Sign in to wowOwow

Enter the email address that you used when registering at wowOwow.
The password field is case sensitive. Click here if you have forgotten your password.

Please register for wowOwow

Newsletter subscriptions
Sign up to receive wowOwow's weekly newsletter and get our best picks delivered right to your inbox. Our newsletter content is hand-picked by the wowOwow editorial team and provides the top features, news, and commentary from our site. Subscribing to our newsletter is free and safe. We will never share your email or other information with a third-party without your direct consent.
By registering, you indicate that you have read and agree
with our privacy policy and terms of service.

Question of the Day | 09/12/2008 12:00 am

What advice would you give a daughter, niece, goddaughter or granddaughter who was pregnant out of wedlock?

© iStock
Liz Smith

Liz Smith | 09/12/2008 12:00 am

Liz Smith Would Offer Options

Well, I would offer options. Abortion is legal and though it is emotionally trying, it is not a crime in my book nor in the lawbooks … carrying a baby to term and offering it for adoption is legal and would make somebody somewhere yearning for a child very happy, but again, the process would be emotionally exhausting … having a baby and keeping it at such a young age would be arduous, trying, possibly financially difficult and life-changing; it would certainly put a crimp in her very young life. But it is a completely honorable and even lovable choice … I would discuss where the so-called "father" might be and what might be expected of him. If she wanted to marry, I’d offer deep caution and my blessing.

Then, with the barn door already wide open, I would discuss birth control for the future. I would try to discuss paracticalities for what’s the use of moralizing at that point?

Click here on this text to read my New York Post column.

Mary Wells

Mary Wells | 09/12/2008 12:00 am

Mary Wells Takes the Focus off Herself

I think every child is different at different times of their youth and no one is in full control of their life especially when they are young. I would want to know all about her feelings about her baby, the young man in the situation and what his dreams of the future are – I am pretty sure I would know her dreams. Although I am pro-abortion, the idea of killing my grandchild makes me sick. But I think I could focus on my daughter, not me, to help her think and feel her way through to her decision. I have adopted children and know how right that can be. But I also know that for young girls to have a child with or without marrying the boy in the story is a decision that can cut a potentially strong and meaningful and useful girl’s life short at the knees.

I have seen young women kid themselves and everyone around them that having the baby is the right thing and they had to have the baby when deep down in some terrified numb place they are screaming they not at all ready for that baby.

I would probably talk and talk and talk and talk and talk and talk until in desperation to shut me up she would talk more revealingly. If that didn’t work I would keep trying to see a right answer appear and not rush marriage or abortion or anything else. Fortunately we live in a time when it is not such a terrible thing to have a child before marriage. Grown-ups are doing it left and right all over the world. And they are adopting children all over the world. So I would do what I could to be sure that my daughter would not feel alone or that she had no alternatives or that I found her disappointing or that she was in some way hurting the family. I would just try work it out with her slowly and find ways to remind her how much we loved her. And I might go to church.

Joan Ganz Cooney

Joan Ganz Cooney | 09/12/2008 12:00 am

Joan Ganz Cooney: The Options Are There, but They're Not Easy

I would tell her that there are no good options and discuss each of them with her. I would suggest that abortion would in some ways be the easiest but not the only.

Sheila Nevins

Sheila Nevins | 09/12/2008 12:00 am

Sheila Nevins: Some Wishes Trump Judgment

I would tell her she is too young to raise a child and that this early fetus can be aborted simply. If my daughter felt she wanted this fertilized egg to become a child and to birth this child, I would help her to follow her wishes — even though it would be against my better judgment. I would wonder why she had not been more careful about conception and I would make certain that for the future she was well-versed in methods of birth control. Though I’m certain I would have versed her in these ideologies from her 12th birthday, if not before. But no matter what ensued I would love her unconditionally because she would have been my very — wanted daughter.
Cynthia McFadden

Cynthia McFadden | 09/12/2008 12:00 am

Cynthia McFadden Would First Ask a Question

I can’t imagine a tougher question. I guess I would start by asking her what was in her heart. What was her relationship with the father? How early in the pregnancy is it? I imagine she knows her options only too well so I guess I’d just tell her that I understand each of the choices are hard choices. Each has consequences. Having been pregnant, knowing the thrill of having your own baby inside of you, I could not easily counsel abortion. Having raised a child and knowing the maturity and patience and time it takes to do it well, I could not easily counsel keeping the child. Having been adopted myself and knowing the complications and heartache placing her child with others might cause her, I could not easily counsel putting the baby up for adoption. I would tell her I would love her and respect her whatever her choice. And then I would try to stop talking and listen.




