146 Reader Comments (so far…) Sign In or Register to comment
No question, my dad ! He was only in my life 13 years, before dying from heart disease. With todays technology, he would still be alive. He was very caring and patient. He was a teacher before going into the military. We had wonderful conversations and we were close. I have missed him everyday for over 40 years ! My mother should never have had children, I have a half brother raised by my grandmother and had a younger brother that took his own life years ago. My mother and I were never close, she is very difficult to deal with. She got so mad at me when my grandmother died that she disinherited me. We had been extranged for over 25 years. She celebrated her 90th birthday last year and I attempted calling her, (she lives 600 miles away) I was unable to reach her. I ran into a friend of hers and she gave me her number and said she thought my mother would like to hear from me. I called her, told her who I was, I wasn’t sure she knew who I was so I continued talking. Finally she said ” Didn’t you used to be my daughter ?” That said it all! I said yes, I guess I used to be. I told her about her grandchildren, her great grandchild, she is very unemotional. I have spoken to her several times over the past five months, it’s like talking to a neighbor that you don’t know very well. She still has a lot of anger. She is extremely vague about how she spends her time. When I mentioned that I would like to go and visit her, she said no, you can’t come, I don’t want you to see my house. She said it was a mess, I told her I could help her but she said she didn’t want me to. I’m not sure if I should honor her wishes or I should go and see what her living conditions are.
Suzanne, If it were me I’d send her a letter (typed with a large font so she can see) a few photos, keep light touch and affirm some of her good qualities. (everyone has some) Try to think of the situation from where she is now, 90 and stuck, probably bitter and embarrassed about her house, doesn’t want upset. But love for even six months can undo 100 years without it and make everything bloom. Difficult people don’t get less difficult so have to approach them with softness, kindness, affirmation. they’re very touchy so any perception of blame just hardens the walls. Perhaps send along that prayer of Saint Francis of Assisi, it’s a good one even for people who aren’t religious or Catholic. Maybe some flowers. Ask her friend what is a good way to approach her. The friend already said she’d like to hear from you. Try not to be oversensitive. “Didn’t you used to be my daughter” doesn’t necessarily say everything. It says she is 90. I’d keep on trying and anticipate a pleasant surprise or only the satisfaction after she dies that you did the right thing. Which is a lot. If someone asked me not to come, I’d respect that for now. If you go against stated wishes it’ll only prove you can’t be trusted. She may be trying to protect her independance and concerned if someone judges her not able to take care of the house they could perhaps stick her in a home, etc. As Audrey Hepburn said, people need to be redeemed and redeemed and redeemed. So start from where she is right now and go from there. By trying to understand her you may gain knowledge that will throw everything in a whole new light. I know it isn’t exactly fair to be cast in the reverse role, but things can change. Or maybe she is just a joyless person and you can confirm that and move on. Congratulations for undertaking something hard. Good luck to both of you.
“Make me an instrument of your peace.
Where there is hatred, let me sow love;
where there is injury,pardon;
where there is doubt, faith;
where there is despair, hope;
where there is darkness, light;
and where there is sadness, joy.
Grant that I may not so much seek
to be consoled as to console;
to be understood as to understand;
to be loved as to love.
For it is in giving that we receive;
it is in pardoning that we are pardoned;
and it is in dying that we are born to eternal life.”
Suzanne de Cornelia,
Thank you for your kind words and wonderful advice, you are a very caring person, I love that we share the same first name. I don’t have any hurt feelings. I have accepted that she is the way she is and I am able to talk with her now without letting her manipulate me or get me into an agrument. I just let her talk and then we move on. She is one of those people that can not take any responsibility for her own actions, she always sees herself as the victim. A lot of things are clear to me that I hadn’t realized before. I was trying to keep my story brief but I sent flowers and fruit at Christmas. When my children were visiting we called her, my son spoke to her, we were not able to reach her when my daughter was visiting. I sent photos of our family explaining who everyone is. I sent a card at Valentines with money for a treat ( I didn’t know what she might like or need), she called me and asked me if I had misplaced some money. I have called her every other week. My brother was planning to go and visit her and she refused to see him, he didn’t make the trip so we don’t know if she would have changed her mind. I have assured her that I understand that she has not been able to keep her house the way she would like to and I would be happy to come and help her. I would never try to put her in a home,she would hate it. She seems like she is still very self sufficient. However, I am concerned about her, she tells me she drives, shops and cooks for herself. I know there are agencies that would be able to help her now or in the future, that would go to her house, help her run errands etc.
