Sign in to wowOwow

Enter the email address that you used when registering at wowOwow.
The password field is case sensitive. Click here if you have forgotten your password.

Please register for wowOwow

Newsletter subscriptions
Sign up to receive wowOwow's weekly newsletter and get our best picks delivered right to your inbox. Our newsletter content is hand-picked by the wowOwow editorial team and provides the top features, news, and commentary from our site. Subscribing to our newsletter is free and safe. We will never share your email or other information with a third-party without your direct consent.
By registering, you indicate that you have read and agree
with our privacy policy and terms of service.

Gay-to-Straight Therapy, APA | 08/06/2009 9:10 am

APA Says Gay-to-Straight Therapy Tactics Just Don't Work

America’s largest psychological group says efforts to switch a person’s sexual orientation through aversive treatments might cause harm — including loss of sexual feeling, thoughts of suicide, depression and more
By The Staff of wowOwow.com
© Shutterstock

For years, many mental-health professionals have been treating patients who are gay or think they may be by telling them they can change who they are through therapy and other treatments. Well now, the country’s leading psychological group says there’s no proof such tactics work.

"Contrary to claims of sexual orientation change advocates and practitioners, there is insufficient evidence to support the use of psychological interventions to change sexual orientation," said Judith M. Glassgold, PsyD, chair of the American Psychological Association’s Task Force on Appropriate Therapeutic Responses to Sexual Orientation. "At most, certain studies suggested that some individuals learned how to ignore or not act on their homosexual attractions."

According to the APA, there’s evidence that efforts to switch a person’s sexual orientation through aversive treatments might cause harm — including loss of sexual feeling, thoughts of suicide, depression, anxiety, spiritual distress and a negative self-image. Better treatments offered include encouraging celibacy or switching to churches that are more accepting. In fact, the APA declassified homosexuality as a mental disorder in 1973, a move based on scientific evidence and supported by various practitioners in the community.

"Homophobia, bias and discrimination are what make it difficult for people to accept and be open about their sexual orientation," said Joe Solmonese, president of the Human Rights Campaign. "We have to change hearts and minds, not our sexual orientation, and we are hopeful that the position of the APA helps to heal those who have been hurt by rejection and betrayal, and to foster greater awareness, skills and knowledge among mental health professionals." 

Of course, not everyone sides with the APA’s suggestions.

Alan Chambers, president of Exodus International ministries and the author of "Leaving Homosexuality" is one of them. He said he’s proof that such mental transformations can work. "The fact is that there are tens of thousands of men and women just like me who once identified as gay," Chambers told CNN, noting that about a third of those who try to switch their sexual orientation through Exodus ministries are successful. "For me and for these people, the truth is change is possible."

What do you think of APA’s recommendations? Will it be more harmful or helpful?

34 Reader Comments (so far…) Sign In or Register to comment

C Hardy

Why can’t we just let people be who they want to be?  Let them feel what they want to feel?  Why are we always wanting to change someone to our normal?  Whats normal for me is not normal for everyone…

 

By C Hardy on 08/06/2009 9:47 am
georgia fatwood
Hi CH…reminds me of my favorite line from "The Fantasticks"….."Please, god, please…don’t let me be NORRR-MAL-L-L….!"
By georgia fatwood on 08/07/2009 10:30 am
S G
C Hardy I couldn’t agree more. You are so right;)
By S G on 08/08/2009 9:44 am
carly torino
The APA just confirmed what every intelligent person already knew. there is a related post at http://iamsoannoyed.com/?page_id=588
By carly torino on 08/06/2009 9:52 am
Maggie W

Good grief and then some!  They have been treating homosexuality as a " mental disorder"????  Please tell me that was a misprint or some kind of early April Fool’s joke.

By Maggie W on 08/06/2009 10:09 am
Kelly In Texas

Who has been treating homosexuality as a "mental disorder?" What associations? What mental health specialists? Which ones?

I believe that homosexuality is a confusion of sexual identity that happens at an early age. Mental disorder…no. No more than having a preference for blondes or redheads is a mental disorder.

By Kelly In Texas on 08/06/2009 7:53 pm
Andrea Brandon

Maggie, no, no, no.

The wowowow staff once again failed to read the APA article correctly. Search a little lower in this thread and fine my other responses to what the APA really said.