134 Reader Comments (so far…) Sign In or Register to comment

Sherrie Crews
What I did tell her; You do what you think is right for you and your Mom and Dad will be here to support you through it in whatever way we need to and can.
By Sherrie Crews on 09/13/2008 7:54 pm
Alessan O
One mistake is okay, but two is tacky without love and marriage.
By Alessan O on 09/13/2008 9:32 pm
kelsey davies
Sorry i misspelled again i ment mean mot men.
By kelsey davies on 09/13/2008 10:53 pm
RoseMerry Hoffman
Are you ready? Are you prepared for a 20 year or so commitment to be responsible for raising another human? Do you have the means to do this and do this right? If there are any doubts, any at all, abort and abort as early as possible. The fact is, we do not need any more children - there are far too many all ready and we certainly do not need for you bring a child into this world without someone who can give it the best care it needs. The United States should make abortion free and easy. We should encourage birth control but also abortion when it does not work. It will make our society stronger and better. Womb Nazi’s who would take this choice away from women can all go to hell rather than make this a hell on Earth from your overpopulating, free breeding ways!
By RoseMerry Hoffman on 09/14/2008 4:41 am
Bella Mia
Russia has made abortion free and easy, and now Russians are experiencing a demographic crises of epic proportions that will drastically effect their social stability. They are now frantically trying to pay women to have children. Their national and fiscal security now depends on convincing more women to have children. Germany is in the same straits with sewer systems blocked and overrun with weeds from years of unuse due to the dwindling population. It is a huge demographic crisis throughout Europe. The big collapses are coming in the state pension security systems. Mark Steyn wrote an excellent book on the topic called America Alone. “And, if you’re anti-capitalist, don’t console yourself with the thought that you don’t need all those businesses anyway. Big Government depends on bigger population: Americans have a relatively smallish government compared to Canada and Europe, but the US Social Security system assumes a 30 per cent population growth between now and 2075 or so and, even then, expects to be running a deficit after 2017. Now imagine you’re Spain and you’ve got even bigger public pensions liabilities and a population that’s going to be halving every 35 years. The progressive left can be in favor of Big Government and population control but not both. That mutual incompatibility is about to plunge Europe into societal collapse. There is no precedent in human history for economic growth on declining human capital – and that’s before anyone invented unsustainable welfare systems. “True, birth rates are falling all over the world, and it may be that eventually every couple on the planet decides to opt for the western yuppie model of one designer baby at the age of 39. But demographics is a game of last man standing. The groups that succumb to demographic apathy last will have a huge advantage - and those societies with expensive social programs dependent on mass immigration will be in the worst predicament. It’s no consolation for the European Union with its deathbed birth statistics if the Third World’s demographics are also falling: they’re your nursery, they’re the babies you couldn’t be bothered having; if their fertility rate goes the same way yours has, that will be a problem for you long before it’s a problem for them. Unless it corrects course within the next five to ten years, Europe by the end of this century will be a continent after the neutron bomb: the grand buildings will still be standing but the people who built them will be gone. By the next century, German will be spoken only at Hitler, Himmler, Goebbels and Goering’s Monday night poker game in Hell. And long before the Maldive Islands are submerged by “rising sea levels” every Spaniard and Italian will be six foot under. But sure, go ahead: worry about “climate change”. http://216.92.123.84/page24.html
By Bella Mia on 09/14/2008 9:39 am
kelsey davies
Abortion shouldnt be legal.
By kelsey davies on 09/14/2008 10:28 am
Sherrie Crews
Well gee Belia Mia, maybe the solution is to put women into concentration camps and force them to be impregnated and give birth so we can balance the economy. (I hope you Dems see my eyes rolling, the reps will probably think its a reasonable solution.)
By Sherrie Crews on 09/14/2008 10:36 am
Didi Lorillard
Too many of my friends suffer from mysterious aliments that doctors cannot detect, since giving birth to a baby that they were forced to give away. So many women suffer from depression because they had to give up an unplanned baby. Emotionally stunted these women live seemingly unfufilled lives, whereas friends who had an abortion were empowered by having made such an important decision, on their own at such a young age, have gone on to live worthwhile happy lives. No one should have to give birth to a baby that she does not want because that baby will always know that she was not wanted. Whenever I have the opportunity to tell a young person why I believe in a women’s right to choose, I speak my mind. I’ve explained the importance of a person having the right to decide her own future to children as young and ten years old. That’s how important I believe the issue is. Over the years here in Newport, RI, where sex education is not taught until eleventh grade, I’ve followed the lives of seventh and eighth graders whose parents punish their twelve, thirteen, or fourteen year old daughter by making her stay out of school to take care of her baby.
By Didi Lorillard on 09/14/2008 1:11 pm
kelsey davies
I dont think women have the right to kill there babies. As i said in an earlier post they sould teach independent living classes in high school so both women and men know how to live on there own.
By kelsey davies on 09/14/2008 2:15 pm
Didi Lorillard
Ms. Davies, the problem is that in Rhode Island (I don’t know about the other states.) the schools don’t teach what you call “independent living classes” until eleventh grade; by then most eleventh graders have had an average of twenty sexual partners, according to a recent study. When girls as young as twelve are having babies and thereby having to leave school in order to take care of those babies, who is supposed to take care of those twelve year olds having babies? These young girls become chronically depressed with a depression that lasts a life time. If you have ever been depressed, then you understand how debilitating depression can be. These twelve year old girls should be in high school learning life skills that will help her take care of and provide for a family when she is ready to do so.
