Sign in to wowOwow

Enter the email address that you used when registering at wowOwow.
The password field is case sensitive. Click here if you have forgotten your password.

Please register for wowOwow

Newsletter subscriptions
Sign up to receive wowOwow's weekly newsletter and get our best picks delivered right to your inbox. Our newsletter content is hand-picked by the wowOwow editorial team and provides the top features, news, and commentary from our site. Subscribing to our newsletter is free and safe. We will never share your email or other information with a third-party without your direct consent.
By registering, you indicate that you have read and agree
with our privacy policy and terms of service.

Dear Margo | 09/11/2009 2:00 am

Dear Margo: Love Thy Neighbor (or Brother) as Thyself -- Unless He Is Gay …

Margo Howard

Love Thy Neighbor (or Brother) as Thyself — Unless He Is Gay …

Dear Margo: I need advice about how to address my oldest brother’s hurtful actions toward me and the paralysis it has caused my family. I am a 40-year-old gay man in the Bible Belt. Last December, I married my partner of five years in a legally recognized ceremony in New England. Knowing that many people would be unable to join us out of state, we arranged a reception at our home down south a month later. We were blessed to have over a dozen people travel through a snowstorm to join us in December (including my father and middle brother from Georgia) and another 100 people at our reception the following month. My oldest brother, however, an evangelical Christian, was not one of them.

He told my father and brother that he can’t acknowledge our marriage because it conflicts with his Christian beliefs — even though we were all raised in the same Southern Baptist household and my husband and I are Christian, as well. We have not spoken since Christmas. What worries me is that the rest of my family is so afraid of potential clashes that they’ve essentially canceled our regular family events. How can I help the rest of my family to move forward, or must this no-winners war consume our future? — Southern Discomfort

Dear South: This is an old and sad story. In your case, something’s got to give, or rather, someone. I suggest you tell your relatives that the traditional family occasions you’ve celebrated in the past must continue. Because your brother is, let us say, intransigent, propose that you and your husband alternate get-togethers with your brother. Alas, you will not change his mind, because while you and I might think him benighted, he believes his religion is dictating his responses. I am more impressed with the way your father and middle brother are interpreting their Christian beliefs. — Margo, sadly 

Calling All Greeting Card Companies!

Dear Margo: I am a girl who just turned 25 (and, by the way, I was born a boy). You may have heard stories about transgender people who are aware, even as young children, of what their situation is. Not me. In my case, the confusion lasted until about eight months ago. I am currently in the process of transitioning to life as a woman. I live as a female 100 percent of the time while at home, and about 60 percent of the time when I go out. I would like to be "full time" ASAP, but this is problematic due to the physical realities of the transition process. For example, I am not allowed to shave or wear makeup 24 hours prior to facial electrolysis appointments. My problem is my mother. She is one of those people who professes, "I am open-minded, I am accepting," but she doesn’t act like it.

For my birthday this week she sent me a birthday card that said "Dear Son" on it. Now, I realize I was her son for a long time, and that Hallmark doesn’t sell birthday cards that say "Dear Son/Daughter" or "Happy Birthday, Offspring." I predicted my dad would react poorly, but as it turned out, I did not give him enough credit. On the night I told him, he said no matter what happened he would always be there for me because he loves me. Why can’t my mom be like that? — Preferring Pink but Feeling Blue

Dear Pre: I am glad your dad was quick to get with the program, and I hope you cut your mother a little slack. It has to be difficult, I am guessing, for any parent — after a quarter of a century — to redo one’s thinking from "him" to "her." If there was a passive-aggressive element to her choosing a card that said "Son," I expect that as you progress on your journey of change she will feel more at home with your new persona. Good luck. — Margo, transformatively

***
Dear Margo is written by Margo Howard, Ann Landers’ daughter. All letters must be sent via e-mail to dearmargo@creators.com. Due to a high volume of e-mail, not all letters will be answered. To read more about Margo Howard, click here.

COPYRIGHT 2009 MARGO HOWARD
DISTRIBUTED BY CREATORS SYNDICATE, INC.

Every Thursday and Friday, you can find "Dear Margo" and her latest words of wisdom on our home page at www.wowowow.com. Or better yet, click to sign up for an instant email alert that will send a message right to your in-box every time a new "Dear Margo" column is posted on wowOwow. 