By Andrea Brandon on 08/07/2009 3:33 pm
Nancy Cleveland
Well, it’s about time the APA reversed their hypothesis publicly…and God knows why they even went there in the first place!  As to Exodis Ministries president, Alan Chambers…with all due respect I’d venture to suppose that most of his convertees either were not gay (and possibly ‘experimenting’) or are in some form of denial of their true selves, tamping down what they, themselves, cannot find comfortable or possibly find damaging to career, family expectations, whatever.  It took me half my life (given that I plan to live until I reach my century…you do the math! :)  )  and 28yrs. of marriage (and he WAS a wonderful man) to understand why I’d never been comfortable, didn’t seem to fit my own skin.  When I did, it came as quite a shock, frankly, but once recognising and accepting it I could not believe the change in me.  I felt I had "come home" to myself, I ‘fit’, was happier and more peaceful than I had ever been;  much less of the introvert…even my spirituality was enhanced.  Then, two years later I met my partner…we have been together twelve years and in those twelve years everything has been in place, right.  I love my world, love my life…I love me more than I could ever have thought possible.  Mental disorder??  Hmmmm…okay, then… 
By Nancy Cleveland on 08/06/2009 10:26 am
Andrea Brandon

Nancy,

No, No, NO. Read all my posts on this thread.

Once again the wowowow staff has outdone themselves and totally misinterpreted what the APA said.

By Andrea Brandon on 08/07/2009 3:34 pm
F P

The APA says that secular therapists should be mindful that some patients will choose faith over health and respect the patients’ decisions. Exodus sees that as an endorsement of their monstrous practices.
By F P on 08/06/2009 10:32 am
Andrea Brandon

FP,

Where did you read that?

Who is "Exodus"?

By Andrea Brandon on 08/07/2009 3:38 pm
Andrea Brandon
"For years, many psychologists have been treating patients who are gay or think they may be by telling them they can change who they are through therapy and other treatments. " 

That is such total bull, wowowow, and you should apologize to the APA for your words.  You’ve twisted them. You didn’t understand what you read. But twisting words seems to be common on this website. I am appalled at the lack of ability of the wowowow staff to read and comprehend.

What the APA found was that a very “small but persistent group of therapists, often allied with religious conservatives, were maintaining that gays can change.”  You should know, too, that the term “mental health professionals” can include everything but the kitchen sink, including religious leaders themselves.

If you had bothered to read the article, or better yet, linked it to the wowow website so we could read it without your erroneously distorted picture, you would have noted that the report the APA released   “…breaks new ground in its detailed and nuanced assessment of how therapists should deal with gay clients struggling to remain loyal to a religious faith that disapproves of homosexuality.” 

I do not know of one Ph.D. level psychologist or MFT  who condones or practices a treatment protocol that re-trains a homosexual into a heterosexual. Religious leaders apparently refuse to believe their methods don’t work..

 

http://www.google.com/hostednews/ap/article/ALeqM5imq5p7gufaDJosXTctawTPjW7uDwD99T09TG0

  Once again, wowowow, you’ve outdone yourself in misinterpreting what was written and have instead put an asinine slant on the subject. You should be ashamed.
By Andrea Brandon on 08/06/2009 5:40 pm
F P
I know of at least one: Marcus Bachmann, Michelle’s husband, a Christian therapist that says he cures gays. You could look it up.
By F P on 08/07/2009 7:12 am
F P
oops! typo:  make that "who says". 
By F P on 08/07/2009 8:40 am
Andrea Brandon

FP,

As I wrote before, "I do not know of one Ph.D. level psychologist or MFT  who condones or practices a treatment protocol that re-trains a homosexual into a heterosexual." By that I meant that I do not personally know of one. [And I know many psychologists and MFT’s.]   You see, psychologists do not see homosexuality as pathological [a mental health disorder nor is it a medical condition]. It is not in the DSM-IV TR, the "bible" for mental health pathology. 

I looked up Marcus Bachmann and he does indeed provide "re-orientation" counseling. I don’t know how he can make the claim that he cures gays. How can he prove it? And what’s to cure when it’s not a disease or a pathology?

I’m not going to delve into sexual attraction. Suffice it to say that if it’s repressed in any way there will invariably be  anxiety and tremendous dissatisfaction with life.

So is Dr. Bachmann and others repressing gender identity? 

The man has a deep religious connection and I suspect that he and others may not tolerate gay people due to their religious indoctrination. This is exactly the kind of "mental health professional" that the APA was referring to.

By Andrea Brandon on 08/07/2009 2:22 pm