. Then I got sick and I went down to 60pds. Then they put a feeding tube in me and now I am 135pds. I do not like how I look and I can not exercise because of the pain. So I eat in moderation , and for a snack I will eat those 100 calorie cookies. But because of my digestive problems I can not eat real fruit nor vegies.
So I guess no I have not done anything like tummy tucks, botox. The only surgeries I have had was for my health .

By CAROLINE MuLVEY on 04/02/2008 4:53 am
Previous ArticleNext Article
'Trust Your Gut, It’s the Only Thing That Separates You From Everybody Else'What the Hell Happened to Lara Flynn Boyle?