Click here for all "Dear Margo" columns.

 

94 Reader Comments (so far…) Sign In or Register to comment

Zainab A

Letter #1: I find it interesting how this type of view (held by his evangelical Christian brother) is not only found in Christianity, but in Islam as well (I say this as a Muslim who encounters it often). It is somehow this idea that acknowledging and accepting someone for who they are somehow means you are also completely condoning and/or agreeing with their behavior. His brother, therefore, if he doesn’t "agree" with Southern Discomfort’s choices in life (marrying someone of the same sex), should at least be able to agree that he loves his brother, regardless, and look past whatever "behavior" he doesn’t like when they are forced to interact and at least be civil, if not friendly. No one is asking him to enter into a gay marriage, just for a little tolerance on the part of his brother.

Letter #2:  I agree the mother sounds a little passive-aggressive, though if not, still just not able to completely accept the fact that the person she considered her son for so long is now her daughter. I think with time, however, and when Preferring Pink fully transitions to being a girl "full-time", then it might finally hit her.

By Zainab A on 09/11/2009 1:23 am
Christine L.

LW#1: "Intransigent"…good word, Margo. The only problem I have is the part where you say the writer "and [his] husband alternate get-togethers with [his] brother." I feel like the writer’s husband would probably feel a bit uncomfortable in that situation, without having HIS husband (the writer of the letter) present around such (at least theologically different) family members.

I think you should let the more supportive family members know that you don’t want your family traditions to stop (like Margo said), and if you must, plan/host these regular family events yourselves. It seems like your brother’s the one who will end up ostracized due to his ignorance.

LW#2: I agree with Margo. Never having been in the situation of having a child myself (I’m pretty young) I can still see why it would be hard for a mother to suddenly accept/understand the fact that the boy she gave birth to is not (really) a boy. You say your mother professes herself to be "open-minded … accepting," and she probably is; I can believe that. It just seems like she’s simply having a hard time relating her true beliefs about things like this to her own kin. I don’t know how old you are, but your mother probably just isn’t used to this "you". You’re so lucky to have at least one supportive parent. It’s only been 8 months; I have a feeling your mother will come around eventually, and reconcile with her feelings and beliefs. In the mean time, be patient and understand.

By Christine L. on 09/11/2009 1:49 am
Rachel F

"The only problem I have is the part where you say the writer "and [his] husband alternate get-togethers with [his] brother." I feel like the writer’s husband would probably feel a bit uncomfortable in that situation, without having HIS husband (the writer of the letter) present around such (at least theologically different) family members."

Christine, I think Margo means LW#1/spouse show up at one, then next time the brother shows up, then they do, etc. :-)

By Rachel F on 09/11/2009 8:34 am
RS Gar

I thought she was saying that the writer along WITH his husband attend functions on an alternating basis with the brother, so their paths never have to cross.

By RS Gar on 09/11/2009 12:43 pm
Jessica Dury

It takes time to adjust to the switch between pronouns and even someone who is open minded will slip up for a while even after years especially when referring to childhood. Birthdays, holidays and all things that are designated he/she, son/daughter will just take time to face the change.

Please don’t read anything into it yet. It may have been a slip up or it may be denial and not necessarily a passive aggressive attempt to point out the difference.

Btw, how you respond to these slip-ups can go a long way in helping with the process.

By Jessica Dury on 09/11/2009 2:04 am
Karleen S
I agree with you.  I don’t think anything was meant by it, and LW2 is too keenly attuned to the issue because s/he probably *is* confronted negatively about it a great deal.  I don’t think that thinking in terms of "son" still means she’s unaccepting.  Transgender issue is still relatively new and etiquette is still being developed.
By Karleen S on 09/11/2009 8:55 am
Cecile Tunstead

I agree.  Many people simply do not know that it is correct to refer to a pre-op transgender as their true gender and not their current biological gender.