By Didi Lorillard on 09/14/2008 2:43 pm
kelsey davies
Well for one thing if there parents cared at all they would help a little. They should offer independent living classes not only in high school in middle school too. Have classes like independent living, personal development, and marriage and family. If i were in that situation abortion would not be an option it might be my only chance to have a baby.
By kelsey davies on 09/14/2008 5:51 pm
Dorothy Nichols
I was 19 when I first got pregnant, I had dropped out of high school and had only ever held one job. I was absolutely terrified - words just don’t suffice to describe how scary that situation can be. The father swore upon all things holy or sacred he would be there and take care of us, and I believed him. We moved into my mom’s house, and a few months later I kicked him out because he had yet to get a job - any job would have done, really - and I knew I wasn’t up to supporting a kid and the father. He never did become dependable, and a few years ago I pretty much told him to leave our lives and not come back until he grew up. I haven’t seen or heard from him since. The second time, a few years later, that I got pregnant was only slightly better. He had a job, and a place of his own - but in the end refused to do what it was going to take to get us into a place big enough for a family. Oh, he also never really accepted that I earned more than he did at the time - so that’s a sign right there, isn’t it? That relationship didn’t last the pregnancy, either. He sees his daughter on the weekends, and makes his child support payments about half the time. I was fortunate to have had support from family and friends in both situations. It has been rough going - I’m 31 and working on a college degree now, and won’t be in the workforce again full-time for another year and half. I’m lucky enough to have found someone who supports me fully and loves me and my kids. I have new daughter through him who is now twelve, and I’ve already discussed with her regular birth control, emergency contraception, STD prevention, and promised to provide her with these things without judgment. So: I would be totally straight - if you choose to keep the child, be prepared to bear the full responsibility. This means time, effort, energy, finances, at the very least postponing your own goals, medical care for her and the child - the whole shebang. I’d be totally straight about the options - all the options. I would emphasize that the family would be here for her, and help her out with a baby should she decide to keep it. And I would do my very best to be around when that baby arrived - because you need someone to tell you it’s okay to let a baby cry if it just becomes too much, that babies don’t break nearly as easily as you might think, and all those other wonderful things my mom passed on to me. I would make it clear that we would help her make a plan to achieve independence financially, and support her fully in whatever education or career choices she made. I would support her if she chose adoption - though I would encourage her to choose someone in the family, or at the very least an agency that allowed her to choose a loving family. I would support her if she chose abortion, help her pay for it if necessary, and be there to make sure she was okay - and beyond that I would make sure she knew that I would protect her privacy. And I would do everything I could short of totally alienating her to get her on birth control so that it doesn’t happen again.
By Dorothy Nichols on 09/15/2008 10:57 am
LA R
I would say: I will not raise this child for you. You have some decisions to make. What alternatives have you considered? What are the pros and cons of each? Do you know what resources are available for helping you make your decision? This is not the end of the world and you are in charge. But that means you and your child have to accept the consequences of the choices you make. You don’t have to decide right now, so think about this and make some notes. Then we’ll talk again about it in two days. Just remember, the one rule is that I will not raise this child for you.
By LA R on 09/16/2008 11:49 am
Dalissa Vargas
I find it interesting in the four responses above the presumption is that the girl would be a teenager, although the question never specifies that. As a woman who got pregnant at the age of 32 at a time when I was not financially prepared to raise a child but had always wanted children I would say two things resonated in my experience, one was a choice I personally made about my situation the other was the advice of my distraught and disappointed mother. My mother through her anger and disappointment (who is pro choice) said to me when I did not have an answer regarding if I was going to have the baby — If you have one percent of doubt around terminating this pregnancy it is the wrong decision. It is a choice you can not alter and take back and it is a choice you will never get a second chance at. As tough as the prospect of raising a child or giving one up for adoption is, abortion is something you absolutely should have 100% certainty about - even in the pain of making the decision, your gut will tell you if it is the right decision for you. The second was I knew my relationship with my daughter’s father was not a love relationship. It was one of respect and joy but we were not in a place of committing to one another. When I chose to have the baby, I was diligent in not allowing the two issues to influence each other. What I mean is, the conversations, choices and decisions we made around the baby had nothing to do with our personal/romantic relationship. The baby and our role as parents was separate. I didn’t want to have clouded emotions and make him out to be more to me because I was having his child. As we got through my pregnancy it became very evident he was not going to have any role in my daughter’s life and I am forever grateful emotionally that at the beginning I had separated the two issues. It has left me in a place that I am content with the choices I have made and most of all I am without anger. I have lingering sadness that my daughter’s father has chosen to not be a part of her life, but I don’t harbor ill will or a sense of revenge around it. As a result my daughter is surrounded by love - not tension.
By Dalissa Vargas on 10/01/2008 12:39 pm