I think I am a better mother to my children because of having her for a mother.
Suzanne, “I think I am a better mother to my children because of having her for a mother.” that’s a tremendous gift to be the kind of person who learns/improves even from disappointments. You bridged a 25 year gap…that’s wonderful too. Reminds me that JFK once got a letter from a poor shut-in without a TV…he asked his staff to rush a new TV to the elderly lady right away. He received another letter from her that berated him for the small size of the TV “and with all your money!” He said, “She isn’t a shut-in, they locked her in.” He was so funny.
Both of my parents were SO important to me. If I had only known how important earlier!!!! My mom died in 1992 at the age of 72 and my Dad died in 2004 at the age of 87. They were both bright, kind, giving, loving, well-rounded people with love for us and for each other. Mom was quick witted, a fantastic cook, loved puzzles and games and anything involving the English language. She also loved music from all decades, and instilled that in each of us and consequently in her grandchildren. Dad was the most selfless man I’ve ever met. He was kind to a fault. Every single person without exception that ever met him loved him instantly. He was so schooled in history and in the English language and his and Mom’s love for knowledge was remarkable. I miss them so much. I truly do feel like an orphan. My life has less meaning with them gone. Their presence in my life was extraordinary and special. I talk out loud to them many times a day and cry over not being able to call them or speak to them. I have a craving in my heart to hear their voices and feel their hugs. My Mom was Jewish and my Dad was a sounthern “christian” boy. They met on Christmas Eve in New York and my Dad was shipping out during WW11 the next morning. They talked all night and wrote to each other the whole time he was gone. As his ship limped in after being hit (he was on a destroyer) he couldn’t wait to see hi Sara again. So, after docking in California, he journeyed across the country to New York and married his Sara after only seeing each other once. They stayed together until her death and he never remarried. We call it “the greatest love story ever told”. You would love the whole story. So, both parents were equally important to me, because they were my heroes and they allowed me to be their hero too. That is how they treated everyone. Everyone was special in their eyes. God, how I miss them. Michele
Michele, What a wonderful story that brought tears to my eyes. My son and I have also been super close since he was born. He’s an only child and his father died very young. Since I worry about him having the same feelings you express here, I’ve said to him….”..never cry for me when I’m gone. I had a terrific life and you were the greatest gift in it.” Primoridal relationships never end…you’ll meet them again…you’re connected still. What would your parents say to you? After Audrey Hepburn died her longtime partner Rob Wolders said you discover the depth of your pain has an inverse relationship with the amount of your love. I missed someone everyday for 20 years too. But to have that much love for someone is to be truly blessed still…even though you can’t deny the big part of your heart that is gone, you are still loved by them through eternity and blessed. This is a great story. Write it down!
Unfortunately, neither my mother or my father. My mother was so narcissistic and was always involved with my brother—I could never meet her standards. My father traveled all the time, so he too was unavailable. Finally, my brother terrorized me, so I was left totally alone. I grew up feeling ‘less than’ and not worthy, however, I have recently realized that my family was presenting me keys to my own self-worth, except in a backwards way. I finally have taken my key to stand up for myself, know that I am an intelligent woman and do not need others to clarify my worthiness for me. I am a loving, strong woman and am pleased to announce such to the world.
A weekend alcoholic that became abusive to his wife in his drunkenness. The second of their 4 children often prayed for his death. Never mind his physical and mental abusive outbursts, gambling and adulteress behavior; his widow now so proudly recounts the wonderful times they shared and so proudly states the fact that they were married for more than 57 years. An outsider would say that he was a fitting husband, attentive father and a constant provider for his family. He never missed a day’s work because of his seemingly uncontrollable urges. I resented his physical being and especially enjoyed his drunken weekend that kept him away for two days. Neither I, nor my siblings ever had a need for anything and were granted many of our desires. You see, life gives us so much knowledge that someone’s story cannot give its full account into a person’s past. You see, we all have baggage, good and bad. In later years my grandmother told me that my father, as a child, had a horrible accident on a farm where he was dragged by a horse with the harness hung around his heck that left him with what was later believed to have caused a brain injury. I spent my teenage years hating him for what he was doing to mom and causing his family pain. Above all, at that time I couldn’t understand why mom would not leave him. She spent many years caring for him; you see he was an insulin dependent diabetic that in later years left him totally dependent upon her care. He was blessed, lived to be 80 and with all of his faults left a lasting impression on all of us. You see he never learned to read or write. Aside from his drunkenness, he had a quiet manner, extraordinary mathematical skills and an exceptional memory; shared many stories with us about his life living on a sharecropper’s farm. My mother now shares with me how much she misses him. I wish I could say the same. I am very close to my mother. She is my best friend. She is religious, patient, strong, honest, energetic, and would do anything for her children. At 87 she lives alone and we talk every day. I believe I am a stronger person having lived with hate in my heart and learned to love through experience and endurance. I cannot say one is more important to me than the other; I have learned so much from each of them however I am my mother’s daughter. God gave me to them and they both cared for me with what they had. I am here, I am healthy and I am at peace. I love them equally for what they have given me, I am blessed.