By Cecile Tunstead on 09/11/2009 9:04 am
Jessica Dury
If it’s someone I’ve known all my life as in seeing them in both sexes then the switch of pronouns is harder to adjust to and it embarrasses me when I slip up so if the person is forgiving and ignores the slip, it is greatly appreciated. For those I’ve meet and never saw them as the other sex meaning I never visualized them as the other sex then I only mess up when discussing the issue with them. Some people who physically look one sex never give off the impression of their birth sex so knowing of the change or that it will happen doesn’t cause such a problem to me. Btw, I’ve known a few who struggled with this issue.
By Jessica Dury on 09/11/2009 1:24 pm
RS Gar
An old school pal who was on the verge of beginning The Change when we were in our 20’s and partied together is now a woman and lives in my neighborhood in another city. I ran into her one time with my mom and said, "Mom, this is X - he and I went to school together." My old friend (totally looking female) blanched and I wanted to die on the spot. I still run into her from time to time and she is cordial but a bit chilly. I can hardly blame her, yikes!
By RS Gar on 09/11/2009 1:46 pm
samantha brehm

#1 Have you tried calling your brother and "clearing the air" , maybe re assuring him that you are not trying to "convert him" or change his mind on the topic but that it would be lovely if your family did not have to be torn in two would help to ease the stick out of his butt. Your brother needs to be reminded that simply coexisting in the same family circle with someone does not mean any "gayness" will rub off on him …

#2 If you have a penis you are still her son.. maybe wearing girl clothes for 8 months or so seems to be just another phase you are going through to her- I am sure she has seen you go through many phases and hopes this too shall pass. Yes she loved you when you were 2 and eating glue and yes she loves you now.  Just because she doesn’t express it the way you would like doesn’t mean she loves you any less.

By samantha brehm on 09/11/2009 2:32 am
Elle Troy

#1: These people can’t be reasoned with if when they’re that zealous.

 

#2: Sex is what’s between the legs; GENDER is what’s between the ears (and in the heart).  Let’s hope mom adjusts.  The person with the penis is her DAUGHTER.

By Elle Troy on 09/11/2009 6:12 am
Karleen S

You’ve got that right! (#1).  I got into a "discussion" very recently with someone about gay marriage and he started thumping the bible and threw out Sodom and Gomorrah as proof that god doesn’t like gays and they shouldn’t be given full acceptance.  I had to laugh because apparently he stopped reading the story after the first few lines.  I asked him if, given that Lot and his family were spared, that meant god approves of offering your daughters to an angry mob, because that’s what he did when he first tried to quell the issue.  Also, the jury/interpreters are still out as to whether the whole thing was about homosexuality or the city being inhospitable to outsiders.  You know, closed off and unaccepting.  Nevertheless, after Lot and his family escaped, and the unnamed wife turned into a pillar of salt, you then have the daughters getting daddy drunk and bearing children with him.  If this story is supposed to be an example of what’s right and wrong, that makes me kind of scared.  Of course my "friend" abandoned that one and invoked Leviticus and the verses about abomination, and I had to point out that also in Leviticus lobster, swordfish, oysters, and women wearing pants are also abominations and he cannot pick and choose.  That always leads to Mosaic law being done away with by Jesus Christ in the New Testament, so those dietary restrictions are not valid to Christians.  Well, it’s all part of the same Mosaic law, so Christ must have done away with the whole gay thing, too.  In the end, if god created everything, then how can anything he made be an abomination?

Until people can actually reconcile the whole bible, cherry-picking what’s good and evil to suit a personal outlook or interpretation is more wrong than the issue they’re trying to apply it to.  Especially when a lot of that reconciliation reveals Christ to very liberal, and these zealous, exclusionary attitudes are anything but Christlike.

By Karleen S on 09/11/2009 9:15 am
Lubna Dovel
I am not a Christian but probably should do a reading of the Bible again, just to remind myself of that stuff. I get tired of hearing people talk about abominations and sins, but I cannot imagine any book or word representing God as being judgemental or hateful, which is what a lot of people who preach from Bibles also tend to be.
By Lubna Dovel on 09/11/2009 10:47 am
Karleen S
That’s so true.  It’s almost because I read the bible that I finally determined I was an atheist.  I have also found that I probably know more of what’s in the bible than religious folk who just tend to thump the cover.
By Karleen S on 09/11/2009 11:21 am
Jrz Wrld
Haha, Karleen, that’s what happened to me. I started reading the bible out of intellectual curiosity, and eventually decided it was too incoherent and inconsistent to be interpreted absolutely. I’m an agnostic. Incidentally, NONE of the devout believers in my family have ever read it cover to cover.
By Jrz Wrld on 09/12/2009 5:13 pm