A Friend Stopped By | 03/23/2009 8:50 am
Are You Suffering From a 'Sunshine Deficit'? by Dr. Holly Andersen

Editor’s Note: Dr. Holly Andersen is dual board certified in Internal Medicine and Cardiology, is a Fellow of the American College of Cardiology and the American College of Sports Medicine and is an assistant professor of medicine at the Weill Cornell Medical Center. Dr. Andersen has been selected as one of America’s "Best Doctors" every year by Castle Connolly since 2001, and in 2008 was named by the Consumers’ Research Council of America as one of "America’s Top Cardiologists."
Vitamin D deficiency is an increasingly prevalent, largely unrecognized problem. A recent study estimates that vitamin D deficiency affects up to half of adults and apparently healthy children in the United States. The role of vitamin D in our body appears far greater than previously thought. In the past, we only focused on its relationship to our bones, but now we are finding that even mild deficiency can cause muscle weakness, impaired balance and depression, and low levels have been linked to heart disease, stroke and an impaired ability to fight the common cold and the flu.
Our diet has very little vitamin D. Only cod-liver oil, oily fish and fortified dairy products contain more than trace amounts, and many commercial brands of milk have less vitamin D than they say; some have zero! So our main source of vitamin D comes from sunlight, which stimulates our skin to produce it. Older skin and darker skin produce vitamin D less well, and vitamin D gets diluted by subcutaneous fat, so obese people are also at increased risk. People who live in northern latitudes and areas of increased air pollution also have a higher risk. But let’s face it, most of us work indoors and, thanks to our dermatologists, we all wear sunblock when we are outdoors.
Clearly, vitamin D supplementation helps prevent age-related bone loss. Vitamin D is essential for calcium absorption and is needed for supplemental calcium to be used efficiently and appropriately – so if you’re taking calcium with insufficient vitamin D, it may not be going where you want it to, but don’t worry — you’re probably not absorbing it in the first place. Vitamin D supplementation has also been shown to reduce your fracture risk by reducing “body sway,” a measurement of balance and/or muscle strength, which reduces your risk of falling. Generalized body aches and pains are also thought to be related to low vitamin D; studies have shown improvement in chronic back pain with supplementation. Even more exciting, vitamin D has been shown to improve athletic performance – the most convincing evidence for this comes from German and Russian literature in the ’70s– remember who won every Olympics then?
Vitamin D is also linked to heart health. Several large studies have shown that people with low vitamin D levels were twice as likely to have a heart attack, stroke or other heart-related event during follow-up, compared to those with higher levels. The lowest rates of heart disease are in the sun-drenched Mediterranean coast and in southern versus northern Europe. Heart-related deaths are highest in the winter. Other studies have shown that high blood pressure, diabetes and high triglycerides were significantly more common in patients with the lowest levels of vitamin D. Severe vitamin D deficiency is commonly seen in patients with heart failure.
Brain function has also been related to vitamin D levels. A recent study from the Journal of Geriatric Psychology and Neurology showed that, compared with those in the highest quarter for vitamin D levels, those in the lowest were 2.3 times more likely to be cognitively impaired, even after adjusting for age, sex, education and ethnicity. Recently, vitamin D has even been touted to have a protective role against ADA and multiple sclerosis. Vitamin D deficiency may also contribute to depression, particularly seasonal affective disorder (SAD) or winter depression, which occurs when vitamin D levels are at their lowest.























9 Reader Comments (so far…) Sign In or Register to comment
It is very important for blacks and persons with darker complexions to include Vitamin D as a daily supplement in their diets. At present, I’m taking a daily multiple vitamin for seniors ,potassium and a 81mg childrens aspirin daily. ……….I eat lots of fresh fruits and vegetables. I substitute ground turkey for beef when cooking spaghetti , meatloaf or burgers. I’m fond of sauteed onions and peppers. I especially love grain breads and drink fresh spring or filtered water. I do not drink sodas instead I drink fruit juices or water with fresh lemon.———-We have to continue to be or become wise consumers. Our lives depend on it! There’re lots of healthy foods we can prepare daily and they’re inexpensive! We have to use coupons and all means available to us.———-Keep me informed. I am open to any and all good tips!
I’ve been paying attention to the recent news about vitamin D. It’s hard for me to tell whether it’s the latest fad or something that we need to be concerned about. Remember how hormone-replacement therapy was supposed to keep us young, free of heart disease and smart as a whip? Remember vitamin C as a cure for the common cold? Vitamin E… not longer effective against the effects of aging. Now, vitamin D is in the news. Sometimes, I think that the pharmaceutical business starts these fads or, at least, encourages them. In Europe, they say that a healthy American is one who hasn’t had enough tests. My doctor would prescribe all manner of pills if I let him, saying, for example, that X will halve my chances of getting a heart attack. So I go on line and check my chances without the drug: 2 in 10,000. And so, with the drug, 1 in 10,000. Not to mention the side effects. My doctor is right: it would halve my chances but, heck, my chances are pretty minimal anyway.
My overweight diabetic husband takes eight different pills a day: for diabetes and cholesterol etc. And he eats a diet that is 95% carbohydrate, in spite of the fact that the fridge bulges with fresh fruit and veggies.
Eat right, exercise, don’t smoke, don’t drink and try to maintain a healthy weight. These choices beat pills (even vitamin D pills) every time. But some, like my husband, prefer the pills. Go figure!
Sam Mirando,
You are quite correct. Supplements have never been shown to provide the benefits of whole foods - never. Eating right and exercising are the most important elements in keeping healthy. But, I have been quite impressed with our emerging knowledge of the biochemistry of vitamin D and its many effects in our bodies. This is not a vitamin we can easily ingest in our diet, and we don’t spend nearly as much time outside as our ancestors. This is a vitamin which can be easily measured in our blood and easily replenished. It’s worth checking yours.
Dr. A
I live in the pacific northwest in the part that rains for months on end. in 2008 we had TEN sunny days in five months! our local HMO did a bunch of vitamin D testing and found that 80+ percent of folks were not at acceptable levels. so i figure what the hell…. might as well. i don’t think a little extra vitamin D can hurt.
Since I started taking more Vitamin D about ten years ago, my health has improved enormously. I get fewer colds, and my bone density stopped declining. I was surprised that it took so long for doctors to put Vitamin D and the various ailments that were impacted by latitude together. Really, you can map the continent for incidence of say, colon cancer, and a clear pattern begins to emerge.
Anyway, I am happy to see that sunshine is being put back in place as a healthy pursuit, even though it is simply not possible for non tropical people to get enough in the winter.