I like to think that I am closer to my Dad, but in reality, I know I am not. Don’t get me wrong….I am Daddy’s girl, and I am very proud of it. He has always been the one I called on whenever I thought there was a problem with my car or there was a plumbing issue I thought he could walk me through over the phone. I especially came to depend on him when I was married because my husband was so inadequate on many levels, I felt my dad was the only one I could turn to. OVer the last three or four years, I have found myself relying on my father less and relying on my boyfriend more. The reason—Jeff is a lot like my father, and I know I can depend on him just like I have always been able to depend on Daddy. The relationship I have with my mother has always been good, but I have always felt like I was being judged for being overweight or making decisions that she “knew” were the wrong decisions. The funny thing is that most of my life has been a carbon copy of hers: being overweight, marrying an abusive man—her first physically abused her, my first mentally abused me—and now we are with basically the type of man…someone who wants to protect us and take care of us while at the same time, he wants us to take care of him.
I love both of my parents deeply, and I cannot imagine my life without either one of them. I can see as I grow older just how blessed my life has been because of them and the examples that they set before my brother and me. They have taught me the importance of a good name/reputation, the value of hard work and discipline, and the importance of attending church and the role of faith in our lives.
I was always a daddy’s girl. Sadly, my dad died young. My mother and I always had “issues”, especially in my teen years, mostly because she was such a strong woman and I felt inadequate by comparison. Thankfully I think we resolved those issues before I lost her too. My dad gave me the best thing, an example of what a good, loving man is. My mom gave me a great example of what I could be.
Neither. My parents should never have had kids. They, however, lived the “formula”… grow up, buy house, have kids, marry them off to someone else so they becomes someone else’s problem. It was like being raised by abusive, yet, distant and disconnected zombies… My sister and I were beat over the slightest offense… shoes on the floor of your closet??? beatings… cry??? beatings…
I have been married for over 22 years and have two wonderful daughters. When my oldest has a concert or my youngest has a game, it really never occurs to me that I should call my parents and invite them to the concert and/or game. They just have no interest in being a part of our lives. My parents are morbidly obese, and all they do is eat and watch television all day long. My mother does, however, call me when someone dies… she just loves to make the telephone call about someone’s death or tragedy… my sister and I call it the “death call”… “Did you get the Death Call today about Aunt Mary?”… “Yes, I got it”…
I guess I could say that my mother has influenced me the most. When something comes up that I don’t know how to handle, I think… “what would my mother had done?”… then, I do the exact opposit…
very good question. obviously it brings up intense stuff for us all in the different ways we relate to each of our parents. my father was a classic relatively distant quiet type, however my brothers and i always had the sense that he taught us integrity, respect for him, individuals and for ourselves and the room to roam creatively or around the neighborhood, etc. we alsways had the sense we were taken care of, and allowed to make our own mistakes and grow from them. i definitely had a superman view of him for most of my life. life circumstances at this point are proving his all too human fallibity now that he’s in the last phases of life….our mother was narcissitic and had mental health (never addressed) and health issues which made our lives very difficult in her constant criticism, inability to please her no matter what, everything and nothing we did was ever seen as positive and always was about her rather than our own growth. thanlk god for the sense of one stable parent. i recall a conversation w/ my father from when i was in college and home for a weekend. there had been another incredibly vitriolic fight with my mother where she was blaming some unknown public humiliation on me yet again. I was sobbing and throwing my belongings back into my little car to head back to school. my father was trying to explain her yet again, and i said the boys and i don’t have a choice, she’s our mother, but you do, why didn’t you ever leave her rather than put up with her insanity, and to my dying days i will never forget his answer, “someone has to take care of her.” i recently relayed this story to some in laws, re: the mental illness of one of their own, and this aunt of my husband, replied, “now that’s love.” so you can see why i have had a lifetime of idolizing view of my father. though i am now able to see that he was not perfect, either.but he was always honorable.
146 Reader Comments (so far…) Sign In or Register to comment